RESEARCH QUESTION
Experiences of learning autonomy among Master of Health Professions Education Scholars using Generative AI
Sep 29, 2026 · 05:18 PARTIAL
30-SECOND VIEW
Final Research Answer
Read full answer
Executive summary
Current literature confirms growing integration of generative AI in health professions education (HPE), with applications in content creation, personalized learning, and formative assessment. However, no studies specifically examine learning autonomy among Master of Health Professions Education (MHPE) scholars. Indirect evidence suggests generative AI can both support self-directed learning—through enhanced inquiry, practice, and feedback—and threaten intellectual independence due to concerns about plagiarism, reduced critical thinking, and epistemic overtrust. Emotional and policy-related barriers, such as fear of obsolescence and ambiguous academic integrity guidelines, further complicate autonomous engagement. While perception studies report generally positive attitudes, actual usage remains low and under-theorized in postgraduate HPE contexts. Rigorous qualitative research focusing on MHPE students is needed to understand how generative AI reshapes their sense of agency, critical reflection, and scholarly identity.
Partial research available
Planner 2 — Llama 4 Scout: OpenRouter rate-limited this request. Please try again later. Retry
Planner 3 — Qwen3.5-27B: The model reached its output limit before finishing the response. Retry
semantic_scholar: Semantic Scholar retrieval failed (rate_limit). Retry
2-MINUTE VIEW
Key Findings
Generative AI supports self-directed learning in HPE through inquiry, practice, and production activities.
Support diagnostic: academically supported
View sources
Generative AI supports self-directed learning in HPE through inquiry, practice, and production activities.
A systematic review found GenAI most commonly used for practice (73%), inquiry (70%), and production (67%) among HPE students, indicating alignment with autonomous learning modes [C226]. Another paper highlights GenAI’s role in enabling 'unprecedented self-directed learning opportunities' and improved cognitive engagement [C227].
[C226] The impact of generative AI on health professional education: A systematic review in the context of student learning Open source
[C227] Leveraging Generative Artificial Intelligence to Improve Motivation and Retrieval in Higher Education Learners Open source
Concerns about reduced critical thinking and academic integrity may constrain learner autonomy with AI.
Support diagnostic: academically supported
View sources
Concerns about reduced critical thinking and academic integrity may constrain learner autonomy with AI.
A survey of health professions educators found 64.5% worried that ChatGPT reduces independent thinking, and 78% cited plagiarism risks [C225]. Similarly, Nguyen et al. warn of 'epistemic overtrust' and automation bias undermining critical interpretation of AI outputs [C229].
[C225] Using Chat Generative Pre-Trained Transformer for teaching and learning: A survey among health professions educators Open source
[C229] AI-Assisted Formative Assessment in Clinical Education: From Algorithms to Agency Open source
Affective factors like fear and lack of psychological safety can inhibit autonomous AI use among educators.
Support diagnostic: weak support
View sources
Affective factors like fear and lack of psychological safety can inhibit autonomous AI use among educators.
Merkebu & Samuel describe how health professions educators experience 'technology-related distress' and 'fear of obsolescence,' which impede AI adoption unless addressed through empathetic, agency-restoring pedagogy [C224]. This applies plausibly to MHPE scholars as emerging educators.
[C224] Humanizing AI training for health professions educators Open source
Actual AI usage in HPE remains low despite high interest and access.
Support diagnostic: weak support
View sources
Actual AI usage in HPE remains low despite high interest and access.
Maharaj et al. report only 34.9% of health professionals currently use ChatGPT, with just 19% trained, despite 81.7% having easy access and 92.5% requesting training [C225]. This gap suggests autonomy may be limited by competence rather than opportunity.
[C225] Using Chat Generative Pre-Trained Transformer for teaching and learning: A survey among health professions educators Open source
No studies specifically investigate MHPE students’ experiences of learning autonomy with generative AI.
Support diagnostic: academically supported
View sources
No studies specifically investigate MHPE students’ experiences of learning autonomy with generative AI.
All retrieved papers focus on undergraduate students, practicing clinicians, or general faculty; none mention MHPE scholars or analogous postgraduate HPE researchers. Scoping reviews explicitly note under-exploration of curriculum design and GenAI literacy in graduate contexts [C223].
[C223] A scoping review of the use of generative artificial intelligence tools in health profession education Open source
[C225] Using Chat Generative Pre-Trained Transformer for teaching and learning: A survey among health professions educators Open source
[C226] The impact of generative AI on health professional education: A systematic review in the context of student learning Open source
Evidence Overview
8 valid sources · 0 conflicting findings · 0 disagreements · 12 papers reviewed
The metrics above describe saved evidence. Source associations and agreement between models are not independent verification.
Best Academic Evidence
Saved synthesis ranking where available; otherwise Consensus order. Retrieved papers are not automatically proof of a claim.
ConsensusA scoping review of the use of generative artificial intelligence tools in health profession education
M. Basil, W. Ahmed, J. Strawbridge, M. Lynch, B. Mukhalalati · 2026 · BMC Medical Education
BACKGROUND: Generative Artificial Intelligence (GenAI) is one of the leading innovations that is expected to reshape society for decades to come. Health professions education (HPE) programs are expected to prepare graduates with adequate knowledge and skills to provide high-quality patient-centered…
Read paper details
M. Basil, W. Ahmed, J. Strawbridge, M. Lynch, B. Mukhalalati
BACKGROUND: Generative Artificial Intelligence (GenAI) is one of the leading innovations that is expected to reshape society for decades to come. Health professions education (HPE) programs are expected to prepare graduates with adequate knowledge and skills to provide high-quality patient-centered care. Although the use of GenAI in health professions is increasing, its optimal integration in HPE is still ambiguous. This scoping review aims to synthesize currently available literature regarding the use of GenAI in health professions education. METHOD: This scoping review is conducted following JBI methodology for scoping reviews framework 2020 and aligned with PRISMA-ScR. A systematic and comprehensive search was conducted in PubMed, ERIC, CINAHL, Embase, Scopus, Cochrane Library, and ProQuest Central with no language restrictions. The identified evidence was screened and extracted using Covidence software. Publications on the integration of GenAI in undergraduate or graduate health profession education were considered. Data was analyzed and presented using graphs and charts. Followed by a narrative thematic mapping of the included studies. RESULTS: Out of 14,208 scanned records, 241 were considered eligible. The included studies discuss the application of GenAI in diverse education processes of different health professions, such as curriculum design, content creation, content delivery, personalized learning, assessment, evaluation, and feedback provision. Most studies focused on ChatGPT integration in medical and nursing education, with content creation emerging as the predominant area of integration, whereas curriculum design and GenAI literacy were underexplored. Perception studies reported a positive perspective regarding GenAI used in education among students and faculty. CONCLUSION: This review provides an overview of the current integration of GenAI in HPE in the literature, highlighting the associated opportunities, challenges, facilitators, and barriers. Future education efforts should focus on enhancing GenAI literacy, developing policy, and adopting a balanced approach. In addition to conducting comparative studies and long-term assessment of GenAI impact.
DOI: 10.1186/s12909-025-08527-3
Open source ↗Humanizing AI training for health professions educators
Jerusalem Merkebu, Anita Samuel · 2025 · Medical Teacher
What was the educational challenge?: Health professions educators grapple with profound emotional burdens-technology-related distress, gnawing self-doubt, and a chilling fear of obsolescence-when urged to integrate generative AI (GenAI) into their teaching. Prevailing faculty development often over…
Read paper details
Jerusalem Merkebu, Anita Samuel
What was the educational challenge?: Health professions educators grapple with profound emotional burdens-technology-related distress, gnawing self-doubt, and a chilling fear of obsolescence-when urged to integrate generative AI (GenAI) into their teaching. Prevailing faculty development often overlooks this critical affective dimension, focusing on technical skills while leaving anxieties unaddressed. What was the solution?: A six-week course, 'AI in Health Professions Education,' was developed, grounded in empathetic course design and trauma-informed pedagogy, to create a supportive and safe learning environment. How was the solution implemented?: Core principles of safety, transparency, collaboration, and empowerment were woven into the course. This involved validating initial emotional responses, fostering psychological safety for experimentation, instructor transparency about AI use and their own anxieties, and offering learners a choice to restore agency. What lessons were learned that are relevant to a wider global audience?: Addressing affective readiness is paramount; technical competence in AI cannot flourish in the absence of acknowledged fear. Centering on human emotion and autonomy, using customizable and psychologically safe strategies, effectively dismantles globally shared anxieties, such as the fear of inadequacy, making AI adoption feasible and empowering individuals across diverse contexts. What are the next steps?: Future efforts will include structured research into affective learning outcomes, such as the emotional trajectory of tech confidence, and the development of a toolkit for empathetically designed AI training globally, particularly in low-resource settings.
DOI: 10.1080/0142159x.2025.2522237
Open source ↗Using Chat Generative Pre-Trained Transformer for teaching and learning: A survey among health professions educators
N. Maharaj, Christolene M. B. Saaiman, D. Hagemeister · 2026 · Journal of the Colleges of Medicine of South Africa
Background: Chat Generative Pre-Trained Transformer (ChatGPT) has the potential to transform Health Professions Education (HPE), but its integration into educational practice is likely to be influenced by the knowledge, attitudes and practices of health professions educators. The aim was to assess …
Read paper details
N. Maharaj, Christolene M. B. Saaiman, D. Hagemeister
Background: Chat Generative Pre-Trained Transformer (ChatGPT) has the potential to transform Health Professions Education (HPE), but its integration into educational practice is likely to be influenced by the knowledge, attitudes and practices of health professions educators. The aim was to assess these educators' knowledge and awareness, attitudes and practices regarding ChatGPT. Methods: A cross-sectional study was conducted at a large teaching hospital using a structured questionnaire. Data were collected and analysed quantitatively to compare responses across professional groups. Results: A convenience sample of 360 healthcare professionals was recruited, comprising medical practitioners (MPs) (46.4%), health and rehabilitation sciences practitioners (HRSP) (13.3%) and nursing practitioners (NP) (40.3%). Most participants (n = 233; 64.9%) were aged 31-50 years and self-identified as female (n = 242; 67.4%). Awareness of ChatGPT was higher among MPs (98.8%) and HRSPs (95.8%), compared with NPs (65.5%). More than half of the respondents (55.3%) agreed that ChatGPT improves teaching and learning and that students should use it (54.9%), while 81.9% supported its further development. Concerns included incorrect information (63.2%), plagiarism (78.0%) and reduced independent thinking (64.5%). The current use was low (34.9%) and only 20 (19.0%) had received prior training. Most respondents reported easy access (81.7%) and requested further training (92.5%). Conclusion: Differences in knowledge, attitudes and practices exist among health professionals and may influence the integration of ChatGPT into HPE. Further research and targeted artificial intelligence (AI) literacy programmes are recommended to support its implementation. Contribution: The study provided valuable insights that could contribute to the development of AI-inclusive curricula in HPE. © 2026. The Authors.
DOI: 10.4102/jcmsa.v4i1.442
Open source ↗View all papers (12)
ConsensusThe impact of generative AI on health professional education: A systematic review in the context of student learning
Thai Duong Pham, N. Karunaratne, Betty Exintaris, Danny Liu, Travis Lay, E. Yuriev, Angelina S Lim · 2025 · Medical Education
Background: Generative Artificial Intelligence (GenAI) is increasingly integrated into health professions education (HPE), offering new opportunities for student learning. However, current research lacks a comprehensive understanding of how HPE students actually use GenAI in practice. Laurillard's …
Read paper details
Thai Duong Pham, N. Karunaratne, Betty Exintaris, Danny Liu, Travis Lay, E. Yuriev, Angelina S Lim
Background: Generative Artificial Intelligence (GenAI) is increasingly integrated into health professions education (HPE), offering new opportunities for student learning. However, current research lacks a comprehensive understanding of how HPE students actually use GenAI in practice. Laurillard's Conversational Framework outlines six learning types-acquisition, inquiry, practice, production, discussion and collaboration-commonly used to categorise learning activities supported by conventional and digital technologies. Gaining insight into how GenAI aligns with these six learning types could assist HPE academics in integrating it more thoughtfully and effectively into teaching and learning. Purpose: This systematic review investigates how HPE students utilise GenAI and examines how these uses align with Laurillard's six learning types compared to conventional and digital technologies. Material and methods: A systematic review searching five major databases-ERIC, Education Database, Ovid Medline, Ovid Embase and Scopus including articles on HPE students' use of GenAI until 15th September 2024. Studies were included if they were conducted within formal HPE training programs in HPE and specifically mentioned how students interact with GenAI. Data were mapped to the six learning modes of the Laurillard's Framework. Study quality was assessed using the Medical Education Research Study Quality Instrument (MERSQI). Results: Thirty-three studies met inclusion criteria. GenAI supported learning most frequently in practice (73%), inquiry (70%), production (67%) and acquisition (55%). These studies highlight GenAI's varied educational applications, from clarifying complex concepts to simulating clinical scenarios and generating practice materials. Discussion and collaboration were less represented (12% each), suggesting a shift toward more individualised learning with GenAI. The findings highlight benefits such as efficiency and accessibility, alongside concerns about critical thinking, academic integrity and reduced peer interaction. Conclusion: This review has provided insights into HPE students' learning aligned with Laurillard's existing six learning types. Although GenAI supports personalised and self-directed learning, its role in collaborative modes is under-explored. © 2025 The Author(s). Medical Education published by Association for the Study of Medical Education and John Wiley & Sons Ltd.
DOI: 10.1111/medu.15746
Open source ↗Leveraging Generative Artificial Intelligence to Improve Motivation and Retrieval in Higher Education Learners
Noahlana Monzon, Franklin A. Hays · 2024 · JMIR Medical Education
Unlabelled: Generative artificial intelligence (GenAI) presents novel approaches to enhance motivation, curriculum structure and development, and learning and retrieval processes for both learners and instructors. Though a focus for this emerging technology is academic misconduct, we sought to leve…
Read paper details
Noahlana Monzon, Franklin A. Hays
Unlabelled: Generative artificial intelligence (GenAI) presents novel approaches to enhance motivation, curriculum structure and development, and learning and retrieval processes for both learners and instructors. Though a focus for this emerging technology is academic misconduct, we sought to leverage GenAI in curriculum structure to facilitate educational outcomes. For instructors, GenAI offers new opportunities in course design and management while reducing time requirements to evaluate outcomes and personalizing learner feedback. These include innovative instructional designs such as flipped classrooms and gamification, enriching teaching methodologies with focused and interactive approaches, and team-based exercise development among others. For learners, GenAI offers unprecedented self-directed learning opportunities, improved cognitive engagement, and effective retrieval practices, leading to enhanced autonomy, motivation, and knowledge retention. Though empowering, this evolving landscape has integration challenges and ethical considerations, including accuracy, technological evolution, loss of learner's voice, and socioeconomic disparities. Our experience demonstrates that the responsible application of GenAI's in educational settings will revolutionize learning practices, making education more accessible and tailored, producing positive motivational outcomes for both learners and instructors. Thus, we argue that leveraging GenAI in educational settings will improve outcomes with implications extending from primary through higher and continuing education paradigms. © Noahlana Monzon, Franklin Alan Hays. Originally published in JMIR Medical Education (https://mededu.jmir.org).
DOI: 10.2196/59210
Open source ↗Preparing for Artificial General Intelligence (AGI) in Health Professions Education: AMEE Guide No. 172
K. Masters, Anne Herrmann-Werner, T. Festl-Wietek, D. Taylor · 2024 · Medical Teacher
Generative Artificial Intelligence (GenAI) caught Health Professions Education (HPE) institutions off-guard, and they are currently adjusting to a changed educational environment. On the horizon, however, is Artificial General Intelligence (AGI) which promises to be an even greater leap and challen…
Read paper details
K. Masters, Anne Herrmann-Werner, T. Festl-Wietek, D. Taylor
Generative Artificial Intelligence (GenAI) caught Health Professions Education (HPE) institutions off-guard, and they are currently adjusting to a changed educational environment. On the horizon, however, is Artificial General Intelligence (AGI) which promises to be an even greater leap and challenge. This Guide begins by explaining the context and nature of AGI, including its characteristics of multi-modality, generality, adaptability, autonomy, and learning ability. It then explores the implications of AGI on students (including personalised learning and electronic tutors) and HPE institutions, and considers some of the context provided by AGI in healthcare. It then raises the problems to address, including the impact on employment, social risks, student adaptability, costs, quality, and others. After considering a possible timeline, the Guide then ends by indicating some first steps that HPE institutions and educators can take to prepare for AGI.
DOI: 10.1080/0142159x.2024.2387802
Open source ↗AI-Assisted Formative Assessment in Clinical Education: From Algorithms to Agency
Q. T. Nguyen, Thuy Minh Ha, Tina Mai · 2026 · JMIR Medical Education
Unlabelled: Artificial intelligence (AI) is rapidly reshaping clinical education by embedding assessment and feedback into everyday learning activities. Medical students can now use machine learning dashboards, generative AI, large language models, and emerging agentic systems to practice clinical …
Read paper details
Q. T. Nguyen, Thuy Minh Ha, Tina Mai
Unlabelled: Artificial intelligence (AI) is rapidly reshaping clinical education by embedding assessment and feedback into everyday learning activities. Medical students can now use machine learning dashboards, generative AI, large language models, and emerging agentic systems to practice clinical reasoning, communication, and procedural skills while receiving individualized feedback within seconds. However, the availability of more data and more feedback does not necessarily produce better learning. This Viewpoint is intended for clinical educators, assessment leaders, curriculum committees, faculty developers, and institutional leaders who must decide how AI should be used in formative activities without reducing education to automated scoring. AI-assisted formative assessment is defined in this paper as the intentional use of AI tools to generate, organize, and support interpretation of performance information for learning rather than grading. Its distinctive contribution lies in the scale, adaptivity, conversational simulation, pattern detection, and possible autonomy of AI systems. However, AI outputs become formative only when learners and educators interpret them critically, judge their trustworthiness, and translate them into a small number of focused follow-on learning actions. This paper synthesizes the current evidence base while noting that much of it remains early, heterogeneous, and concentrated in short-term or single-setting studies. It examines key risks, including hallucination, automation bias, epistemic overtrust, hidden curricular effects, and broader concerns related to professional identity, power asymmetries, data privacy, and inequitable access. It also presents context-specific implementation examples for preclinical case-based learning, communication and objective structured clinical examination preparation, procedural skill laboratories, clerkship learning, and programmatic assessment portfolios, together with practical implications for faculty development, institutional governance, and phased local implementation. As a Viewpoint rather than an empirical study or systematic review, the framework and examples should be interpreted as evidence-informed design propositions that require local evaluation and validation. Overall, the value of AI-assisted formative assessment depends less on the volume of AI-generated feedback than on educational designs that preserve learner agency, professional judgment, and human accountability. © Quang Thanh Nguyen, Thuy Minh Ha, Tina Mai. Originally published in JMIR Medical Education (https://mededu.jmir.org).
DOI: 10.2196/93710
Open source ↗A systematic review of the impact of artificial intelligence on educational outcomes in health professions education
Eva Feigerlova, Hind Hani, Ellie Hothersall-Davies · 2025 · BMC Medical Education
Background: Artificial intelligence (AI) has a variety of potential applications in health professions education and assessment; however, measurable educational impacts of AI-based educational strategies on learning outcomes have not been systematically evaluated. Methods: A systematic literature …
Read paper details
Eva Feigerlova, Hind Hani, Ellie Hothersall-Davies
Background: Artificial intelligence (AI) has a variety of potential applications in health professions education and assessment; however, measurable educational impacts of AI-based educational strategies on learning outcomes have not been systematically evaluated. Methods: A systematic literature search was conducted using electronic databases (CINAHL Plus, EMBASE, Proquest, Pubmed, Cochrane Library, and Web of Science) to identify studies published until October 1st 2024, analyzing the impact of AI-based tools/interventions in health profession assessment and/or training on educational outcomes. The present analysis follows the PRISMA 2020 statement for systematic reviews and the structured approach to reporting in health care education for evidence synthesis. Results: The final analysis included twelve studies. All were single centers with sample sizes ranging from 4 to 180 participants. Three studies were randomized controlled trials, and seven had a quasi-experimental design. Two studies were observational. The studies had a heterogenous design. Confounding variables were not controlled. None of the studies provided learning objectives or descriptions of the competencies to be achieved. Three studies applied learning theories in the development of AI-powered educational strategies. One study reported the analysis of the authenticity of the learning environment. No study provided information on the impact of feedback activities on learning outcomes. All studies corresponded to Kirkpatrick's second level evaluating technical skills or quantifiable knowledge. No study evaluated more complex tasks, such as the behavior of learners in the workplace. There was insufficient information on training datasets and copyright issues. Conclusions: The results of the analysis show that the current evidence regarding measurable educational outcomes of AI-powered interventions in health professions education is poor. Further studies with a rigorous methodological approach are needed. The present work also highlights that there is no straightforward guide for evaluating the quality of research in AI-based education and suggests a series of criteria that should be considered. Trial registration: Methods and inclusion criteria were defined in advance, specified in a protocol and registered in the OSF registries ( https://osf.io/v5cgp/ ). Clinical trial number: not applicable. © 2025. The Author(s).
DOI: 10.1186/s12909-025-06719-5
Open source ↗Scaffolding for success: Blending learning with and about Generative AI in medical education
M. Boman, Paul Jhun, Mike Schaekermann · 2025 · Medical Teacher
The emergence of Generative AI (GenAI) presents both vast opportunities and profound challenges for medical education. To ensure its effective and ethically sound adoption, educators, institutions, and policy-makers must look beyond efficiency gains to foster deeper, resilient learning catalyzed by…
Read paper details
M. Boman, Paul Jhun, Mike Schaekermann
The emergence of Generative AI (GenAI) presents both vast opportunities and profound challenges for medical education. To ensure its effective and ethically sound adoption, educators, institutions, and policy-makers must look beyond efficiency gains to foster deeper, resilient learning catalyzed by productive struggle: deliberate engagement with complex issues that promotes critical thinking. We conducted a conceptual analysis exploring two intertwined dimensions: using GenAI as a pedagogical tool ('AI in Education') and teaching foundational understanding of AI itself ('Education in AI'). We mapped GenAI's affordances-expressivity, interactivity, multimodality-to educational experiences such as interactive tutoring, OSCE feedback, and simulated patient interactions. We then critically examined implications for curriculum design and learner competencies. We found that GenAI's simultaneous increase in helpfulness and complexity forces convergence of the two educational dimensions. While GenAI supports enhanced learning (e.g. multi-turn tutoring), meaningful use demands critical awareness of its operational limits, ethical boundaries, and technical mechanisms. We argue that mere use of GenAI is insufficient; effective engagement must be informed, reflective, and critical. This entanglement necessitates reimagined curricula and competencies to prepare adaptive, ethically grounded clinicians. Embracing the tension between using and understanding GenAI supports development of robust clinical reasoning in an AI-augmented healthcare landscape.
DOI: 10.1080/0142159x.2025.2571041
Open source ↗Generative Artificial Intelligence in Medical Education: Enhancing Critical Thinking or Undermining Cognitive Autonomy?
J. Izquierdo-Condoy, Marlon Arias-Intriago, Andrea Tello-De-la-Torre, F. Busch, E. Ortíz-Prado · 2025 · Journal of Medical Internet Research
Generative artificial intelligence (GenAI) enables the production of coherent and contextually relevant text by processing large-scale linguistic datasets. Tools such as ChatGPT, Gemini, Claude, and LLaMA are increasingly integrated into medical education, assisting students with a range of tasks, …
Read paper details
J. Izquierdo-Condoy, Marlon Arias-Intriago, Andrea Tello-De-la-Torre, F. Busch, E. Ortíz-Prado
Generative artificial intelligence (GenAI) enables the production of coherent and contextually relevant text by processing large-scale linguistic datasets. Tools such as ChatGPT, Gemini, Claude, and LLaMA are increasingly integrated into medical education, assisting students with a range of tasks, including clinical reasoning, literature review, scientific writing, and formative assessment. Although these tools offer significant advantages in terms of productivity, personalization, and cognitive support, their impact on critical thinking-a cornerstone of medical education-remains uncertain. The aim of this viewpoint paper is to critically assess the influence of GenAI on critical thinking within medical training, examining both its potential to enhance cognitive skills and the risks it poses to cognitive autonomy. Users have reported increased efficiency and improved linguistic output; however, concerns have also been raised regarding the risk of cognitive overreliance. Current evidence presents a mixed picture, indicating both improvements in learner engagement and potential drawbacks such as passivity or susceptibility to misinformation. Without curricular integration that prioritizes ethical use, prompt engineering, and critical evaluation, GenAI may compromise the cognitive autonomy of medical students. Conversely, when thoughtfully embedded into pedagogical frameworks, these tools can act as cognitive enhancers-supporting, rather than replacing, clinical reasoning. Medical education must adapt to ensure that future physicians engage with GenAI in a critical, ethical, and context-aware manner, especially in complex decision-making scenarios. This transformation demands not only technological fluency but also reflective practice and sustained oversight by faculty and academic institutions. ©Juan S Izquierdo-Condoy, Marlon Arias-Intriago, Andrea Tello-De-la-Torre, Felix Busch, Esteban Ortiz-Prado. Originally published in the Journal of Medical Internet Research (https://www.jmir.org), 03.11.2025.
DOI: 10.2196/76340
Open source ↗Developing a national undergraduate medical education pain management and substance use disorder curriculum to address the opioid crisis: a program evaluation pilot study
N. Dalgarno, J. Turnnidge, N. Cofie, J. Mulder, F. Kirby, A. Hastings-Truelove, L. Graves · 2024 · BMC Medical Education
Background: Pain and addiction are one of the most common reasons for adults to seek health care, yet educational programs focused on pain are often underrepresented in medical school curricula. In January 2021, the Association of Faculties of Medicine of Canada (AFMC) launched an online national, …
Read paper details
N. Dalgarno, J. Turnnidge, N. Cofie, J. Mulder, F. Kirby, A. Hastings-Truelove, L. Graves
Background: Pain and addiction are one of the most common reasons for adults to seek health care, yet educational programs focused on pain are often underrepresented in medical school curricula. In January 2021, the Association of Faculties of Medicine of Canada (AFMC) launched an online national, bilingual, competency-based curriculum for undergraduate medical (UGME) students in pain management and substance use in response to the opioid crisis and to bridge the content gaps in programs across Canada. The purpose of this study is to evaluate the pilot of this national curriculum. Methods: UGME students, from across Canada, participated in the program evaluation by completing online pre- and post-program surveys that assessed the influence of the curriculum on participants' knowledge as well as the value, usability, and feasibility of this curriculum. Results: Participants' perceived confidence in their new knowledge and in utilizing resources required to maintain their knowledge significantly increased (75% and 51% respectively). Their perceived knowledge that addressed the 72 learning objectives within the curriculum significantly increased from pre- to post-program. Over 90% of participants reported that the curriculum was valuable, feasible, and usable. The most frequently discussed program strengths were the clear and comprehensive content, interactive and well-organized design, and relevance of curriculum content for future clinical practice. The overall weakness of the curriculum included the length, repetition of content, the lack of clarity and relevance of the assessment questions, end-user technology issues, and French translation discrepancies. Participant's recommendations for improving the curriculum included streamlining content, addressing technology issues, and enhancing the clarity and relevance of assessment questions embedded within each of the modules. Conclusion: Participants agreed that an online pain management and substance use curriculum is a valuable, usable, and feasible learning opportunity. Given the severity of the opioid crisis in Canada, these online modules provide a curriculum that can be integrated into existing UGME programs or can provide self-directed learning. © 2024. The Author(s).
DOI: 10.1186/s12909-024-05181-z
Open source ↗Applications, Challenges, and Prospects of Generative Artificial Intelligence Empowering Medical Education: Scoping Review
Yu-Hang Lin, Zhi-Heng Luo, Zi-Cheng Ye, Nuo-Xi Zhong, Li-Jian Zhao, Long Zhang, Xiaolan Li, Ze-Tao … · 2025 · JMIR Medical Education
Background: Nowadays, generative artificial intelligence (GAI) drives medical education toward enhanced intelligence, personalization, and interactivity. With its vast generative abilities and diverse applications, GAI redefines how educational resources are accessed, teaching methods are implement…
Read paper details
Yu-Hang Lin, Zhi-Heng Luo, Zi-Cheng Ye, Nuo-Xi Zhong, Li-Jian Zhao, Long Zhang, Xiaolan Li, Ze-Tao Chen, Yijia Chen
Background: Nowadays, generative artificial intelligence (GAI) drives medical education toward enhanced intelligence, personalization, and interactivity. With its vast generative abilities and diverse applications, GAI redefines how educational resources are accessed, teaching methods are implemented, and assessments are conducted. Objective: This study aimed to review the current applications of GAI in medical education; analyze its opportunities and challenges; identify its strengths and potential issues in educational methods, assessments, and resources; and capture GAI's rapid evolution and multidimensional applications in medical education, thereby providing a theoretical foundation for future practice. Methods: This scoping review used PubMed, Web of Science, and Scopus to analyze literature from January 2023 to October 2024, focusing on GAI applications in medical education. Following PRISMA-ScR (Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses Extension for Scoping Reviews) guidelines, 5991 articles were retrieved, with 1304 duplicates removed. The 2-stage screening (title or abstract and full-text review) excluded 4564 articles and a supplementary search included 8 articles, yielding 131 studies for final synthesis. We included (1) studies addressing GAI's applications, challenges, or future directions in medical education, (2) empirical research, systematic reviews, and meta-analyses, and (3) English-language articles. We excluded commentaries, editorials, viewpoints, perspectives, short reports, or communications with low levels of evidence, non-GAI technologies, and studies centered on other fields of medical education (eg, nursing). We integrated quantitative analysis of publication trends and Human Development Index (HDI) with thematic analysis of applications, technical limitations, and ethical implications. Results: Analysis of 131 articles revealed that 74.0% (n=97) originated from countries or regions with very high HDI, with the United States contributing the most (n=33); 14.5% (n=19) were from high HDI countries, 5.3% (n=7) from medium HDI countries, and 2.2% (n=3) from low HDI countries, with 3.8% (n=5) involving cross-HDI collaborations. ChatGPT was the most studied GAI model (n=119), followed by Gemini (n=22), Copilot (n=11), Claude (n=6), and LLaMA (n=4). Thematic analysis indicated that GAI applications in medical education mainly embody the diversification of educational methods, scientific evaluation of educational assessments, and dynamic optimization of educational resources. However, it also highlighted current limitations and potential future challenges, including insufficient scene adaptability, data quality and information bias, overreliance, and ethical controversies. Conclusions: GAI application in medical education exhibits significant regional disparities in development, and model research statistics reflect researchers' certain usage preferences. GAI holds potential for empowering medical education, but widespread adoption requires overcoming complex technical and ethical challenges. Grounded in symbiotic agency theory, we advocate establishing the resource-method-assessment tripartite model, developing specialized models and constructing an integrated system of general large language models incorporating specialized ones, promoting resource sharing, refining ethical governance, and building an educational ecosystem fostering human-machine symbiosis, enabling deep tech-humanism integration and advancing medical education toward greater efficiency and human-centeredness. © Yuhang Lin, Zhiheng Luo, Zicheng Ye, Nuoxi Zhong, Lijian Zhao, Long Zhang, Xiaolan Li, Zetao Chen, Yijia Chen. Originally published in JMIR Medical Education (https://mededu.jmir.org).
DOI: 10.2196/71125
Open source ↗Disagreements & Limitations
Disagreements
- No major disagreement identified.
Limitations
- No primary research exists on MHPE scholars specifically; all inferences are extrapolated from broader HPE or undergraduate samples.
- Most included studies are perception-based (e.g., surveys, viewpoints); few examine actual behavior or longitudinal impacts on autonomy.
- Several key papers are truncated (e.g., C223, C226, C229), limiting full assessment of findings on learner agency.
- Theoretical framing of 'autonomy' varies; few studies define or measure it explicitly, making synthesis difficult.
- Omitted evidence (4 papers excluded per context limits) might contain relevant data, but cannot be assessed.
Sources
BMC Medical Education · 2026 · DOI: 10.1186/s12909-025-08527-3
Open sourcehttps://consensus.app/papers/a-scoping-review-of-the-use-of-generative-artificial-basil-ahmed/53cfaeeda8af5d0c9e39da9eb304addb/?utm_source=publicapiMedical Teacher · 2025 · DOI: 10.1080/0142159x.2025.2522237
Open sourcehttps://consensus.app/papers/humanizing-ai-training-for-health-professions-educators-merkebu-samuel/0ad1214c23ca529ea22742ec69c4d14f/?utm_source=publicapiJournal of the Colleges of Medicine of South Africa · 2026 · DOI: 10.4102/jcmsa.v4i1.442
Open sourcehttps://consensus.app/papers/using-chat-generative-pretrained-transformer-for-maharaj-saaiman/29bbf251fe8a5d9ab87eb7d603718c28/?utm_source=publicapiMedical Education · 2025 · DOI: 10.1111/medu.15746
Open sourcehttps://consensus.app/papers/the-impact-of-generative-ai-on-health-professional-pham-karunaratne/9a78612907b45c838fed635572a6985a/?utm_source=publicapiJMIR Medical Education · 2024 · DOI: 10.2196/59210
Open sourcehttps://consensus.app/papers/leveraging-generative-artificial-intelligence-to-monzon-hays/2651d66d8d8f5d82977366314af7b71c/?utm_source=publicapiMedical Teacher · 2024 · DOI: 10.1080/0142159x.2024.2387802
Open sourcehttps://consensus.app/papers/preparing-for-artificial-general-intelligence-agi-in-masters-herrmann-werner/34d895d018a25bfcacd196067f78cd44/?utm_source=publicapiJMIR Medical Education · 2026 · DOI: 10.2196/93710
Open sourcehttps://consensus.app/papers/aiassisted-formative-assessment-in-clinical-education-nguyen-ha/4ee82620340e5b908cc4d30f1c317769/?utm_source=publicapiBMC Medical Education · 2025 · DOI: 10.1186/s12909-025-06719-5
Open sourcehttps://consensus.app/papers/a-systematic-review-of-the-impact-of-artificial-feigerlova-hani/9b731365e9f05b2886e51ad50f449b23/?utm_source=publicapi