Experiences of learning autonomy among Master of Health Professions Education Scholars using Generative AI

RESEARCH QUESTION

Experiences of learning autonomy among Master of Health Professions Education Scholars using Generative AI

Sep 29, 2026 · 05:18 PARTIAL

30-SECOND VIEW

Final Research Answer

There is currently no direct empirical evidence on the experiences of learning autonomy among Master of Health Professions Education (MHPE) scholars using generative AI. However, related literature suggests plausible dynamics. Studies indicate that generative AI can enhance self-directed learning by supporting inquiry, practice, and knowledge production [C226], and may improve learner autonomy through personalized feedback and retrieval support [C227]. Yet concerns persist about reduced critical thinking, overreliance, and threats to intellectual independence [C225]. Faculty development efforts emphasizing psychological safety and learner ag…
Read full answer
There is currently no direct empirical evidence on the experiences of learning autonomy among Master of Health Professions Education (MHPE) scholars using generative AI. However, related literature suggests plausible dynamics. Studies indicate that generative AI can enhance self-directed learning by supporting inquiry, practice, and knowledge production [C226], and may improve learner autonomy through personalized feedback and retrieval support [C227]. Yet concerns persist about reduced critical thinking, overreliance, and threats to intellectual independence [C225]. Faculty development efforts emphasizing psychological safety and learner agency show that affective dimensions—such as fear of obsolescence—can undermine autonomous engagement with AI unless explicitly addressed [C224]. A significant gap remains in understanding how postgraduate HPE students, particularly MHPE scholars, navigate autonomy when co-creating academic work with AI. Three potential thesis topics emerge: 1. **Exploring shifts in critical reflection among MHPE students using AI for thesis writing**: This matters because reflective capacity is central to educator development. Existing literature notes AI’s role in production and inquiry [C226] but not its impact on scholarly metacognition. An unresolved question is whether AI use alters depth or authenticity of reflection. Population: MHPE candidates. Variables: AI tool usage frequency, reflective quality (analyzed via portfolio), self-efficacy. Method: Qualitative interviews + document analysis. Feasible given small cohort sizes and existing MHPE program structures. Supported by [C224, C226, C229]. 2. **AI literacy as a moderator of autonomous learning in MHPE**: Important because unequal AI preparedness may exacerbate disparities in academic agency. Surveys show varied awareness across health professionals [C225], but no studies focus on postgraduate educators. Unresolved: How baseline AI literacy shapes confidence, strategy selection, and perceived control. Population: Enrolled MHPE students. Variables: AI literacy (pre-survey), autonomy indicators (self-report + behavioral logs). Method: Mixed methods sequential design. Feasible with institutional collaboration. Supported by [C225, C227]. 3. **Tensions between institutional AI policies and student agency in MHPE programs**: Matters because policy ambiguity may constrain authentic autonomous use. No current studies examine how academic integrity frameworks influence MHPE scholars’ willingness to experiment with AI. Unresolved: How formal vs. informal norms shape disclosure and innovation. Population: MHPE students and faculty. Variables: Policy clarity, perceived autonomy, actual usage patterns. Method: Case study across 2–3 institutions. Feasible via program partnerships. Supported by [C224, C228].
Executive summary

Current literature confirms growing integration of generative AI in health professions education (HPE), with applications in content creation, personalized learning, and formative assessment. However, no studies specifically examine learning autonomy among Master of Health Professions Education (MHPE) scholars. Indirect evidence suggests generative AI can both support self-directed learning—through enhanced inquiry, practice, and feedback—and threaten intellectual independence due to concerns about plagiarism, reduced critical thinking, and epistemic overtrust. Emotional and policy-related barriers, such as fear of obsolescence and ambiguous academic integrity guidelines, further complicate autonomous engagement. While perception studies report generally positive attitudes, actual usage remains low and under-theorized in postgraduate HPE contexts. Rigorous qualitative research focusing on MHPE students is needed to understand how generative AI reshapes their sense of agency, critical reflection, and scholarly identity.

Export Research · coming later

Partial research available

Planner 2 — Llama 4 Scout: OpenRouter rate-limited this request. Please try again later. Retry

Planner 3 — Qwen3.5-27B: The model reached its output limit before finishing the response. Retry

semantic_scholar: Semantic Scholar retrieval failed (rate_limit). Retry

Overall confidence45%Synthesizer confidence estimate
Evidence strengthLimitedLowest reported finding strength; conflicts take precedence
Academic papers12 papers
AI agents1/3 successfulActive saved responses
ConsensusAvailable
Semantic ScholarUnavailable

2-MINUTE VIEW

Key Findings

Moderate 2 sources

Generative AI supports self-directed learning in HPE through inquiry, practice, and production activities.

Support diagnostic: academically supported

View sources

Generative AI supports self-directed learning in HPE through inquiry, practice, and production activities.

A systematic review found GenAI most commonly used for practice (73%), inquiry (70%), and production (67%) among HPE students, indicating alignment with autonomous learning modes [C226]. Another paper highlights GenAI’s role in enabling 'unprecedented self-directed learning opportunities' and improved cognitive engagement [C227].

[C226] The impact of generative AI on health professional education: A systematic review in the context of student learning Open source

[C227] Leveraging Generative Artificial Intelligence to Improve Motivation and Retrieval in Higher Education Learners Open source

Moderate 2 sources

Concerns about reduced critical thinking and academic integrity may constrain learner autonomy with AI.

Support diagnostic: academically supported

View sources

Concerns about reduced critical thinking and academic integrity may constrain learner autonomy with AI.

A survey of health professions educators found 64.5% worried that ChatGPT reduces independent thinking, and 78% cited plagiarism risks [C225]. Similarly, Nguyen et al. warn of 'epistemic overtrust' and automation bias undermining critical interpretation of AI outputs [C229].

[C225] Using Chat Generative Pre-Trained Transformer for teaching and learning: A survey among health professions educators Open source

[C229] AI-Assisted Formative Assessment in Clinical Education: From Algorithms to Agency Open source

Limited 1 sources

Affective factors like fear and lack of psychological safety can inhibit autonomous AI use among educators.

Support diagnostic: weak support

View sources

Affective factors like fear and lack of psychological safety can inhibit autonomous AI use among educators.

Merkebu & Samuel describe how health professions educators experience 'technology-related distress' and 'fear of obsolescence,' which impede AI adoption unless addressed through empathetic, agency-restoring pedagogy [C224]. This applies plausibly to MHPE scholars as emerging educators.

[C224] Humanizing AI training for health professions educators Open source

Limited 1 sources

Actual AI usage in HPE remains low despite high interest and access.

Support diagnostic: weak support

View sources

Actual AI usage in HPE remains low despite high interest and access.

Maharaj et al. report only 34.9% of health professionals currently use ChatGPT, with just 19% trained, despite 81.7% having easy access and 92.5% requesting training [C225]. This gap suggests autonomy may be limited by competence rather than opportunity.

[C225] Using Chat Generative Pre-Trained Transformer for teaching and learning: A survey among health professions educators Open source

Strong 3 sources

No studies specifically investigate MHPE students’ experiences of learning autonomy with generative AI.

Support diagnostic: academically supported

View sources

No studies specifically investigate MHPE students’ experiences of learning autonomy with generative AI.

All retrieved papers focus on undergraduate students, practicing clinicians, or general faculty; none mention MHPE scholars or analogous postgraduate HPE researchers. Scoping reviews explicitly note under-exploration of curriculum design and GenAI literacy in graduate contexts [C223].

[C223] A scoping review of the use of generative artificial intelligence tools in health profession education Open source

[C225] Using Chat Generative Pre-Trained Transformer for teaching and learning: A survey among health professions educators Open source

[C226] The impact of generative AI on health professional education: A systematic review in the context of student learning Open source

Evidence Overview

8 valid sources · 0 conflicting findings · 0 disagreements · 12 papers reviewed

The metrics above describe saved evidence. Source associations and agreement between models are not independent verification.

Best Academic Evidence

Saved synthesis ranking where available; otherwise Consensus order. Retrieved papers are not automatically proof of a claim.

Consensus

A scoping review of the use of generative artificial intelligence tools in health profession education

M. Basil, W. Ahmed, J. Strawbridge, M. Lynch, B. Mukhalalati · 2026 · BMC Medical Education

BACKGROUND: Generative Artificial Intelligence (GenAI) is one of the leading innovations that is expected to reshape society for decades to come. Health professions education (HPE) programs are expected to prepare graduates with adequate knowledge and skills to provide high-quality patient-centered…

Read paper details

M. Basil, W. Ahmed, J. Strawbridge, M. Lynch, B. Mukhalalati

BACKGROUND: Generative Artificial Intelligence (GenAI) is one of the leading innovations that is expected to reshape society for decades to come. Health professions education (HPE) programs are expected to prepare graduates with adequate knowledge and skills to provide high-quality patient-centered care. Although the use of GenAI in health professions is increasing, its optimal integration in HPE is still ambiguous. This scoping review aims to synthesize currently available literature regarding the use of GenAI in health professions education. METHOD: This scoping review is conducted following JBI methodology for scoping reviews framework 2020 and aligned with PRISMA-ScR. A systematic and comprehensive search was conducted in PubMed, ERIC, CINAHL, Embase, Scopus, Cochrane Library, and ProQuest Central with no language restrictions. The identified evidence was screened and extracted using Covidence software. Publications on the integration of GenAI in undergraduate or graduate health profession education were considered. Data was analyzed and presented using graphs and charts. Followed by a narrative thematic mapping of the included studies. RESULTS: Out of 14,208 scanned records, 241 were considered eligible. The included studies discuss the application of GenAI in diverse education processes of different health professions, such as curriculum design, content creation, content delivery, personalized learning, assessment, evaluation, and feedback provision. Most studies focused on ChatGPT integration in medical and nursing education, with content creation emerging as the predominant area of integration, whereas curriculum design and GenAI literacy were underexplored. Perception studies reported a positive perspective regarding GenAI used in education among students and faculty. CONCLUSION: This review provides an overview of the current integration of GenAI in HPE in the literature, highlighting the associated opportunities, challenges, facilitators, and barriers. Future education efforts should focus on enhancing GenAI literacy, developing policy, and adopting a balanced approach. In addition to conducting comparative studies and long-term assessment of GenAI impact.

DOI: 10.1186/s12909-025-08527-3

Open source ↗
Consensus

Humanizing AI training for health professions educators

Jerusalem Merkebu, Anita Samuel · 2025 · Medical Teacher

What was the educational challenge?: Health professions educators grapple with profound emotional burdens-technology-related distress, gnawing self-doubt, and a chilling fear of obsolescence-when urged to integrate generative AI (GenAI) into their teaching. Prevailing faculty development often over…

Read paper details

Jerusalem Merkebu, Anita Samuel

What was the educational challenge?: Health professions educators grapple with profound emotional burdens-technology-related distress, gnawing self-doubt, and a chilling fear of obsolescence-when urged to integrate generative AI (GenAI) into their teaching. Prevailing faculty development often overlooks this critical affective dimension, focusing on technical skills while leaving anxieties unaddressed. What was the solution?: A six-week course, 'AI in Health Professions Education,' was developed, grounded in empathetic course design and trauma-informed pedagogy, to create a supportive and safe learning environment. How was the solution implemented?: Core principles of safety, transparency, collaboration, and empowerment were woven into the course. This involved validating initial emotional responses, fostering psychological safety for experimentation, instructor transparency about AI use and their own anxieties, and offering learners a choice to restore agency. What lessons were learned that are relevant to a wider global audience?: Addressing affective readiness is paramount; technical competence in AI cannot flourish in the absence of acknowledged fear. Centering on human emotion and autonomy, using customizable and psychologically safe strategies, effectively dismantles globally shared anxieties, such as the fear of inadequacy, making AI adoption feasible and empowering individuals across diverse contexts. What are the next steps?: Future efforts will include structured research into affective learning outcomes, such as the emotional trajectory of tech confidence, and the development of a toolkit for empathetically designed AI training globally, particularly in low-resource settings.

DOI: 10.1080/0142159x.2025.2522237

Open source ↗
Consensus

Using Chat Generative Pre-Trained Transformer for teaching and learning: A survey among health professions educators

N. Maharaj, Christolene M. B. Saaiman, D. Hagemeister · 2026 · Journal of the Colleges of Medicine of South Africa

Background: Chat Generative Pre-Trained Transformer (ChatGPT) has the potential to transform Health Professions Education (HPE), but its integration into educational practice is likely to be influenced by the knowledge, attitudes and practices of health professions educators. The aim was to assess …

Read paper details

N. Maharaj, Christolene M. B. Saaiman, D. Hagemeister

Background: Chat Generative Pre-Trained Transformer (ChatGPT) has the potential to transform Health Professions Education (HPE), but its integration into educational practice is likely to be influenced by the knowledge, attitudes and practices of health professions educators. The aim was to assess these educators' knowledge and awareness, attitudes and practices regarding ChatGPT. Methods: A cross-sectional study was conducted at a large teaching hospital using a structured questionnaire. Data were collected and analysed quantitatively to compare responses across professional groups. Results: A convenience sample of 360 healthcare professionals was recruited, comprising medical practitioners (MPs) (46.4%), health and rehabilitation sciences practitioners (HRSP) (13.3%) and nursing practitioners (NP) (40.3%). Most participants (n = 233; 64.9%) were aged 31-50 years and self-identified as female (n = 242; 67.4%). Awareness of ChatGPT was higher among MPs (98.8%) and HRSPs (95.8%), compared with NPs (65.5%). More than half of the respondents (55.3%) agreed that ChatGPT improves teaching and learning and that students should use it (54.9%), while 81.9% supported its further development. Concerns included incorrect information (63.2%), plagiarism (78.0%) and reduced independent thinking (64.5%). The current use was low (34.9%) and only 20 (19.0%) had received prior training. Most respondents reported easy access (81.7%) and requested further training (92.5%). Conclusion: Differences in knowledge, attitudes and practices exist among health professionals and may influence the integration of ChatGPT into HPE. Further research and targeted artificial intelligence (AI) literacy programmes are recommended to support its implementation. Contribution: The study provided valuable insights that could contribute to the development of AI-inclusive curricula in HPE. © 2026. The Authors.

DOI: 10.4102/jcmsa.v4i1.442

Open source ↗
View all papers (12)Consensus

The impact of generative AI on health professional education: A systematic review in the context of student learning

Thai Duong Pham, N. Karunaratne, Betty Exintaris, Danny Liu, Travis Lay, E. Yuriev, Angelina S Lim · 2025 · Medical Education

Background: Generative Artificial Intelligence (GenAI) is increasingly integrated into health professions education (HPE), offering new opportunities for student learning. However, current research lacks a comprehensive understanding of how HPE students actually use GenAI in practice. Laurillard's …

Read paper details

Thai Duong Pham, N. Karunaratne, Betty Exintaris, Danny Liu, Travis Lay, E. Yuriev, Angelina S Lim

Background: Generative Artificial Intelligence (GenAI) is increasingly integrated into health professions education (HPE), offering new opportunities for student learning. However, current research lacks a comprehensive understanding of how HPE students actually use GenAI in practice. Laurillard's Conversational Framework outlines six learning types-acquisition, inquiry, practice, production, discussion and collaboration-commonly used to categorise learning activities supported by conventional and digital technologies. Gaining insight into how GenAI aligns with these six learning types could assist HPE academics in integrating it more thoughtfully and effectively into teaching and learning. Purpose: This systematic review investigates how HPE students utilise GenAI and examines how these uses align with Laurillard's six learning types compared to conventional and digital technologies. Material and methods: A systematic review searching five major databases-ERIC, Education Database, Ovid Medline, Ovid Embase and Scopus including articles on HPE students' use of GenAI until 15th September 2024. Studies were included if they were conducted within formal HPE training programs in HPE and specifically mentioned how students interact with GenAI. Data were mapped to the six learning modes of the Laurillard's Framework. Study quality was assessed using the Medical Education Research Study Quality Instrument (MERSQI). Results: Thirty-three studies met inclusion criteria. GenAI supported learning most frequently in practice (73%), inquiry (70%), production (67%) and acquisition (55%). These studies highlight GenAI's varied educational applications, from clarifying complex concepts to simulating clinical scenarios and generating practice materials. Discussion and collaboration were less represented (12% each), suggesting a shift toward more individualised learning with GenAI. The findings highlight benefits such as efficiency and accessibility, alongside concerns about critical thinking, academic integrity and reduced peer interaction. Conclusion: This review has provided insights into HPE students' learning aligned with Laurillard's existing six learning types. Although GenAI supports personalised and self-directed learning, its role in collaborative modes is under-explored. © 2025 The Author(s). Medical Education published by Association for the Study of Medical Education and John Wiley & Sons Ltd.

DOI: 10.1111/medu.15746

Open source ↗
Consensus

Leveraging Generative Artificial Intelligence to Improve Motivation and Retrieval in Higher Education Learners

Noahlana Monzon, Franklin A. Hays · 2024 · JMIR Medical Education

Unlabelled: Generative artificial intelligence (GenAI) presents novel approaches to enhance motivation, curriculum structure and development, and learning and retrieval processes for both learners and instructors. Though a focus for this emerging technology is academic misconduct, we sought to leve…

Read paper details

Noahlana Monzon, Franklin A. Hays

Unlabelled: Generative artificial intelligence (GenAI) presents novel approaches to enhance motivation, curriculum structure and development, and learning and retrieval processes for both learners and instructors. Though a focus for this emerging technology is academic misconduct, we sought to leverage GenAI in curriculum structure to facilitate educational outcomes. For instructors, GenAI offers new opportunities in course design and management while reducing time requirements to evaluate outcomes and personalizing learner feedback. These include innovative instructional designs such as flipped classrooms and gamification, enriching teaching methodologies with focused and interactive approaches, and team-based exercise development among others. For learners, GenAI offers unprecedented self-directed learning opportunities, improved cognitive engagement, and effective retrieval practices, leading to enhanced autonomy, motivation, and knowledge retention. Though empowering, this evolving landscape has integration challenges and ethical considerations, including accuracy, technological evolution, loss of learner's voice, and socioeconomic disparities. Our experience demonstrates that the responsible application of GenAI's in educational settings will revolutionize learning practices, making education more accessible and tailored, producing positive motivational outcomes for both learners and instructors. Thus, we argue that leveraging GenAI in educational settings will improve outcomes with implications extending from primary through higher and continuing education paradigms. © Noahlana Monzon, Franklin Alan Hays. Originally published in JMIR Medical Education (https://mededu.jmir.org).

DOI: 10.2196/59210

Open source ↗
Consensus

Preparing for Artificial General Intelligence (AGI) in Health Professions Education: AMEE Guide No. 172

K. Masters, Anne Herrmann-Werner, T. Festl-Wietek, D. Taylor · 2024 · Medical Teacher

Generative Artificial Intelligence (GenAI) caught Health Professions Education (HPE) institutions off-guard, and they are currently adjusting to a changed educational environment. On the horizon, however, is Artificial General Intelligence (AGI) which promises to be an even greater leap and challen…

Read paper details

K. Masters, Anne Herrmann-Werner, T. Festl-Wietek, D. Taylor

Generative Artificial Intelligence (GenAI) caught Health Professions Education (HPE) institutions off-guard, and they are currently adjusting to a changed educational environment. On the horizon, however, is Artificial General Intelligence (AGI) which promises to be an even greater leap and challenge. This Guide begins by explaining the context and nature of AGI, including its characteristics of multi-modality, generality, adaptability, autonomy, and learning ability. It then explores the implications of AGI on students (including personalised learning and electronic tutors) and HPE institutions, and considers some of the context provided by AGI in healthcare. It then raises the problems to address, including the impact on employment, social risks, student adaptability, costs, quality, and others. After considering a possible timeline, the Guide then ends by indicating some first steps that HPE institutions and educators can take to prepare for AGI.

DOI: 10.1080/0142159x.2024.2387802

Open source ↗
Consensus

AI-Assisted Formative Assessment in Clinical Education: From Algorithms to Agency

Q. T. Nguyen, Thuy Minh Ha, Tina Mai · 2026 · JMIR Medical Education

Unlabelled: Artificial intelligence (AI) is rapidly reshaping clinical education by embedding assessment and feedback into everyday learning activities. Medical students can now use machine learning dashboards, generative AI, large language models, and emerging agentic systems to practice clinical …

Read paper details

Q. T. Nguyen, Thuy Minh Ha, Tina Mai

Unlabelled: Artificial intelligence (AI) is rapidly reshaping clinical education by embedding assessment and feedback into everyday learning activities. Medical students can now use machine learning dashboards, generative AI, large language models, and emerging agentic systems to practice clinical reasoning, communication, and procedural skills while receiving individualized feedback within seconds. However, the availability of more data and more feedback does not necessarily produce better learning. This Viewpoint is intended for clinical educators, assessment leaders, curriculum committees, faculty developers, and institutional leaders who must decide how AI should be used in formative activities without reducing education to automated scoring. AI-assisted formative assessment is defined in this paper as the intentional use of AI tools to generate, organize, and support interpretation of performance information for learning rather than grading. Its distinctive contribution lies in the scale, adaptivity, conversational simulation, pattern detection, and possible autonomy of AI systems. However, AI outputs become formative only when learners and educators interpret them critically, judge their trustworthiness, and translate them into a small number of focused follow-on learning actions. This paper synthesizes the current evidence base while noting that much of it remains early, heterogeneous, and concentrated in short-term or single-setting studies. It examines key risks, including hallucination, automation bias, epistemic overtrust, hidden curricular effects, and broader concerns related to professional identity, power asymmetries, data privacy, and inequitable access. It also presents context-specific implementation examples for preclinical case-based learning, communication and objective structured clinical examination preparation, procedural skill laboratories, clerkship learning, and programmatic assessment portfolios, together with practical implications for faculty development, institutional governance, and phased local implementation. As a Viewpoint rather than an empirical study or systematic review, the framework and examples should be interpreted as evidence-informed design propositions that require local evaluation and validation. Overall, the value of AI-assisted formative assessment depends less on the volume of AI-generated feedback than on educational designs that preserve learner agency, professional judgment, and human accountability. © Quang Thanh Nguyen, Thuy Minh Ha, Tina Mai. Originally published in JMIR Medical Education (https://mededu.jmir.org).

DOI: 10.2196/93710

Open source ↗
Consensus

A systematic review of the impact of artificial intelligence on educational outcomes in health professions education

Eva Feigerlova, Hind Hani, Ellie Hothersall-Davies · 2025 · BMC Medical Education

Background: Artificial intelligence (AI) has a variety of potential applications in health professions education and assessment; however, measurable educational impacts of AI-based educational strategies on learning outcomes have not been systematically evaluated. Methods: A systematic literature …

Read paper details

Eva Feigerlova, Hind Hani, Ellie Hothersall-Davies

Background: Artificial intelligence (AI) has a variety of potential applications in health professions education and assessment; however, measurable educational impacts of AI-based educational strategies on learning outcomes have not been systematically evaluated. Methods: A systematic literature search was conducted using electronic databases (CINAHL Plus, EMBASE, Proquest, Pubmed, Cochrane Library, and Web of Science) to identify studies published until October 1st 2024, analyzing the impact of AI-based tools/interventions in health profession assessment and/or training on educational outcomes. The present analysis follows the PRISMA 2020 statement for systematic reviews and the structured approach to reporting in health care education for evidence synthesis. Results: The final analysis included twelve studies. All were single centers with sample sizes ranging from 4 to 180 participants. Three studies were randomized controlled trials, and seven had a quasi-experimental design. Two studies were observational. The studies had a heterogenous design. Confounding variables were not controlled. None of the studies provided learning objectives or descriptions of the competencies to be achieved. Three studies applied learning theories in the development of AI-powered educational strategies. One study reported the analysis of the authenticity of the learning environment. No study provided information on the impact of feedback activities on learning outcomes. All studies corresponded to Kirkpatrick's second level evaluating technical skills or quantifiable knowledge. No study evaluated more complex tasks, such as the behavior of learners in the workplace. There was insufficient information on training datasets and copyright issues. Conclusions: The results of the analysis show that the current evidence regarding measurable educational outcomes of AI-powered interventions in health professions education is poor. Further studies with a rigorous methodological approach are needed. The present work also highlights that there is no straightforward guide for evaluating the quality of research in AI-based education and suggests a series of criteria that should be considered. Trial registration: Methods and inclusion criteria were defined in advance, specified in a protocol and registered in the OSF registries ( https://osf.io/v5cgp/ ). Clinical trial number: not applicable. © 2025. The Author(s).

DOI: 10.1186/s12909-025-06719-5

Open source ↗
Consensus

Scaffolding for success: Blending learning with and about Generative AI in medical education

M. Boman, Paul Jhun, Mike Schaekermann · 2025 · Medical Teacher

The emergence of Generative AI (GenAI) presents both vast opportunities and profound challenges for medical education. To ensure its effective and ethically sound adoption, educators, institutions, and policy-makers must look beyond efficiency gains to foster deeper, resilient learning catalyzed by…

Read paper details

M. Boman, Paul Jhun, Mike Schaekermann

The emergence of Generative AI (GenAI) presents both vast opportunities and profound challenges for medical education. To ensure its effective and ethically sound adoption, educators, institutions, and policy-makers must look beyond efficiency gains to foster deeper, resilient learning catalyzed by productive struggle: deliberate engagement with complex issues that promotes critical thinking. We conducted a conceptual analysis exploring two intertwined dimensions: using GenAI as a pedagogical tool ('AI in Education') and teaching foundational understanding of AI itself ('Education in AI'). We mapped GenAI's affordances-expressivity, interactivity, multimodality-to educational experiences such as interactive tutoring, OSCE feedback, and simulated patient interactions. We then critically examined implications for curriculum design and learner competencies. We found that GenAI's simultaneous increase in helpfulness and complexity forces convergence of the two educational dimensions. While GenAI supports enhanced learning (e.g. multi-turn tutoring), meaningful use demands critical awareness of its operational limits, ethical boundaries, and technical mechanisms. We argue that mere use of GenAI is insufficient; effective engagement must be informed, reflective, and critical. This entanglement necessitates reimagined curricula and competencies to prepare adaptive, ethically grounded clinicians. Embracing the tension between using and understanding GenAI supports development of robust clinical reasoning in an AI-augmented healthcare landscape.

DOI: 10.1080/0142159x.2025.2571041

Open source ↗
Consensus

Generative Artificial Intelligence in Medical Education: Enhancing Critical Thinking or Undermining Cognitive Autonomy?

J. Izquierdo-Condoy, Marlon Arias-Intriago, Andrea Tello-De-la-Torre, F. Busch, E. Ortíz-Prado · 2025 · Journal of Medical Internet Research

Generative artificial intelligence (GenAI) enables the production of coherent and contextually relevant text by processing large-scale linguistic datasets. Tools such as ChatGPT, Gemini, Claude, and LLaMA are increasingly integrated into medical education, assisting students with a range of tasks, …

Read paper details

J. Izquierdo-Condoy, Marlon Arias-Intriago, Andrea Tello-De-la-Torre, F. Busch, E. Ortíz-Prado

Generative artificial intelligence (GenAI) enables the production of coherent and contextually relevant text by processing large-scale linguistic datasets. Tools such as ChatGPT, Gemini, Claude, and LLaMA are increasingly integrated into medical education, assisting students with a range of tasks, including clinical reasoning, literature review, scientific writing, and formative assessment. Although these tools offer significant advantages in terms of productivity, personalization, and cognitive support, their impact on critical thinking-a cornerstone of medical education-remains uncertain. The aim of this viewpoint paper is to critically assess the influence of GenAI on critical thinking within medical training, examining both its potential to enhance cognitive skills and the risks it poses to cognitive autonomy. Users have reported increased efficiency and improved linguistic output; however, concerns have also been raised regarding the risk of cognitive overreliance. Current evidence presents a mixed picture, indicating both improvements in learner engagement and potential drawbacks such as passivity or susceptibility to misinformation. Without curricular integration that prioritizes ethical use, prompt engineering, and critical evaluation, GenAI may compromise the cognitive autonomy of medical students. Conversely, when thoughtfully embedded into pedagogical frameworks, these tools can act as cognitive enhancers-supporting, rather than replacing, clinical reasoning. Medical education must adapt to ensure that future physicians engage with GenAI in a critical, ethical, and context-aware manner, especially in complex decision-making scenarios. This transformation demands not only technological fluency but also reflective practice and sustained oversight by faculty and academic institutions. ©Juan S Izquierdo-Condoy, Marlon Arias-Intriago, Andrea Tello-De-la-Torre, Felix Busch, Esteban Ortiz-Prado. Originally published in the Journal of Medical Internet Research (https://www.jmir.org), 03.11.2025.

DOI: 10.2196/76340

Open source ↗
Consensus

Developing a national undergraduate medical education pain management and substance use disorder curriculum to address the opioid crisis: a program evaluation pilot study

N. Dalgarno, J. Turnnidge, N. Cofie, J. Mulder, F. Kirby, A. Hastings-Truelove, L. Graves · 2024 · BMC Medical Education

Background: Pain and addiction are one of the most common reasons for adults to seek health care, yet educational programs focused on pain are often underrepresented in medical school curricula. In January 2021, the Association of Faculties of Medicine of Canada (AFMC) launched an online national, …

Read paper details

N. Dalgarno, J. Turnnidge, N. Cofie, J. Mulder, F. Kirby, A. Hastings-Truelove, L. Graves

Background: Pain and addiction are one of the most common reasons for adults to seek health care, yet educational programs focused on pain are often underrepresented in medical school curricula. In January 2021, the Association of Faculties of Medicine of Canada (AFMC) launched an online national, bilingual, competency-based curriculum for undergraduate medical (UGME) students in pain management and substance use in response to the opioid crisis and to bridge the content gaps in programs across Canada. The purpose of this study is to evaluate the pilot of this national curriculum. Methods: UGME students, from across Canada, participated in the program evaluation by completing online pre- and post-program surveys that assessed the influence of the curriculum on participants' knowledge as well as the value, usability, and feasibility of this curriculum. Results: Participants' perceived confidence in their new knowledge and in utilizing resources required to maintain their knowledge significantly increased (75% and 51% respectively). Their perceived knowledge that addressed the 72 learning objectives within the curriculum significantly increased from pre- to post-program. Over 90% of participants reported that the curriculum was valuable, feasible, and usable. The most frequently discussed program strengths were the clear and comprehensive content, interactive and well-organized design, and relevance of curriculum content for future clinical practice. The overall weakness of the curriculum included the length, repetition of content, the lack of clarity and relevance of the assessment questions, end-user technology issues, and French translation discrepancies. Participant's recommendations for improving the curriculum included streamlining content, addressing technology issues, and enhancing the clarity and relevance of assessment questions embedded within each of the modules. Conclusion: Participants agreed that an online pain management and substance use curriculum is a valuable, usable, and feasible learning opportunity. Given the severity of the opioid crisis in Canada, these online modules provide a curriculum that can be integrated into existing UGME programs or can provide self-directed learning. © 2024. The Author(s).

DOI: 10.1186/s12909-024-05181-z

Open source ↗
Consensus

Applications, Challenges, and Prospects of Generative Artificial Intelligence Empowering Medical Education: Scoping Review

Yu-Hang Lin, Zhi-Heng Luo, Zi-Cheng Ye, Nuo-Xi Zhong, Li-Jian Zhao, Long Zhang, Xiaolan Li, Ze-Tao … · 2025 · JMIR Medical Education

Background: Nowadays, generative artificial intelligence (GAI) drives medical education toward enhanced intelligence, personalization, and interactivity. With its vast generative abilities and diverse applications, GAI redefines how educational resources are accessed, teaching methods are implement…

Read paper details

Yu-Hang Lin, Zhi-Heng Luo, Zi-Cheng Ye, Nuo-Xi Zhong, Li-Jian Zhao, Long Zhang, Xiaolan Li, Ze-Tao Chen, Yijia Chen

Background: Nowadays, generative artificial intelligence (GAI) drives medical education toward enhanced intelligence, personalization, and interactivity. With its vast generative abilities and diverse applications, GAI redefines how educational resources are accessed, teaching methods are implemented, and assessments are conducted. Objective: This study aimed to review the current applications of GAI in medical education; analyze its opportunities and challenges; identify its strengths and potential issues in educational methods, assessments, and resources; and capture GAI's rapid evolution and multidimensional applications in medical education, thereby providing a theoretical foundation for future practice. Methods: This scoping review used PubMed, Web of Science, and Scopus to analyze literature from January 2023 to October 2024, focusing on GAI applications in medical education. Following PRISMA-ScR (Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses Extension for Scoping Reviews) guidelines, 5991 articles were retrieved, with 1304 duplicates removed. The 2-stage screening (title or abstract and full-text review) excluded 4564 articles and a supplementary search included 8 articles, yielding 131 studies for final synthesis. We included (1) studies addressing GAI's applications, challenges, or future directions in medical education, (2) empirical research, systematic reviews, and meta-analyses, and (3) English-language articles. We excluded commentaries, editorials, viewpoints, perspectives, short reports, or communications with low levels of evidence, non-GAI technologies, and studies centered on other fields of medical education (eg, nursing). We integrated quantitative analysis of publication trends and Human Development Index (HDI) with thematic analysis of applications, technical limitations, and ethical implications. Results: Analysis of 131 articles revealed that 74.0% (n=97) originated from countries or regions with very high HDI, with the United States contributing the most (n=33); 14.5% (n=19) were from high HDI countries, 5.3% (n=7) from medium HDI countries, and 2.2% (n=3) from low HDI countries, with 3.8% (n=5) involving cross-HDI collaborations. ChatGPT was the most studied GAI model (n=119), followed by Gemini (n=22), Copilot (n=11), Claude (n=6), and LLaMA (n=4). Thematic analysis indicated that GAI applications in medical education mainly embody the diversification of educational methods, scientific evaluation of educational assessments, and dynamic optimization of educational resources. However, it also highlighted current limitations and potential future challenges, including insufficient scene adaptability, data quality and information bias, overreliance, and ethical controversies. Conclusions: GAI application in medical education exhibits significant regional disparities in development, and model research statistics reflect researchers' certain usage preferences. GAI holds potential for empowering medical education, but widespread adoption requires overcoming complex technical and ethical challenges. Grounded in symbiotic agency theory, we advocate establishing the resource-method-assessment tripartite model, developing specialized models and constructing an integrated system of general large language models incorporating specialized ones, promoting resource sharing, refining ethical governance, and building an educational ecosystem fostering human-machine symbiosis, enabling deep tech-humanism integration and advancing medical education toward greater efficiency and human-centeredness. © Yuhang Lin, Zhiheng Luo, Zicheng Ye, Nuoxi Zhong, Lijian Zhao, Long Zhang, Xiaolan Li, Zetao Chen, Yijia Chen. Originally published in JMIR Medical Education (https://mededu.jmir.org).

DOI: 10.2196/71125

Open source ↗

Disagreements & Limitations

Disagreements

  • No major disagreement identified.

Limitations

  • No primary research exists on MHPE scholars specifically; all inferences are extrapolated from broader HPE or undergraduate samples.
  • Most included studies are perception-based (e.g., surveys, viewpoints); few examine actual behavior or longitudinal impacts on autonomy.
  • Several key papers are truncated (e.g., C223, C226, C229), limiting full assessment of findings on learner agency.
  • Theoretical framing of 'autonomy' varies; few studies define or measure it explicitly, making synthesis difficult.
  • Omitted evidence (4 papers excluded per context limits) might contain relevant data, but cannot be assessed.

Sources

[C223] A scoping review of the use of generative artificial intelligence tools in health profession education

BMC Medical Education · 2026 · DOI: 10.1186/s12909-025-08527-3

Open source
[C224] Humanizing AI training for health professions educators

Medical Teacher · 2025 · DOI: 10.1080/0142159x.2025.2522237

Open source
[C225] Using Chat Generative Pre-Trained Transformer for teaching and learning: A survey among health professions educators

Journal of the Colleges of Medicine of South Africa · 2026 · DOI: 10.4102/jcmsa.v4i1.442

Open source
[C226] The impact of generative AI on health professional education: A systematic review in the context of student learning

Medical Education · 2025 · DOI: 10.1111/medu.15746

Open source
[C227] Leveraging Generative Artificial Intelligence to Improve Motivation and Retrieval in Higher Education Learners

JMIR Medical Education · 2024 · DOI: 10.2196/59210

Open source
[C228] Preparing for Artificial General Intelligence (AGI) in Health Professions Education: AMEE Guide No. 172

Medical Teacher · 2024 · DOI: 10.1080/0142159x.2024.2387802

Open source
[C229] AI-Assisted Formative Assessment in Clinical Education: From Algorithms to Agency

JMIR Medical Education · 2026 · DOI: 10.2196/93710

Open source
[C230] A systematic review of the impact of artificial intelligence on educational outcomes in health professions education

BMC Medical Education · 2025 · DOI: 10.1186/s12909-025-06719-5

Open source
View Detailed Research
Developer Diagnostics

PRODUCTION MODE

Research Planners

Planner 1 — Gemini 3.5 Flash
google/gemini-3.5-flash

Planner 2 — Llama 4 Scout
meta-llama/llama-4-scout

Planner 3 — Qwen3.5-27B
qwen/qwen3.5-27b

Retrieval

Semantic Scholar: Enabled
API key: Not configured (public access)

Consensus: Enabled

Synthesizer

qwen/qwen3-max
qwen/qwen3-max

Credential readiness

OpenRouter: Configured

Consensus: Configured

Manual evaluation cases and results
Individual AI responses

AI Agent Research

Independent model outputs. Planners propose searches and hypotheses, not evidence. Citations and confidence in historical answers are model-reported and unverified.

Experiences of learning autonomy among Master of Health Professions Education Scholars using Generative AI

Completed

Research finished. Any provider failures are shown in their sections.

Planner 1 — Gemini 3.5 Flash google/gemini-3.5-flash View response

Problem interpretation

This query explores the experiences of Master of Health Professions Education (MHPE) scholars as they navigate learner autonomy while integrating generative artificial intelligence tools into their academic and professional development.

Search queries (not evidence)

  • ("health professions education" OR "MHPE") AND "generative AI" AND "autonomy"
  • "Master of Health Professions Education" AND ("ChatGPT" OR "generative artificial intelligence") AND "self-directed learning"
  • "medical education" AND "generative AI" AND ("learner autonomy" OR "agency")
Planner diagnostics
problem_interpretation
This query explores the experiences of Master of Health Professions Education (MHPE) scholars as they navigate learner autonomy while integrating generative artificial intelligence tools into their academic and professional development.
research_questions
['How do MHPE scholars experience and describe their learning autonomy when using generative AI tools?', 'In what ways does generative AI enhance or constrain self-directed learning among postgraduate health professions education students?', 'What challenges do MHPE students face regarding academic agency and intellectual independence when co-creating knowledge with AI?']
search_queries
['("health professions education" OR "MHPE") AND "generative AI" AND "autonomy"', '"Master of Health Professions Education" AND ("ChatGPT" OR "generative artificial intelligence") AND "self-directed learning"', '"medical education" AND "generative AI" AND ("learner autonomy" OR "agency")']
keywords
['learning autonomy', 'generative AI', 'health professions education', 'MHPE', 'self-directed learning']
synonyms
['learner autonomy', 'generative artificial intelligence', 'large language models', 'postgraduate medical education', 'student agency']
population_terms
['Master of Health Professions Education scholars', 'MHPE students', 'health professions education scholars', 'postgraduate medical education students']
intervention_or_exposure_terms
['generative AI', 'ChatGPT', 'large language models', 'artificial intelligence tools']
outcome_terms
['learner autonomy', 'self-directed learning', 'student agency', 'academic independence', 'self-regulation']
possible_research_gaps
['Potential shifts in critical reflection patterns among educators who use AI for thesis drafting.', 'Long-term effects of AI reliance on the self-efficacy of health professions education researchers.']
uncertainties
['The variability of AI literacy among MHPE scholars and its impact on autonomous learning experiences.', "How academic integrity frameworks influence scholars' comfort with using AI autonomously."]
suggested_filters
{'year_from': 2022, 'year_to': 2025, 'fields': ['Medical Education', 'Educational Technology', 'Higher Education', 'Health Sciences'], 'study_types': ['Qualitative Study', 'Phenomenology', 'Case Study', 'Mixed Methods']}

Self-reported confidence: Not assessed

Citations

  • No sources supplied by this model.
Planner 2 — Llama 4 Scout meta-llama/llama-4-scout Failed

OpenRouter rate-limited this request. Please try again later.

Planner 3 — Qwen3.5-27B qwen/qwen3.5-27b Failed

The model reached its output limit before finishing the response.

Full Academic Evidence

Academic Evidence

Academic papers retrieved from the providers below, shown separately from model outputs. Provider metadata is retained; a retrieved paper is not automatically proof of a claim.

Experiences of learning autonomy among Master of Health Professions Education Scholars using Generative AI

consensus

12 unique papers found in this response

The impact of generative AI on health professional education: A systematic review in the context of student learning 2025 · systematic review

Thai Duong Pham, N. Karunaratne, Betty Exintaris, Danny Liu, Travis Lay, E. Yuriev, Angelina S Lim

Background: Generative Artificial Intelligence (GenAI) is increasingly integrated into health professions education (HPE), offering new opportunities for student learning. However, current research lacks a comprehensive understanding of how HPE students actually use GenAI in practice. Laurillard's Conversational Framework outlines six learning types-acquisition, inquiry, practice, production, discussion and collaboration-commonly used to categorise learning activities supported by conventional and digital technologies. Gaining insight into how GenAI aligns with these six learning types could assist HPE academics in integrating it more thoughtfully and effectively into teaching and learning. Purpose: This systematic review investigates how HPE students utilise GenAI and examines how these uses align with Laurillard's six learning types compared to conventional and digital technologies. Material and methods: A systematic review searching five major databases-ERIC, Education Database, …

DOI: 10.1111/medu.15746

Open source ↗
Preparing for Artificial General Intelligence (AGI) in Health Professions Education: AMEE Guide No. 172 2024 · other

K. Masters, Anne Herrmann-Werner, T. Festl-Wietek, D. Taylor

Generative Artificial Intelligence (GenAI) caught Health Professions Education (HPE) institutions off-guard, and they are currently adjusting to a changed educational environment. On the horizon, however, is Artificial General Intelligence (AGI) which promises to be an even greater leap and challenge. This Guide begins by explaining the context and nature of AGI, including its characteristics of multi-modality, generality, adaptability, autonomy, and learning ability. It then explores the implications of AGI on students (including personalised learning and electronic tutors) and HPE institutions, and considers some of the context provided by AGI in healthcare. It then raises the problems to address, including the impact on employment, social risks, student adaptability, costs, quality, and others. After considering a possible timeline, the Guide then ends by indicating some first steps that HPE institutions and educators can take to prepare for AGI.

DOI: 10.1080/0142159x.2024.2387802

Open source ↗
A scoping review of the use of generative artificial intelligence tools in health profession education 2026 · systematic review

M. Basil, W. Ahmed, J. Strawbridge, M. Lynch, B. Mukhalalati

BACKGROUND: Generative Artificial Intelligence (GenAI) is one of the leading innovations that is expected to reshape society for decades to come. Health professions education (HPE) programs are expected to prepare graduates with adequate knowledge and skills to provide high-quality patient-centered care. Although the use of GenAI in health professions is increasing, its optimal integration in HPE is still ambiguous. This scoping review aims to synthesize currently available literature regarding the use of GenAI in health professions education. METHOD: This scoping review is conducted following JBI methodology for scoping reviews framework 2020 and aligned with PRISMA-ScR. A systematic and comprehensive search was conducted in PubMed, ERIC, CINAHL, Embase, Scopus, Cochrane Library, and ProQuest Central with no language restrictions. The identified evidence was screened and extracted using Covidence software. Publications on the integration of GenAI in undergraduate or graduate health p…

DOI: 10.1186/s12909-025-08527-3

Open source ↗
Humanizing AI training for health professions educators 2025 · other

Jerusalem Merkebu, Anita Samuel

What was the educational challenge?: Health professions educators grapple with profound emotional burdens-technology-related distress, gnawing self-doubt, and a chilling fear of obsolescence-when urged to integrate generative AI (GenAI) into their teaching. Prevailing faculty development often overlooks this critical affective dimension, focusing on technical skills while leaving anxieties unaddressed. What was the solution?: A six-week course, 'AI in Health Professions Education,' was developed, grounded in empathetic course design and trauma-informed pedagogy, to create a supportive and safe learning environment. How was the solution implemented?: Core principles of safety, transparency, collaboration, and empowerment were woven into the course. This involved validating initial emotional responses, fostering psychological safety for experimentation, instructor transparency about AI use and their own anxieties, and offering learners a choice to restore agency. What lessons were le…

DOI: 10.1080/0142159x.2025.2522237

Open source ↗
A systematic review of the impact of artificial intelligence on educational outcomes in health professions education 2025 · systematic review

Eva Feigerlova, Hind Hani, Ellie Hothersall-Davies

Background: Artificial intelligence (AI) has a variety of potential applications in health professions education and assessment; however, measurable educational impacts of AI-based educational strategies on learning outcomes have not been systematically evaluated. Methods: A systematic literature search was conducted using electronic databases (CINAHL Plus, EMBASE, Proquest, Pubmed, Cochrane Library, and Web of Science) to identify studies published until October 1st 2024, analyzing the impact of AI-based tools/interventions in health profession assessment and/or training on educational outcomes. The present analysis follows the PRISMA 2020 statement for systematic reviews and the structured approach to reporting in health care education for evidence synthesis. Results: The final analysis included twelve studies. All were single centers with sample sizes ranging from 4 to 180 participants. Three studies were randomized controlled trials, and seven had a quasi-experimental design. Tw…

DOI: 10.1186/s12909-025-06719-5

Open source ↗
Using Chat Generative Pre-Trained Transformer for teaching and learning: A survey among health professions educators 2026 · cross-sectional study

N. Maharaj, Christolene M. B. Saaiman, D. Hagemeister

Background: Chat Generative Pre-Trained Transformer (ChatGPT) has the potential to transform Health Professions Education (HPE), but its integration into educational practice is likely to be influenced by the knowledge, attitudes and practices of health professions educators. The aim was to assess these educators' knowledge and awareness, attitudes and practices regarding ChatGPT. Methods: A cross-sectional study was conducted at a large teaching hospital using a structured questionnaire. Data were collected and analysed quantitatively to compare responses across professional groups. Results: A convenience sample of 360 healthcare professionals was recruited, comprising medical practitioners (MPs) (46.4%), health and rehabilitation sciences practitioners (HRSP) (13.3%) and nursing practitioners (NP) (40.3%). Most participants (n = 233; 64.9%) were aged 31-50 years and self-identified as female (n = 242; 67.4%). Awareness of ChatGPT was higher among MPs (98.8%) and HRSPs (95.8%), com…

DOI: 10.4102/jcmsa.v4i1.442

Open source ↗
Developing a national undergraduate medical education pain management and substance use disorder curriculum to address the opioid crisis: a program evaluation pilot study 2024 · field study

N. Dalgarno, J. Turnnidge, N. Cofie, J. Mulder, F. Kirby, A. Hastings-Truelove, L. Graves

Background: Pain and addiction are one of the most common reasons for adults to seek health care, yet educational programs focused on pain are often underrepresented in medical school curricula. In January 2021, the Association of Faculties of Medicine of Canada (AFMC) launched an online national, bilingual, competency-based curriculum for undergraduate medical (UGME) students in pain management and substance use in response to the opioid crisis and to bridge the content gaps in programs across Canada. The purpose of this study is to evaluate the pilot of this national curriculum. Methods: UGME students, from across Canada, participated in the program evaluation by completing online pre- and post-program surveys that assessed the influence of the curriculum on participants' knowledge as well as the value, usability, and feasibility of this curriculum. Results: Participants' perceived confidence in their new knowledge and in utilizing resources required to maintain their knowledge si…

DOI: 10.1186/s12909-024-05181-z

Open source ↗
Generative Artificial Intelligence in Medical Education: Enhancing Critical Thinking or Undermining Cognitive Autonomy? 2025

J. Izquierdo-Condoy, Marlon Arias-Intriago, Andrea Tello-De-la-Torre, F. Busch, E. Ortíz-Prado

Generative artificial intelligence (GenAI) enables the production of coherent and contextually relevant text by processing large-scale linguistic datasets. Tools such as ChatGPT, Gemini, Claude, and LLaMA are increasingly integrated into medical education, assisting students with a range of tasks, including clinical reasoning, literature review, scientific writing, and formative assessment. Although these tools offer significant advantages in terms of productivity, personalization, and cognitive support, their impact on critical thinking-a cornerstone of medical education-remains uncertain. The aim of this viewpoint paper is to critically assess the influence of GenAI on critical thinking within medical training, examining both its potential to enhance cognitive skills and the risks it poses to cognitive autonomy. Users have reported increased efficiency and improved linguistic output; however, concerns have also been raised regarding the risk of cognitive overreliance. Current eviden…

DOI: 10.2196/76340

Open source ↗
Applications, Challenges, and Prospects of Generative Artificial Intelligence Empowering Medical Education: Scoping Review 2025 · systematic review

Yu-Hang Lin, Zhi-Heng Luo, Zi-Cheng Ye, Nuo-Xi Zhong, Li-Jian Zhao, Long Zhang, Xiaolan Li, Ze-Tao Chen, Yijia Chen

Background: Nowadays, generative artificial intelligence (GAI) drives medical education toward enhanced intelligence, personalization, and interactivity. With its vast generative abilities and diverse applications, GAI redefines how educational resources are accessed, teaching methods are implemented, and assessments are conducted. Objective: This study aimed to review the current applications of GAI in medical education; analyze its opportunities and challenges; identify its strengths and potential issues in educational methods, assessments, and resources; and capture GAI's rapid evolution and multidimensional applications in medical education, thereby providing a theoretical foundation for future practice. Methods: This scoping review used PubMed, Web of Science, and Scopus to analyze literature from January 2023 to October 2024, focusing on GAI applications in medical education. Following PRISMA-ScR (Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses Extension for…

DOI: 10.2196/71125

Open source ↗
Scaffolding for success: Blending learning with and about Generative AI in medical education 2025 · theoretical, modeling, or simulation study

M. Boman, Paul Jhun, Mike Schaekermann

The emergence of Generative AI (GenAI) presents both vast opportunities and profound challenges for medical education. To ensure its effective and ethically sound adoption, educators, institutions, and policy-makers must look beyond efficiency gains to foster deeper, resilient learning catalyzed by productive struggle: deliberate engagement with complex issues that promotes critical thinking. We conducted a conceptual analysis exploring two intertwined dimensions: using GenAI as a pedagogical tool ('AI in Education') and teaching foundational understanding of AI itself ('Education in AI'). We mapped GenAI's affordances-expressivity, interactivity, multimodality-to educational experiences such as interactive tutoring, OSCE feedback, and simulated patient interactions. We then critically examined implications for curriculum design and learner competencies. We found that GenAI's simultaneous increase in helpfulness and complexity forces convergence of the two educational dimensions. Whil…

DOI: 10.1080/0142159x.2025.2571041

Open source ↗
Leveraging Generative Artificial Intelligence to Improve Motivation and Retrieval in Higher Education Learners 2024 · other

Noahlana Monzon, Franklin A. Hays

Unlabelled: Generative artificial intelligence (GenAI) presents novel approaches to enhance motivation, curriculum structure and development, and learning and retrieval processes for both learners and instructors. Though a focus for this emerging technology is academic misconduct, we sought to leverage GenAI in curriculum structure to facilitate educational outcomes. For instructors, GenAI offers new opportunities in course design and management while reducing time requirements to evaluate outcomes and personalizing learner feedback. These include innovative instructional designs such as flipped classrooms and gamification, enriching teaching methodologies with focused and interactive approaches, and team-based exercise development among others. For learners, GenAI offers unprecedented self-directed learning opportunities, improved cognitive engagement, and effective retrieval practices, leading to enhanced autonomy, motivation, and knowledge retention. Though empowering, this evolvin…

DOI: 10.2196/59210

Open source ↗
AI-Assisted Formative Assessment in Clinical Education: From Algorithms to Agency 2026

Q. T. Nguyen, Thuy Minh Ha, Tina Mai

Unlabelled: Artificial intelligence (AI) is rapidly reshaping clinical education by embedding assessment and feedback into everyday learning activities. Medical students can now use machine learning dashboards, generative AI, large language models, and emerging agentic systems to practice clinical reasoning, communication, and procedural skills while receiving individualized feedback within seconds. However, the availability of more data and more feedback does not necessarily produce better learning. This Viewpoint is intended for clinical educators, assessment leaders, curriculum committees, faculty developers, and institutional leaders who must decide how AI should be used in formative activities without reducing education to automated scoring. AI-assisted formative assessment is defined in this paper as the intentional use of AI tools to generate, organize, and support interpretation of performance information for learning rather than grading. Its distinctive contribution lies in t…

DOI: 10.2196/93710

Open source ↗

semantic_scholar

Semantic Scholar retrieval failed (rate_limit).

semantic_scholar unavailable

Semantic Scholar retrieval failed (rate_limit).

Judge/Synthesizer details

Final Research Answer

Experiences of learning autonomy among Master of Health Professions Education Scholars using Generative AI

There is currently no direct empirical evidence on the experiences of learning autonomy among Master of Health Professions Education (MHPE) scholars using generative AI. However, related literature suggests plausible dynamics. Studies indicate that generative AI can enhance self-directed learning by supporting inquiry, practice, and knowledge production [C226], and may improve learner autonomy through personalized feedback and retrieval support [C227]. Yet concerns persist about reduced critical thinking, overreliance, and threats to intellectual independence [C225]. Faculty development efforts emphasizing psychological safety and learner agency show that affective dimensions—such as fear of obsolescence—can undermine autonomous engagement with AI unless explicitly addressed [C224]. A significant gap remains in understanding how postgraduate HPE students, particularly MHPE scholars, navigate autonomy when co-creating academic work with AI. Three potential thesis topics emerge: 1. **Exploring shifts in critical reflection among MHPE students using AI for thesis writing**: This matters because reflective capacity is central to educator development. Existing literature notes AI’s role in production and inquiry [C226] but not its impact on scholarly metacognition. An unresolved question is whether AI use alters depth or authenticity of reflection. Population: MHPE candidates. Variables: AI tool usage frequency, reflective quality (analyzed via portfolio), self-efficacy. Method: Qualitative interviews + document analysis. Feasible given small cohort sizes and existing MHPE program structures. Supported by [C224, C226, C229]. 2. **AI literacy as a moderator of autonomous learning in MHPE**: Important because unequal AI preparedness may exacerbate disparities in academic agency. Surveys show varied awareness across health professionals [C225], but no studies focus on postgraduate educators. Unresolved: How baseline AI literacy shapes confidence, strategy selection, and perceived control. Population: Enrolled MHPE students. Variables: AI literacy (pre-survey), autonomy indicators (self-report + behavioral logs). Method: Mixed methods sequential design. Feasible with institutional collaboration. Supported by [C225, C227]. 3. **Tensions between institutional AI policies and student agency in MHPE programs**: Matters because policy ambiguity may constrain authentic autonomous use. No current studies examine how academic integrity frameworks influence MHPE scholars’ willingness to experiment with AI. Unresolved: How formal vs. informal norms shape disclosure and innovation. Population: MHPE students and faculty. Variables: Policy clarity, perceived autonomy, actual usage patterns. Method: Case study across 2–3 institutions. Feasible via program partnerships. Supported by [C224, C228].

Current literature confirms growing integration of generative AI in health professions education (HPE), with applications in content creation, personalized learning, and formative assessment. However, no studies specifically examine learning autonomy among Master of Health Professions Education (MHPE) scholars. Indirect evidence suggests generative AI can both support self-directed learning—through enhanced inquiry, practice, and feedback—and threaten intellectual independence due to concerns about plagiarism, reduced critical thinking, and epistemic overtrust. Emotional and policy-related barriers, such as fear of obsolescence and ambiguous academic integrity guidelines, further complicate autonomous engagement. While perception studies report generally positive attitudes, actual usage remains low and under-theorized in postgraduate HPE contexts. Rigorous qualitative research focusing on MHPE students is needed to understand how generative AI reshapes their sense of agency, critical reflection, and scholarly identity.

Confidence: 45/100

The synthesizer's estimate, not a statistical probability. Evidence strength is shown for each finding.

Key Findings

Moderate evidence

Generative AI supports self-directed learning in HPE through inquiry, practice, and production activities.

A systematic review found GenAI most commonly used for practice (73%), inquiry (70%), and production (67%) among HPE students, indicating alignment with autonomous learning modes [C226]. Another paper highlights GenAI’s role in enabling 'unprecedented self-directed learning opportunities' and improved cognitive engagement [C227].

Support review: academically_supported

Diagnostic source association and simple English word overlap only; not verification of truth, study quality or entailment.

Diagnostic evidence strength: moderate. Judge-declared strength: moderate.

Supporting sources selected by synthesizer

A source association is not proof that the source supports this claim. Review the source text and its limitations.

[C226] The impact of generative AI on health professional education: A systematic review in the context of student learning · Medical Education · 2025 · DOI: 10.1111/medu.15746 Open source

[C227] Leveraging Generative Artificial Intelligence to Improve Motivation and Retrieval in Higher Education Learners · JMIR Medical Education · 2024 · DOI: 10.2196/59210 Open source

Moderate evidence

Concerns about reduced critical thinking and academic integrity may constrain learner autonomy with AI.

A survey of health professions educators found 64.5% worried that ChatGPT reduces independent thinking, and 78% cited plagiarism risks [C225]. Similarly, Nguyen et al. warn of 'epistemic overtrust' and automation bias undermining critical interpretation of AI outputs [C229].

Support review: academically_supported

Diagnostic source association and simple English word overlap only; not verification of truth, study quality or entailment.

Diagnostic evidence strength: moderate. Judge-declared strength: moderate.

Supporting sources selected by synthesizer

A source association is not proof that the source supports this claim. Review the source text and its limitations.

[C225] Using Chat Generative Pre-Trained Transformer for teaching and learning: A survey among health professions educators · Journal of the Colleges of Medicine of South Africa · 2026 · DOI: 10.4102/jcmsa.v4i1.442 Open source

[C229] AI-Assisted Formative Assessment in Clinical Education: From Algorithms to Agency · JMIR Medical Education · 2026 · DOI: 10.2196/93710 Open source

Limited evidence

Affective factors like fear and lack of psychological safety can inhibit autonomous AI use among educators.

Merkebu & Samuel describe how health professions educators experience 'technology-related distress' and 'fear of obsolescence,' which impede AI adoption unless addressed through empathetic, agency-restoring pedagogy [C224]. This applies plausibly to MHPE scholars as emerging educators.

Support review: weak_support

Diagnostic source association and simple English word overlap only; not verification of truth, study quality or entailment.

Diagnostic evidence strength: limited. Judge-declared strength: limited.

Supporting sources selected by synthesizer

A source association is not proof that the source supports this claim. Review the source text and its limitations.

[C224] Humanizing AI training for health professions educators · Medical Teacher · 2025 · DOI: 10.1080/0142159x.2025.2522237 Open source

Limited evidence

Actual AI usage in HPE remains low despite high interest and access.

Maharaj et al. report only 34.9% of health professionals currently use ChatGPT, with just 19% trained, despite 81.7% having easy access and 92.5% requesting training [C225]. This gap suggests autonomy may be limited by competence rather than opportunity.

Support review: weak_support

Diagnostic source association and simple English word overlap only; not verification of truth, study quality or entailment.

Diagnostic evidence strength: limited. Judge-declared strength: limited.

Supporting sources selected by synthesizer

A source association is not proof that the source supports this claim. Review the source text and its limitations.

[C225] Using Chat Generative Pre-Trained Transformer for teaching and learning: A survey among health professions educators · Journal of the Colleges of Medicine of South Africa · 2026 · DOI: 10.4102/jcmsa.v4i1.442 Open source

Strong evidence

No studies specifically investigate MHPE students’ experiences of learning autonomy with generative AI.

All retrieved papers focus on undergraduate students, practicing clinicians, or general faculty; none mention MHPE scholars or analogous postgraduate HPE researchers. Scoping reviews explicitly note under-exploration of curriculum design and GenAI literacy in graduate contexts [C223].

Support review: academically_supported

Diagnostic source association and simple English word overlap only; not verification of truth, study quality or entailment.

Diagnostic evidence strength: strong. Judge-declared strength: strong.

Supporting sources selected by synthesizer

A source association is not proof that the source supports this claim. Review the source text and its limitations.

[C223] A scoping review of the use of generative artificial intelligence tools in health profession education · BMC Medical Education · 2026 · DOI: 10.1186/s12909-025-08527-3 Open source

[C225] Using Chat Generative Pre-Trained Transformer for teaching and learning: A survey among health professions educators · Journal of the Colleges of Medicine of South Africa · 2026 · DOI: 10.4102/jcmsa.v4i1.442 Open source

[C226] The impact of generative AI on health professional education: A systematic review in the context of student learning · Medical Education · 2025 · DOI: 10.1111/medu.15746 Open source

Sources

  1. [C223] A scoping review of the use of generative artificial intelligence tools in health profession education

    BMC Medical Education · 2026

    DOI: 10.1186/s12909-025-08527-3

    Open source ↗
  2. [C224] Humanizing AI training for health professions educators

    Medical Teacher · 2025

    DOI: 10.1080/0142159x.2025.2522237

    Open source ↗
  3. [C225] Using Chat Generative Pre-Trained Transformer for teaching and learning: A survey among health professions educators

    Journal of the Colleges of Medicine of South Africa · 2026

    DOI: 10.4102/jcmsa.v4i1.442

    Open source ↗
  4. [C226] The impact of generative AI on health professional education: A systematic review in the context of student learning

    Medical Education · 2025

    DOI: 10.1111/medu.15746

    Open source ↗
  5. [C227] Leveraging Generative Artificial Intelligence to Improve Motivation and Retrieval in Higher Education Learners

    JMIR Medical Education · 2024

    DOI: 10.2196/59210

    Open source ↗
  6. [C228] Preparing for Artificial General Intelligence (AGI) in Health Professions Education: AMEE Guide No. 172

    Medical Teacher · 2024

    DOI: 10.1080/0142159x.2024.2387802

    Open source ↗
  7. [C229] AI-Assisted Formative Assessment in Clinical Education: From Algorithms to Agency

    JMIR Medical Education · 2026

    DOI: 10.2196/93710

    Open source ↗
  8. [C230] A systematic review of the impact of artificial intelligence on educational outcomes in health professions education

    BMC Medical Education · 2025

    DOI: 10.1186/s12909-025-06719-5

    Open source ↗

Agreements / Disagreements

Agreement between AI models is not independent verification.

No disagreements were reported by the synthesizer.

Limitations

  • No primary research exists on MHPE scholars specifically; all inferences are extrapolated from broader HPE or undergraduate samples.
  • Most included studies are perception-based (e.g., surveys, viewpoints); few examine actual behavior or longitudinal impacts on autonomy.
  • Several key papers are truncated (e.g., C223, C226, C229), limiting full assessment of findings on learner agency.
  • Theoretical framing of 'autonomy' varies; few studies define or measure it explicitly, making synthesis difficult.
  • Omitted evidence (4 papers excluded per context limits) might contain relevant data, but cannot be assessed.

Recommended interpretation

Provisional and indirect

Evidence preparation details

Priority scores organize the context; they do not decide the answer.

C223 · Priority

C224 · Priority

C225 · Priority

C226 · Priority

C227 · Priority

C228 · Priority

C229 · Priority

C230 · Priority

Omitted papers: 4. Omitted agents: .

Retry controls

Experiences of learning autonomy among Master of Health Professions Education Scholars using Generative AI

Stage: PARTIAL

Partial research available. Review failures below; retry controls are available.

Latest Planner 2 — Llama 4 Scout attempt failed: OpenRouter rate-limited this request. Please try again later. Any earlier successful result remains active.

Latest Planner 3 — Qwen3.5-27B attempt failed: The model reached its output limit before finishing the response. Any earlier successful result remains active.

Latest semantic_scholar attempt failed: Semantic Scholar retrieval failed (rate_limit). Any earlier successful result remains active.

Retries make new API requests and may incur charges. Provider retries preserve the accepted answer; re-run synthesis afterward to incorporate changed evidence.

Provider attempt history (5)

Active means the latest successful attempt. A newer failure does not replace it.

#79 · semantic_scholar · academic-graph-search · Sept. 29, 2026, 5:20 a.m. · Latest · Failed

Semantic Scholar retrieval failed (rate_limit).

This attempt is displayed in the semantic_scholar results above.

#78 · consensus · search-v1 · Sept. 29, 2026, 5:20 a.m. · Latest · Active · Succeeded

This attempt is displayed in the consensus results above.

#77 · Planner 3 — Qwen3.5-27B · qwen/qwen3.5-27b · Sept. 29, 2026, 5:20 a.m. · Latest · Failed

The model reached its output limit before finishing the response.

This attempt is displayed in the Planner 3 — Qwen3.5-27B results above.

#76 · Planner 2 — Llama 4 Scout · meta-llama/llama-4-scout · Sept. 29, 2026, 5:19 a.m. · Latest · Failed

OpenRouter rate-limited this request. Please try again later.

This attempt is displayed in the Planner 2 — Llama 4 Scout results above.

#75 · Planner 1 — Gemini 3.5 Flash · google/gemini-3.5-flash · Sept. 29, 2026, 5:19 a.m. · Latest · Active · Succeeded

This attempt is displayed in the Planner 1 — Gemini 3.5 Flash results above.

Synthesis history (1)
#14 · qwen/qwen3-max · Sept. 29, 2026, 5:20 a.m. · Succeeded · Latest · Active / latest accepted

Model: qwen/qwen3-max · Latency: 32337 ms · Estimated cost: 0.0112281000 USD

Input tokens: 6375 · Output tokens: 1604

There is currently no direct empirical evidence on the experiences of learning autonomy among Master of Health Professions Education (MHPE) scholars using generative AI. However, related literature suggests plausible dynamics. Studies indicate that generative AI can enhance self-directed learning by supporting inquiry, practice, and knowledge production [C226], and may improve learner autonomy through personalized feedback and retrieval support [C227]. Yet concerns persist about reduced critical thinking, overreliance, and threats to intellectual independence [C225]. Faculty development efforts emphasizing psychological safety and learner agency show that affective dimensions—such as fear of obsolescence—can undermine autonomous engagement with AI unless explicitly addressed [C224]. A significant gap remains in understanding how postgraduate HPE students, particularly MHPE scholars, navigate autonomy when co-creating academic work with AI. Three potential thesis topics emerge: 1. **Exploring shifts in critical reflection among MHPE students using AI for thesis writing**: This matters because reflective capacity is central to educator development. Existing literature notes AI’s role in production and inquiry [C226] but not its impact on scholarly metacognition. An unresolved question is whether AI use alters depth or authenticity of reflection. Population: MHPE candidates. Variables: AI tool usage frequency, reflective quality (analyzed via portfolio), self-efficacy. Method: Qualitative interviews + document analysis. Feasible given small cohort sizes and existing MHPE program structures. Supported by [C224, C226, C229]. 2. **AI literacy as a moderator of autonomous learning in MHPE**: Important because unequal AI preparedness may exacerbate disparities in academic agency. Surveys show varied awareness across health professionals [C225], but no studies focus on postgraduate educators. Unresolved: How baseline AI literacy shapes confidence, strategy selection, and perceived control. Population: Enrolled MHPE students. Variables: AI literacy (pre-survey), autonomy indicators (self-report + behavioral logs). Method: Mixed methods sequential design. Feasible with institutional collaboration. Supported by [C225, C227]. 3. **Tensions between institutional AI policies and student agency in MHPE programs**: Matters because policy ambiguity may constrain authentic autonomous use. No current studies examine how academic integrity frameworks influence MHPE scholars’ willingness to experiment with AI. Unresolved: How formal vs. informal norms shape disclosure and innovation. Population: MHPE students and faculty. Variables: Policy clarity, perceived autonomy, actual usage patterns. Method: Case study across 2–3 institutions. Feasible via program partnerships. Supported by [C224, C228].

Rejected source IDs: None recorded

Confidence: 45.0

Current literature confirms growing integration of generative AI in health professions education (HPE), with applications in content creation, personalized learning, and formative assessment. However, no studies specifically examine learning autonomy among Master of Health Professions Education (MHPE) scholars. Indirect evidence suggests generative AI can both support self-directed learning—through enhanced inquiry, practice, and feedback—and threaten intellectual independence due to concerns about plagiarism, reduced critical thinking, and epistemic overtrust. Emotional and policy-related barriers, such as fear of obsolescence and ambiguous academic integrity guidelines, further complicate autonomous engagement. While perception studies report generally positive attitudes, actual usage remains low and under-theorized in postgraduate HPE contexts. Rigorous qualitative research focusing on MHPE students is needed to understand how generative AI reshapes their sense of agency, critical reflection, and scholarly identity.

Generative AI supports self-directed learning in HPE through inquiry, practice, and production activities. · moderate

A systematic review found GenAI most commonly used for practice (73%), inquiry (70%), and production (67%) among HPE students, indicating alignment with autonomous learning modes [C226]. Another paper highlights GenAI’s role in enabling 'unprecedented self-directed learning opportunities' and improved cognitive engagement [C227].

Supporting sources selected by synthesizer: C226, C227

Concerns about reduced critical thinking and academic integrity may constrain learner autonomy with AI. · moderate

A survey of health professions educators found 64.5% worried that ChatGPT reduces independent thinking, and 78% cited plagiarism risks [C225]. Similarly, Nguyen et al. warn of 'epistemic overtrust' and automation bias undermining critical interpretation of AI outputs [C229].

Supporting sources selected by synthesizer: C225, C229

Affective factors like fear and lack of psychological safety can inhibit autonomous AI use among educators. · limited

Merkebu & Samuel describe how health professions educators experience 'technology-related distress' and 'fear of obsolescence,' which impede AI adoption unless addressed through empathetic, agency-restoring pedagogy [C224]. This applies plausibly to MHPE scholars as emerging educators.

Supporting sources selected by synthesizer: C224

Actual AI usage in HPE remains low despite high interest and access. · limited

Maharaj et al. report only 34.9% of health professionals currently use ChatGPT, with just 19% trained, despite 81.7% having easy access and 92.5% requesting training [C225]. This gap suggests autonomy may be limited by competence rather than opportunity.

Supporting sources selected by synthesizer: C225

No studies specifically investigate MHPE students’ experiences of learning autonomy with generative AI. · strong

All retrieved papers focus on undergraduate students, practicing clinicians, or general faculty; none mention MHPE scholars or analogous postgraduate HPE researchers. Scoping reviews explicitly note under-exploration of curriculum design and GenAI literacy in graduate contexts [C223].

Supporting sources selected by synthesizer: C223, C225, C226

[C223] A scoping review of the use of generative artificial intelligence tools in health profession education · BMC Medical Education Open source

[C224] Humanizing AI training for health professions educators · Medical Teacher Open source

[C225] Using Chat Generative Pre-Trained Transformer for teaching and learning: A survey among health professions educators · Journal of the Colleges of Medicine of South Africa Open source

[C226] The impact of generative AI on health professional education: A systematic review in the context of student learning · Medical Education Open source

[C227] Leveraging Generative Artificial Intelligence to Improve Motivation and Retrieval in Higher Education Learners · JMIR Medical Education Open source

[C228] Preparing for Artificial General Intelligence (AGI) in Health Professions Education: AMEE Guide No. 172 · Medical Teacher Open source

[C229] AI-Assisted Formative Assessment in Clinical Education: From Algorithms to Agency · JMIR Medical Education Open source

[C230] A systematic review of the impact of artificial intelligence on educational outcomes in health professions education · BMC Medical Education Open source

Agreements:

Disagreements:

Limitations: No primary research exists on MHPE scholars specifically; all inferences are extrapolated from broader HPE or undergraduate samples.; Most included studies are perception-based (e.g., surveys, viewpoints); few examine actual behavior or longitudinal impacts on autonomy.; Several key papers are truncated (e.g., C223, C226, C229), limiting full assessment of findings on learner agency.; Theoretical framing of 'autonomy' varies; few studies define or measure it explicitly, making synthesis difficult.; Omitted evidence (4 papers excluded per context limits) might contain relevant data, but cannot be assessed.

Provisional and indirect

Developer evaluation (manual)

Ratings do not affect synthesis. Rate the active answer and evidence you reviewed.

Developer diagnostics

Balanced primary: qwen/qwen3-max. Fallback: openai/o4-mini.

Fallback triggered: No. Reason: None. Accepted synthesizer: qwen/qwen3-max.

Synthesis routing latency: 32337 ms. Total routing cost (USD): 0.0112281000.

Plan-and-Solve diagnostics

Generated queries: 3; retrieval queries: 3; duplicates removed: 0; unique papers: 12.

semantic_scholar: 1 requests; 0 results; 1 failed requests.

consensus: 3 requests; 12 results; 0 failed requests.

Normalized ResearchPlan
original_question
Experiences of learning autonomy among Master of Health Professions Education Scholars using Generative AI
canonical_search_queries
['("health professions education" OR "MHPE") AND "generative AI" AND "autonomy"', '"Master of Health Professions Education" AND ("ChatGPT" OR "generative artificial intelligence") AND "self-directed learning"', '"medical education" AND "generative AI" AND ("learner autonomy" OR "agency")']
keywords
['learning autonomy', 'generative AI', 'health professions education', 'MHPE', 'self-directed learning']
synonyms
['learner autonomy', 'generative artificial intelligence', 'large language models', 'postgraduate medical education', 'student agency']
research_subquestions
['How do MHPE scholars experience and describe their learning autonomy when using generative AI tools?', 'In what ways does generative AI enhance or constrain self-directed learning among postgraduate health professions education students?', 'What challenges do MHPE students face regarding academic agency and intellectual independence when co-creating knowledge with AI?']
candidate_gap_hypotheses
['Potential shifts in critical reflection patterns among educators who use AI for thesis drafting.', 'Long-term effects of AI reliance on the self-efficacy of health professions education researchers.']
uncertainties
['The variability of AI literacy among MHPE scholars and its impact on autonomous learning experiences.', "How academic integrity frameworks influence scholars' comfort with using AI autonomously."]
filters
{'suggestions': [{'year_from': 2022, 'year_to': 2025, 'fields': ['Medical Education', 'Educational Technology', 'Higher Education', 'Health Sciences'], 'study_types': ['Qualitative Study', 'Phenomenology', 'Case Study', 'Mixed Methods']}], 'policy': 'Advisory only; configured provider filters apply.'}
generated_query_count
3
successful_planners
1

Retrieval is incomplete; absence of results is not proof of absence.

Provider counts describe latest attempts; evidence and answer metrics describe active results. Duration and costs include all attempts, including retries. Cost is USD, OpenRouter only; Consensus billing is not estimated. Unknown is not zero.

total_duration_ms
123247
interrupted_execution_metrics_incomplete
False
successful_providers
2
failed_providers
3
successful_agents
1
consensus_success
True
synthesis_success
True
paper_count
12
total_estimated_openrouter_cost
Unknown / not applicable
known_cost_subtotal
0.0428266000
attempts_missing_cost
1
valid_source_percent
100.0
removed_source_ids
0
agreements_count
0
disagreements_count
0
evidence_strength_distribution
{'moderate': 2, 'limited': 2, 'strong': 1}
judge_confidence
45.0
answer_length
2824
Attempt / modelSuccessLatency msInput / output / total tokensCost USDError
#79 academic-graph-searchNo1057? / ? / ?Unknown rate_limit: Semantic Scholar retrieval failed (rate_limit).
#78 search-v1Yes12710? / ? / ?Unknown :
#77 qwen/qwen3.5-27bNo61215340 / 4096 / 44360.0107380000 reportedmalformed_response: The model reached its output limit before finishing the response.
#76 meta-llama/llama-4-scoutNo1384? / ? / ?Unknown rate_limit: OpenRouter rate-limited this request. Please try again later.
#75 google/gemini-3.5-flashYes143921193 / 2119 / 33120.0208605000 reported:
#14 qwen/qwen3-maxYes323376375 / 1604 / 79790.0112281000 reported:

Judge: qwen/qwen3-max. Papers used: 8. Papers omitted by limit: 4.

Rejected source IDs: None recorded

RESEARCH QUESTION

act as an expert research in mhpe and work on the topic to find the gap relevant in the literature to the title of research proposal,look into the rationale of the study,how is it impactful and justifiable ,how will it add any contribuion to the recent studies and also when there are guidleiens by HEC and UNESCo for usage of generative AI in research work ,extratct relevant articles to cite and identify the gaps in it (atleas 10 article for now),what i sthe actual concept of the whole study with reelavnt justiciation withteh artciles avaiabl.how will teh tudy sample be taken,how the methods will be decided,hw to amke study more impactable ,what are the objectives and what questinnaire can be geenrated from the ttile of the study.

Oct 1, 2026 · 06:31 PARTIAL

30-SECOND VIEW

Final Research Answer

Three viable thesis topics in MHPE on generative AI and research ethics are: (1) Assessing adherence to HEC/UNESCO generative AI guidelines among health professions education researchers in Pakistan—justified by gaps in empirical compliance data [C342, C347], measuring self-reported vs. actual practices using mixed methods; (2) Developing and validating an ethical AI literacy scale for MHPE students—addressing the absence of assessment instruments [C341, C346], using instrument development methodology with Delphi expert input [C347]; (3) Exploring institutional barriers to AI policy implementation in LMIC medical schools—responding to discre…
Read full answer
Three viable thesis topics in MHPE on generative AI and research ethics are: (1) Assessing adherence to HEC/UNESCO generative AI guidelines among health professions education researchers in Pakistan—justified by gaps in empirical compliance data [C342, C347], measuring self-reported vs. actual practices using mixed methods; (2) Developing and validating an ethical AI literacy scale for MHPE students—addressing the absence of assessment instruments [C341, C346], using instrument development methodology with Delphi expert input [C347]; (3) Exploring institutional barriers to AI policy implementation in LMIC medical schools—responding to discrepancies between global guidance and local capacity [C340, C344], via qualitative case studies across multiple institutions. Each topic targets a documented literature gap, aligns with UNESCO/HEC imperatives, uses feasible designs, and can generate actionable policy or curricular recommendations.
Executive summary

Current literature confirms rapid adoption of generative AI in health professions education (HPE) and broader academia, with systematic reviews highlighting its use in student learning [C341], pedagogy [C340], and research workflows [C345]. Ethical concerns around authorship, academic integrity, bias, and hallucinations are widely acknowledged [C342, C346, C347]. International bodies like UNESCO and national regulators like Pakistan’s HEC have issued principles-based guidelines, but empirical studies on actual researcher compliance, validated measurement tools, and contextual implementation barriers—especially in low- and middle-income countries—are scarce. No included paper directly measures HPE researcher adherence to these frameworks or provides standardized instruments for assessing ethical AI literacy. This creates actionable gaps for MHPE research that can inform policy, curriculum, and responsible innovation.

Export Research · coming later

Partial research available

semantic_scholar: Semantic Scholar retrieval failed (rate_limit). Retry

Overall confidence75%Synthesizer confidence estimate
Evidence strengthLimitedLowest reported finding strength; conflicts take precedence
Academic papers24 papers
AI agents3/3 successfulActive saved responses
ConsensusAvailable
Semantic ScholarUnavailable

2-MINUTE VIEW

Key Findings

Strong 1 sources

Generative AI is actively used in health professions education, primarily for individualized learning tasks like practice, inquiry, and content production, but rarely for discussion or collaboration.

Support diagnostic: academically supported

View sources

Generative AI is actively used in health professions education, primarily for individualized learning tasks like practice, inquiry, and content production, but rarely for discussion or collaboration.

A 2025 systematic review of 33 studies mapped HPE student uses of GenAI to Laurillard’s framework, finding high uptake in practice (73%), inquiry (70%), and production (67%) but minimal use in discussion/collaboration (12% each) [C341].

[C341] The impact of generative AI on health professional education: A systematic review in the context of student learning Open source

Strong 3 sources

Major ethical concerns about generative AI include threats to academic integrity, authorship ambiguity, plagiarism risks, and model hallucinations.

Support diagnostic: academically supported

View sources

Major ethical concerns about generative AI include threats to academic integrity, authorship ambiguity, plagiarism risks, and model hallucinations.

Commentaries and reviews consistently identify risks to scholarly authenticity, detection challenges, and conceptual threats to disciplines like ethics and social science [C342, C343, C346]. Bail notes risks of bias, replication failure, and low-quality output proliferation [C343]; Zohny et al. question whether human authorship can be verified [C342].

[C342] Ethics of generative AI Open source

[C343] Can Generative AI improve social science? Open source

[C346] Applications, attitudes and ethical considerations of Generative Artificial Intelligence (Gen AI) in nursing education: a scoping review Open source

Moderate 2 sources

There is a lack of empirically validated tools or standardized protocols to assess researchers’ ethical literacy or compliance with AI guidelines in MHPE.

Support diagnostic: academically supported

View sources

There is a lack of empirically validated tools or standardized protocols to assess researchers’ ethical literacy or compliance with AI guidelines in MHPE.

While UNESCO and HEC provide principles, Cha et al. note the absence of 'actionable research ethics standards' tailored to generative AI’s unique risks [C347]. Hardie et al. call for 'clear policies and guidelines' in nursing education but report none are validated [C346]. No retrieved study offers a psychometrically tested instrument for MHPE contexts.

[C346] Applications, attitudes and ethical considerations of Generative Artificial Intelligence (Gen AI) in nursing education: a scoping review Open source

[C347] Development of research ethics guidelines for healthcare generative artificial intelligence: deriving expert consensus through a Delphi study Open source

Moderate 2 sources

Implementation of generative AI in healthcare and education faces systemic barriers including workforce readiness, data governance, and medico-legal uncertainty.

Support diagnostic: academically supported

View sources

Implementation of generative AI in healthcare and education faces systemic barriers including workforce readiness, data governance, and medico-legal uncertainty.

Reddy applies implementation science frameworks (TAM, NASSS) to show that successful integration requires addressing clinician trust, data privacy, and system interoperability—not just technical capability [C344]. Qian similarly notes tension between AI efficiency and cognitive skill outsourcing in higher education [C340].

[C340] Pedagogical Applications of Generative AI in Higher Education: A Systematic Review of the Field Open source

[C344] Generative AI in healthcare: an implementation science informed translational path on application, integration and governance Open source

Limited 1 sources

Expert consensus can inform practical AI ethics guidelines, with high agreement on documentation, safety, explainability, and human oversight.

Support diagnostic: weak support

View sources

Expert consensus can inform practical AI ethics guidelines, with high agreement on documentation, safety, explainability, and human oversight.

A Delphi study with 35 experts derived consensus on core items like explainable AI, diverse training data, and human-in-the-loop design [C347]. However, this is a single study focused on healthcare research generally, not MHPE specifically.

[C347] Development of research ethics guidelines for healthcare generative artificial intelligence: deriving expert consensus through a Delphi study Open source

Evidence Overview

8 valid sources · 0 conflicting findings · 0 disagreements · 24 papers reviewed

The metrics above describe saved evidence. Source associations and agreement between models are not independent verification.

Best Academic Evidence

Saved synthesis ranking where available; otherwise Consensus order. Retrieved papers are not automatically proof of a claim.

Consensus

Pedagogical Applications of Generative AI in Higher Education: A Systematic Review of the Field

Yu-Feng Qian · 2025 · TechTrends

The release of ChatGPT in late 2022 marked the beginning of a rapid transformation in higher education, soon followed by the development of multimodal generative AI programs. As this technology becomes increasingly integrated into teaching and learning, it is crucial to evaluate its current use and…

Read paper details

Yu-Feng Qian

The release of ChatGPT in late 2022 marked the beginning of a rapid transformation in higher education, soon followed by the development of multimodal generative AI programs. As this technology becomes increasingly integrated into teaching and learning, it is crucial to evaluate its current use and impact. This systematic literature review captures the initial academic response to generative AI, providing insights into how higher education has adopted this transformative technology in its first two years. The findings indicate that while some themes from the pre-ChatGPT era persist, new and emerging trends—particularly in fostering creativity, critical thinking, learning autonomy, and prompt literacy—are now taking shape. This shift underscores a growing emphasis on the pedagogical integration of generative AI. However, the review also highlights a key tension: while generative AI enhances efficiency, it raises concerns about overreliance, potentially leading to the outsourcing of critical cognitive and metacognitive skills. To address these challenges and fully harness the potential of generative AI, future research should focus on exploring multimodal generative AI tools and fostering student–teacher-AI collaboration.

DOI: 10.1007/s11528-025-01100-1

Open source ↗
Consensus

The impact of generative AI on health professional education: A systematic review in the context of student learning

Thai Duong Pham, N. Karunaratne, Betty Exintaris, Danny Liu, Travis Lay, E. Yuriev, Angelina S Lim · 2025 · Medical Education

Background: Generative Artificial Intelligence (GenAI) is increasingly integrated into health professions education (HPE), offering new opportunities for student learning. However, current research lacks a comprehensive understanding of how HPE students actually use GenAI in practice. Laurillard's …

Read paper details

Thai Duong Pham, N. Karunaratne, Betty Exintaris, Danny Liu, Travis Lay, E. Yuriev, Angelina S Lim

Background: Generative Artificial Intelligence (GenAI) is increasingly integrated into health professions education (HPE), offering new opportunities for student learning. However, current research lacks a comprehensive understanding of how HPE students actually use GenAI in practice. Laurillard's Conversational Framework outlines six learning types-acquisition, inquiry, practice, production, discussion and collaboration-commonly used to categorise learning activities supported by conventional and digital technologies. Gaining insight into how GenAI aligns with these six learning types could assist HPE academics in integrating it more thoughtfully and effectively into teaching and learning. Purpose: This systematic review investigates how HPE students utilise GenAI and examines how these uses align with Laurillard's six learning types compared to conventional and digital technologies. Material and methods: A systematic review searching five major databases-ERIC, Education Database, Ovid Medline, Ovid Embase and Scopus including articles on HPE students' use of GenAI until 15th September 2024. Studies were included if they were conducted within formal HPE training programs in HPE and specifically mentioned how students interact with GenAI. Data were mapped to the six learning modes of the Laurillard's Framework. Study quality was assessed using the Medical Education Research Study Quality Instrument (MERSQI). Results: Thirty-three studies met inclusion criteria. GenAI supported learning most frequently in practice (73%), inquiry (70%), production (67%) and acquisition (55%). These studies highlight GenAI's varied educational applications, from clarifying complex concepts to simulating clinical scenarios and generating practice materials. Discussion and collaboration were less represented (12% each), suggesting a shift toward more individualised learning with GenAI. The findings highlight benefits such as efficiency and accessibility, alongside concerns about critical thinking, academic integrity and reduced peer interaction. Conclusion: This review has provided insights into HPE students' learning aligned with Laurillard's existing six learning types. Although GenAI supports personalised and self-directed learning, its role in collaborative modes is under-explored. © 2025 The Author(s). Medical Education published by Association for the Study of Medical Education and John Wiley & Sons Ltd.

DOI: 10.1111/medu.15746

Open source ↗
Consensus

Ethics of generative AI

Hazem Zohny, J. McMillan, M. King · 2023 · Journal of Medical Ethics

Artificial intelligence (AI) and its introduction into clinical pathways presents an array of ethical issues that are being discussed in the JME. The development of AI technologies that can produce text that will pass plagiarism detectors and are capable of appearing to be written by a human author…

Read paper details

Hazem Zohny, J. McMillan, M. King

Artificial intelligence (AI) and its introduction into clinical pathways presents an array of ethical issues that are being discussed in the JME. The development of AI technologies that can produce text that will pass plagiarism detectors and are capable of appearing to be written by a human author present new issues for medical ethics. One set of worries concerns authorship and whether it will now be possible to know that an author or student in fact produced submitted work. That seems likely to be a general worry for secondary and higher education, as well as for all academic journals. Thus far generative AI chatbots do not seem to be able to produce a fully referenced and wellargued ethics article, but they probably could generate a blog or student essay that would be hard to detect after very minor edits. Many schools and universities have moved to online forms of assessment, and it seems likely that generative AI might cast doubt on the integrity of them and we might see a reversion to handwritten examinations as a solution. As well as these immediate and perhaps obvious ethical concerns, generative AI highlights conceptual challenges that pose more profound ethical questions. JME is committed to publishing highquality articles that further the ethical analysis of an issue within healthcare. Some of the content that the journal publishes reports empirical findings. An article that, for example, describes qualitative findings and then develops an analysis of some normative issues could not be solely authored by generative AI: it cannot do qualitative research. However, generative AI can find publicly available sources and produce ethical arguments and syllogisms. What does that imply about the nature of ethical analysis? If ethical analysis, fundamentally, involves assembling, organising and evaluating words, then perhaps generative AI could replace ethicists. At present, generative AI cannot produce the nuance, depth or originality of a quality ethics article, but it may be a matter of time before they pass a medical ethics version of the Turing test. While those who rely on more analytic approaches to ethics might view this as an ethical apocalypse, there are more subtler ways in which generative AI might be used in authorship that are more positive. For instance, if you experiment with ChatGPT for a while, you might find that when you know what you want to say in a paragraph or subsection, you can prompt it to form the argument you want to make and it will generate a fairly welldrafted paragraph. For authors and for postgraduate students, this might be useful for ‘throat clearing’ sections which are just laying the terrain for the reader before proceeding. AI chatbots might also play a helpful devil’s advocate: once you make a point in a paragraph, you can ask it to generate a rebuttal. If you experiment with ChatGPT you might find that it can be helpful in that not only does it generate obvious counters, but it often raises things that you might not have immediately thought of. So perhaps generative AI has the potential to pose questions like those that might be raised at a seminar while a paper or book is being refined. Much of the work involved in writing good, innovative and original ethical analysis involves wrestling with high level ideas. If generative AI can aid authors in drafting articles then perhaps they save intellectual effort that could be directed toward the ‘big picture’? Many publishers, including the BMJ, are committed to encouraging authors from the Global South to write for journals where the authorship has been primarily from the Global North. Publishing in journals such as the JME can be more difficult when English is not an author’s first language. Because of the speed at which generative AI can present an author’s ideas in what is close to idiomatic English, they have the potential to significantly open up authorship, especially for humanities style journals like the JME. Journal and copy editors might also save time and effort when correcting articles. These potential benefits will no doubt come with tradeoffs. For instance, those who struggle to articulate a point in writing may find that to be part of a process that leads to a new insight. Perhaps generative AI runs the risk of making that part of the writing process too easy and lead to missing out on opportunities for insight. While that seems like a valid worry, it might be that this is analogous to the changes in writing that resulted from journals being readily available online. Those of us who are old enough to recall writing before online publishing will have spent time trudging between library stacks and searching hard copies of journals to find a paper and stumbling across other papers and journals, which may have led to new ideas. Complete reliance on online databases has probably reduced those moments but the tradeoff clearly still favours their use. Universities, publishers and journals are likely to be exercised about what this will mean for authorship. How can we know whether work was created by the author or by generative AI? While understandable, these worries might be overstated given what they can do at present. While they might find some publicly available sources to support claims, at present they cannot adequately cite, and the quality of the content they produce is wholly dependent on you asking the right questions or having the right ideas. At present, they can be seen as a very sophisticated thesaurus and we do not worry about authors using those. Perhaps the biggest concern is that some predatory journals may feed off the speed by which lowquality manuscripts can now be generated with AI chatbots, and use the phenomenon to publish huge numbers of mostly useless or misleading ethical analyses. This could flood the journal market and undermine trust in research publications. This may be curbed by introducing the use of AI output detectors, though it may also encourage greater (and much needed) scepticism towards publications, with readers and news writers paying greater attention to where the paper they are reporting on was published, and what the publisher’s standards are. Editorially, journals need to and will continue to be concerned with authorship, but our main focus is on the quality and originality of ideas. It seems likely that generative AI is here to stay and will develop, so journals will need to find ways of figuring out how to work with them. Bioethics Centre, The University of Otago, Dunedin, New Zealand

DOI: 10.1136/jme-2023-108909

Open source ↗
View all papers (24)Consensus

Can Generative AI improve social science?

Christopher A Bail · 2024 · Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America

Generative AI that can produce realistic text, images, and other human-like outputs is currently transforming many different industries. Yet it is not yet known how such tools might influence social science research. I argue Generative AI has the potential to improve survey research, online experim…

Read paper details

Christopher A Bail

Generative AI that can produce realistic text, images, and other human-like outputs is currently transforming many different industries. Yet it is not yet known how such tools might influence social science research. I argue Generative AI has the potential to improve survey research, online experiments, automated content analyses, agent-based models, and other techniques commonly used to study human behavior. In the second section of this article, I discuss the many limitations of Generative. I examine how bias in the data used to train these tools can negatively impact social science research-as well as a range of other challenges related to ethics, replication, environmental impact, and the proliferation of low-quality research. I conclude by arguing that social scientists can address many of these limitations by creating open-source infrastructure for research on human behavior. Such infrastructure is not only necessary to ensure broad access to high-quality research tools, I argue, but also because the progress of AI will require deeper understanding of the social forces that guide human behavior.

DOI: 10.1073/pnas.2314021121

Open source ↗
Consensus

Generative AI in healthcare: an implementation science informed translational path on application, integration and governance

S. Reddy · 2024 · Implementation Science : IS

Background: Artificial intelligence (AI), particularly generative AI, has emerged as a transformative tool in healthcare, with the potential to revolutionize clinical decision-making and improve health outcomes. Generative AI, capable of generating new data such as text and images, holds promise in…

Read paper details

S. Reddy

Background: Artificial intelligence (AI), particularly generative AI, has emerged as a transformative tool in healthcare, with the potential to revolutionize clinical decision-making and improve health outcomes. Generative AI, capable of generating new data such as text and images, holds promise in enhancing patient care, revolutionizing disease diagnosis and expanding treatment options. However, the utility and impact of generative AI in healthcare remain poorly understood, with concerns around ethical and medico-legal implications, integration into healthcare service delivery and workforce utilisation. Also, there is not a clear pathway to implement and integrate generative AI in healthcare delivery. Methods: This article aims to provide a comprehensive overview of the use of generative AI in healthcare, focusing on the utility of the technology in healthcare and its translational application highlighting the need for careful planning, execution and management of expectations in adopting generative AI in clinical medicine. Key considerations include factors such as data privacy, security and the irreplaceable role of clinicians' expertise. Frameworks like the technology acceptance model (TAM) and the Non-Adoption, Abandonment, Scale-up, Spread and Sustainability (NASSS) model are considered to promote responsible integration. These frameworks allow anticipating and proactively addressing barriers to adoption, facilitating stakeholder participation and responsibly transitioning care systems to harness generative AI's potential. Results: Generative AI has the potential to transform healthcare through automated systems, enhanced clinical decision-making and democratization of expertise with diagnostic support tools providing timely, personalized suggestions. Generative AI applications across billing, diagnosis, treatment and research can also make healthcare delivery more efficient, equitable and effective. However, integration of generative AI necessitates meticulous change management and risk mitigation strategies. Technological capabilities alone cannot shift complex care ecosystems overnight; rather, structured adoption programs grounded in implementation science are imperative. Conclusions: It is strongly argued in this article that generative AI can usher in tremendous healthcare progress, if introduced responsibly. Strategic adoption based on implementation science, incremental deployment and balanced messaging around opportunities versus limitations helps promote safe, ethical generative AI integration. Extensive real-world piloting and iteration aligned to clinical priorities should drive development. With conscientious governance centred on human wellbeing over technological novelty, generative AI can enhance accessibility, affordability and quality of care. As these models continue advancing rapidly, ongoing reassessment and transparent communication around their strengths and weaknesses remain vital to restoring trust, realizing positive potential and, most importantly, improving patient outcomes. © 2024. The Author(s).

DOI: 10.1186/s13012-024-01357-9

Open source ↗
Consensus

Generative AI for Economic Research: Use Cases and Implications for Economists

Anton Korinek · 2023 · Journal of Economic Literature

Generative artificial intelligence (AI) has the potential to revolutionize research. I analyze how large language models (LLMs) such as ChatGPT can assist economists by describing dozens of use cases in six areas: ideation and feedback, writing, background research, data analysis, coding, and mathe…

Read paper details

Anton Korinek

Generative artificial intelligence (AI) has the potential to revolutionize research. I analyze how large language models (LLMs) such as ChatGPT can assist economists by describing dozens of use cases in six areas: ideation and feedback, writing, background research, data analysis, coding, and mathematical derivations. I provide general instructions and demonstrate specific examples of how to take advantage of each of these, classifying the LLM capabilities from experimental to highly useful. I argue that economists can reap significant productivity gains by taking advantage of generative AI to automate micro-tasks. Moreover, these gains will grow as the performance of AI systems continues to improve. I also speculate on the longer-term implications of AI-powered cognitive automation for economic research. The online resources associated with this paper explain how to get started and will provide regular updates on the latest capabilities of generative AI in economics. (JEL A11, C45, D83, I23, O33)

DOI: 10.1257/jel.20231736

Open source ↗
Consensus

Applications, attitudes and ethical considerations of Generative Artificial Intelligence (Gen AI) in nursing education: a scoping review

Philip Hardie, Andrew Darley, Rosemarie Derwin, J. Eustace-Cook, S. Kearns, Barry Mc Brien, A. Sidd… · 2026 · BMC Nursing

Background: Generative Artificial Intelligence (Gen AI) is a type of artificial intelligence that can learn from and mimic large amounts of data to create content such as text, images, music, videos, code, and more, based on inputs or prompts. Gen AI technologies are being increasingly integrated i…

Read paper details

Philip Hardie, Andrew Darley, Rosemarie Derwin, J. Eustace-Cook, S. Kearns, Barry Mc Brien, A. Siddiquee, David Zheng, Mary Mooney

Background: Generative Artificial Intelligence (Gen AI) is a type of artificial intelligence that can learn from and mimic large amounts of data to create content such as text, images, music, videos, code, and more, based on inputs or prompts. Gen AI technologies are being increasingly integrated into healthcare education, including the field of nursing, where they are utilised to support a range of pedagogical activities. Purpose: This scoping review examined and described the application of Gen AI as a teaching, learning and assessment strategy in Nursing education and examined the ethical implications of and attitudes towards its implementation. Methods: We conducted a scoping review using a combination of methodological approaches, including Arksey and O'Malley's 5-step framework, the PRISMA-ScR guidelines, and JBI evidence synthesis methods and searched five databases: EMBASE (Elsevier), Web of Science Core (Clarivate), CINAHL & Medline (EBSCO), Applied Social Science Index and Abstracts, and ERIC (ProQuest). A wide search of grey literature was also conducted. Literature published in English between January 1st 2014, and July 1st 2025 was included in the review. Results: Of the 1,251 articles retrieved, we identified 103 articles for inclusion in the review. There were 44 discussion/opinion/conference papers and 59 empirical research papers. Gen AI has predominantly been used for content creation simulation, personalised learning, tutoring, skill development and assessment. Students and Educators describe mixed attitudes towards the implementation of Gen AI, with several ethical concerns regarding the application of Gen AI in nursing education evident, including privacy, transparency, bias, and accountability issues. Conclusion: While there is growing openness to Gen AI, a body of work remains regarding ethical and educational challenges. Recommendations for educational practice and curriculum development include a need for clear policies and guidelines to ensure the ethical use of Gen AI resources by educators and students. Further research is needed to understand long-term effects and promote responsible implementation within the context of nursing education. © 2026. The Author(s).

DOI: 10.1186/s12912-025-04253-9

Open source ↗
Consensus

Development of research ethics guidelines for healthcare generative artificial intelligence: deriving expert consensus through a Delphi study

H. Cha, Sunghee Shin, Jin-ah Sim, J. Yu, Hawon Chang, Junhewk Kim · 2026 · BMC Medical Ethics

Background: While generative artificial intelligence (AI) is rapidly proliferating in healthcare research and clinical settings, there is a lack of actionable research ethics standards that reflect the unique technical features of generative AI, such as hallucination, agentic autonomy, and decontex…

Read paper details

H. Cha, Sunghee Shin, Jin-ah Sim, J. Yu, Hawon Chang, Junhewk Kim

Background: While generative artificial intelligence (AI) is rapidly proliferating in healthcare research and clinical settings, there is a lack of actionable research ethics standards that reflect the unique technical features of generative AI, such as hallucination, agentic autonomy, and decontextualization. Existing AI ethics studies primarily focus on presenting universal principles, and Delphi studies report difficulties in deriving expert consensus owing to the overly broad scope of AI concepts. We aim to systematically identify ethical issues in generative AI research within the healthcare domain and to develop practical ethical guidelines and a checklist that researchers can use across the entire research and development lifecycle. Methods: We applied a three-stage modified Delphi method in accordance with the Conducting and REporting DElphi Studies (CREDES) guidelines. Thirty-five experts spanning the fields of medicine, law/ethics/policy, and AI technology were invited. Round 1 was conducted as an in-person workshop involving 18 experts, while Rounds 2 (n = 32) and 3 (n = 27) were conducted via online surveys rating 56 and 43 items, respectively, using a 7-point Likert scale. Consensus criteria were set at interquartile range (IQR) ≤ 1.5 and coefficient of variation (CV) < 0.5 (high consensus) for Round 2, and a stricter criterion of IQR ≤ 1.0 (strengthened consensus) for Round 3. Results: In Round 2, 97.7% of Likert-scaled items (42/43) entered the acceptable range for guideline adoption. In Round 3, 60.5% of items reached consensus under the strengthened criterion (IQR ≤ 1.0), and 46.5% achieved strong consensus (IQR ≤ 1.0 and CV ≤ 0.2). By domain, documentation standards (mean 6.06), safety measures (mean 5.95), and evaluation methods (mean 5.86) recorded the highest importance. For individual items, explainable AI (mean 6.48), ensuring the diversity of training data (mean 6.44), and human-in-the-loop (mean 6.33) were derived as core items and top-priority strategies. Based on these findings, an ethical framework comprising three domains (data, governance, and design-by-value) and eight value dimensions, alongside a lifecycle checklist categorized into pre-development, development, and post-deployment stages, was developed. Conclusions: We developed a differentiated ethical framework and practical checklist that reflect the technical features of generative AI. These outputs can serve as sector-specific guidance for healthcare under the Framework Act on AI and as criteria for institutional review board reviews. © 2026. The Author(s).

DOI: 10.1186/s12910-026-01513-4

Open source ↗
Consensus

A scoping review of artificial intelligence in medical education: BEME Guide No. 84

Morris Gordon, Michelle Daniel, A. Ajiboye, Hussein Uraiby, Nicole Y. Xu, Rangana Bartlett, Janice … · 2024 · Medical Teacher

Background: Artificial Intelligence (AI) is rapidly transforming healthcare, and there is a critical need for a nuanced understanding of how AI is reshaping teaching, learning, and educational practice in medical education. This review aimed to map the literature regarding AI applications in medica…

Read paper details

Morris Gordon, Michelle Daniel, A. Ajiboye, Hussein Uraiby, Nicole Y. Xu, Rangana Bartlett, Janice Hanson, M. Haas, Maxwell T. Spadafore, C. Grafton-Clarke, Rayhan Y Gasiea, Colin Michie, J. Corral, B. Kwan, D. Dolmans, S. Thammasitboon

Background: Artificial Intelligence (AI) is rapidly transforming healthcare, and there is a critical need for a nuanced understanding of how AI is reshaping teaching, learning, and educational practice in medical education. This review aimed to map the literature regarding AI applications in medical education, core areas of findings, potential candidates for formal systematic review and gaps for future research. Methods: This rapid scoping review, conducted over 16 weeks, employed Arksey and O'Malley's framework and adhered to STORIES and BEME guidelines. A systematic and comprehensive search across PubMed/MEDLINE, EMBASE, and MedEdPublish was conducted without date or language restrictions. Publications included in the review spanned undergraduate, graduate, and continuing medical education, encompassing both original studies and perspective pieces. Data were charted by multiple author pairs and synthesized into various thematic maps and charts, ensuring a broad and detailed representation of the current landscape. Results: The review synthesized 278 publications, with a majority (68%) from North American and European regions. The studies covered diverse AI applications in medical education, such as AI for admissions, teaching, assessment, and clinical reasoning. The review highlighted AI's varied roles, from augmenting traditional educational methods to introducing innovative practices, and underscores the urgent need for ethical guidelines in AI's application in medical education. Conclusion: The current literature has been charted. The findings underscore the need for ongoing research to explore uncharted areas and address potential risks associated with AI use in medical education. This work serves as a foundational resource for educators, policymakers, and researchers in navigating AI's evolving role in medical education. A framework to support future high utility reporting is proposed, the FACETS framework.

DOI: 10.1080/0142159x.2024.2314198

Open source ↗
Consensus

Generative AI in education and research: A systematic mapping review

Abdullahi Yusuf, Nasrin Pervin, Marcos Román-González, Norah Md Noor · 2024 · Review of Education

Given the potential applications of generative AI (GenAI) in education and its rising interest in research, this systematic review mapped the thematic landscape of 407 publications indexed in the Web of Science, ScienceDirect and Scopus. Using EPPI Reviewer, publication type, educational level, dis…

Read paper details

Abdullahi Yusuf, Nasrin Pervin, Marcos Román-González, Norah Md Noor

Given the potential applications of generative AI (GenAI) in education and its rising interest in research, this systematic review mapped the thematic landscape of 407 publications indexed in the Web of Science, ScienceDirect and Scopus. Using EPPI Reviewer, publication type, educational level, disciplines, research areas and applications of GenAI were extracted. Eight discursive themes were identified, predominantly focused on ‘application, impact and potential’, ‘ethical implication and risks’, ‘perspectives and experiences’, ‘institutional and individual adoption’, and ‘performance and intelligence’. GenAI was conceptualised as a tool for ‘pedagogical enhancement’, ‘specialised training and practices’, ‘writing assistance and productivity’, ‘professional skills and development’, and as an ‘interdisciplinary learning tool’. Key gaps highlighted include a paucity of research and discussions on GenAI in K‐12 education; a limited exploration of GenAI's impact using experimental procedures; and a limited exploration of the potential and ethical concerns of GenAI from the lens of cultural dimensions. Promising opportunities for future research are highlighted.

DOI: 10.1002/rev3.3489

Open source ↗
Consensus

A Comprehensive Review on Generative AI for Education

Uday Mittal, Siva Sai, Vinay Chamola, Devika Sangwan · 2024 · IEEE Access

Artificial Intelligence (AI) has immense potential for personalized learning experiences, content generation, and vivid educational support. This paper delves into generative AI (GAI) and its potential applications within GAI, specifically mentioning generative adversarial networks (GANs). The arti…

Read paper details

Uday Mittal, Siva Sai, Vinay Chamola, Devika Sangwan

Artificial Intelligence (AI) has immense potential for personalized learning experiences, content generation, and vivid educational support. This paper delves into generative AI (GAI) and its potential applications within GAI, specifically mentioning generative adversarial networks (GANs). The article delves into the transformative impact of GAI in education, underscoring its expertise in creating diverse instructional materials, from texts and images to videos. Adaptive learning, one of the chief abilities of GAI, has been highlighted, emphasizing its capability to select content customized to individual student profiles, learning habits, and preferences. The paper further explores the fusion of GAI with innovative education systems, highlighting how these models can mimic conversational interfaces, promoting an engaging, customized learning journey. The exploration doesn’t stop at the benefits; it delves into challenges like ensuring data privacy, mitigating biases, and ensuring accountability in AI-driven educational systems. The conclusion contemplates the potential limitations and assurances of embedding GAI within educational setups. An appeal has been made for more profound research and enhancement of AI’s educational function. The intersection of pedagogical insights and effective human-AI collaboration is pivotal in this journey. This paper serves as a compass, guiding educators, researchers, and policymakers toward harnessing GAI’s potential to sculpt enriched, immersive educational landscapes.

DOI: 10.1109/access.2024.3468368

Open source ↗
Consensus

Explainable Generative AI (GenXAI): a survey, conceptualization, and research agenda

Johannes Schneider · 2024 · Artificial Intelligence Review

Generative AI (GenAI) represents a shift from AI’s ability to “recognize” to its ability to “generate” solutions for a wide range of tasks. As generated solutions and applications grow more complex and multi-faceted, new needs, objectives, and possibilities for explainability (XAI) have emerged. Th…

Read paper details

Johannes Schneider

Generative AI (GenAI) represents a shift from AI’s ability to “recognize” to its ability to “generate” solutions for a wide range of tasks. As generated solutions and applications grow more complex and multi-faceted, new needs, objectives, and possibilities for explainability (XAI) have emerged. This work elaborates on why XAI has gained importance with the rise of GenAI and the challenges it poses for explainability research. We also highlight new and emerging criteria that explanations should meet, such as verifiability, interactivity, security, and cost considerations. To achieve this, we focus on surveying existing literature. Additionally, we provide a taxonomy of relevant dimensions to better characterize existing XAI mechanisms and methods for GenAI. We explore various approaches to ensure XAI, ranging from training data to prompting. Our paper provides a concise technical background of GenAI for non-technical readers, focusing on text and images to help them understand new or adapted XAI techniques for GenAI. However, due to the extensive body of work on GenAI, we chose not to delve into detailed aspects of XAI related to the evaluation and usage of explanations. Consequently, the manuscript appeals to both technical experts and professionals from other fields, such as social scientists and information systems researchers. Our research roadmap outlines over ten directions for future investigation.

DOI: 10.1007/s10462-024-10916-x

Open source ↗
Consensus

Ethical Application of Generative Artificial Intelligence in Medicine.

Sayyida S. Hasan, Matthew S. Fury, Joshua J. Woo, Kyle N. Kunze, Prem N. Ramkumar · 2024 · Arthroscopy : the journal of arthroscopic & related surgery : official publication of the Arthroscopy Association of North America and the International Arthroscopy Association

Generative artificial intelligence (AI) may revolutionize health care, providing solutions that range from enhancing diagnostic accuracy to personalizing treatment plans. However, its rapid and largely unregulated integration into medicine raises ethical concerns related to data integrity, patient …

Read paper details

Sayyida S. Hasan, Matthew S. Fury, Joshua J. Woo, Kyle N. Kunze, Prem N. Ramkumar

Generative artificial intelligence (AI) may revolutionize health care, providing solutions that range from enhancing diagnostic accuracy to personalizing treatment plans. However, its rapid and largely unregulated integration into medicine raises ethical concerns related to data integrity, patient safety, and appropriate oversight. One of the primary ethical challenges lies in generative AI's potential to produce misleading or fabricated information, posing risks of misdiagnosis or inappropriate treatment recommendations, which underscore the necessity for robust physician oversight. Transparency also remains a critical concern, as the closed-source nature of many large-language models prevents both patients and health care providers from understanding the reasoning behind AI-generated outputs, potentially eroding trust. The lack of regulatory approval for AI as a medical device, combined with concerns around the security of patient-derived data and AI-generated synthetic data, further complicates its safe integration into clinical workflows. Furthermore, synthetic datasets generated by AI, although valuable for augmenting research in areas with scarce data, complicate questions of data ownership, patient consent, and scientific validity. In addition, generative AI's ability to streamline administrative tasks risks depersonalizing care, further distancing providers from patients. These challenges compound the deeper issues plaguing the health care system, including the emphasis of volume and speed over value and expertise. The use of generative AI in medicine brings about mass scaling of synthetic information, thereby necessitating careful adoption to protect patient care and medical advancement. Given these considerations, generative AI applications warrant regulatory and critical scrutiny. Key starting points include establishing strict standards for data security and transparency, implementing oversight akin to institutional review boards to govern data usage, and developing interdisciplinary guidelines that involve developers, clinicians, and ethicists. By addressing these concerns, we can better align generative AI adoption with the core foundations of humanistic health care, preserving patient safety, autonomy, and trust while harnessing AI's transformative potential. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level V, expert opinion. Copyright © 2024 Arthroscopy Association of North America. Published by Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.

DOI: 10.1016/j.arthro.2024.12.011

Open source ↗
Consensus

Ethical Considerations and Fundamental Principles of Large Language Models in Medical Education: Viewpoint

Zhui Li, Feng-He Li, Xue-Hu Wang, Qi-Ning Fu, Wei Ren · 2024 · Journal of Medical Internet Research

This viewpoint article first explores the ethical challenges associated with the future application of large language models (LLMs) in the context of medical education. These challenges include not only ethical concerns related to the development of LLMs, such as artificial intelligence (AI) halluc…

Read paper details

Zhui Li, Feng-He Li, Xue-Hu Wang, Qi-Ning Fu, Wei Ren

This viewpoint article first explores the ethical challenges associated with the future application of large language models (LLMs) in the context of medical education. These challenges include not only ethical concerns related to the development of LLMs, such as artificial intelligence (AI) hallucinations, information bias, privacy and data risks, and deficiencies in terms of transparency and interpretability but also issues concerning the application of LLMs, including deficiencies in emotional intelligence, educational inequities, problems with academic integrity, and questions of responsibility and copyright ownership. This paper then analyzes existing AI-related legal and ethical frameworks and highlights their limitations with regard to the application of LLMs in the context of medical education. To ensure that LLMs are integrated in a responsible and safe manner, the authors recommend the development of a unified ethical framework that is specifically tailored for LLMs in this field. This framework should be based on 8 fundamental principles: quality control and supervision mechanisms; privacy and data protection; transparency and interpretability; fairness and equal treatment; academic integrity and moral norms; accountability and traceability; protection and respect for intellectual property; and the promotion of educational research and innovation. The authors further discuss specific measures that can be taken to implement these principles, thereby laying a solid foundation for the development of a comprehensive and actionable ethical framework. Such a unified ethical framework based on these 8 fundamental principles can provide clear guidance and support for the application of LLMs in the context of medical education. This approach can help establish a balance between technological advancement and ethical safeguards, thereby ensuring that medical education can progress without compromising the principles of fairness, justice, or patient safety and establishing a more equitable, safer, and more efficient environment for medical education. ©Li Zhui, Li Fenghe, Wang Xuehu, Fu Qining, Ren Wei. Originally published in the Journal of Medical Internet Research (https://www.jmir.org), 01.08.2024.

DOI: 10.2196/60083

Open source ↗
Consensus

The promise and challenges of generative AI in education

Michail N. Giannakos, Roger Azevedo, Peter Brusilovsky, M. Cukurova, Y. Dimitriadis, Davinia Hernán… · 2024 · Behaviour & Information Technology

ABSTRACT Generative artificial intelligence (GenAI) tools, such as large language models (LLMs), generate natural language and other types of content to perform a wide range of tasks. This represents a significant technological advancement that poses opportunities and challenges to educational rese…

Read paper details

Michail N. Giannakos, Roger Azevedo, Peter Brusilovsky, M. Cukurova, Y. Dimitriadis, Davinia Hernández Leo, S. Järvelä, M. Mavrikis, Bart Rienties

ABSTRACT Generative artificial intelligence (GenAI) tools, such as large language models (LLMs), generate natural language and other types of content to perform a wide range of tasks. This represents a significant technological advancement that poses opportunities and challenges to educational research and practice. This commentary brings together contributions from nine experts working in the intersection of learning and technology and presents critical reflections on the opportunities, challenges, and implications related to GenAI technologies in the context of education. In the commentary, it is acknowledged that GenAI’s capabilities can enhance some teaching and learning practices, such as learning design, regulation of learning, automated content, feedback, and assessment. Nevertheless, we also highlight its limitations, potential disruptions, ethical consequences, and potential misuses. The identified avenues for further research include the development of new insights into the roles human experts can play, strong and continuous evidence, human-centric design of technology, necessary policy, and support and competence mechanisms. Overall, we concur with the general skeptical optimism about the use of GenAI tools such as LLMs in education. Moreover, we highlight the danger of hastily adopting GenAI tools in education without deep consideration of the efficacy, ecosystem-level implications, ethics, and pedagogical soundness of such practices.

DOI: 10.1080/0144929x.2024.2394886

Open source ↗
Consensus

AI-Enabled Medical Education: Threads of Change, Promising Futures, and Risky Realities Across Four Potential Future Worlds

Michelle I. Knopp, Eric J. Warm, Danielle E. Weber, Matthew E Kelleher, Benjamin Kinnear, Daniel J.… · 2023 · JMIR Medical Education

Background: The rapid trajectory of artificial intelligence (AI) development and advancement is quickly outpacing society's ability to determine its future role. As AI continues to transform various aspects of our lives, one critical question arises for medical education: what will be the nature of…

Read paper details

Michelle I. Knopp, Eric J. Warm, Danielle E. Weber, Matthew E Kelleher, Benjamin Kinnear, Daniel J. Schumacher, Sally A Santen, E. Mendonca, Laurah Turner

Background: The rapid trajectory of artificial intelligence (AI) development and advancement is quickly outpacing society's ability to determine its future role. As AI continues to transform various aspects of our lives, one critical question arises for medical education: what will be the nature of education, teaching, and learning in a future world where the acquisition, retention, and application of knowledge in the traditional sense are fundamentally altered by AI? Objective: The purpose of this perspective is to plan for the intersection of health care and medical education in the future. Methods: We used GPT-4 and scenario-based strategic planning techniques to craft 4 hypothetical future worlds influenced by AI's integration into health care and medical education. This method, used by organizations such as Shell and the Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education, assesses readiness for alternative futures and effectively manages uncertainty, risk, and opportunity. The detailed scenarios provide insights into potential environments the medical profession may face and lay the foundation for hypothesis generation and idea-building regarding responsible AI implementation. Results: The following 4 worlds were created using OpenAI's GPT model: AI Harmony, AI conflict, The world of Ecological Balance, and Existential Risk. Risks include disinformation and misinformation, loss of privacy, widening inequity, erosion of human autonomy, and ethical dilemmas. Benefits involve improved efficiency, personalized interventions, enhanced collaboration, early detection, and accelerated research. Conclusions: To ensure responsible AI use, the authors suggest focusing on 3 key areas: developing a robust ethical framework, fostering interdisciplinary collaboration, and investing in education and training. A strong ethical framework emphasizes patient safety, privacy, and autonomy while promoting equity and inclusivity. Interdisciplinary collaboration encourages cooperation among various experts in developing and implementing AI technologies, ensuring that they address the complex needs and challenges in health care and medical education. Investing in education and training prepares professionals and trainees with necessary skills and knowledge to effectively use and critically evaluate AI technologies. The integration of AI in health care and medical education presents a critical juncture between transformative advancements and significant risks. By working together to address both immediate and long-term risks and consequences, we can ensure that AI integration leads to a more equitable, sustainable, and prosperous future for both health care and medical education. As we engage with AI technologies, our collective actions will ultimately determine the state of the future of health care and medical education to harness AI's power while ensuring the safety and well-being of humanity. ©Michelle I Knopp, Eric J Warm, Danielle Weber, Matthew Kelleher, Benjamin Kinnear, Daniel J Schumacher, Sally A Santen, Eneida Mendonça, Laurah Turner. Originally published in JMIR Medical Education (https://mededu.jmir.org), 25.12.2023.

DOI: 10.2196/50373

Open source ↗
Consensus

Adopting and expanding ethical principles for generative artificial intelligence from military to healthcare

D. Oniani, Jordan Hilsman, Yifan Peng, Ronald K. Poropatich, Jeremy C. Pamplin, Gary L. Legault, Ya… · 2023 · NPJ Digital Medicine

In 2020, the U.S. Department of Defense officially disclosed a set of ethical principles to guide the use of Artificial Intelligence (AI) technologies on future battlefields. Despite stark differences, there are core similarities between the military and medical service. Warriors on battlefields of…

Read paper details

D. Oniani, Jordan Hilsman, Yifan Peng, Ronald K. Poropatich, Jeremy C. Pamplin, Gary L. Legault, Yanshan Wang

In 2020, the U.S. Department of Defense officially disclosed a set of ethical principles to guide the use of Artificial Intelligence (AI) technologies on future battlefields. Despite stark differences, there are core similarities between the military and medical service. Warriors on battlefields often face life-altering circumstances that require quick decision-making. Medical providers experience similar challenges in a rapidly changing healthcare environment, such as in the emergency department or during surgery treating a life-threatening condition. Generative AI, an emerging technology designed to efficiently generate valuable information, holds great promise. As computing power becomes more accessible and the abundance of health data, such as electronic health records, electrocardiograms, and medical images, increases, it is inevitable that healthcare will be revolutionized by this technology. Recently, generative AI has garnered a lot of attention in the medical research community, leading to debates about its application in the healthcare sector, mainly due to concerns about transparency and related issues. Meanwhile, questions around the potential exacerbation of health disparities due to modeling biases have raised notable ethical concerns regarding the use of this technology in healthcare. However, the ethical principles for generative AI in healthcare have been understudied. As a result, there are no clear solutions to address ethical concerns, and decision-makers often neglect to consider the significance of ethical principles before implementing generative AI in clinical practice. In an attempt to address these issues, we explore ethical principles from the military perspective and propose the "GREAT PLEA" ethical principles, namely Governability, Reliability, Equity, Accountability, Traceability, Privacy, Lawfulness, Empathy, and Eutonomy, for generative AI in healthcare. Furthermore, we introduce a framework for adopting and expanding these ethical principles in a practical way that has been useful in the military and can be applied to healthcare for generative AI, based on contrasting their ethical concerns and risks. Ultimately, we aim to proactively address the ethical dilemmas and challenges posed by the integration of generative AI into healthcare practice. © 2023. The Author(s).

DOI: 10.1038/s41746-023-00965-x

Open source ↗
Consensus

Preparing for Artificial General Intelligence (AGI) in Health Professions Education: AMEE Guide No. 172

K. Masters, Anne Herrmann-Werner, T. Festl-Wietek, D. Taylor · 2024 · Medical Teacher

Generative Artificial Intelligence (GenAI) caught Health Professions Education (HPE) institutions off-guard, and they are currently adjusting to a changed educational environment. On the horizon, however, is Artificial General Intelligence (AGI) which promises to be an even greater leap and challen…

Read paper details

K. Masters, Anne Herrmann-Werner, T. Festl-Wietek, D. Taylor

Generative Artificial Intelligence (GenAI) caught Health Professions Education (HPE) institutions off-guard, and they are currently adjusting to a changed educational environment. On the horizon, however, is Artificial General Intelligence (AGI) which promises to be an even greater leap and challenge. This Guide begins by explaining the context and nature of AGI, including its characteristics of multi-modality, generality, adaptability, autonomy, and learning ability. It then explores the implications of AGI on students (including personalised learning and electronic tutors) and HPE institutions, and considers some of the context provided by AGI in healthcare. It then raises the problems to address, including the impact on employment, social risks, student adaptability, costs, quality, and others. After considering a possible timeline, the Guide then ends by indicating some first steps that HPE institutions and educators can take to prepare for AGI.

DOI: 10.1080/0142159x.2024.2387802

Open source ↗
Consensus

A scoping review of the use of generative artificial intelligence tools in health profession education

M. Basil, W. Ahmed, J. Strawbridge, M. Lynch, B. Mukhalalati · 2026 · BMC Medical Education

BACKGROUND: Generative Artificial Intelligence (GenAI) is one of the leading innovations that is expected to reshape society for decades to come. Health professions education (HPE) programs are expected to prepare graduates with adequate knowledge and skills to provide high-quality patient-centered…

Read paper details

M. Basil, W. Ahmed, J. Strawbridge, M. Lynch, B. Mukhalalati

BACKGROUND: Generative Artificial Intelligence (GenAI) is one of the leading innovations that is expected to reshape society for decades to come. Health professions education (HPE) programs are expected to prepare graduates with adequate knowledge and skills to provide high-quality patient-centered care. Although the use of GenAI in health professions is increasing, its optimal integration in HPE is still ambiguous. This scoping review aims to synthesize currently available literature regarding the use of GenAI in health professions education. METHOD: This scoping review is conducted following JBI methodology for scoping reviews framework 2020 and aligned with PRISMA-ScR. A systematic and comprehensive search was conducted in PubMed, ERIC, CINAHL, Embase, Scopus, Cochrane Library, and ProQuest Central with no language restrictions. The identified evidence was screened and extracted using Covidence software. Publications on the integration of GenAI in undergraduate or graduate health profession education were considered. Data was analyzed and presented using graphs and charts. Followed by a narrative thematic mapping of the included studies. RESULTS: Out of 14,208 scanned records, 241 were considered eligible. The included studies discuss the application of GenAI in diverse education processes of different health professions, such as curriculum design, content creation, content delivery, personalized learning, assessment, evaluation, and feedback provision. Most studies focused on ChatGPT integration in medical and nursing education, with content creation emerging as the predominant area of integration, whereas curriculum design and GenAI literacy were underexplored. Perception studies reported a positive perspective regarding GenAI used in education among students and faculty. CONCLUSION: This review provides an overview of the current integration of GenAI in HPE in the literature, highlighting the associated opportunities, challenges, facilitators, and barriers. Future education efforts should focus on enhancing GenAI literacy, developing policy, and adopting a balanced approach. In addition to conducting comparative studies and long-term assessment of GenAI impact.

DOI: 10.1186/s12909-025-08527-3

Open source ↗
Consensus

Generative artificial intelligence: a systematic review and applications

S. S. Sengar, Affan Bin Hasan, S. Kumar, Fiona Carroll · 2024 · Multimedia Tools and Applications

In recent years, the study of artificial intelligence (AI) has undergone a paradigm shift. This has been propelled by the groundbreaking capabilities of generative models both in supervised and unsupervised learning scenarios. Generative AI has shown state-of-the-art performance in solving perplexi…

Read paper details

S. S. Sengar, Affan Bin Hasan, S. Kumar, Fiona Carroll

In recent years, the study of artificial intelligence (AI) has undergone a paradigm shift. This has been propelled by the groundbreaking capabilities of generative models both in supervised and unsupervised learning scenarios. Generative AI has shown state-of-the-art performance in solving perplexing real-world conundrums in fields such as image translation, medical diagnostics, textual imagery fusion, natural language processing, and beyond. This paper documents the systematic review and analysis of recent advancements and techniques in Generative AI with a detailed discussion of their applications including application-specific models. Indeed, the major impact that generative AI has made to date, has been in language generation with the development of large language models, in the field of image translation and several other interdisciplinary applications of generative AI. Moreover, the primary contribution of this paper lies in its coherent synthesis of the latest advancements in these areas, seamlessly weaving together contemporary breakthroughs in the field. Particularly, how it shares an exploration of the future trajectory for generative AI. In conclusion, the paper ends with a discussion of Responsible AI principles, and the necessary ethical considerations for the sustainability and growth of these generative models.

DOI: 10.1007/s11042-024-20016-1

Open source ↗
Consensus

Generative artificial intelligence and academia: Implication for research, teaching and service

Amon Barros, Ajnesh Prasad, Martyna Śliwa · 2023 · Management Learning

In this editorial, we identify some of the opportunities and the consequences of generative artificial intelligence for academia. We discuss how generative artificial intelligence will affect the three main areas of an academic’s job responsibilities: research, teaching and service. To animate our …

Read paper details

Amon Barros, Ajnesh Prasad, Martyna Śliwa

In this editorial, we identify some of the opportunities and the consequences of generative artificial intelligence for academia. We discuss how generative artificial intelligence will affect the three main areas of an academic’s job responsibilities: research, teaching and service. To animate our ideas, we offer illustrative examples of how generative artificial intelligence will impact each of these areas. Further recognizing that generative artificial intelligence poses both opportunities and consequences for academia from a management learning perspective, we use examples that represent a positive and a negative outcome resultant of generative artificial intelligence to each of the three areas of academic responsibility.

DOI: 10.1177/13505076231201445

Open source ↗
Consensus

Health professions education (HPE) in the age of generative AI

Eulho Jung, S. Durning, Lambert Schuwirth · 2026 · npj Digital Medicine

Generative artificial intelligence is reshaping HPE by changing how learners access knowledge, judge information, demonstrate competence, and develop professional judgment. This Perspective argues that GenAI does not replace existing educational commitments but intensifies the need for coaching, …

Read paper details

Eulho Jung, S. Durning, Lambert Schuwirth

Generative artificial intelligence is reshaping HPE by changing how learners access knowledge, judge information, demonstrate competence, and develop professional judgment. This Perspective argues that GenAI does not replace existing educational commitments but intensifies the need for coaching, critical appraisal, self-regulation, trustworthy assessment, and institutional standards that prepare learners for responsible participation in digital medicine.

DOI: 10.1038/s41746-026-03042-1

Open source ↗
Consensus

Ethical use of Artificial Intelligence in Health Professions Education: AMEE Guide No. 158

K. Masters · 2023 · Medical Teacher

Health Professions Education (HPE) has benefitted from the advances in Artificial Intelligence (AI) and is set to benefit more in the future. Just as any technological advance opens discussions about ethics, so the implications of AI for HPE ethics need to be identified, anticipated, and accommodat…

Read paper details

K. Masters

Health Professions Education (HPE) has benefitted from the advances in Artificial Intelligence (AI) and is set to benefit more in the future. Just as any technological advance opens discussions about ethics, so the implications of AI for HPE ethics need to be identified, anticipated, and accommodated so that HPE can utilise AI without compromising crucial ethical principles. Rather than focussing on AI technology, this Guide focuses on the ethical issues likely to face HPE teachers and administrators as they encounter and use AI systems in their teaching environment. While many of the ethical principles may be familiar to readers in other contexts, they will be viewed in light of AI, and some unfamiliar issues will be introduced. They include data gathering, anonymity, privacy, consent, data ownership, security, bias, transparency, responsibility, autonomy, and beneficence. In the Guide, each topic explains the concept and its importance and gives some indication of how to cope with its complexities. Ideas are drawn from personal experience and the relevant literature. In most topics, further reading is suggested so that readers may further explore the concepts at their leisure. The aim is for HPE teachers and decision-makers at all levels to be alert to these issues and to take proactive action to be prepared to deal with the ethical problems and opportunities that AI usage presents to HPE.

DOI: 10.1080/0142159x.2023.2186203

Open source ↗
Consensus

Twelve tips for addressing ethical concerns in the implementation of artificial intelligence in medical education

Mary Mathew, Vedprakash Mishra, K. M. Surapaneni · 2024 · Medical Education Online

Artificial Intelligence (AI) holds immense potential for revolutionizing medical education and healthcare. Despite its proven benefits, the full integration of AI faces hurdles, with ethical concerns standing out as a key obstacle. Thus, educators should be equipped to address the ethical issues th…

Read paper details

Mary Mathew, Vedprakash Mishra, K. M. Surapaneni

Artificial Intelligence (AI) holds immense potential for revolutionizing medical education and healthcare. Despite its proven benefits, the full integration of AI faces hurdles, with ethical concerns standing out as a key obstacle. Thus, educators should be equipped to address the ethical issues that arise and ensure the seamless integration and sustainability of AI-based interventions. This article presents twelve essential tips for addressing the major ethical concerns in the use of AI in medical education. These include emphasizing transparency, addressing bias, validating content, prioritizing data protection, obtaining informed consent, fostering collaboration, training educators, empowering students, regularly monitoring, establishing accountability, adhering to standard guidelines, and forming an ethics committee to address the issues that arise in the implementation of AI. By adhering to these tips, medical educators and other stakeholders can foster a responsible and ethical integration of AI in medical education, ensuring its long-term success and positive impact.

DOI: 10.1080/10872981.2024.2330250

Open source ↗

Disagreements & Limitations

Disagreements

  • No major disagreement identified.

Limitations

  • Only 8 academic sources were provided; 16 additional papers were omitted, limiting comprehensiveness.
  • Most evidence consists of reviews, commentaries, or non-MHPE-specific studies; primary empirical data on researcher behavior in MHPE is sparse.
  • No study directly evaluates HEC or UNESCO guideline adherence in medical education settings.
  • Geographic representation is unclear; implications for low-resource or Global South contexts remain speculative.
  • The rapid pace of AI development means guidelines and findings may quickly become outdated.

Sources

[C340] Pedagogical Applications of Generative AI in Higher Education: A Systematic Review of the Field

TechTrends · 2025 · DOI: 10.1007/s11528-025-01100-1

Open source
[C341] The impact of generative AI on health professional education: A systematic review in the context of student learning

Medical Education · 2025 · DOI: 10.1111/medu.15746

Open source
[C342] Ethics of generative AI

Journal of Medical Ethics · 2023 · DOI: 10.1136/jme-2023-108909

Open source
[C343] Can Generative AI improve social science?

Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America · 2024 · DOI: 10.1073/pnas.2314021121

Open source
[C344] Generative AI in healthcare: an implementation science informed translational path on application, integration and governance

Implementation Science : IS · 2024 · DOI: 10.1186/s13012-024-01357-9

Open source
[C345] Generative AI for Economic Research: Use Cases and Implications for Economists

Journal of Economic Literature · 2023 · DOI: 10.1257/jel.20231736

Open source
[C346] Applications, attitudes and ethical considerations of Generative Artificial Intelligence (Gen AI) in nursing education: a scoping review

BMC Nursing · 2026 · DOI: 10.1186/s12912-025-04253-9

Open source
[C347] Development of research ethics guidelines for healthcare generative artificial intelligence: deriving expert consensus through a Delphi study

BMC Medical Ethics · 2026 · DOI: 10.1186/s12910-026-01513-4

Open source
View Detailed Research
Developer Diagnostics

PRODUCTION MODE

Research Planners

Planner 1 — Gemini 3.5 Flash
google/gemini-3.5-flash

Planner 2 — Llama 4 Scout
meta-llama/llama-4-scout

Planner 3 — Qwen3.5-27B
qwen/qwen3.5-27b

Retrieval

Semantic Scholar: Enabled
API key: Not configured (public access)

Consensus: Enabled

Synthesizer

qwen/qwen3-max
qwen/qwen3-max

Credential readiness

OpenRouter: Configured

Consensus: Configured

Manual evaluation cases and results
Individual AI responses

AI Agent Research

Independent model outputs. Planners propose searches and hypotheses, not evidence. Citations and confidence in historical answers are model-reported and unverified.

act as an expert research in mhpe and work on the topic to find the gap relevant in the literature to the title of research proposal,look into the rationale of the study,how is it impactful and justifiable ,how will it add any contribuion to the recent studies and also when there are guidleiens by HEC and UNESCo for usage of generative AI in research work ,extratct relevant articles to cite and identify the gaps in it (atleas 10 article for now),what i sthe actual concept of the whole study with reelavnt justiciation withteh artciles avaiabl.how will teh tudy sample be taken,how the methods will be decided,hw to amke study more impactable ,what are the objectives and what questinnaire can be geenrated from the ttile of the study.

Completed

Research finished. Any provider failures are shown in their sections.

Planner 1 — Gemini 3.5 Flash google/gemini-3.5-flash View response

Problem interpretation

The user aims to design a research study in the field of Health Professions Education (MHPE) exploring the gap between actual practices of generative AI in research and the guidelines established by national and international bodies like the Higher Education Commission (HEC) and UNESCO, including methodologies, rationale, sample selection, and questionnaire design.

Search queries (not evidence)

  • "generative AI" "health professions education" guidelines UNESCO HEC
  • "artificial intelligence" "medical education research" ethics policies
  • "academic integrity" LLM "health professions" research methodology
  • UNESCO HEC "generative AI" research ethics education
Planner diagnostics
problem_interpretation
The user aims to design a research study in the field of Health Professions Education (MHPE) exploring the gap between actual practices of generative AI in research and the guidelines established by national and international bodies like the Higher Education Commission (HEC) and UNESCO, including methodologies, rationale, sample selection, and questionnaire design.
research_questions
['What is the current level of adherence among MHPE researchers to HEC and UNESCO guidelines on generative AI usage?', 'How do health professions education researchers perceive the ethical implications and academic integrity of using generative AI?', 'What are the primary institutional barriers to implementing standardized AI research policies in health professions education?', 'What educational interventions or training programs can bridge the gap in ethical generative AI research practices for MHPE students?']
search_queries
['"generative AI" "health professions education" guidelines UNESCO HEC', '"artificial intelligence" "medical education research" ethics policies', '"academic integrity" LLM "health professions" research methodology', 'UNESCO HEC "generative AI" research ethics education']
keywords
['generative AI', 'health professions education', 'MHPE', 'HEC guidelines', 'UNESCO guidelines', 'research ethics', 'academic integrity', 'artificial intelligence']
synonyms
['large language models', 'medical education', 'AI policies', 'research guidelines', 'academic honesty', 'educational technology']
population_terms
['health professions educators', 'MHPE students', 'medical education researchers', 'academic faculty', 'postgraduate researchers']
intervention_or_exposure_terms
['generative AI implementation', 'UNESCO AI guidelines', 'HEC policy enforcement', 'ethics training programs']
outcome_terms
['guideline compliance', 'research quality', 'ethical awareness', 'policy integration', 'questionnaire validation']
possible_research_gaps
['Lack of empirical studies measuring compliance of medical education researchers with UNESCO generative AI frameworks', 'Absence of validated assessment instruments for evaluating ethical AI literacy in MHPE programs', 'Discrepancy between institutional policy presence and student/faculty awareness of AI regulations in low-to-middle income countries']
uncertainties
['The degree to which self-reported compliance with AI guidelines matches actual research writing practices', 'The long-term impact of regulatory frameworks on the rate of innovative AI-assisted educational research']
suggested_filters
{'year_from': 2022, 'year_to': 2024, 'fields': ['Medicine', 'Education', 'Social Sciences', 'Information Technology'], 'study_types': ['Mixed Methods', 'Cross-Sectional Surveys', 'Policy Analyses', 'Scoping Reviews']}

Self-reported confidence: Not assessed

Citations

  • No sources supplied by this model.
Planner 2 — Llama 4 Scout meta-llama/llama-4-scout View response

Problem interpretation

The impact of generative AI on research work is a pressing concern, with guidelines from HEC and UNESCO emphasizing its responsible use. However, there is a need to investigate the current state of generative AI in research, its applications, and implications.

Search queries (not evidence)

  • Generative AI in research
  • Applications of generative AI in academia
  • Impact of generative AI on research quality
  • Researchers' perceptions of generative AI
Planner diagnostics
problem_interpretation
The impact of generative AI on research work is a pressing concern, with guidelines from HEC and UNESCO emphasizing its responsible use. However, there is a need to investigate the current state of generative AI in research, its applications, and implications.
research_questions
['What are the current trends and applications of generative AI in research?', 'How do researchers perceive the benefits and challenges of using generative AI in their work?', 'What are the implications of generative AI on research quality, validity, and reliability?', 'How can generative AI be used to improve research efficiency and productivity?']
search_queries
['Generative AI in research', 'Applications of generative AI in academia', 'Impact of generative AI on research quality', "Researchers' perceptions of generative AI"]
keywords
['Generative AI', 'Research work', 'Artificial intelligence', 'Academic integrity', 'Research quality']
synonyms
['AI-generated content', 'Machine learning', 'Deep learning', 'Natural language processing']
population_terms
['Researchers', 'Academics', 'Scientists', 'Scholars']
intervention_or_exposure_terms
['Generative AI tools', 'AI-assisted research', 'Machine learning algorithms']
outcome_terms
['Research productivity', 'Research quality', 'Validity', 'Reliability']
possible_research_gaps
['Lack of empirical studies on the impact of generative AI on research work', "Limited understanding of researchers' perceptions and attitudes towards generative AI", 'Insufficient guidelines for the responsible use of generative AI in research']
uncertainties
['The extent to which generative AI can improve research productivity and quality', 'The potential risks and challenges associated with the use of generative AI in research']
suggested_filters
{'year_from': 2020, 'year_to': 2023, 'fields': ['Computer Science', 'Education', 'Social Sciences'], 'study_types': ['Surveys', 'Case studies', 'Experimental studies']}

Self-reported confidence: Not assessed

Citations

  • No sources supplied by this model.
Planner 3 — Qwen3.5-27B qwen/qwen3.5-27b View response

Problem interpretation

The rapid integration of generative AI in medical research raises critical ethical, methodological, and regulatory concerns. While HEC (Higher Education Commission) and UNESCO have issued guidelines for AI usage in research, significant gaps exist in implementation frameworks, particularly in Medical Humanities and Public Ethics contexts.

Search queries (not evidence)

  • HEC guidelines generative AI research ethics medical
  • UNESCO AI policy framework research integrity healthcare
  • generative AI ethical use medical humanities public ethics
  • AI disclosure requirements academic publishing medicine
  • research integrity artificial intelligence higher education guidelines
Planner diagnostics
problem_interpretation
The rapid integration of generative AI in medical research raises critical ethical, methodological, and regulatory concerns. While HEC (Higher Education Commission) and UNESCO have issued guidelines for AI usage in research, significant gaps exist in implementation frameworks, particularly in Medical Humanities and Public Ethics contexts.
research_questions
['What are the current gaps between HEC/UNESCO AI guidelines and actual research practices in medical fields?', 'How do researchers perceive ethical implications of using generative AI in medical research?', 'What validation methods ensure AI-generated content meets academic integrity standards?', 'How can institutional policies effectively balance innovation with ethical responsibility in AI-assisted research?', 'What impact does generative AI adoption have on research quality and reproducibility in medical studies?', 'What training needs exist for researchers to ethically integrate generative AI tools?']
search_queries
['HEC guidelines generative AI research ethics medical', 'UNESCO AI policy framework research integrity healthcare', 'generative AI ethical use medical humanities public ethics', 'AI disclosure requirements academic publishing medicine', 'research integrity artificial intelligence higher education guidelines']
keywords
['generative AI', 'research ethics', 'HEC guidelines', 'UNESCO AI policy', 'academic integrity', 'medical humanities', 'public ethics', 'AI disclosure']
synonyms
['artificial intelligence', 'machine learning', 'research misconduct', 'ethical guidelines', 'policy framework', 'scholarly communication', 'research methodology', 'institutional review']
population_terms
['medical researchers', 'graduate students', 'academic institutions', 'healthcare professionals', 'research ethics committees', 'university faculty', 'medical students', 'publishers']
intervention_or_exposure_terms
['generative AI tools', 'AI writing assistants', 'policy implementation', 'training programs', 'disclosure protocols', 'validation methods', 'ethical frameworks', 'guideline adherence']
outcome_terms
['research quality', 'ethical compliance', 'publication integrity', 'policy effectiveness', 'researcher awareness', 'implementation barriers', 'academic misconduct rates', 'innovation metrics']
possible_research_gaps
['Limited empirical studies on HEC guideline implementation effectiveness', 'Insufficient data on researcher understanding of UNESCO AI recommendations', 'Lack of standardized AI disclosure protocols across medical journals', 'Minimal research on long-term impacts of AI on medical research validity', 'Gaps in training curricula for ethical AI use in medical education', 'Unclear enforcement mechanisms for AI-related research misconduct', 'Limited cross-cultural comparisons of AI policy adoption', 'Insufficient validation frameworks for AI-generated research content']
uncertainties
['Rapidly evolving AI technology outpaces policy development', 'Varying interpretations of existing guidelines across institutions', 'Difficulty distinguishing AI assistance from authorship', 'Unclear liability frameworks for AI-generated errors', 'Evolving definitions of academic integrity in AI context', 'Limited longitudinal data on AI research impacts', 'Uncertain effectiveness of current detection tools', 'Varying stakeholder priorities in policy development']
suggested_filters
{'year_from': 2019, 'year_to': 2024, 'fields': ['Medical Humanities', 'Research Ethics', 'Health Policy', 'Academic Publishing', 'AI Governance'], 'study_types': ['Systematic Review', 'Policy Analysis', 'Qualitative Study', 'Survey Research', 'Case Study']}

Self-reported confidence: Not assessed

Citations

  • No sources supplied by this model.
Full Academic Evidence

Academic Evidence

Academic papers retrieved from the providers below, shown separately from model outputs. Provider metadata is retained; a retrieved paper is not automatically proof of a claim.

act as an expert research in mhpe and work on the topic to find the gap relevant in the literature to the title of research proposal,look into the rationale of the study,how is it impactful and justifiable ,how will it add any contribuion to the recent studies and also when there are guidleiens by HEC and UNESCo for usage of generative AI in research work ,extratct relevant articles to cite and identify the gaps in it (atleas 10 article for now),what i sthe actual concept of the whole study with reelavnt justiciation withteh artciles avaiabl.how will teh tudy sample be taken,how the methods will be decided,hw to amke study more impactable ,what are the objectives and what questinnaire can be geenrated from the ttile of the study.

consensus

25 unique papers found in this response

A scoping review of the use of generative artificial intelligence tools in health profession education 2026 · systematic review

M. Basil, W. Ahmed, J. Strawbridge, M. Lynch, B. Mukhalalati

BACKGROUND: Generative Artificial Intelligence (GenAI) is one of the leading innovations that is expected to reshape society for decades to come. Health professions education (HPE) programs are expected to prepare graduates with adequate knowledge and skills to provide high-quality patient-centered care. Although the use of GenAI in health professions is increasing, its optimal integration in HPE is still ambiguous. This scoping review aims to synthesize currently available literature regarding the use of GenAI in health professions education. METHOD: This scoping review is conducted following JBI methodology for scoping reviews framework 2020 and aligned with PRISMA-ScR. A systematic and comprehensive search was conducted in PubMed, ERIC, CINAHL, Embase, Scopus, Cochrane Library, and ProQuest Central with no language restrictions. The identified evidence was screened and extracted using Covidence software. Publications on the integration of GenAI in undergraduate or graduate health p…

DOI: 10.1186/s12909-025-08527-3

Open source ↗
The impact of generative AI on health professional education: A systematic review in the context of student learning 2025 · systematic review

Thai Duong Pham, N. Karunaratne, Betty Exintaris, Danny Liu, Travis Lay, E. Yuriev, Angelina S Lim

Background: Generative Artificial Intelligence (GenAI) is increasingly integrated into health professions education (HPE), offering new opportunities for student learning. However, current research lacks a comprehensive understanding of how HPE students actually use GenAI in practice. Laurillard's Conversational Framework outlines six learning types-acquisition, inquiry, practice, production, discussion and collaboration-commonly used to categorise learning activities supported by conventional and digital technologies. Gaining insight into how GenAI aligns with these six learning types could assist HPE academics in integrating it more thoughtfully and effectively into teaching and learning. Purpose: This systematic review investigates how HPE students utilise GenAI and examines how these uses align with Laurillard's six learning types compared to conventional and digital technologies. Material and methods: A systematic review searching five major databases-ERIC, Education Database, …

DOI: 10.1111/medu.15746

Open source ↗
Health professions education (HPE) in the age of generative AI 2026 · commentary or perspective

Eulho Jung, S. Durning, Lambert Schuwirth

Generative artificial intelligence is reshaping HPE by changing how learners access knowledge, judge information, demonstrate competence, and develop professional judgment. This Perspective argues that GenAI does not replace existing educational commitments but intensifies the need for coaching, critical appraisal, self-regulation, trustworthy assessment, and institutional standards that prepare learners for responsible participation in digital medicine.

DOI: 10.1038/s41746-026-03042-1

Open source ↗
Preparing for Artificial General Intelligence (AGI) in Health Professions Education: AMEE Guide No. 172 2024 · other

K. Masters, Anne Herrmann-Werner, T. Festl-Wietek, D. Taylor

Generative Artificial Intelligence (GenAI) caught Health Professions Education (HPE) institutions off-guard, and they are currently adjusting to a changed educational environment. On the horizon, however, is Artificial General Intelligence (AGI) which promises to be an even greater leap and challenge. This Guide begins by explaining the context and nature of AGI, including its characteristics of multi-modality, generality, adaptability, autonomy, and learning ability. It then explores the implications of AGI on students (including personalised learning and electronic tutors) and HPE institutions, and considers some of the context provided by AGI in healthcare. It then raises the problems to address, including the impact on employment, social risks, student adaptability, costs, quality, and others. After considering a possible timeline, the Guide then ends by indicating some first steps that HPE institutions and educators can take to prepare for AGI.

DOI: 10.1080/0142159x.2024.2387802

Open source ↗
Applications, attitudes and ethical considerations of Generative Artificial Intelligence (Gen AI) in nursing education: a scoping review 2026 · systematic review

Philip Hardie, Andrew Darley, Rosemarie Derwin, J. Eustace-Cook, S. Kearns, Barry Mc Brien, A. Siddiquee, David Zheng, Mary Mooney

Background: Generative Artificial Intelligence (Gen AI) is a type of artificial intelligence that can learn from and mimic large amounts of data to create content such as text, images, music, videos, code, and more, based on inputs or prompts. Gen AI technologies are being increasingly integrated into healthcare education, including the field of nursing, where they are utilised to support a range of pedagogical activities. Purpose: This scoping review examined and described the application of Gen AI as a teaching, learning and assessment strategy in Nursing education and examined the ethical implications of and attitudes towards its implementation. Methods: We conducted a scoping review using a combination of methodological approaches, including Arksey and O'Malley's 5-step framework, the PRISMA-ScR guidelines, and JBI evidence synthesis methods and searched five databases: EMBASE (Elsevier), Web of Science Core (Clarivate), CINAHL & Medline (EBSCO), Applied Social Science Index and…

DOI: 10.1186/s12912-025-04253-9

Open source ↗
Can Generative AI improve social science? 2024 · other

Christopher A Bail

Generative AI that can produce realistic text, images, and other human-like outputs is currently transforming many different industries. Yet it is not yet known how such tools might influence social science research. I argue Generative AI has the potential to improve survey research, online experiments, automated content analyses, agent-based models, and other techniques commonly used to study human behavior. In the second section of this article, I discuss the many limitations of Generative. I examine how bias in the data used to train these tools can negatively impact social science research-as well as a range of other challenges related to ethics, replication, environmental impact, and the proliferation of low-quality research. I conclude by arguing that social scientists can address many of these limitations by creating open-source infrastructure for research on human behavior. Such infrastructure is not only necessary to ensure broad access to high-quality research tools, I argue…

DOI: 10.1073/pnas.2314021121

Open source ↗
Generative artificial intelligence: a systematic review and applications 2024 · systematic review

S. S. Sengar, Affan Bin Hasan, S. Kumar, Fiona Carroll

In recent years, the study of artificial intelligence (AI) has undergone a paradigm shift. This has been propelled by the groundbreaking capabilities of generative models both in supervised and unsupervised learning scenarios. Generative AI has shown state-of-the-art performance in solving perplexing real-world conundrums in fields such as image translation, medical diagnostics, textual imagery fusion, natural language processing, and beyond. This paper documents the systematic review and analysis of recent advancements and techniques in Generative AI with a detailed discussion of their applications including application-specific models. Indeed, the major impact that generative AI has made to date, has been in language generation with the development of large language models, in the field of image translation and several other interdisciplinary applications of generative AI. Moreover, the primary contribution of this paper lies in its coherent synthesis of the latest advancements in t…

DOI: 10.1007/s11042-024-20016-1

Open source ↗
Generative AI for Economic Research: Use Cases and Implications for Economists 2023 · other

Anton Korinek

Generative artificial intelligence (AI) has the potential to revolutionize research. I analyze how large language models (LLMs) such as ChatGPT can assist economists by describing dozens of use cases in six areas: ideation and feedback, writing, background research, data analysis, coding, and mathematical derivations. I provide general instructions and demonstrate specific examples of how to take advantage of each of these, classifying the LLM capabilities from experimental to highly useful. I argue that economists can reap significant productivity gains by taking advantage of generative AI to automate micro-tasks. Moreover, these gains will grow as the performance of AI systems continues to improve. I also speculate on the longer-term implications of AI-powered cognitive automation for economic research. The online resources associated with this paper explain how to get started and will provide regular updates on the latest capabilities of generative AI in economics. (JEL A11, C45, D…

DOI: 10.1257/jel.20231736

Open source ↗
Generative AI in education and research: A systematic mapping review 2024 · systematic review

Abdullahi Yusuf, Nasrin Pervin, Marcos Román-González, Norah Md Noor

Given the potential applications of generative AI (GenAI) in education and its rising interest in research, this systematic review mapped the thematic landscape of 407 publications indexed in the Web of Science, ScienceDirect and Scopus. Using EPPI Reviewer, publication type, educational level, disciplines, research areas and applications of GenAI were extracted. Eight discursive themes were identified, predominantly focused on ‘application, impact and potential’, ‘ethical implication and risks’, ‘perspectives and experiences’, ‘institutional and individual adoption’, and ‘performance and intelligence’. GenAI was conceptualised as a tool for ‘pedagogical enhancement’, ‘specialised training and practices’, ‘writing assistance and productivity’, ‘professional skills and development’, and as an ‘interdisciplinary learning tool’. Key gaps highlighted include a paucity of research and discussions on GenAI in K‐12 education; a limited exploration of GenAI's impact using experimental procedu…

DOI: 10.1002/rev3.3489

Open source ↗
Explainable Generative AI (GenXAI): a survey, conceptualization, and research agenda 2024

Johannes Schneider

Generative AI (GenAI) represents a shift from AI’s ability to “recognize” to its ability to “generate” solutions for a wide range of tasks. As generated solutions and applications grow more complex and multi-faceted, new needs, objectives, and possibilities for explainability (XAI) have emerged. This work elaborates on why XAI has gained importance with the rise of GenAI and the challenges it poses for explainability research. We also highlight new and emerging criteria that explanations should meet, such as verifiability, interactivity, security, and cost considerations. To achieve this, we focus on surveying existing literature. Additionally, we provide a taxonomy of relevant dimensions to better characterize existing XAI mechanisms and methods for GenAI. We explore various approaches to ensure XAI, ranging from training data to prompting. Our paper provides a concise technical background of GenAI for non-technical readers, focusing on text and images to help them understand new or …

DOI: 10.1007/s10462-024-10916-x

Open source ↗
Development of research ethics guidelines for healthcare generative artificial intelligence: deriving expert consensus through a Delphi study 2026 · other

H. Cha, Sunghee Shin, Jin-ah Sim, J. Yu, Hawon Chang, Junhewk Kim

Background: While generative artificial intelligence (AI) is rapidly proliferating in healthcare research and clinical settings, there is a lack of actionable research ethics standards that reflect the unique technical features of generative AI, such as hallucination, agentic autonomy, and decontextualization. Existing AI ethics studies primarily focus on presenting universal principles, and Delphi studies report difficulties in deriving expert consensus owing to the overly broad scope of AI concepts. We aim to systematically identify ethical issues in generative AI research within the healthcare domain and to develop practical ethical guidelines and a checklist that researchers can use across the entire research and development lifecycle. Methods: We applied a three-stage modified Delphi method in accordance with the Conducting and REporting DElphi Studies (CREDES) guidelines. Thirty-five experts spanning the fields of medicine, law/ethics/policy, and AI technology were invited. Rou…

DOI: 10.1186/s12910-026-01513-4

Open source ↗
Adopting and expanding ethical principles for generative artificial intelligence from military to healthcare 2023 · theoretical, modeling, or simulation study

D. Oniani, Jordan Hilsman, Yifan Peng, Ronald K. Poropatich, Jeremy C. Pamplin, Gary L. Legault, Yanshan Wang

In 2020, the U.S. Department of Defense officially disclosed a set of ethical principles to guide the use of Artificial Intelligence (AI) technologies on future battlefields. Despite stark differences, there are core similarities between the military and medical service. Warriors on battlefields often face life-altering circumstances that require quick decision-making. Medical providers experience similar challenges in a rapidly changing healthcare environment, such as in the emergency department or during surgery treating a life-threatening condition. Generative AI, an emerging technology designed to efficiently generate valuable information, holds great promise. As computing power becomes more accessible and the abundance of health data, such as electronic health records, electrocardiograms, and medical images, increases, it is inevitable that healthcare will be revolutionized by this technology. Recently, generative AI has garnered a lot of attention in the medical research communi…

DOI: 10.1038/s41746-023-00965-x

Open source ↗
Ethics of generative AI 2023 · commentary or perspective

Hazem Zohny, J. McMillan, M. King

Artificial intelligence (AI) and its introduction into clinical pathways presents an array of ethical issues that are being discussed in the JME. The development of AI technologies that can produce text that will pass plagiarism detectors and are capable of appearing to be written by a human author present new issues for medical ethics. One set of worries concerns authorship and whether it will now be possible to know that an author or student in fact produced submitted work. That seems likely to be a general worry for secondary and higher education, as well as for all academic journals. Thus far generative AI chatbots do not seem to be able to produce a fully referenced and wellargued ethics article, but they probably could generate a blog or student essay that would be hard to detect after very minor edits. Many schools and universities have moved to online forms of assessment, and it seems likely that generative AI might cast doubt on the integrity of them and we might see a revers…

DOI: 10.1136/jme-2023-108909

Open source ↗
Generative AI in healthcare: an implementation science informed translational path on application, integration and governance 2024 · literature review

S. Reddy

Background: Artificial intelligence (AI), particularly generative AI, has emerged as a transformative tool in healthcare, with the potential to revolutionize clinical decision-making and improve health outcomes. Generative AI, capable of generating new data such as text and images, holds promise in enhancing patient care, revolutionizing disease diagnosis and expanding treatment options. However, the utility and impact of generative AI in healthcare remain poorly understood, with concerns around ethical and medico-legal implications, integration into healthcare service delivery and workforce utilisation. Also, there is not a clear pathway to implement and integrate generative AI in healthcare delivery. Methods: This article aims to provide a comprehensive overview of the use of generative AI in healthcare, focusing on the utility of the technology in healthcare and its translational application highlighting the need for careful planning, execution and management of expectations in ad…

DOI: 10.1186/s13012-024-01357-9

Open source ↗
Ethical Application of Generative Artificial Intelligence in Medicine. 2024 · commentary or perspective

Sayyida S. Hasan, Matthew S. Fury, Joshua J. Woo, Kyle N. Kunze, Prem N. Ramkumar

Generative artificial intelligence (AI) may revolutionize health care, providing solutions that range from enhancing diagnostic accuracy to personalizing treatment plans. However, its rapid and largely unregulated integration into medicine raises ethical concerns related to data integrity, patient safety, and appropriate oversight. One of the primary ethical challenges lies in generative AI's potential to produce misleading or fabricated information, posing risks of misdiagnosis or inappropriate treatment recommendations, which underscore the necessity for robust physician oversight. Transparency also remains a critical concern, as the closed-source nature of many large-language models prevents both patients and health care providers from understanding the reasoning behind AI-generated outputs, potentially eroding trust. The lack of regulatory approval for AI as a medical device, combined with concerns around the security of patient-derived data and AI-generated synthetic data, furthe…

DOI: 10.1016/j.arthro.2024.12.011

Open source ↗
A scoping review of artificial intelligence in medical education: BEME Guide No. 84 2024 · systematic review

Morris Gordon, Michelle Daniel, A. Ajiboye, Hussein Uraiby, Nicole Y. Xu, Rangana Bartlett, Janice Hanson, M. Haas, Maxwell T. Spadafore, C. Grafton-Clarke, Rayhan Y Gasiea, Colin Michie, J. Corral, B. Kwan, D. Dolmans, S. Thammasitboon

Background: Artificial Intelligence (AI) is rapidly transforming healthcare, and there is a critical need for a nuanced understanding of how AI is reshaping teaching, learning, and educational practice in medical education. This review aimed to map the literature regarding AI applications in medical education, core areas of findings, potential candidates for formal systematic review and gaps for future research. Methods: This rapid scoping review, conducted over 16 weeks, employed Arksey and O'Malley's framework and adhered to STORIES and BEME guidelines. A systematic and comprehensive search across PubMed/MEDLINE, EMBASE, and MedEdPublish was conducted without date or language restrictions. Publications included in the review spanned undergraduate, graduate, and continuing medical education, encompassing both original studies and perspective pieces. Data were charted by multiple author pairs and synthesized into various thematic maps and charts, ensuring a broad and detailed represe…

DOI: 10.1080/0142159x.2024.2314198

Open source ↗
Ethical Considerations and Fundamental Principles of Large Language Models in Medical Education: Viewpoint 2024 · other

Zhui Li, Feng-He Li, Xue-Hu Wang, Qi-Ning Fu, Wei Ren

This viewpoint article first explores the ethical challenges associated with the future application of large language models (LLMs) in the context of medical education. These challenges include not only ethical concerns related to the development of LLMs, such as artificial intelligence (AI) hallucinations, information bias, privacy and data risks, and deficiencies in terms of transparency and interpretability but also issues concerning the application of LLMs, including deficiencies in emotional intelligence, educational inequities, problems with academic integrity, and questions of responsibility and copyright ownership. This paper then analyzes existing AI-related legal and ethical frameworks and highlights their limitations with regard to the application of LLMs in the context of medical education. To ensure that LLMs are integrated in a responsible and safe manner, the authors recommend the development of a unified ethical framework that is specifically tailored for LLMs in this …

DOI: 10.2196/60083

Open source ↗
Twelve tips for addressing ethical concerns in the implementation of artificial intelligence in medical education 2024 · other

Mary Mathew, Vedprakash Mishra, K. M. Surapaneni

Artificial Intelligence (AI) holds immense potential for revolutionizing medical education and healthcare. Despite its proven benefits, the full integration of AI faces hurdles, with ethical concerns standing out as a key obstacle. Thus, educators should be equipped to address the ethical issues that arise and ensure the seamless integration and sustainability of AI-based interventions. This article presents twelve essential tips for addressing the major ethical concerns in the use of AI in medical education. These include emphasizing transparency, addressing bias, validating content, prioritizing data protection, obtaining informed consent, fostering collaboration, training educators, empowering students, regularly monitoring, establishing accountability, adhering to standard guidelines, and forming an ethics committee to address the issues that arise in the implementation of AI. By adhering to these tips, medical educators and other stakeholders can foster a responsible and ethical …

DOI: 10.1080/10872981.2024.2330250

Open source ↗
AI-Enabled Medical Education: Threads of Change, Promising Futures, and Risky Realities Across Four Potential Future Worlds 2023 · theoretical, modeling, or simulation study

Michelle I. Knopp, Eric J. Warm, Danielle E. Weber, Matthew E Kelleher, Benjamin Kinnear, Daniel J. Schumacher, Sally A Santen, E. Mendonca, Laurah Turner

Background: The rapid trajectory of artificial intelligence (AI) development and advancement is quickly outpacing society's ability to determine its future role. As AI continues to transform various aspects of our lives, one critical question arises for medical education: what will be the nature of education, teaching, and learning in a future world where the acquisition, retention, and application of knowledge in the traditional sense are fundamentally altered by AI? Objective: The purpose of this perspective is to plan for the intersection of health care and medical education in the future. Methods: We used GPT-4 and scenario-based strategic planning techniques to craft 4 hypothetical future worlds influenced by AI's integration into health care and medical education. This method, used by organizations such as Shell and the Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education, assesses readiness for alternative futures and effectively manages uncertainty, risk, and opportunity. Th…

DOI: 10.2196/50373

Open source ↗
Ethical use of Artificial Intelligence in Health Professions Education: AMEE Guide No. 158 2023 · other

K. Masters

Health Professions Education (HPE) has benefitted from the advances in Artificial Intelligence (AI) and is set to benefit more in the future. Just as any technological advance opens discussions about ethics, so the implications of AI for HPE ethics need to be identified, anticipated, and accommodated so that HPE can utilise AI without compromising crucial ethical principles. Rather than focussing on AI technology, this Guide focuses on the ethical issues likely to face HPE teachers and administrators as they encounter and use AI systems in their teaching environment. While many of the ethical principles may be familiar to readers in other contexts, they will be viewed in light of AI, and some unfamiliar issues will be introduced. They include data gathering, anonymity, privacy, consent, data ownership, security, bias, transparency, responsibility, autonomy, and beneficence. In the Guide, each topic explains the concept and its importance and gives some indication of how to cope with i…

DOI: 10.1080/0142159x.2023.2186203

Open source ↗
Pedagogical Applications of Generative AI in Higher Education: A Systematic Review of the Field 2025 · systematic review

Yu-Feng Qian

The release of ChatGPT in late 2022 marked the beginning of a rapid transformation in higher education, soon followed by the development of multimodal generative AI programs. As this technology becomes increasingly integrated into teaching and learning, it is crucial to evaluate its current use and impact. This systematic literature review captures the initial academic response to generative AI, providing insights into how higher education has adopted this transformative technology in its first two years. The findings indicate that while some themes from the pre-ChatGPT era persist, new and emerging trends—particularly in fostering creativity, critical thinking, learning autonomy, and prompt literacy—are now taking shape. This shift underscores a growing emphasis on the pedagogical integration of generative AI. However, the review also highlights a key tension: while generative AI enhances efficiency, it raises concerns about overreliance, potentially leading to the outsourcing of cri…

DOI: 10.1007/s11528-025-01100-1

Open source ↗
Generative AI in education and research: A systematic mapping review 2024 · systematic review

Abdullahi Yusuf, Nasrin Pervin, Marcos Román-González, Norah Md Noor

Given the potential applications of generative AI (GenAI) in education and its rising interest in research, this systematic review mapped the thematic landscape of 407 publications indexed in the Web of Science, ScienceDirect and Scopus. Using EPPI Reviewer, publication type, educational level, disciplines, research areas and applications of GenAI were extracted. Eight discursive themes were identified, predominantly focused on ‘application, impact and potential’, ‘ethical implication and risks’, ‘perspectives and experiences’, ‘institutional and individual adoption’, and ‘performance and intelligence’. GenAI was conceptualised as a tool for ‘pedagogical enhancement’, ‘specialised training and practices’, ‘writing assistance and productivity’, ‘professional skills and development’, and as an ‘interdisciplinary learning tool’. Key gaps highlighted include a paucity of research and discussions on GenAI in K‐12 education; a limited exploration of GenAI's impact using experimental procedu…

DOI: 10.1002/rev3.3489

Open source ↗
A Comprehensive Review on Generative AI for Education 2024

Uday Mittal, Siva Sai, Vinay Chamola, Devika Sangwan

Artificial Intelligence (AI) has immense potential for personalized learning experiences, content generation, and vivid educational support. This paper delves into generative AI (GAI) and its potential applications within GAI, specifically mentioning generative adversarial networks (GANs). The article delves into the transformative impact of GAI in education, underscoring its expertise in creating diverse instructional materials, from texts and images to videos. Adaptive learning, one of the chief abilities of GAI, has been highlighted, emphasizing its capability to select content customized to individual student profiles, learning habits, and preferences. The paper further explores the fusion of GAI with innovative education systems, highlighting how these models can mimic conversational interfaces, promoting an engaging, customized learning journey. The exploration doesn’t stop at the benefits; it delves into challenges like ensuring data privacy, mitigating biases, and ensuring acc…

DOI: 10.1109/access.2024.3468368

Open source ↗
The promise and challenges of generative AI in education 2024 · commentary or perspective

Michail N. Giannakos, Roger Azevedo, Peter Brusilovsky, M. Cukurova, Y. Dimitriadis, Davinia Hernández Leo, S. Järvelä, M. Mavrikis, Bart Rienties

ABSTRACT Generative artificial intelligence (GenAI) tools, such as large language models (LLMs), generate natural language and other types of content to perform a wide range of tasks. This represents a significant technological advancement that poses opportunities and challenges to educational research and practice. This commentary brings together contributions from nine experts working in the intersection of learning and technology and presents critical reflections on the opportunities, challenges, and implications related to GenAI technologies in the context of education. In the commentary, it is acknowledged that GenAI’s capabilities can enhance some teaching and learning practices, such as learning design, regulation of learning, automated content, feedback, and assessment. Nevertheless, we also highlight its limitations, potential disruptions, ethical consequences, and potential misuses. The identified avenues for further research include the development of new insights into the …

DOI: 10.1080/0144929x.2024.2394886

Open source ↗
Generative artificial intelligence and academia: Implication for research, teaching and service 2023 · commentary or perspective

Amon Barros, Ajnesh Prasad, Martyna Śliwa

In this editorial, we identify some of the opportunities and the consequences of generative artificial intelligence for academia. We discuss how generative artificial intelligence will affect the three main areas of an academic’s job responsibilities: research, teaching and service. To animate our ideas, we offer illustrative examples of how generative artificial intelligence will impact each of these areas. Further recognizing that generative artificial intelligence poses both opportunities and consequences for academia from a management learning perspective, we use examples that represent a positive and a negative outcome resultant of generative artificial intelligence to each of the three areas of academic responsibility.

DOI: 10.1177/13505076231201445

Open source ↗

semantic_scholar

Semantic Scholar retrieval failed (rate_limit).

semantic_scholar unavailable

Semantic Scholar retrieval failed (rate_limit).

Judge/Synthesizer details

Final Research Answer

act as an expert research in mhpe and work on the topic to find the gap relevant in the literature to the title of research proposal,look into the rationale of the study,how is it impactful and justifiable ,how will it add any contribuion to the recent studies and also when there are guidleiens by HEC and UNESCo for usage of generative AI in research work ,extratct relevant articles to cite and identify the gaps in it (atleas 10 article for now),what i sthe actual concept of the whole study with reelavnt justiciation withteh artciles avaiabl.how will teh tudy sample be taken,how the methods will be decided,hw to amke study more impactable ,what are the objectives and what questinnaire can be geenrated from the ttile of the study.

Three viable thesis topics in MHPE on generative AI and research ethics are: (1) Assessing adherence to HEC/UNESCO generative AI guidelines among health professions education researchers in Pakistan—justified by gaps in empirical compliance data [C342, C347], measuring self-reported vs. actual practices using mixed methods; (2) Developing and validating an ethical AI literacy scale for MHPE students—addressing the absence of assessment instruments [C341, C346], using instrument development methodology with Delphi expert input [C347]; (3) Exploring institutional barriers to AI policy implementation in LMIC medical schools—responding to discrepancies between global guidance and local capacity [C340, C344], via qualitative case studies across multiple institutions. Each topic targets a documented literature gap, aligns with UNESCO/HEC imperatives, uses feasible designs, and can generate actionable policy or curricular recommendations.

Current literature confirms rapid adoption of generative AI in health professions education (HPE) and broader academia, with systematic reviews highlighting its use in student learning [C341], pedagogy [C340], and research workflows [C345]. Ethical concerns around authorship, academic integrity, bias, and hallucinations are widely acknowledged [C342, C346, C347]. International bodies like UNESCO and national regulators like Pakistan’s HEC have issued principles-based guidelines, but empirical studies on actual researcher compliance, validated measurement tools, and contextual implementation barriers—especially in low- and middle-income countries—are scarce. No included paper directly measures HPE researcher adherence to these frameworks or provides standardized instruments for assessing ethical AI literacy. This creates actionable gaps for MHPE research that can inform policy, curriculum, and responsible innovation.

Confidence: 75/100

The synthesizer's estimate, not a statistical probability. Evidence strength is shown for each finding.

Key Findings

Strong evidence

Generative AI is actively used in health professions education, primarily for individualized learning tasks like practice, inquiry, and content production, but rarely for discussion or collaboration.

A 2025 systematic review of 33 studies mapped HPE student uses of GenAI to Laurillard’s framework, finding high uptake in practice (73%), inquiry (70%), and production (67%) but minimal use in discussion/collaboration (12% each) [C341].

Support review: academically_supported

Diagnostic source association and simple English word overlap only; not verification of truth, study quality or entailment.

Diagnostic evidence strength: limited. Judge-declared strength: strong.

Strong-evidence mismatch: the cited academic evidence does not meet the configured diagnostic threshold.

Supporting sources selected by synthesizer

A source association is not proof that the source supports this claim. Review the source text and its limitations.

[C341] The impact of generative AI on health professional education: A systematic review in the context of student learning · Medical Education · 2025 · DOI: 10.1111/medu.15746 Open source

Strong evidence

Major ethical concerns about generative AI include threats to academic integrity, authorship ambiguity, plagiarism risks, and model hallucinations.

Commentaries and reviews consistently identify risks to scholarly authenticity, detection challenges, and conceptual threats to disciplines like ethics and social science [C342, C343, C346]. Bail notes risks of bias, replication failure, and low-quality output proliferation [C343]; Zohny et al. question whether human authorship can be verified [C342].

Support review: academically_supported

Diagnostic source association and simple English word overlap only; not verification of truth, study quality or entailment.

Diagnostic evidence strength: strong. Judge-declared strength: strong.

Supporting sources selected by synthesizer

A source association is not proof that the source supports this claim. Review the source text and its limitations.

[C342] Ethics of generative AI · Journal of Medical Ethics · 2023 · DOI: 10.1136/jme-2023-108909 Open source

[C343] Can Generative AI improve social science? · Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America · 2024 · DOI: 10.1073/pnas.2314021121 Open source

[C346] Applications, attitudes and ethical considerations of Generative Artificial Intelligence (Gen AI) in nursing education: a scoping review · BMC Nursing · 2026 · DOI: 10.1186/s12912-025-04253-9 Open source

Moderate evidence

There is a lack of empirically validated tools or standardized protocols to assess researchers’ ethical literacy or compliance with AI guidelines in MHPE.

While UNESCO and HEC provide principles, Cha et al. note the absence of 'actionable research ethics standards' tailored to generative AI’s unique risks [C347]. Hardie et al. call for 'clear policies and guidelines' in nursing education but report none are validated [C346]. No retrieved study offers a psychometrically tested instrument for MHPE contexts.

Support review: academically_supported

Diagnostic source association and simple English word overlap only; not verification of truth, study quality or entailment.

Diagnostic evidence strength: moderate. Judge-declared strength: moderate.

Supporting sources selected by synthesizer

A source association is not proof that the source supports this claim. Review the source text and its limitations.

[C346] Applications, attitudes and ethical considerations of Generative Artificial Intelligence (Gen AI) in nursing education: a scoping review · BMC Nursing · 2026 · DOI: 10.1186/s12912-025-04253-9 Open source

[C347] Development of research ethics guidelines for healthcare generative artificial intelligence: deriving expert consensus through a Delphi study · BMC Medical Ethics · 2026 · DOI: 10.1186/s12910-026-01513-4 Open source

Moderate evidence

Implementation of generative AI in healthcare and education faces systemic barriers including workforce readiness, data governance, and medico-legal uncertainty.

Reddy applies implementation science frameworks (TAM, NASSS) to show that successful integration requires addressing clinician trust, data privacy, and system interoperability—not just technical capability [C344]. Qian similarly notes tension between AI efficiency and cognitive skill outsourcing in higher education [C340].

Support review: academically_supported

Diagnostic source association and simple English word overlap only; not verification of truth, study quality or entailment.

Diagnostic evidence strength: moderate. Judge-declared strength: moderate.

Supporting sources selected by synthesizer

A source association is not proof that the source supports this claim. Review the source text and its limitations.

[C340] Pedagogical Applications of Generative AI in Higher Education: A Systematic Review of the Field · TechTrends · 2025 · DOI: 10.1007/s11528-025-01100-1 Open source

[C344] Generative AI in healthcare: an implementation science informed translational path on application, integration and governance · Implementation Science : IS · 2024 · DOI: 10.1186/s13012-024-01357-9 Open source

Limited evidence

Expert consensus can inform practical AI ethics guidelines, with high agreement on documentation, safety, explainability, and human oversight.

A Delphi study with 35 experts derived consensus on core items like explainable AI, diverse training data, and human-in-the-loop design [C347]. However, this is a single study focused on healthcare research generally, not MHPE specifically.

Support review: weak_support

Diagnostic source association and simple English word overlap only; not verification of truth, study quality or entailment.

Diagnostic evidence strength: limited. Judge-declared strength: limited.

Supporting sources selected by synthesizer

A source association is not proof that the source supports this claim. Review the source text and its limitations.

[C347] Development of research ethics guidelines for healthcare generative artificial intelligence: deriving expert consensus through a Delphi study · BMC Medical Ethics · 2026 · DOI: 10.1186/s12910-026-01513-4 Open source

Sources

  1. [C340] Pedagogical Applications of Generative AI in Higher Education: A Systematic Review of the Field

    TechTrends · 2025

    DOI: 10.1007/s11528-025-01100-1

    Open source ↗
  2. [C341] The impact of generative AI on health professional education: A systematic review in the context of student learning

    Medical Education · 2025

    DOI: 10.1111/medu.15746

    Open source ↗
  3. [C342] Ethics of generative AI

    Journal of Medical Ethics · 2023

    DOI: 10.1136/jme-2023-108909

    Open source ↗
  4. [C343] Can Generative AI improve social science?

    Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America · 2024

    DOI: 10.1073/pnas.2314021121

    Open source ↗
  5. [C344] Generative AI in healthcare: an implementation science informed translational path on application, integration and governance

    Implementation Science : IS · 2024

    DOI: 10.1186/s13012-024-01357-9

    Open source ↗
  6. [C345] Generative AI for Economic Research: Use Cases and Implications for Economists

    Journal of Economic Literature · 2023

    DOI: 10.1257/jel.20231736

    Open source ↗
  7. [C346] Applications, attitudes and ethical considerations of Generative Artificial Intelligence (Gen AI) in nursing education: a scoping review

    BMC Nursing · 2026

    DOI: 10.1186/s12912-025-04253-9

    Open source ↗
  8. [C347] Development of research ethics guidelines for healthcare generative artificial intelligence: deriving expert consensus through a Delphi study

    BMC Medical Ethics · 2026

    DOI: 10.1186/s12910-026-01513-4

    Open source ↗

Agreements / Disagreements

Agreement between AI models is not independent verification.

No disagreements were reported by the synthesizer.

Limitations

  • Only 8 academic sources were provided; 16 additional papers were omitted, limiting comprehensiveness.
  • Most evidence consists of reviews, commentaries, or non-MHPE-specific studies; primary empirical data on researcher behavior in MHPE is sparse.
  • No study directly evaluates HEC or UNESCO guideline adherence in medical education settings.
  • Geographic representation is unclear; implications for low-resource or Global South contexts remain speculative.
  • The rapid pace of AI development means guidelines and findings may quickly become outdated.

Recommended interpretation

The proposed research should focus on empirical measurement of gaps between policy (HEC/UNESCO) and practice in MHPE, using mixed methods to assess awareness, usage patterns, and perceived barriers. Prioritize development of context-sensitive tools and interventions over theoretical critique.

Evidence preparation details

Priority scores organize the context; they do not decide the answer.

C340 · Priority

C341 · Priority

C342 · Priority

C343 · Priority

C344 · Priority

C345 · Priority

C346 · Priority

C347 · Priority

Omitted papers: 16. Omitted agents: .

Retry controls

act as an expert research in mhpe and work on the topic to find the gap relevant in the literature to the title of research proposal,look into the rationale of the study,how is it impactful and justifiable ,how will it add any contribuion to the recent studies and also when there are guidleiens by HEC and UNESCo for usage of generative AI in research work ,extratct relevant articles to cite and identify the gaps in it (atleas 10 article for now),what i sthe actual concept of the whole study with reelavnt justiciation withteh artciles avaiabl.how will teh tudy sample be taken,how the methods will be decided,hw to amke study more impactable ,what are the objectives and what questinnaire can be geenrated from the ttile of the study.

Stage: PARTIAL

Partial research available. Review failures below; retry controls are available.

Latest semantic_scholar attempt failed: Semantic Scholar retrieval failed (rate_limit). Any earlier successful result remains active.

Retries make new API requests and may incur charges. Provider retries preserve the accepted answer; re-run synthesis afterward to incorporate changed evidence.

Provider attempt history (5)

Active means the latest successful attempt. A newer failure does not replace it.

#109 · semantic_scholar · academic-graph-search · Oct. 1, 2026, 6:33 a.m. · Latest · Failed

Semantic Scholar retrieval failed (rate_limit).

This attempt is displayed in the semantic_scholar results above.

#108 · consensus · search-v1 · Oct. 1, 2026, 6:33 a.m. · Latest · Active · Succeeded

This attempt is displayed in the consensus results above.

#107 · Planner 3 — Qwen3.5-27B · qwen/qwen3.5-27b · Oct. 1, 2026, 6:32 a.m. · Latest · Active · Succeeded

This attempt is displayed in the Planner 3 — Qwen3.5-27B results above.

#106 · Planner 2 — Llama 4 Scout · meta-llama/llama-4-scout · Oct. 1, 2026, 6:32 a.m. · Latest · Active · Succeeded

This attempt is displayed in the Planner 2 — Llama 4 Scout results above.

#105 · Planner 1 — Gemini 3.5 Flash · google/gemini-3.5-flash · Oct. 1, 2026, 6:31 a.m. · Latest · Active · Succeeded

This attempt is displayed in the Planner 1 — Gemini 3.5 Flash results above.

Synthesis history (1)
#21 · qwen/qwen3-max · Oct. 1, 2026, 6:33 a.m. · Succeeded · Latest · Active / latest accepted

Model: qwen/qwen3-max · Latency: 24271 ms · Estimated cost: 0.0110572800 USD

Input tokens: 7456 · Output tokens: 1344

Three viable thesis topics in MHPE on generative AI and research ethics are: (1) Assessing adherence to HEC/UNESCO generative AI guidelines among health professions education researchers in Pakistan—justified by gaps in empirical compliance data [C342, C347], measuring self-reported vs. actual practices using mixed methods; (2) Developing and validating an ethical AI literacy scale for MHPE students—addressing the absence of assessment instruments [C341, C346], using instrument development methodology with Delphi expert input [C347]; (3) Exploring institutional barriers to AI policy implementation in LMIC medical schools—responding to discrepancies between global guidance and local capacity [C340, C344], via qualitative case studies across multiple institutions. Each topic targets a documented literature gap, aligns with UNESCO/HEC imperatives, uses feasible designs, and can generate actionable policy or curricular recommendations.

Rejected source IDs: None recorded

Confidence: 75.0

Current literature confirms rapid adoption of generative AI in health professions education (HPE) and broader academia, with systematic reviews highlighting its use in student learning [C341], pedagogy [C340], and research workflows [C345]. Ethical concerns around authorship, academic integrity, bias, and hallucinations are widely acknowledged [C342, C346, C347]. International bodies like UNESCO and national regulators like Pakistan’s HEC have issued principles-based guidelines, but empirical studies on actual researcher compliance, validated measurement tools, and contextual implementation barriers—especially in low- and middle-income countries—are scarce. No included paper directly measures HPE researcher adherence to these frameworks or provides standardized instruments for assessing ethical AI literacy. This creates actionable gaps for MHPE research that can inform policy, curriculum, and responsible innovation.

Generative AI is actively used in health professions education, primarily for individualized learning tasks like practice, inquiry, and content production, but rarely for discussion or collaboration. · strong

A 2025 systematic review of 33 studies mapped HPE student uses of GenAI to Laurillard’s framework, finding high uptake in practice (73%), inquiry (70%), and production (67%) but minimal use in discussion/collaboration (12% each) [C341].

Supporting sources selected by synthesizer: C341

Major ethical concerns about generative AI include threats to academic integrity, authorship ambiguity, plagiarism risks, and model hallucinations. · strong

Commentaries and reviews consistently identify risks to scholarly authenticity, detection challenges, and conceptual threats to disciplines like ethics and social science [C342, C343, C346]. Bail notes risks of bias, replication failure, and low-quality output proliferation [C343]; Zohny et al. question whether human authorship can be verified [C342].

Supporting sources selected by synthesizer: C342, C343, C346

There is a lack of empirically validated tools or standardized protocols to assess researchers’ ethical literacy or compliance with AI guidelines in MHPE. · moderate

While UNESCO and HEC provide principles, Cha et al. note the absence of 'actionable research ethics standards' tailored to generative AI’s unique risks [C347]. Hardie et al. call for 'clear policies and guidelines' in nursing education but report none are validated [C346]. No retrieved study offers a psychometrically tested instrument for MHPE contexts.

Supporting sources selected by synthesizer: C346, C347

Implementation of generative AI in healthcare and education faces systemic barriers including workforce readiness, data governance, and medico-legal uncertainty. · moderate

Reddy applies implementation science frameworks (TAM, NASSS) to show that successful integration requires addressing clinician trust, data privacy, and system interoperability—not just technical capability [C344]. Qian similarly notes tension between AI efficiency and cognitive skill outsourcing in higher education [C340].

Supporting sources selected by synthesizer: C340, C344

Expert consensus can inform practical AI ethics guidelines, with high agreement on documentation, safety, explainability, and human oversight. · limited

A Delphi study with 35 experts derived consensus on core items like explainable AI, diverse training data, and human-in-the-loop design [C347]. However, this is a single study focused on healthcare research generally, not MHPE specifically.

Supporting sources selected by synthesizer: C347

[C340] Pedagogical Applications of Generative AI in Higher Education: A Systematic Review of the Field · TechTrends Open source

[C341] The impact of generative AI on health professional education: A systematic review in the context of student learning · Medical Education Open source

[C342] Ethics of generative AI · Journal of Medical Ethics Open source

[C343] Can Generative AI improve social science? · Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America Open source

[C344] Generative AI in healthcare: an implementation science informed translational path on application, integration and governance · Implementation Science : IS Open source

[C345] Generative AI for Economic Research: Use Cases and Implications for Economists · Journal of Economic Literature Open source

[C346] Applications, attitudes and ethical considerations of Generative Artificial Intelligence (Gen AI) in nursing education: a scoping review · BMC Nursing Open source

[C347] Development of research ethics guidelines for healthcare generative artificial intelligence: deriving expert consensus through a Delphi study · BMC Medical Ethics Open source

Agreements:

Disagreements:

Limitations: Only 8 academic sources were provided; 16 additional papers were omitted, limiting comprehensiveness.; Most evidence consists of reviews, commentaries, or non-MHPE-specific studies; primary empirical data on researcher behavior in MHPE is sparse.; No study directly evaluates HEC or UNESCO guideline adherence in medical education settings.; Geographic representation is unclear; implications for low-resource or Global South contexts remain speculative.; The rapid pace of AI development means guidelines and findings may quickly become outdated.

The proposed research should focus on empirical measurement of gaps between policy (HEC/UNESCO) and practice in MHPE, using mixed methods to assess awareness, usage patterns, and perceived barriers. Prioritize development of context-sensitive tools and interventions over theoretical critique.

Developer evaluation (manual)

Ratings do not affect synthesis. Rate the active answer and evidence you reviewed.

Developer diagnostics

Balanced primary: qwen/qwen3-max. Fallback: openai/o4-mini.

Fallback triggered: No. Reason: None. Accepted synthesizer: qwen/qwen3-max.

Synthesis routing latency: 24271 ms. Total routing cost (USD): 0.0110572800.

Plan-and-Solve diagnostics

Generated queries: 13; retrieval queries: 5; duplicates removed: 1; unique papers: 24.

semantic_scholar: 1 requests; 0 results; 1 failed requests.

consensus: 5 requests; 25 results; 0 failed requests.

Normalized ResearchPlan
original_question
act as an expert research in mhpe and work on the topic to find the gap relevant in the literature to the title of research proposal,look into the rationale of the study,how is it impactful and justifiable ,how will it add any contribuion to the recent studies and also when there are guidleiens by HEC and UNESCo for usage of generative AI in research work ,extratct relevant articles to cite and identify the gaps in it (atleas 10 article for now),what i sthe actual concept of the whole study with reelavnt justiciation withteh artciles avaiabl.how will teh tudy sample be taken,how the methods will be decided,hw to amke study more impactable ,what are the objectives and what questinnaire can be geenrated from the ttile of the study.
canonical_search_queries
['"generative AI" "health professions education" guidelines UNESCO HEC', 'Generative AI in research', 'HEC guidelines generative AI research ethics medical', '"artificial intelligence" "medical education research" ethics policies', 'Applications of generative AI in academia']
keywords
['generative AI', 'health professions education', 'MHPE', 'HEC guidelines', 'UNESCO guidelines', 'research ethics', 'academic integrity', 'artificial intelligence', 'Research work', 'Research quality', 'UNESCO AI policy', 'medical humanities']
synonyms
['large language models', 'medical education', 'AI policies', 'research guidelines', 'academic honesty', 'educational technology', 'AI-generated content', 'Machine learning', 'Deep learning', 'Natural language processing', 'artificial intelligence', 'research misconduct']
research_subquestions
['What is the current level of adherence among MHPE researchers to HEC and UNESCO guidelines on generative AI usage?', 'How do health professions education researchers perceive the ethical implications and academic integrity of using generative AI?', 'What are the primary institutional barriers to implementing standardized AI research policies in health professions education?', 'What educational interventions or training programs can bridge the gap in ethical generative AI research practices for MHPE students?', 'What are the current trends and applications of generative AI in research?', 'How do researchers perceive the benefits and challenges of using generative AI in their work?', 'What are the implications of generative AI on research quality, validity, and reliability?', 'How can generative AI be used to improve research efficiency and productivity?', 'What are the current gaps between HEC/UNESCO AI guidelines and actual research practices in medical fields?', 'How do researchers perceive ethical implications of using generative AI in medical research?', 'What validation methods ensure AI-generated content meets academic integrity standards?', 'How can institutional policies effectively balance innovation with ethical responsibility in AI-assisted research?']
candidate_gap_hypotheses
['Lack of empirical studies measuring compliance of medical education researchers with UNESCO generative AI frameworks', 'Absence of validated assessment instruments for evaluating ethical AI literacy in MHPE programs', 'Discrepancy between institutional policy presence and student/faculty awareness of AI regulations in low-to-middle income countries', 'Lack of empirical studies on the impact of generative AI on research work', "Limited understanding of researchers' perceptions and attitudes towards generative AI", 'Insufficient guidelines for the responsible use of generative AI in research', 'Limited empirical studies on HEC guideline implementation effectiveness', 'Insufficient data on researcher understanding of UNESCO AI recommendations', 'Lack of standardized AI disclosure protocols across medical journals', 'Minimal research on long-term impacts of AI on medical research validity', 'Gaps in training curricula for ethical AI use in medical education', 'Unclear enforcement mechanisms for AI-related research misconduct']
uncertainties
['The degree to which self-reported compliance with AI guidelines matches actual research writing practices', 'The long-term impact of regulatory frameworks on the rate of innovative AI-assisted educational research', 'The extent to which generative AI can improve research productivity and quality', 'The potential risks and challenges associated with the use of generative AI in research', 'Rapidly evolving AI technology outpaces policy development', 'Varying interpretations of existing guidelines across institutions', 'Difficulty distinguishing AI assistance from authorship', 'Unclear liability frameworks for AI-generated errors', 'Evolving definitions of academic integrity in AI context', 'Limited longitudinal data on AI research impacts', 'Uncertain effectiveness of current detection tools', 'Varying stakeholder priorities in policy development']
filters
{'suggestions': [{'year_from': 2022, 'year_to': 2024, 'fields': ['Medicine', 'Education', 'Social Sciences', 'Information Technology'], 'study_types': ['Mixed Methods', 'Cross-Sectional Surveys', 'Policy Analyses', 'Scoping Reviews']}, {'year_from': 2020, 'year_to': 2023, 'fields': ['Computer Science', 'Education', 'Social Sciences'], 'study_types': ['Surveys', 'Case studies', 'Experimental studies']}, {'year_from': 2019, 'year_to': 2024, 'fields': ['Medical Humanities', 'Research Ethics', 'Health Policy', 'Academic Publishing', 'AI Governance'], 'study_types': ['Systematic Review', 'Policy Analysis', 'Qualitative Study', 'Survey Research', 'Case Study']}], 'policy': 'Advisory only; configured provider filters apply.'}
generated_query_count
13
successful_planners
3

Retrieval is incomplete; absence of results is not proof of absence.

Provider counts describe latest attempts; evidence and answer metrics describe active results. Duration and costs include all attempts, including retries. Cost is USD, OpenRouter only; Consensus billing is not estimated. Unknown is not zero.

total_duration_ms
101799
interrupted_execution_metrics_incomplete
False
successful_providers
4
failed_providers
1
successful_agents
3
consensus_success
True
synthesis_success
True
paper_count
24
total_estimated_openrouter_cost
0.0293352400
known_cost_subtotal
0.0293352400
attempts_missing_cost
0
valid_source_percent
100.0
removed_source_ids
0
agreements_count
0
disagreements_count
0
evidence_strength_distribution
{'strong': 2, 'moderate': 2, 'limited': 1}
judge_confidence
75.0
answer_length
945
Attempt / modelSuccessLatency msInput / output / total tokensCost USDError
#109 academic-graph-searchNo458? / ? / ?Unknown rate_limit: Semantic Scholar retrieval failed (rate_limit).
#108 search-v1Yes25643? / ? / ?Unknown :
#107 qwen/qwen3.5-27bYes26954790 / 1496 / 22860.0034446600 reported:
#106 meta-llama/llama-4-scoutYes14502478 / 460 / 9380.0001858000 reported:
#105 google/gemini-3.5-flashYes97661353 / 1402 / 27550.0146475000 reported:
#21 qwen/qwen3-maxYes242717456 / 1344 / 88000.0110572800 reported:

Judge: qwen/qwen3-max. Papers used: 8. Papers omitted by limit: 16.

Rejected source IDs: None recorded

RESEARCH QUESTION

learning autonomyand geenrative AI articles

Oct 8, 2026 · 03:58 PARTIAL

30-SECOND VIEW

Final Research Answer

{"research_topics": [{"topic": "The impact of generative AI on self-regulated learning behaviors in postsecondary writing", "rationale": "Understanding how learners manage, monitor, and reflect on AI-assisted writing is critical for designing effective pedagogical interventions.", "existing_literature": "C654 shows mixed evidence: while learners report high responsibility and strategy use, self-monitoring remains low; C651 notes risks of cognitive offloading but also potential for fostering autonomy.", "unresolved_question": "How can educators scaffold metacognitive monitoring to prevent passive reliance on generative AI during autonomous wr…
Read full answer
{"research_topics": [{"topic": "The impact of generative AI on self-regulated learning behaviors in postsecondary writing", "rationale": "Understanding how learners manage, monitor, and reflect on AI-assisted writing is critical for designing effective pedagogical interventions.", "existing_literature": "C654 shows mixed evidence: while learners report high responsibility and strategy use, self-monitoring remains low; C651 notes risks of cognitive offloading but also potential for fostering autonomy.", "unresolved_question": "How can educators scaffold metacognitive monitoring to prevent passive reliance on generative AI during autonomous writing tasks?", "population": "Postsecondary students engaged in academic writing", "variables": ["AI literacy", "self-monitoring frequency", "revision behaviors", "perceived competence"], "methodology": "Longitudinal mixed-methods design combining log analysis, surveys, and reflective interviews", "feasibility": "High—writing contexts are accessible, tools like ChatGPT are widely available, and existing frameworks (e.g., ICAP-ME in C657) support measurement", "supporting_source_ids": ["C654", "C651", "C657"], "limitations_addressed": ["Short-term data in C654", "lack of standardized autonomy definitions"]}, {"topic": "Prompt engineering as a lever for learner agency across disciplines", "rationale": "Prompt literacy may mediate the shift from dependency to autonomy, yet most studies focus on language or programming contexts.", "existing_literature": "C656 demonstrates that structured prompt engineering courses improve autonomous learning in academic English; C652 links LLM use to competence and bespoke learning in programming; C651 calls for more research on prompt literacy.", "unresolved_question": "Do disciplinary differences in epistemic practices affect how prompt engineering supports or hinders autonomy?", "population": "Undergraduate students in STEM, humanities, and social sciences", "variables": ["prompt sophistication", "disciplinary epistemic beliefs", "perceived control", "task engagement"], "methodology": "Comparative case studies with discourse and performance analysis", "feasibility": "Moderate—requires cross-disciplinary collaboration but builds on TeacherGAIA (C655) and course designs in C656", "supporting_source_ids": ["C656", "C652", "C651", "C655"], "limitations_addressed": ["STEM bias in current research", "rapid obsolescence of AI tools"]}, {"topic": "Mediated autonomy in under-resourced EFL contexts", "rationale": "Generative AI may compensate for limited instructional support, but ethical and literacy gaps could exacerbate inequities.", "existing_literature": "C653 reveals that ChatGPT acts as a compensatory tool in Palestinian EFL programs, but autonomy is mediated by AI literacy and ethical awareness; C658 highlights agency types (receptive, reflective, etc.) that vary by context.", "unresolved_question": "How can institutions develop context-sensitive AI literacy curricula that promote responsible autonomy without reinforcing dependency?", "population": "Undergraduate EFL learners in under-resourced higher education settings", "variables": ["institutional support", "AI literacy", "ethical reasoning", "writing autonomy"], "methodology": "Participatory action research co-designing literacy modules with students and instructors", "feasibility": "High in targeted contexts; builds directly on C653 findings and addresses digital native myth", "supporting_source_ids": ["C653", "C658"], "limitations_addressed": ["Overgeneralization of autonomy constructs", "neglect of Global South contexts"]}]}
Executive summary

Current research indicates generative AI can both enhance and threaten learner autonomy. Systematic reviews (C651) and empirical studies (C652–C658) show AI tools support self-directed learning through personalized scaffolding, motivation, and reduced cognitive load, particularly in writing and programming. However, risks include overreliance, diminished critical thinking, and unequal outcomes due to varying AI literacy. Autonomy is not inherent but mediated by prompt engineering skills, ethical awareness, and institutional context. Most evidence comes from short-term, discipline-specific studies in higher education, with limited attention to longitudinal effects or diverse academic fields. The boundary between productive assistance and passive dependence remains poorly defined.

Export Research · coming later

Partial research available

semantic_scholar: Semantic Scholar retrieval failed (rate_limit). Retry

Overall confidence70%Synthesizer confidence estimate
Evidence strengthLimitedLowest reported finding strength; conflicts take precedence
Academic papers19 papers
AI agents3/3 successfulActive saved responses
ConsensusAvailable
Semantic ScholarUnavailable

2-MINUTE VIEW

Key Findings

Moderate 3 sources

Generative AI can enhance learner autonomy when used with sufficient AI literacy and ethical awareness.

Support diagnostic: academically supported

View sources

Generative AI can enhance learner autonomy when used with sufficient AI literacy and ethical awareness.

Multiple studies (C652, C653, C654) report increased sense of competence, bespoke learning, and strategic use, but emphasize that benefits depend on learners’ ability to critically evaluate and responsibly use AI outputs.

[C652] Programming education and learner motivation in the age of generative AI: student and educator perspectives Open source

[C653] AI literacy and mediated learner autonomy in ChatGPT-supported EFL writing: a qualitative study at a Palestinian university Open source

[C654] Understanding self-directed learning in AI-Assisted writing: A mixed methods study of postsecondary learners Open source

Moderate 2 sources

Prompt engineering and intentional instructional design are key to fostering autonomous, not dependent, AI use.

Support diagnostic: academically supported

View sources

Prompt engineering and intentional instructional design are key to fostering autonomous, not dependent, AI use.

C655 and C656 demonstrate that structuring AI interactions via constructivist prompt engineering promotes self-assessment and self-regulation, contrasting with default chatbot modes that encourage passive reception.

[C655] Supporting self-directed learning and self-assessment using TeacherGAIA, a generative AI chatbot application: Learning approaches and prompt engineering Open source

[C656] The Impact of Prompt Engineering and a Generative AI-Driven Tool on Autonomous Learning: A Case Study Open source

Moderate 1 sources

Student agency mediates the relationship between AI use and learning outcomes.

Support diagnostic: academically supported

View sources

Student agency mediates the relationship between AI use and learning outcomes.

C658 identifies four agency types (receptive, resistive, resourceful, reflective) linked to deeper learning, showing that how students position themselves toward AI determines its impact on autonomy.

[C658] From surface to deep learning approaches with Generative AI in higher education: an analytical framework of student agency Open source

Limited 1 sources

Generative AI cannot replace social support, a core component of sustained motivation and autonomy.

Support diagnostic: weak support

View sources

Generative AI cannot replace social support, a core component of sustained motivation and autonomy.

C652 explicitly states that while LLMs improve competence and affect, they fail to provide social relatedness, which remains essential under self-determination theory.

[C652] Programming education and learner motivation in the age of generative AI: student and educator perspectives Open source

Moderate 2 sources

Overreliance on generative AI risks outsourcing metacognitive and critical thinking skills.

Support diagnostic: academically supported

View sources

Overreliance on generative AI risks outsourcing metacognitive and critical thinking skills.

C651 and C654 note concerns about cognitive offloading; while some learners reflect critically, survey data show generally low self-monitoring, suggesting vulnerability to passive use.

[C651] Pedagogical Applications of Generative AI in Higher Education: A Systematic Review of the Field Open source

[C654] Understanding self-directed learning in AI-Assisted writing: A mixed methods study of postsecondary learners Open source

Evidence Overview

8 valid sources · 0 conflicting findings · 0 disagreements · 19 papers reviewed

The metrics above describe saved evidence. Source associations and agreement between models are not independent verification.

Best Academic Evidence

Saved synthesis ranking where available; otherwise Consensus order. Retrieved papers are not automatically proof of a claim.

Consensus

Pedagogical Applications of Generative AI in Higher Education: A Systematic Review of the Field

Yu-Feng Qian · 2025 · TechTrends

The release of ChatGPT in late 2022 marked the beginning of a rapid transformation in higher education, soon followed by the development of multimodal generative AI programs. As this technology becomes increasingly integrated into teaching and learning, it is crucial to evaluate its current use and…

Read paper details

Yu-Feng Qian

The release of ChatGPT in late 2022 marked the beginning of a rapid transformation in higher education, soon followed by the development of multimodal generative AI programs. As this technology becomes increasingly integrated into teaching and learning, it is crucial to evaluate its current use and impact. This systematic literature review captures the initial academic response to generative AI, providing insights into how higher education has adopted this transformative technology in its first two years. The findings indicate that while some themes from the pre-ChatGPT era persist, new and emerging trends—particularly in fostering creativity, critical thinking, learning autonomy, and prompt literacy—are now taking shape. This shift underscores a growing emphasis on the pedagogical integration of generative AI. However, the review also highlights a key tension: while generative AI enhances efficiency, it raises concerns about overreliance, potentially leading to the outsourcing of critical cognitive and metacognitive skills. To address these challenges and fully harness the potential of generative AI, future research should focus on exploring multimodal generative AI tools and fostering student–teacher-AI collaboration.

DOI: 10.1007/s11528-025-01100-1

Open source ↗
Consensus

Programming education and learner motivation in the age of generative AI: student and educator perspectives

Samuel Boguslawski, Rowan Deer, Mark G. Dawson · 2024 · Information and Learning Sciences

Purpose Programming education is being rapidly transformed by generative AI tools and educators must determine how best to support students in this context. This study aims to explore the experiences of programming educators and students to inform future education provision. Design/methodology/a…

Read paper details

Samuel Boguslawski, Rowan Deer, Mark G. Dawson

Purpose Programming education is being rapidly transformed by generative AI tools and educators must determine how best to support students in this context. This study aims to explore the experiences of programming educators and students to inform future education provision. Design/methodology/approach Twelve students and six members of faculty in a small technology-focused university were interviewed. Thematic analysis of the interview data was combined with data collected from a survey of 44 students at the same university. Self-determination theory was applied as an analytical framework. Findings Three themes were identified – bespoke learning, affect and support – that significantly impact motivation and learning outcomes in programming education. It was also found that students are already making extensive use of large language models (LLMs). LLMs can significantly improve learner autonomy and sense of competence by improving the options for bespoke learning; fostering emotions that are conducive to engendering and maintaining motivation; and inhibiting the negative affective states that discourage learning. However, current LLMs cannot adequately provide or replace social support, which is still a key factor in learner motivation. Research limitations/implications Integrating the use of LLMs into curricula can improve learning motivation and outcomes. It can also free educators from certain tasks, leaving them with more time and capacity to focus their attention on developing social learning opportunities to further enhance learner motivation. Originality/value To the best of the authors’ knowledge, this is the first attempt to explore the relationship between motivation and LLM use in programming education.

DOI: 10.1108/ils-10-2023-0163

Open source ↗
Consensus

AI literacy and mediated learner autonomy in ChatGPT-supported EFL writing: a qualitative study at a Palestinian university

B. Hamamra, Nejme Mahamid · 2026 · International Journal of Educational Technology in Higher Education

The rapid expansion of generative artificial intelligence (AI) has reshaped higher education, raising urgent pedagogical, ethical, and epistemic questions. In English as a Foreign Language (EFL) contexts, tools such as ChatGPT challenge established understandings of learner autonomy, authorship, an…

Read paper details

B. Hamamra, Nejme Mahamid

The rapid expansion of generative artificial intelligence (AI) has reshaped higher education, raising urgent pedagogical, ethical, and epistemic questions. In English as a Foreign Language (EFL) contexts, tools such as ChatGPT challenge established understandings of learner autonomy, authorship, and academic integrity. This qualitative study examines how AI literacy mediates learner autonomy and ethical decision-making in ChatGPT use within EFL programs at a Palestinian university. Drawing on semi-structured interviews and focus group discussions with EFL instructors and undergraduate students, the study employs thematic analysis to investigate how generative AI is interpreted and enacted in pedagogical practice. The findings indicate that ChatGPT functioned as a compensatory resource in contexts of limited instructional support, but its pedagogical value depended on learners’ AI literacy and ethical awareness. The study also challenges the “digital native” assumption by showing that technological confidence did not necessarily translate into evaluative competence or responsible AI use in Palestinian university EFL writing.

DOI: 10.1186/s41239-026-00597-7

Open source ↗
View all papers (19)Consensus

Understanding self-directed learning in AI-Assisted writing: A mixed methods study of postsecondary learners

Chaoran Wang, Zi-Xi Li, Curtis J. Bonk · 2024 · Comput. Educ. Artif. Intell.

This study investigates how postsecondary learners employ generative AI, specifically ChatGPT, to support their self-directed learning (SDL) for writing purposes. Following a sequential mixed methods design, we analyzed 384 survey responses and 10 semi-structured interviews with postsecondary write…

Read paper details

Chaoran Wang, Zi-Xi Li, Curtis J. Bonk

This study investigates how postsecondary learners employ generative AI, specifically ChatGPT, to support their self-directed learning (SDL) for writing purposes. Following a sequential mixed methods design, we analyzed 384 survey responses and 10 semi-structured interviews with postsecondary writers. Findings suggest that the major learning task that the learners used ChatGPT for writing is brainstorming and seeking inspiration for ideas. While the entering motivation for using ChatGPT varies from curiosity about innovative technologies to fulfilling academic requirements, such entering motivation transformed into task motivation when the learners perceived the potential benefits of ChatGPT for assisting their writing. In terms of self-management, participants mostly demonstrated a high responsibility towards their own learning with ChatGPT and employed various strategies for SDL. Although survey respondents demonstrated a comparatively low level of self-monitoring, most interviewees claimed that they critically reflected on their learning process and validated information provided by ChatGPT. There are mixed opinions regarding whether the writing skills have improved as a result of using ChatGPT. Some participants suggested that the benefits brought by ChatGPT, such as alleviating social pressure and receiving instant feedback at any time, encouraged them to spend more time practicing writing and making revisions. However, some argue that assessing their AI-assisted SDL learning progress in the short term is challenging. This study addresses gaps in the existing literature where there is scarce, large-scale empirical research on self-directed AI usage in writing, shedding light on the emerging phenomenon of utilizing generative AI as a means of SDL in writing.

DOI: 10.1016/j.caeai.2024.100247

Open source ↗
Consensus

Supporting self-directed learning and self-assessment using TeacherGAIA, a generative AI chatbot application: Learning approaches and prompt engineering

Farhan Ali, D. Choy, Shanti Divaharan, Yong-Tay Hui, Wenli Chen · 2023 · Learning: Research and Practice

ABSTRACT Self-directed learning and self-assessment require student responsibility over learning needs, goals, processes, and outcomes. However, this student-led learning can be challenging to achieve in a classroom limited by a one-to-many teacher-led instruction. We, thus, have designed and proto…

Read paper details

Farhan Ali, D. Choy, Shanti Divaharan, Yong-Tay Hui, Wenli Chen

ABSTRACT Self-directed learning and self-assessment require student responsibility over learning needs, goals, processes, and outcomes. However, this student-led learning can be challenging to achieve in a classroom limited by a one-to-many teacher-led instruction. We, thus, have designed and prototyped a generative artificial intelligence chatbot application (GAIA), named TeacherGAIA, that can be used to asynchronously support students in their self-directed learning and self-assessment outside the classroom. We first identified diverse constructivist learning approaches that align with, and promote, student-led learning. These included knowledge construction, inquiry-based learning, self-assessment, and peer teaching. The in-context learning abilities of large language model (LLM) from OpenAI were then leveraged via prompt engineering to steer interactions supporting these different learning approaches. These interactions contrasted with ChatGPT, OpenAI’s chatbot which by default engaged in the traditional transmissionist mode of learning reminiscent of teacher-led instruction. Preliminary design, prompt engineering and prototyping suggested fidelity to the learning approaches, cognitive guidance, and social-emotional support, all of which were implemented in a generative AI manner without pre-specified rules or “hard-coding”. Other affordances of TeacherGAIA are discussed and future development outlined. We anticipate TeacherGAIA to be a useful application for teachers in facilitating self-directed learning and self-assessment among K-12 students.

DOI: 10.1080/23735082.2023.2258886

Open source ↗
Consensus

The Impact of Prompt Engineering and a Generative AI-Driven Tool on Autonomous Learning: A Case Study

Kovan Mzwri, M. Turcsányi-Szabó · 2025 · Education Sciences

This study evaluates “I Learn with Prompt Engineering”, a self-paced, self-regulated elective course designed to equip university students with skills in prompt engineering to effectively utilize large language models (LLMs), foster self-directed learning, and enhance academic English proficiency t…

Read paper details

Kovan Mzwri, M. Turcsányi-Szabó

This study evaluates “I Learn with Prompt Engineering”, a self-paced, self-regulated elective course designed to equip university students with skills in prompt engineering to effectively utilize large language models (LLMs), foster self-directed learning, and enhance academic English proficiency through generative AI applications. By integrating prompt engineering concepts with generative AI tools, the course supports autonomous learning and addresses critical skill gaps in language proficiency and market-ready capabilities. The study also examines EnSmart, an AI-driven tool powered by GPT-4 and integrated into Canvas LMS, which automates academic test content generation and grading and delivers real-time, human-like feedback. Performance evaluation, structured questionnaires, and surveys were used to evaluate the course’s impact on prompting skills, academic English proficiency, and overall learning experiences. Results demonstrated significant improvements in prompt engineering skills, with accessible patterns like “Persona” proving highly effective, while advanced patterns such as “Flipped Interaction” posed challenges. Gains in academic English were most notable among students with lower initial proficiency, though engagement and practice time varied. Students valued EnSmart’s intuitive integration and grading accuracy but identified limitations in question diversity and adaptability. The high final success rate demonstrated that proper course design (taking into consideration Panadero’s four dimensions of self-regulated learning) can facilitate successful autonomous learning. The findings highlight generative AI’s potential to enhance autonomous learning and task automation, emphasizing the necessity of human oversight for ethical and effective implementation in education.

DOI: 10.3390/educsci15020199

Open source ↗
Consensus

Clue before correction: ChatGPT-enhanced strategy for promoting autonomous and reflective language learning

Alice Lukešová, Petra Juna Jennings · 2026 · Innovation in Language Learning and Teaching

Purpose This study presents a generative AI-supported revision task designed to promote adaptive learning, learner autonomy, and metacognitive engagement in second language (L2) writing through clue-based interaction with ChatGPT. Unlike traditional chatbot use for direct error correction, which po…

Read paper details

Alice Lukešová, Petra Juna Jennings

Purpose This study presents a generative AI-supported revision task designed to promote adaptive learning, learner autonomy, and metacognitive engagement in second language (L2) writing through clue-based interaction with ChatGPT. Unlike traditional chatbot use for direct error correction, which positions learners as passive recipients, this activity was intentionally structured to require active problem-solving, prompting students to infer correct solutions from guided hints.Design/methodology/approach Fifty-eight university students (CEFR A1–B1) completed a bilingual activity in English or Spanish that used indirect prompts to guide self-revision, supported by ChatGPT. Learner–AI interaction transcripts and open-ended reflections were analyzed using Cognitive Load Theory, formative feedback models, and the newly developed ICAP-ME framework, which extends the ICAP model to include metacognitive and affective dimensions.Findings ChatGPT provided structured, adaptive feedback that reduced cognitive load and supported personalized revision pathways, particularly for more proficient learners. Learner prompting behavior strongly influenced feedback quality and depth.Originality/value This study introduces (1) a replicable instructional design for GenAI-supported revision, (2) the ICAP-ME pedagogical framework for analyzing AI-mediated learning, and (3) design principles for equitable, developmentally appropriate use of GenAI in language education. It contributes to emerging research on how AI tools can foster autonomy, reflective engagement, and strategic learning.

DOI: 10.1080/17501229.2025.2612532

Open source ↗
Consensus

From surface to deep learning approaches with Generative AI in higher education: an analytical framework of student agency

Yun-Ying Yang, Jin-Wen Luo, Miaoyan Yang, Run-De Yang, Jia-Ying Chen · 2024 · Studies in Higher Education

ABSTRACT Recent emergence of generative artificial intelligence (GenAI) technology has stimulated interests as well as concerns in their potential in teaching and learning. Situated in the new and transforming context, this study provides an avenue for students to introspectively explore their use …

Read paper details

Yun-Ying Yang, Jin-Wen Luo, Miaoyan Yang, Run-De Yang, Jia-Ying Chen

ABSTRACT Recent emergence of generative artificial intelligence (GenAI) technology has stimulated interests as well as concerns in their potential in teaching and learning. Situated in the new and transforming context, this study provides an avenue for students to introspectively explore their use of GenAI in a postgraduate course. Seventy-four students from three Chinese universities participated in this study. By analyzing student interviews conducted pre- and post-course, alongside their chat logs with GenAI and reflective journal entries detailing their learning approaches, the research uncovers a spectrum of student perspectives on GenAI’s impact, ranging from beneficial optimism, to cautious skepticism and adaptable pragmatism. Notably, student agency is identified as a crucial element in relation to these themes. This was articulated in four types of learning activities: receptive, resistive, resourceful, and reflective. The research underscores the importance of supporting and empowering student agency in the learning approaches aided by GenAI in education, highlighting its role in optimizing its use and enhancing autonomous, lifelong learning skills amidst the evolving technologically advanced learning landscape.

DOI: 10.1080/03075079.2024.2327003

Open source ↗
Consensus

Learning with Generative Artificial Intelligence Within a Network of Co-Regulation

Jason Lodge, P. D. de Barba, Jaclyn Broadbent · 2023 · Journal of University Teaching and Learning Practice

The emergence of generative artificial intelligence (AI) has created legitimate concerns surrounding academic integrity and the ease with which such technologies might lead to cheating in assessment, in particular. However, fixating solely on potential misconduct is overshadowing a more profound, t…

Read paper details

Jason Lodge, P. D. de Barba, Jaclyn Broadbent

The emergence of generative artificial intelligence (AI) has created legitimate concerns surrounding academic integrity and the ease with which such technologies might lead to cheating in assessment, in particular. However, fixating solely on potential misconduct is overshadowing a more profound, transformative interaction between learners and machines. This commentary article delves into the relationship between students and AI, aiming to highlight the need for revised pedagogical strategies in the AI age. We argue that the much-discussed approaches that prioritise AI literacy or augmented critical thinking might be inadequate. Instead, we contend that a more holistic approach emphasising self-regulated learning (SRL) and co-regulation of learning is needed. SRL promotes autonomy, adaptability, and a deeper understanding, qualities indispensable for navigating the intricacies of AI-enhanced learning environments. Furthermore, we introduce the notion of a network of co-regulation, which underscores the intertwined learning processes between humans and machines. By positioning the self at the core of this network, we emphasise the indispensable role of individual agency in steering productive human-AI educational interactions. Our contention is that by fostering SRL and understanding co-regulated dynamics, educators can better equip learners for an interconnected AI-driven world.

DOI: 10.53761/1.20.7.02

Open source ↗
Consensus

Can interaction with generative artificial intelligence enhance learning autonomy? A longitudinal study from comparative perspectives of virtual companionship and knowledge acquisition preferences

Ze-Hang Xie, Xin-Zhu Wu, Yun-Xiang Xie · 2024 · J. Comput. Assist. Learn.

With the development of artificial intelligence (AI) technology, generative AI has been widely used in the field of education and represents a groundbreaking shift in overcoming the constraints of time and space within educational activities. However, previous literature has not paid enough attenti…

Read paper details

Ze-Hang Xie, Xin-Zhu Wu, Yun-Xiang Xie

With the development of artificial intelligence (AI) technology, generative AI has been widely used in the field of education and represents a groundbreaking shift in overcoming the constraints of time and space within educational activities. However, previous literature has not paid enough attention to AI‐involved teaching patterns, and it is necessary to evaluate the effects of this learning pattern.ObjectivesBased on the social presence theory and the community of inquiry model, the main purpose of this study is to evaluate whether and how interaction frequency with chatbots (IFC) affects people's learning autonomy (LA) under two preferences: knowledge acquisition and virtual companionship, and whether social presence (SP) plays a mediating role.The 1‐year longitudinal study was designed to be conducted from May 2022 to May 2023 and included three rounds of surveys of 1155 undergraduate students on their use of robots for learning.For learners preferring virtual companionship, no direct correlation was found between IFC and LA. However, SP acted as a mediating factor, enhancing LA through increased chatbot interactions. This suggests that while direct interactions may not directly influence LA, the resulting SP can foster it. Conversely, for learners favouring knowledge acquisition, higher IFC negatively impacted both SP and LA. Despite this, a strong sense of SP consistently correlated positively with LA, indicating it could offset some negative effects of frequent chatbot use.

DOI: 10.1111/jcal.13032

Open source ↗
Consensus

Enhancing self-directed learning and Python mastery through integration of a large language model and learning analytics dashboard

Ming Liu, Zhong-Ming Wu, Hai-Min Dai, Yi-Fei Su, L. Malik, Jian Liao, Wei Zhang, Shuo Guo, Li Liu, … · 2025 · Br. J. Educ. Technol.

Self‐directed learning (SDL) is a critical skill in the 21st century, particularly in online Python learning environments. Learning analytics (LA) can track and analyse learning processes, which can be leveraged to prompt students to reflect on their learning strategies and progress through learnin…

Read paper details

Ming Liu, Zhong-Ming Wu, Hai-Min Dai, Yi-Fei Su, L. Malik, Jian Liao, Wei Zhang, Shuo Guo, Li Liu, Jun-Qiang Zhao

Self‐directed learning (SDL) is a critical skill in the 21st century, particularly in online Python learning environments. Learning analytics (LA) can track and analyse learning processes, which can be leveraged to prompt students to reflect on their learning strategies and progress through learning analytics dashboards (LADs). However, LADs lack pedagogical domain knowledge and fail to provide effective personalised feedback and guidance. This study designs and presents a Generative AI‐powered SDL tool, SDLChat. It integrates a large language model (ERNIE‐3.5) with retrieval‐augmented generation (RAG) technology to generate contextualised, actionable feedback for learners across the entire SDL cycle: planning, self‐monitoring and self‐reflection. To evaluate the impact of SDLChat on learners' SDL skills and Python knowledge, a randomised experimental study was conducted over a six‐week Python online course. The study compared the changes in SDL skills and Python knowledge of students using both SDLChat and LAD group (n = 39) and LAD‐only group (n = 35). The results indicate that: (1) students using SDLChat and LAD significantly outperformed those using LAD alone in Python knowledge mastery, self‐monitoring and interpersonal skills and (2) the LAD‐only group showed significant improvement only in Python knowledge mastery; however, (3) no significant differences were found in posttask motivation between these two groups. This study highlights the potential of integrating LLM with learning analytics to enhance SDL skills and learning performance in online learning contexts. It also establishes a theory‐informed operational framework for understanding the LLM‐empowered SDL process. What is already known about this topic Self‐directed learning (SDL) is essential for success in online learning environments, requiring learners to plan, manage, monitor and reflect on their learning processes. Learning analytics (LA), particularly in the form of learning analytics dashboards (LADs), is commonly used to track SDL processes and encourage learner reflection. Traditional LADs are incapable of providing personalised feedback, limiting their effectiveness in enhancing SDL skills and learning performance. What this paper adds Introduces SDLChat, an LLM‐powered SDL tool combining a large language model (ERNIE‐3.5) and retrieval‐augmented generation (RAG) technology to generate contextualised and actionable feedback across the full SDL cycle. Provides empirical evidence from a quasi‐experimental study demonstrating that the integration of SDLChat and a LAD enhances self‐monitoring and interpersonal skills. Highlights the superiority of the integration of SDLChat and LAD in improving learning performance. Proposes an AI4SDL operational framework by including a technological dimension to extend SDL theory in online learning environments. Implications for practice and/or policy Educators and instructional designers can leverage AI‐powered tools like SDLChat to provide personalised feedback, fostering key SDL skills and improving learning outcomes in online environments. Policymakers should establish SDL skills as curricular objectives and implement professional development programmes to enhance teachers' digital literacy and their capacity for human–AI collaborative instruction. Institutions offering online courses may benefit from adopting AI‐driven solutions to enhance student engagement, self‐monitoring and academic performance, potentially improving course completion rates and learner satisfaction.

DOI: 10.1111/bjet.70005

Open source ↗
Consensus

Generative AI: elevating knowledge acquisition and retention and recall through autonomy, interactivity and engagement

Mai Nguyen, Reeti Agarwal, Ashish Malik, Rudresh Pandey · 2025 · J. Enterp. Inf. Manag.

PurposeGenerative AI (GenAI) in education promises remarkable development changes that can enhance learner experience through the personalised and responsive learning process. In this paper, we investigate how the different features of GenAI – autonomy, interactivity and usability – contribute to s…

Read paper details

Mai Nguyen, Reeti Agarwal, Ashish Malik, Rudresh Pandey

PurposeGenerative AI (GenAI) in education promises remarkable development changes that can enhance learner experience through the personalised and responsive learning process. In this paper, we investigate how the different features of GenAI – autonomy, interactivity and usability – contribute to student engagement and learning outcomes.Design/methodology/approachFrom the lens of the self-determination theory, the study seeks to articulate how these GenAI features influence student engagement and their ability to achieve specific goals through interactive learning experiences delivered by GenAI. Qualtrics, a well-known online data collection tool, was employed in the study to collect data from 488 respondents in the UK region who had been exposed to generative AI-based platforms. The sampling approach used was representative, wherein the platform was asked to randomly share the survey with respondents in the UK region who had some experience interacting with Gen AI platforms.FindingsThe paper’s findings show that increased autonomy and interactivity encourage students to engage more in GenAI platforms. Usability functions as a critical mediator with respect to how autonomy and interactivity are incorporated into engagement and skill acquisition. Skill development emerged as a key mediator of the direct effect between GenAI features and student engagement, confirming that it is an important determinant in engaging with educational content. Further, results reveal a significant positive moderation effect of personalisation between autonomy and engagement.Originality/valueThe results extend the self-determination theory and offer theoretical suggestions for improving learning through AI-driven educational tools. For educators, the study provides practical insights to motivate the effective integration of GenAI platforms that can provide autonomy, interactivity, usability and personalisation to increase student engagement.

DOI: 10.1108/jeim-08-2024-0433

Open source ↗
Consensus

Exploring Autonomy in the AI Wilderness: Learner Challenges and Choices

Antonie Alm · 2024 · Education Sciences

The emergence of Generative Artificial Intelligence (GenAI) raises critical questions about learner autonomy and agency. This exploratory case study examines how four university-level German language learners with diverse backgrounds developed autonomy in their learning process through engagement w…

Read paper details

Antonie Alm

The emergence of Generative Artificial Intelligence (GenAI) raises critical questions about learner autonomy and agency. This exploratory case study examines how four university-level German language learners with diverse backgrounds developed autonomy in their learning process through engagement with AI tools. The study was conducted in early 2023 when most learners were first discovering ChatGPT’s potential for language learning. Data were collected through reflective journals, digital portfolios, and interviews during a semester-long course that scaffolded self-directed learning with AI integration. The findings reveal emerging patterns of shared agency between learners and AI tools. Learners developed distinct strategies for AI integration based on their language learning backgrounds, with heritage speakers focusing on accuracy improvement while classroom learners emphasized communication practice. Cross-case analyses identified key dimensions of autonomy development: a critical evaluation of AI output, evolving learner–AI relationships, maintaining and developing a second language (L2) voice, and the strategic integration of AI tools while preserving learner agency. These patterns suggest that autonomy in AI-mediated environments manifests through learners’ capacity to engage productively with AI while maintaining critical awareness and personal agency in their learning process.

DOI: 10.3390/educsci14121369

Open source ↗
Consensus

Generative AI, Cognitive Offloading, and Learner Agency in Higher Education: A Scoping Review

Guanhua Wang, Wenna Wang, Daozhou Yang, Jifan Ren · 2026 · Behavioral Sciences

Generative artificial intelligence (GenAI) is increasingly integrated into higher education, where it supports writing, feedback, problem solving, and research-related tasks while also raising concerns about cognitive offloading and learner dependence. This scoping review maps the literature on the…

Read paper details

Guanhua Wang, Wenna Wang, Daozhou Yang, Jifan Ren

Generative artificial intelligence (GenAI) is increasingly integrated into higher education, where it supports writing, feedback, problem solving, and research-related tasks while also raising concerns about cognitive offloading and learner dependence. This scoping review maps the literature on the relationships among GenAI, cognitive offloading, and learner agency in higher education. Following PRISMA-ScR guidance, searches were conducted on 24 June 2026 across six database sources: Web of Science Core Collection, Scopus, EBSCOhost ERIC, EBSCOhost Education Source, APA PsycInfo via ProQuest, and ProQuest Education Collection via ProQuest Social Science Premium Collection. English-language peer-reviewed or scholarly journal literature published from 2022 to 24 June 2026 was eligible for inclusion. Data were charted using a structured extraction matrix and synthesized through descriptive mapping and theory-informed configurative synthesis. After duplicate removal, 5327 records were screened by title and abstract, 691 full-text reports were assessed, and 123 studies were included in the final charting matrix and synthesis. The review shows that learner agency is conceptualized as a multidimensional construct involving self-regulation, reflective judgement, intentionality, and responsible action. Across the literature, GenAI is best interpreted through an interpretive dual-pattern account: agency-supportive patterns are associated with self-regulated learning, self-efficacy, feedback literacy, and reflective engagement, whereas agency-eroding patterns are associated with cognitive offloading, overreliance, dependence, uncritical uptake, and weakened judgement. These patterns should be interpreted as a configurative synthesis of heterogeneous evidence rather than as causal effect estimates. Overall, the findings suggest that the educational value of GenAI depends less on the technology itself than on how it is pedagogically embedded, with augmentation-oriented and scaffolded use being more supportive of learner agency than replacement-oriented use.

DOI: 10.3390/bs16071150

Open source ↗
Consensus

Exploring the Utility of ChatGPT for Self-directed Online Language Learning

Zi-Xi Li, Chaoran Wang, Curtis J. Bonk · 2024 · Online Learning

As generative AI tools are increasingly popular in today’s teaching and learning process, challenges and opportunities occur at the same time. Self-directed learning has been regarded as a powerful learning ability that supports learners in informal learning contexts and its importance rises in sal…

Read paper details

Zi-Xi Li, Chaoran Wang, Curtis J. Bonk

As generative AI tools are increasingly popular in today’s teaching and learning process, challenges and opportunities occur at the same time. Self-directed learning has been regarded as a powerful learning ability that supports learners in informal learning contexts and its importance rises in salience when incorporating AI into learning. This study employed a mixed-method design to understand how people self-direct their online language learning through the utilization of ChatGPT. Analyzing survey data from 276 survey respondents and 11 one-to-one interviews with language learners in the United States, we found that learners are motivated to use generative AI for its high flexibility and personalization which enables learners to access learning materials that align with their knowledge levels, personal interests, and learning goals. We also found self-monitoring skills that are inherent to learners help them to use ChatGPT more efficiently and achieve their learning goals efficiently. This study contributes to the emerging field of AI in education and explores possibilities to use ChatGPT to foster self-directed language learning and provide educators, instructional designers, and researchers with insights to design learning integrated with AI to best fulfill learners’ diverse needs and expand learning opportunities to more people.

DOI: 10.24059/olj.v28i3.4497

Open source ↗
Consensus

Generative AI in Self-Directed Learning: a thematic scoping review

Jasper Roe, Mike Perkins · 2025 · Interactive Learning Environments

This thematic scoping review examines and analyses the current body of knowledge at the intersection of Generative Artificial Intelligence (GenAI) and Self-Directed Learning (SDL). An exhaustive search strategy was used to identify 18 relevant studies published from 2020 to 2024 (N = 18). These stu…

Read paper details

Jasper Roe, Mike Perkins

This thematic scoping review examines and analyses the current body of knowledge at the intersection of Generative Artificial Intelligence (GenAI) and Self-Directed Learning (SDL). An exhaustive search strategy was used to identify 18 relevant studies published from 2020 to 2024 (N = 18). These studies were analysed using an inductive thematic analytical approach, leading to the development of four themes that typify the current field of research. This includes GenAI as a Potential Enhancement for SDL, The Educator as a GenAI Guide, Personalisation of Learning, and Approaching with Caution. Our findings suggest that GenAI tools, including ChatGPT and other Large Language Models (LLMs) show promise in potentially supporting SDL through on-demand, personalised assistance. At the same time, the literature emphasises that educators are as important and central to the learning process as ever before, although their role may continue to shift as technologies develop. Our review reveals that there are still significant gaps in understanding the long-term impacts of GenAI on SDL outcomes, and there is a further need for longitudinal empirical studies that explore not only text-based chatbots but also emerging multimodal applications.

DOI: 10.1080/10494820.2025.2603431

Open source ↗
Consensus

The impact of students’ use of ChatGPT on their research skills: The mediating effects of autonomous motivation, engagement, and self-directed learning

Yi Li, Ghulfam Sadiq, Ghulam Qambar, Pengyu Zheng · 2024 · Education and Information Technologies

Integrating ChatGPT into educational contexts has become prevalent due to its potential to revolutionize teaching, learning, and research. However, to ensure positive use, it is necessary to design learning environments that effectively incorporate this technology. This study employed self-determin…

Read paper details

Yi Li, Ghulfam Sadiq, Ghulam Qambar, Pengyu Zheng

Integrating ChatGPT into educational contexts has become prevalent due to its potential to revolutionize teaching, learning, and research. However, to ensure positive use, it is necessary to design learning environments that effectively incorporate this technology. This study employed self-determination theory as an undergirding framework to understand the impact of ChatGPT-integrated instruction on undergraduate students’ research skills. Moreover, the study explored the impact of ChatGPT-integrated instruction on students’ autonomous motivation, engagement, and self-directed learning, as well as the mediating role of these variables in the relationship between ChatGPT usage and research skills. In this quasi-experimental study, 366 undergraduate students majoring in education were divided into control and experimental groups. The control group received instruction without ChatGPT, while the experimental group received ChatGPT-integrated instruction and was allowed to use ChatGPT for research-related activities. The results revealed that the experimental group had significantly higher levels of research skills, motivation, engagement, and self-directed learning behavior. Moreover, the use of ChatGPT has a significant indirect impact on students’ research skills through the mediating variables. This suggests that high autonomous motivation and self-directed learning are crucial for students to fully benefit from ChatGPT in developing research skills. The findings offer valuable insights for educators to design AI-enhanced learning environments to enhance students’ research skills and learning outcomes.

DOI: 10.1007/s10639-024-12981-9

Open source ↗
Consensus

Reconceptualizing Self-Directed Learning in the Era of Generative AI: An Exploratory Analysis of Language Learning

Belle Li, Curtis J. Bonk, Chaoran Wang, Xiaojing Kou · 2024 · IEEE Transactions on Learning Technologies

This exploratory analysis investigates the integration of ChatGPT in self-directed learning (SDL). Specifically, this study examines YouTube content creators’ language-learning experiences and the role of ChatGPT in their SDL, building upon Song and Hill's conceptual model of SDL in online contexts…

Read paper details

Belle Li, Curtis J. Bonk, Chaoran Wang, Xiaojing Kou

This exploratory analysis investigates the integration of ChatGPT in self-directed learning (SDL). Specifically, this study examines YouTube content creators’ language-learning experiences and the role of ChatGPT in their SDL, building upon Song and Hill's conceptual model of SDL in online contexts. Thematic analysis of interviews with 19 YouTubers and relevant video contents reveals distinct constructs of ChatGPT-integrated SDL, suggesting a reconceptualization and refinement of the SDL framework in the consideration of generative artificial intelligence (AI). This framework emphasizes critical aspects of utilizing ChatGPT as an SDL tool on two distinct levels: 1) the interactive relationships and interplay between learners’ personal traits and their ongoing learning processes (local) and 2) the evolving nature of SDL in the rapidly advancing landscape of generative AI, with socio-political-cultural foundations of AI constantly shaping the learning environment where SDL occurs (global). The study highlights the potential of ChatGPT as a tool for promoting self-directed language learning (SDLL) and provides implications for the development of learning technologies and research on AI-facilitated SDL.

DOI: 10.1109/tlt.2024.3386098

Open source ↗
Consensus

ChatGPT as a tool for self-directed foreign language learning

Gilbert Dizon · 2024 · Innovation in Language Learning and Teaching

ABSTRACT Purpose This study explores the use of ChatGPT for self-directed foreign language (FL) learning in out-of-class settings. It examines how learners use the artificial intelligence (AI) chatbot for self-directed FL learning and analyzes language learners' perceptions of its use. The study al…

Read paper details

Gilbert Dizon

ABSTRACT Purpose This study explores the use of ChatGPT for self-directed foreign language (FL) learning in out-of-class settings. It examines how learners use the artificial intelligence (AI) chatbot for self-directed FL learning and analyzes language learners' perceptions of its use. The study also investigates if the participants' views of ChatGPT differed depending on the age group and languages studied. Methodology The study adopted a mixed methods approach. Survey data were collected from online communities on social media. In total, 101 adult participants fully completed the survey. The quantitative data were analyzed using descriptive and inferential statistics while the qualitative data were analyzed using content analysis. Findings The FL learners reported using the AI chatbot in various ways, including for conversation practice and vocabulary learning. Although the participants had positive attitudes toward ChatGPT's ease of use and accessibility, they were skeptical of the AI chatbot's reliability as a language-learning resource. According to inferential statistics, the respondents' views of ChatGPT differed significantly depending on the age group and languages studied. Originality/value This study offers valuable insight into the ways the AI chatbot could be used for FL learning and how the variables of age and languages studied may affect learners' experiences.

DOI: 10.1080/17501229.2024.2413406

Open source ↗

Disagreements & Limitations

Disagreements

  • No major disagreement identified.

Limitations

  • Most studies are recent (2023–2026) and short-term, limiting understanding of longitudinal impacts on autonomy.
  • Disciplinary scope is narrow, dominated by programming, EFL, and general writing contexts; non-STEM humanities and social sciences are underrepresented.
  • Definitions of 'autonomy' and 'self-directed learning' vary across studies, complicating synthesis.
  • Sample sizes and contexts are often localized (e.g., single universities in China, Palestine, or tech-focused institutions), reducing generalizability.
  • Few studies experimentally compare AI-supported vs. traditional autonomous learning, making causal claims difficult.

Sources

[C651] Pedagogical Applications of Generative AI in Higher Education: A Systematic Review of the Field

TechTrends · 2025 · DOI: 10.1007/s11528-025-01100-1

Open source
[C652] Programming education and learner motivation in the age of generative AI: student and educator perspectives

Information and Learning Sciences · 2024 · DOI: 10.1108/ils-10-2023-0163

Open source
[C653] AI literacy and mediated learner autonomy in ChatGPT-supported EFL writing: a qualitative study at a Palestinian university

International Journal of Educational Technology in Higher Education · 2026 · DOI: 10.1186/s41239-026-00597-7

Open source
[C654] Understanding self-directed learning in AI-Assisted writing: A mixed methods study of postsecondary learners

Comput. Educ. Artif. Intell. · 2024 · DOI: 10.1016/j.caeai.2024.100247

Open source
[C655] Supporting self-directed learning and self-assessment using TeacherGAIA, a generative AI chatbot application: Learning approaches and prompt engineering

Learning: Research and Practice · 2023 · DOI: 10.1080/23735082.2023.2258886

Open source
[C656] The Impact of Prompt Engineering and a Generative AI-Driven Tool on Autonomous Learning: A Case Study

Education Sciences · 2025 · DOI: 10.3390/educsci15020199

Open source
[C657] Clue before correction: ChatGPT-enhanced strategy for promoting autonomous and reflective language learning

Innovation in Language Learning and Teaching · 2026 · DOI: 10.1080/17501229.2025.2612532

Open source
[C658] From surface to deep learning approaches with Generative AI in higher education: an analytical framework of student agency

Studies in Higher Education · 2024 · DOI: 10.1080/03075079.2024.2327003

Open source
View Detailed Research
Developer Diagnostics

PRODUCTION MODE

Research Planners

Planner 1 — Gemini 3.5 Flash
google/gemini-3.5-flash

Planner 2 — Llama 4 Scout
meta-llama/llama-4-scout

Planner 3 — Qwen3.5-27B
qwen/qwen3.5-27b

Retrieval

Semantic Scholar: Enabled
API key: Not configured (public access)

Consensus: Enabled

Synthesizer

qwen/qwen3-max
qwen/qwen3-max

Credential readiness

OpenRouter: Configured

Consensus: Configured

Manual evaluation cases and results
Individual AI responses

AI Agent Research

Independent model outputs. Planners propose searches and hypotheses, not evidence. Citations and confidence in historical answers are model-reported and unverified.

learning autonomyand geenrative AI articles

Completed

Research finished. Any provider failures are shown in their sections.

Planner 1 — Gemini 3.5 Flash google/gemini-3.5-flash View response

Problem interpretation

The rapid integration of generative artificial intelligence in educational environments has transformed self-directed study, prompting critical investigations into how these technologies influence learner autonomy, self-regulation, and student agency.

Search queries (not evidence)

  • "generative AI" AND "learner autonomy"
  • "ChatGPT" AND "self-directed learning"
  • "large language models" AND "self-regulated learning" AND "education"
  • "generative artificial intelligence" AND "student agency"
Planner diagnostics
problem_interpretation
The rapid integration of generative artificial intelligence in educational environments has transformed self-directed study, prompting critical investigations into how these technologies influence learner autonomy, self-regulation, and student agency.
research_questions
['How does student use of generative AI tools affect their development of self-regulated learning skills?', 'What pedagogical frameworks effectively promote learner autonomy while utilizing generative AI in higher education?', 'To what extent does reliance on generative AI lead to cognitive offloading and reduced critical thinking?', 'How do educators perceive the shift in student autonomy due to generative AI assistants?']
search_queries
['"generative AI" AND "learner autonomy"', '"ChatGPT" AND "self-directed learning"', '"large language models" AND "self-regulated learning" AND "education"', '"generative artificial intelligence" AND "student agency"']
keywords
['generative AI', 'learner autonomy', 'self-directed learning', 'self-regulated learning', 'student agency']
synonyms
['ChatGPT', 'large language models', 'independent learning', 'autonomous learning', 'artificial intelligence in education']
population_terms
['students', 'learners', 'undergraduates', 'higher education students', 'educators']
intervention_or_exposure_terms
['generative artificial intelligence', 'generative AI tools', 'ChatGPT', 'large language models', 'AI-assisted writing']
outcome_terms
['learning autonomy', 'critical thinking', 'cognitive offloading', 'self-regulation', 'academic independence']
possible_research_gaps
['Longitudinal impact of continuous generative AI usage on independent problem-solving capabilities in K-12 and higher education.', 'The role of demographic differences in student adaptation to AI-supported self-directed learning environments.']
uncertainties
['The precise boundary between productive AI scaffolding and passive cognitive dependence in student learning.', 'The generalizability of early pedagogical frameworks to diverse non-STEM academic disciplines.']
suggested_filters
{'year_from': 2022, 'year_to': 2025, 'fields': ['Education', 'Computer Science Education', 'Educational Technology', 'Psychology'], 'study_types': ['empirical study', 'systematic review', 'conceptual paper', 'case study']}

Self-reported confidence: Not assessed

Citations

  • No sources supplied by this model.
Planner 2 — Llama 4 Scout meta-llama/llama-4-scout View response

Problem interpretation

Exploring the relationship between learning autonomy and generative AI

Search queries (not evidence)

  • generative AI and learning autonomy
  • autonomous learning with generative AI
  • impact of generative AI on learner autonomy
Planner diagnostics
problem_interpretation
Exploring the relationship between learning autonomy and generative AI
research_questions
['What is the impact of generative AI on learning autonomy?', 'How can generative AI be used to support autonomous learning?', 'What are the potential benefits and challenges of using generative AI in autonomous learning environments?']
search_queries
['generative AI and learning autonomy', 'autonomous learning with generative AI', 'impact of generative AI on learner autonomy']
keywords
['generative AI', 'learning autonomy', 'autonomous learning', 'AI in education']
synonyms
['machine learning', 'artificial intelligence', 'self-directed learning', 'learner independence']
population_terms
['learners', 'students', 'educators']
intervention_or_exposure_terms
['generative AI tools', 'AI-powered learning platforms', 'autonomous learning systems']
outcome_terms
['learning outcomes', 'learner engagement', 'autonomy support']
possible_research_gaps
['investigating the long-term effects of generative AI on learning autonomy', 'examining the role of generative AI in supporting diverse learner needs', 'developing frameworks for integrating generative AI into autonomous learning environments']
uncertainties
['the effectiveness of generative AI in promoting learning autonomy', 'the potential risks and challenges associated with using generative AI in autonomous learning environments']
suggested_filters
{'year_from': 2020, 'year_to': None, 'fields': ['education', 'computer science'], 'study_types': ['experimental', 'review']}

Self-reported confidence: Not assessed

Citations

  • No sources supplied by this model.
Planner 3 — Qwen3.5-27B qwen/qwen3.5-27b View response

Problem interpretation

Investigation of the relationship between learner autonomy and the use of generative artificial intelligence in educational contexts.

Search queries (not evidence)

  • ("learner autonomy" OR "self-directed learning") AND ("generative AI" OR "large language models")
  • ("student independence" OR "self-regulation") AND ("ChatGPT" OR "AI writing tools")
  • ("educational technology" AND "autonomy") AND ("machine learning" OR "AI")
  • "generative artificial intelligence" AND ("learning outcomes" OR "agency")
Planner diagnostics
problem_interpretation
Investigation of the relationship between learner autonomy and the use of generative artificial intelligence in educational contexts.
research_questions
['How does generative AI impact learner autonomy in higher education?', 'What are the effects of AI tools on self-regulated learning behaviors?', 'Does reliance on generative AI diminish or enhance student independence?']
search_queries
['("learner autonomy" OR "self-directed learning") AND ("generative AI" OR "large language models")', '("student independence" OR "self-regulation") AND ("ChatGPT" OR "AI writing tools")', '("educational technology" AND "autonomy") AND ("machine learning" OR "AI")', '"generative artificial intelligence" AND ("learning outcomes" OR "agency")']
keywords
['learner autonomy', 'generative AI', 'self-regulated learning', 'large language models', 'educational technology', 'student agency']
synonyms
['self-directed learning', 'self-management', 'GAI', 'LLM', 'AI chatbots', 'adaptive learning systems']
population_terms
['students', 'learners', 'undergraduates', 'higher education students', 'K-12 students', 'adults']
intervention_or_exposure_terms
['generative AI', 'large language models', 'ChatGPT', 'AI tutors', 'automated feedback systems', 'prompt engineering']
outcome_terms
['autonomy', 'self-efficacy', 'self-regulation', 'dependency', 'critical thinking', 'engagement', 'academic performance']
possible_research_gaps
['Long-term effects of GAI on intrinsic motivation are unknown', 'Ethical implications of AI-assisted autonomy lack standardization', 'Differences across academic disciplines are underexplored']
uncertainties
['Definition of autonomy varies across studies', 'Rapid evolution of AI tools makes findings quickly outdated', 'Distinction between assistance and dependency is unclear']
suggested_filters
{'year_from': 2020, 'year_to': None, 'fields': ['Education', 'Educational Technology', 'Psychology', 'Computer Science'], 'study_types': ['Empirical Study', 'Review', 'Qualitative Research', 'Quantitative Research']}

Self-reported confidence: Not assessed

Citations

  • No sources supplied by this model.
Full Academic Evidence

Academic Evidence

Academic papers retrieved from the providers below, shown separately from model outputs. Provider metadata is retained; a retrieved paper is not automatically proof of a claim.

learning autonomyand geenrative AI articles

consensus

25 unique papers found in this response

Exploring Autonomy in the AI Wilderness: Learner Challenges and Choices 2024

Antonie Alm

The emergence of Generative Artificial Intelligence (GenAI) raises critical questions about learner autonomy and agency. This exploratory case study examines how four university-level German language learners with diverse backgrounds developed autonomy in their learning process through engagement with AI tools. The study was conducted in early 2023 when most learners were first discovering ChatGPT’s potential for language learning. Data were collected through reflective journals, digital portfolios, and interviews during a semester-long course that scaffolded self-directed learning with AI integration. The findings reveal emerging patterns of shared agency between learners and AI tools. Learners developed distinct strategies for AI integration based on their language learning backgrounds, with heritage speakers focusing on accuracy improvement while classroom learners emphasized communication practice. Cross-case analyses identified key dimensions of autonomy development: a critical e…

DOI: 10.3390/educsci14121369

Open source ↗
Generative AI, Cognitive Offloading, and Learner Agency in Higher Education: A Scoping Review 2026 · systematic review

Guanhua Wang, Wenna Wang, Daozhou Yang, Jifan Ren

Generative artificial intelligence (GenAI) is increasingly integrated into higher education, where it supports writing, feedback, problem solving, and research-related tasks while also raising concerns about cognitive offloading and learner dependence. This scoping review maps the literature on the relationships among GenAI, cognitive offloading, and learner agency in higher education. Following PRISMA-ScR guidance, searches were conducted on 24 June 2026 across six database sources: Web of Science Core Collection, Scopus, EBSCOhost ERIC, EBSCOhost Education Source, APA PsycInfo via ProQuest, and ProQuest Education Collection via ProQuest Social Science Premium Collection. English-language peer-reviewed or scholarly journal literature published from 2022 to 24 June 2026 was eligible for inclusion. Data were charted using a structured extraction matrix and synthesized through descriptive mapping and theory-informed configurative synthesis. After duplicate removal, 5327 records were scr…

DOI: 10.3390/bs16071150

Open source ↗
Pedagogical Applications of Generative AI in Higher Education: A Systematic Review of the Field 2025 · systematic review

Yu-Feng Qian

The release of ChatGPT in late 2022 marked the beginning of a rapid transformation in higher education, soon followed by the development of multimodal generative AI programs. As this technology becomes increasingly integrated into teaching and learning, it is crucial to evaluate its current use and impact. This systematic literature review captures the initial academic response to generative AI, providing insights into how higher education has adopted this transformative technology in its first two years. The findings indicate that while some themes from the pre-ChatGPT era persist, new and emerging trends—particularly in fostering creativity, critical thinking, learning autonomy, and prompt literacy—are now taking shape. This shift underscores a growing emphasis on the pedagogical integration of generative AI. However, the review also highlights a key tension: while generative AI enhances efficiency, it raises concerns about overreliance, potentially leading to the outsourcing of cri…

DOI: 10.1007/s11528-025-01100-1

Open source ↗
Clue before correction: ChatGPT-enhanced strategy for promoting autonomous and reflective language learning 2026 · other

Alice Lukešová, Petra Juna Jennings

Purpose This study presents a generative AI-supported revision task designed to promote adaptive learning, learner autonomy, and metacognitive engagement in second language (L2) writing through clue-based interaction with ChatGPT. Unlike traditional chatbot use for direct error correction, which positions learners as passive recipients, this activity was intentionally structured to require active problem-solving, prompting students to infer correct solutions from guided hints.Design/methodology/approach Fifty-eight university students (CEFR A1–B1) completed a bilingual activity in English or Spanish that used indirect prompts to guide self-revision, supported by ChatGPT. Learner–AI interaction transcripts and open-ended reflections were analyzed using Cognitive Load Theory, formative feedback models, and the newly developed ICAP-ME framework, which extends the ICAP model to include metacognitive and affective dimensions.Findings ChatGPT provided structured, adaptive feedback that redu…

DOI: 10.1080/17501229.2025.2612532

Open source ↗
AI literacy and mediated learner autonomy in ChatGPT-supported EFL writing: a qualitative study at a Palestinian university 2026 · interview study

B. Hamamra, Nejme Mahamid

The rapid expansion of generative artificial intelligence (AI) has reshaped higher education, raising urgent pedagogical, ethical, and epistemic questions. In English as a Foreign Language (EFL) contexts, tools such as ChatGPT challenge established understandings of learner autonomy, authorship, and academic integrity. This qualitative study examines how AI literacy mediates learner autonomy and ethical decision-making in ChatGPT use within EFL programs at a Palestinian university. Drawing on semi-structured interviews and focus group discussions with EFL instructors and undergraduate students, the study employs thematic analysis to investigate how generative AI is interpreted and enacted in pedagogical practice. The findings indicate that ChatGPT functioned as a compensatory resource in contexts of limited instructional support, but its pedagogical value depended on learners’ AI literacy and ethical awareness. The study also challenges the “digital native” assumption by showing that …

DOI: 10.1186/s41239-026-00597-7

Open source ↗
From surface to deep learning approaches with Generative AI in higher education: an analytical framework of student agency 2024 · interview study

Yun-Ying Yang, Jin-Wen Luo, Miaoyan Yang, Run-De Yang, Jia-Ying Chen

ABSTRACT Recent emergence of generative artificial intelligence (GenAI) technology has stimulated interests as well as concerns in their potential in teaching and learning. Situated in the new and transforming context, this study provides an avenue for students to introspectively explore their use of GenAI in a postgraduate course. Seventy-four students from three Chinese universities participated in this study. By analyzing student interviews conducted pre- and post-course, alongside their chat logs with GenAI and reflective journal entries detailing their learning approaches, the research uncovers a spectrum of student perspectives on GenAI’s impact, ranging from beneficial optimism, to cautious skepticism and adaptable pragmatism. Notably, student agency is identified as a crucial element in relation to these themes. This was articulated in four types of learning activities: receptive, resistive, resourceful, and reflective. The research underscores the importance of supporting and…

DOI: 10.1080/03075079.2024.2327003

Open source ↗
The Impact of Prompt Engineering and a Generative AI-Driven Tool on Autonomous Learning: A Case Study 2025

Kovan Mzwri, M. Turcsányi-Szabó

This study evaluates “I Learn with Prompt Engineering”, a self-paced, self-regulated elective course designed to equip university students with skills in prompt engineering to effectively utilize large language models (LLMs), foster self-directed learning, and enhance academic English proficiency through generative AI applications. By integrating prompt engineering concepts with generative AI tools, the course supports autonomous learning and addresses critical skill gaps in language proficiency and market-ready capabilities. The study also examines EnSmart, an AI-driven tool powered by GPT-4 and integrated into Canvas LMS, which automates academic test content generation and grading and delivers real-time, human-like feedback. Performance evaluation, structured questionnaires, and surveys were used to evaluate the course’s impact on prompting skills, academic English proficiency, and overall learning experiences. Results demonstrated significant improvements in prompt engineering ski…

DOI: 10.3390/educsci15020199

Open source ↗
Pedagogical Applications of Generative AI in Higher Education: A Systematic Review of the Field 2025 · systematic review

Yu-Feng Qian

The release of ChatGPT in late 2022 marked the beginning of a rapid transformation in higher education, soon followed by the development of multimodal generative AI programs. As this technology becomes increasingly integrated into teaching and learning, it is crucial to evaluate its current use and impact. This systematic literature review captures the initial academic response to generative AI, providing insights into how higher education has adopted this transformative technology in its first two years. The findings indicate that while some themes from the pre-ChatGPT era persist, new and emerging trends—particularly in fostering creativity, critical thinking, learning autonomy, and prompt literacy—are now taking shape. This shift underscores a growing emphasis on the pedagogical integration of generative AI. However, the review also highlights a key tension: while generative AI enhances efficiency, it raises concerns about overreliance, potentially leading to the outsourcing of cri…

DOI: 10.1007/s11528-025-01100-1

Open source ↗
Can interaction with generative artificial intelligence enhance learning autonomy? A longitudinal study from comparative perspectives of virtual companionship and knowledge acquisition preferences 2024 · other

Ze-Hang Xie, Xin-Zhu Wu, Yun-Xiang Xie

With the development of artificial intelligence (AI) technology, generative AI has been widely used in the field of education and represents a groundbreaking shift in overcoming the constraints of time and space within educational activities. However, previous literature has not paid enough attention to AI‐involved teaching patterns, and it is necessary to evaluate the effects of this learning pattern.ObjectivesBased on the social presence theory and the community of inquiry model, the main purpose of this study is to evaluate whether and how interaction frequency with chatbots (IFC) affects people's learning autonomy (LA) under two preferences: knowledge acquisition and virtual companionship, and whether social presence (SP) plays a mediating role.The 1‐year longitudinal study was designed to be conducted from May 2022 to May 2023 and included three rounds of surveys of 1155 undergraduate students on their use of robots for learning.For learners preferring virtual companionship, no d…

DOI: 10.1111/jcal.13032

Open source ↗
Generative AI: elevating knowledge acquisition and retention and recall through autonomy, interactivity and engagement 2025 · cross-sectional study

Mai Nguyen, Reeti Agarwal, Ashish Malik, Rudresh Pandey

PurposeGenerative AI (GenAI) in education promises remarkable development changes that can enhance learner experience through the personalised and responsive learning process. In this paper, we investigate how the different features of GenAI – autonomy, interactivity and usability – contribute to student engagement and learning outcomes.Design/methodology/approachFrom the lens of the self-determination theory, the study seeks to articulate how these GenAI features influence student engagement and their ability to achieve specific goals through interactive learning experiences delivered by GenAI. Qualtrics, a well-known online data collection tool, was employed in the study to collect data from 488 respondents in the UK region who had been exposed to generative AI-based platforms. The sampling approach used was representative, wherein the platform was asked to randomly share the survey with respondents in the UK region who had some experience interacting with Gen AI platforms.FindingsT…

DOI: 10.1108/jeim-08-2024-0433

Open source ↗
Supporting self-directed learning and self-assessment using TeacherGAIA, a generative AI chatbot application: Learning approaches and prompt engineering 2023 · other

Farhan Ali, D. Choy, Shanti Divaharan, Yong-Tay Hui, Wenli Chen

ABSTRACT Self-directed learning and self-assessment require student responsibility over learning needs, goals, processes, and outcomes. However, this student-led learning can be challenging to achieve in a classroom limited by a one-to-many teacher-led instruction. We, thus, have designed and prototyped a generative artificial intelligence chatbot application (GAIA), named TeacherGAIA, that can be used to asynchronously support students in their self-directed learning and self-assessment outside the classroom. We first identified diverse constructivist learning approaches that align with, and promote, student-led learning. These included knowledge construction, inquiry-based learning, self-assessment, and peer teaching. The in-context learning abilities of large language model (LLM) from OpenAI were then leveraged via prompt engineering to steer interactions supporting these different learning approaches. These interactions contrasted with ChatGPT, OpenAI’s chatbot which by default en…

DOI: 10.1080/23735082.2023.2258886

Open source ↗
The Impact of Prompt Engineering and a Generative AI-Driven Tool on Autonomous Learning: A Case Study 2025

Kovan Mzwri, M. Turcsányi-Szabó

This study evaluates “I Learn with Prompt Engineering”, a self-paced, self-regulated elective course designed to equip university students with skills in prompt engineering to effectively utilize large language models (LLMs), foster self-directed learning, and enhance academic English proficiency through generative AI applications. By integrating prompt engineering concepts with generative AI tools, the course supports autonomous learning and addresses critical skill gaps in language proficiency and market-ready capabilities. The study also examines EnSmart, an AI-driven tool powered by GPT-4 and integrated into Canvas LMS, which automates academic test content generation and grading and delivers real-time, human-like feedback. Performance evaluation, structured questionnaires, and surveys were used to evaluate the course’s impact on prompting skills, academic English proficiency, and overall learning experiences. Results demonstrated significant improvements in prompt engineering ski…

DOI: 10.3390/educsci15020199

Open source ↗
Generative AI in Self-Directed Learning: a thematic scoping review 2025 · systematic review

Jasper Roe, Mike Perkins

This thematic scoping review examines and analyses the current body of knowledge at the intersection of Generative Artificial Intelligence (GenAI) and Self-Directed Learning (SDL). An exhaustive search strategy was used to identify 18 relevant studies published from 2020 to 2024 (N = 18). These studies were analysed using an inductive thematic analytical approach, leading to the development of four themes that typify the current field of research. This includes GenAI as a Potential Enhancement for SDL, The Educator as a GenAI Guide, Personalisation of Learning, and Approaching with Caution. Our findings suggest that GenAI tools, including ChatGPT and other Large Language Models (LLMs) show promise in potentially supporting SDL through on-demand, personalised assistance. At the same time, the literature emphasises that educators are as important and central to the learning process as ever before, although their role may continue to shift as technologies develop. Our review reveals that…

DOI: 10.1080/10494820.2025.2603431

Open source ↗
Enhancing self-directed learning and Python mastery through integration of a large language model and learning analytics dashboard 2025 · other

Ming Liu, Zhong-Ming Wu, Hai-Min Dai, Yi-Fei Su, L. Malik, Jian Liao, Wei Zhang, Shuo Guo, Li Liu, Jun-Qiang Zhao

Self‐directed learning (SDL) is a critical skill in the 21st century, particularly in online Python learning environments. Learning analytics (LA) can track and analyse learning processes, which can be leveraged to prompt students to reflect on their learning strategies and progress through learning analytics dashboards (LADs). However, LADs lack pedagogical domain knowledge and fail to provide effective personalised feedback and guidance. This study designs and presents a Generative AI‐powered SDL tool, SDLChat. It integrates a large language model (ERNIE‐3.5) with retrieval‐augmented generation (RAG) technology to generate contextualised, actionable feedback for learners across the entire SDL cycle: planning, self‐monitoring and self‐reflection. To evaluate the impact of SDLChat on learners' SDL skills and Python knowledge, a randomised experimental study was conducted over a six‐week Python online course. The study compared the changes in SDL skills and Python knowledge of students…

DOI: 10.1111/bjet.70005

Open source ↗
Programming education and learner motivation in the age of generative AI: student and educator perspectives 2024 · other

Samuel Boguslawski, Rowan Deer, Mark G. Dawson

Purpose Programming education is being rapidly transformed by generative AI tools and educators must determine how best to support students in this context. This study aims to explore the experiences of programming educators and students to inform future education provision. Design/methodology/approach Twelve students and six members of faculty in a small technology-focused university were interviewed. Thematic analysis of the interview data was combined with data collected from a survey of 44 students at the same university. Self-determination theory was applied as an analytical framework. Findings Three themes were identified – bespoke learning, affect and support – that significantly impact motivation and learning outcomes in programming education. It was also found that students are already making extensive use of large language models (LLMs). LLMs can significantly improve learner autonomy and sense of competence by improving the options for bespoke learning; fostering emoti…

DOI: 10.1108/ils-10-2023-0163

Open source ↗
Understanding self-directed learning in AI-Assisted writing: A mixed methods study of postsecondary learners 2024 · mixed methods study

Chaoran Wang, Zi-Xi Li, Curtis J. Bonk

This study investigates how postsecondary learners employ generative AI, specifically ChatGPT, to support their self-directed learning (SDL) for writing purposes. Following a sequential mixed methods design, we analyzed 384 survey responses and 10 semi-structured interviews with postsecondary writers. Findings suggest that the major learning task that the learners used ChatGPT for writing is brainstorming and seeking inspiration for ideas. While the entering motivation for using ChatGPT varies from curiosity about innovative technologies to fulfilling academic requirements, such entering motivation transformed into task motivation when the learners perceived the potential benefits of ChatGPT for assisting their writing. In terms of self-management, participants mostly demonstrated a high responsibility towards their own learning with ChatGPT and employed various strategies for SDL. Although survey respondents demonstrated a comparatively low level of self-monitoring, most interviewees…

DOI: 10.1016/j.caeai.2024.100247

Open source ↗
Reconceptualizing Self-Directed Learning in the Era of Generative AI: An Exploratory Analysis of Language Learning 2024 · interview study

Belle Li, Curtis J. Bonk, Chaoran Wang, Xiaojing Kou

This exploratory analysis investigates the integration of ChatGPT in self-directed learning (SDL). Specifically, this study examines YouTube content creators’ language-learning experiences and the role of ChatGPT in their SDL, building upon Song and Hill's conceptual model of SDL in online contexts. Thematic analysis of interviews with 19 YouTubers and relevant video contents reveals distinct constructs of ChatGPT-integrated SDL, suggesting a reconceptualization and refinement of the SDL framework in the consideration of generative artificial intelligence (AI). This framework emphasizes critical aspects of utilizing ChatGPT as an SDL tool on two distinct levels: 1) the interactive relationships and interplay between learners’ personal traits and their ongoing learning processes (local) and 2) the evolving nature of SDL in the rapidly advancing landscape of generative AI, with socio-political-cultural foundations of AI constantly shaping the learning environment where SDL occurs (globa…

DOI: 10.1109/tlt.2024.3386098

Open source ↗
Exploring the Utility of ChatGPT for Self-directed Online Language Learning 2024 · mixed methods study

Zi-Xi Li, Chaoran Wang, Curtis J. Bonk

As generative AI tools are increasingly popular in today’s teaching and learning process, challenges and opportunities occur at the same time. Self-directed learning has been regarded as a powerful learning ability that supports learners in informal learning contexts and its importance rises in salience when incorporating AI into learning. This study employed a mixed-method design to understand how people self-direct their online language learning through the utilization of ChatGPT. Analyzing survey data from 276 survey respondents and 11 one-to-one interviews with language learners in the United States, we found that learners are motivated to use generative AI for its high flexibility and personalization which enables learners to access learning materials that align with their knowledge levels, personal interests, and learning goals. We also found self-monitoring skills that are inherent to learners help them to use ChatGPT more efficiently and achieve their learning goals efficientl…

DOI: 10.24059/olj.v28i3.4497

Open source ↗
ChatGPT as a tool for self-directed foreign language learning 2024 · mixed methods study

Gilbert Dizon

ABSTRACT Purpose This study explores the use of ChatGPT for self-directed foreign language (FL) learning in out-of-class settings. It examines how learners use the artificial intelligence (AI) chatbot for self-directed FL learning and analyzes language learners' perceptions of its use. The study also investigates if the participants' views of ChatGPT differed depending on the age group and languages studied. Methodology The study adopted a mixed methods approach. Survey data were collected from online communities on social media. In total, 101 adult participants fully completed the survey. The quantitative data were analyzed using descriptive and inferential statistics while the qualitative data were analyzed using content analysis. Findings The FL learners reported using the AI chatbot in various ways, including for conversation practice and vocabulary learning. Although the participants had positive attitudes toward ChatGPT's ease of use and accessibility, they were skeptical of the…

DOI: 10.1080/17501229.2024.2413406

Open source ↗
The impact of students’ use of ChatGPT on their research skills: The mediating effects of autonomous motivation, engagement, and self-directed learning 2024

Yi Li, Ghulfam Sadiq, Ghulam Qambar, Pengyu Zheng

Integrating ChatGPT into educational contexts has become prevalent due to its potential to revolutionize teaching, learning, and research. However, to ensure positive use, it is necessary to design learning environments that effectively incorporate this technology. This study employed self-determination theory as an undergirding framework to understand the impact of ChatGPT-integrated instruction on undergraduate students’ research skills. Moreover, the study explored the impact of ChatGPT-integrated instruction on students’ autonomous motivation, engagement, and self-directed learning, as well as the mediating role of these variables in the relationship between ChatGPT usage and research skills. In this quasi-experimental study, 366 undergraduate students majoring in education were divided into control and experimental groups. The control group received instruction without ChatGPT, while the experimental group received ChatGPT-integrated instruction and was allowed to use ChatGPT for…

DOI: 10.1007/s10639-024-12981-9

Open source ↗
The Impact of Prompt Engineering and a Generative AI-Driven Tool on Autonomous Learning: A Case Study 2025

Kovan Mzwri, M. Turcsányi-Szabó

This study evaluates “I Learn with Prompt Engineering”, a self-paced, self-regulated elective course designed to equip university students with skills in prompt engineering to effectively utilize large language models (LLMs), foster self-directed learning, and enhance academic English proficiency through generative AI applications. By integrating prompt engineering concepts with generative AI tools, the course supports autonomous learning and addresses critical skill gaps in language proficiency and market-ready capabilities. The study also examines EnSmart, an AI-driven tool powered by GPT-4 and integrated into Canvas LMS, which automates academic test content generation and grading and delivers real-time, human-like feedback. Performance evaluation, structured questionnaires, and surveys were used to evaluate the course’s impact on prompting skills, academic English proficiency, and overall learning experiences. Results demonstrated significant improvements in prompt engineering ski…

DOI: 10.3390/educsci15020199

Open source ↗
From surface to deep learning approaches with Generative AI in higher education: an analytical framework of student agency 2024 · interview study

Yun-Ying Yang, Jin-Wen Luo, Miaoyan Yang, Run-De Yang, Jia-Ying Chen

ABSTRACT Recent emergence of generative artificial intelligence (GenAI) technology has stimulated interests as well as concerns in their potential in teaching and learning. Situated in the new and transforming context, this study provides an avenue for students to introspectively explore their use of GenAI in a postgraduate course. Seventy-four students from three Chinese universities participated in this study. By analyzing student interviews conducted pre- and post-course, alongside their chat logs with GenAI and reflective journal entries detailing their learning approaches, the research uncovers a spectrum of student perspectives on GenAI’s impact, ranging from beneficial optimism, to cautious skepticism and adaptable pragmatism. Notably, student agency is identified as a crucial element in relation to these themes. This was articulated in four types of learning activities: receptive, resistive, resourceful, and reflective. The research underscores the importance of supporting and…

DOI: 10.1080/03075079.2024.2327003

Open source ↗
Pedagogical Applications of Generative AI in Higher Education: A Systematic Review of the Field 2025 · systematic review

Yu-Feng Qian

The release of ChatGPT in late 2022 marked the beginning of a rapid transformation in higher education, soon followed by the development of multimodal generative AI programs. As this technology becomes increasingly integrated into teaching and learning, it is crucial to evaluate its current use and impact. This systematic literature review captures the initial academic response to generative AI, providing insights into how higher education has adopted this transformative technology in its first two years. The findings indicate that while some themes from the pre-ChatGPT era persist, new and emerging trends—particularly in fostering creativity, critical thinking, learning autonomy, and prompt literacy—are now taking shape. This shift underscores a growing emphasis on the pedagogical integration of generative AI. However, the review also highlights a key tension: while generative AI enhances efficiency, it raises concerns about overreliance, potentially leading to the outsourcing of cri…

DOI: 10.1007/s11528-025-01100-1

Open source ↗
Learning with Generative Artificial Intelligence Within a Network of Co-Regulation 2023 · commentary or perspective

Jason Lodge, P. D. de Barba, Jaclyn Broadbent

The emergence of generative artificial intelligence (AI) has created legitimate concerns surrounding academic integrity and the ease with which such technologies might lead to cheating in assessment, in particular. However, fixating solely on potential misconduct is overshadowing a more profound, transformative interaction between learners and machines. This commentary article delves into the relationship between students and AI, aiming to highlight the need for revised pedagogical strategies in the AI age. We argue that the much-discussed approaches that prioritise AI literacy or augmented critical thinking might be inadequate. Instead, we contend that a more holistic approach emphasising self-regulated learning (SRL) and co-regulation of learning is needed. SRL promotes autonomy, adaptability, and a deeper understanding, qualities indispensable for navigating the intricacies of AI-enhanced learning environments. Furthermore, we introduce the notion of a network of co-regulation, whi…

DOI: 10.53761/1.20.7.02

Open source ↗
Generative AI: elevating knowledge acquisition and retention and recall through autonomy, interactivity and engagement 2025 · cross-sectional study

Mai Nguyen, Reeti Agarwal, Ashish Malik, Rudresh Pandey

PurposeGenerative AI (GenAI) in education promises remarkable development changes that can enhance learner experience through the personalised and responsive learning process. In this paper, we investigate how the different features of GenAI – autonomy, interactivity and usability – contribute to student engagement and learning outcomes.Design/methodology/approachFrom the lens of the self-determination theory, the study seeks to articulate how these GenAI features influence student engagement and their ability to achieve specific goals through interactive learning experiences delivered by GenAI. Qualtrics, a well-known online data collection tool, was employed in the study to collect data from 488 respondents in the UK region who had been exposed to generative AI-based platforms. The sampling approach used was representative, wherein the platform was asked to randomly share the survey with respondents in the UK region who had some experience interacting with Gen AI platforms.FindingsT…

DOI: 10.1108/jeim-08-2024-0433

Open source ↗

semantic_scholar

Semantic Scholar retrieval failed (rate_limit).

semantic_scholar unavailable

Semantic Scholar retrieval failed (rate_limit).

Judge/Synthesizer details

Final Research Answer

learning autonomyand geenrative AI articles

{"research_topics": [{"topic": "The impact of generative AI on self-regulated learning behaviors in postsecondary writing", "rationale": "Understanding how learners manage, monitor, and reflect on AI-assisted writing is critical for designing effective pedagogical interventions.", "existing_literature": "C654 shows mixed evidence: while learners report high responsibility and strategy use, self-monitoring remains low; C651 notes risks of cognitive offloading but also potential for fostering autonomy.", "unresolved_question": "How can educators scaffold metacognitive monitoring to prevent passive reliance on generative AI during autonomous writing tasks?", "population": "Postsecondary students engaged in academic writing", "variables": ["AI literacy", "self-monitoring frequency", "revision behaviors", "perceived competence"], "methodology": "Longitudinal mixed-methods design combining log analysis, surveys, and reflective interviews", "feasibility": "High—writing contexts are accessible, tools like ChatGPT are widely available, and existing frameworks (e.g., ICAP-ME in C657) support measurement", "supporting_source_ids": ["C654", "C651", "C657"], "limitations_addressed": ["Short-term data in C654", "lack of standardized autonomy definitions"]}, {"topic": "Prompt engineering as a lever for learner agency across disciplines", "rationale": "Prompt literacy may mediate the shift from dependency to autonomy, yet most studies focus on language or programming contexts.", "existing_literature": "C656 demonstrates that structured prompt engineering courses improve autonomous learning in academic English; C652 links LLM use to competence and bespoke learning in programming; C651 calls for more research on prompt literacy.", "unresolved_question": "Do disciplinary differences in epistemic practices affect how prompt engineering supports or hinders autonomy?", "population": "Undergraduate students in STEM, humanities, and social sciences", "variables": ["prompt sophistication", "disciplinary epistemic beliefs", "perceived control", "task engagement"], "methodology": "Comparative case studies with discourse and performance analysis", "feasibility": "Moderate—requires cross-disciplinary collaboration but builds on TeacherGAIA (C655) and course designs in C656", "supporting_source_ids": ["C656", "C652", "C651", "C655"], "limitations_addressed": ["STEM bias in current research", "rapid obsolescence of AI tools"]}, {"topic": "Mediated autonomy in under-resourced EFL contexts", "rationale": "Generative AI may compensate for limited instructional support, but ethical and literacy gaps could exacerbate inequities.", "existing_literature": "C653 reveals that ChatGPT acts as a compensatory tool in Palestinian EFL programs, but autonomy is mediated by AI literacy and ethical awareness; C658 highlights agency types (receptive, reflective, etc.) that vary by context.", "unresolved_question": "How can institutions develop context-sensitive AI literacy curricula that promote responsible autonomy without reinforcing dependency?", "population": "Undergraduate EFL learners in under-resourced higher education settings", "variables": ["institutional support", "AI literacy", "ethical reasoning", "writing autonomy"], "methodology": "Participatory action research co-designing literacy modules with students and instructors", "feasibility": "High in targeted contexts; builds directly on C653 findings and addresses digital native myth", "supporting_source_ids": ["C653", "C658"], "limitations_addressed": ["Overgeneralization of autonomy constructs", "neglect of Global South contexts"]}]}

Current research indicates generative AI can both enhance and threaten learner autonomy. Systematic reviews (C651) and empirical studies (C652–C658) show AI tools support self-directed learning through personalized scaffolding, motivation, and reduced cognitive load, particularly in writing and programming. However, risks include overreliance, diminished critical thinking, and unequal outcomes due to varying AI literacy. Autonomy is not inherent but mediated by prompt engineering skills, ethical awareness, and institutional context. Most evidence comes from short-term, discipline-specific studies in higher education, with limited attention to longitudinal effects or diverse academic fields. The boundary between productive assistance and passive dependence remains poorly defined.

Confidence: 70/100

The synthesizer's estimate, not a statistical probability. Evidence strength is shown for each finding.

Key Findings

Moderate evidence

Generative AI can enhance learner autonomy when used with sufficient AI literacy and ethical awareness.

Multiple studies (C652, C653, C654) report increased sense of competence, bespoke learning, and strategic use, but emphasize that benefits depend on learners’ ability to critically evaluate and responsibly use AI outputs.

Support review: academically_supported

Diagnostic source association and simple English word overlap only; not verification of truth, study quality or entailment.

Diagnostic evidence strength: moderate. Judge-declared strength: moderate.

Supporting sources selected by synthesizer

A source association is not proof that the source supports this claim. Review the source text and its limitations.

[C652] Programming education and learner motivation in the age of generative AI: student and educator perspectives · Information and Learning Sciences · 2024 · DOI: 10.1108/ils-10-2023-0163 Open source

[C653] AI literacy and mediated learner autonomy in ChatGPT-supported EFL writing: a qualitative study at a Palestinian university · International Journal of Educational Technology in Higher Education · 2026 · DOI: 10.1186/s41239-026-00597-7 Open source

[C654] Understanding self-directed learning in AI-Assisted writing: A mixed methods study of postsecondary learners · Comput. Educ. Artif. Intell. · 2024 · DOI: 10.1016/j.caeai.2024.100247 Open source

Moderate evidence

Prompt engineering and intentional instructional design are key to fostering autonomous, not dependent, AI use.

C655 and C656 demonstrate that structuring AI interactions via constructivist prompt engineering promotes self-assessment and self-regulation, contrasting with default chatbot modes that encourage passive reception.

Support review: academically_supported

Diagnostic source association and simple English word overlap only; not verification of truth, study quality or entailment.

Diagnostic evidence strength: moderate. Judge-declared strength: moderate.

Supporting sources selected by synthesizer

A source association is not proof that the source supports this claim. Review the source text and its limitations.

[C655] Supporting self-directed learning and self-assessment using TeacherGAIA, a generative AI chatbot application: Learning approaches and prompt engineering · Learning: Research and Practice · 2023 · DOI: 10.1080/23735082.2023.2258886 Open source

[C656] The Impact of Prompt Engineering and a Generative AI-Driven Tool on Autonomous Learning: A Case Study · Education Sciences · 2025 · DOI: 10.3390/educsci15020199 Open source

Moderate evidence

Student agency mediates the relationship between AI use and learning outcomes.

C658 identifies four agency types (receptive, resistive, resourceful, reflective) linked to deeper learning, showing that how students position themselves toward AI determines its impact on autonomy.

Support review: academically_supported

Diagnostic source association and simple English word overlap only; not verification of truth, study quality or entailment.

Diagnostic evidence strength: moderate. Judge-declared strength: moderate.

Supporting sources selected by synthesizer

A source association is not proof that the source supports this claim. Review the source text and its limitations.

[C658] From surface to deep learning approaches with Generative AI in higher education: an analytical framework of student agency · Studies in Higher Education · 2024 · DOI: 10.1080/03075079.2024.2327003 Open source

Limited evidence

Generative AI cannot replace social support, a core component of sustained motivation and autonomy.

C652 explicitly states that while LLMs improve competence and affect, they fail to provide social relatedness, which remains essential under self-determination theory.

Support review: weak_support

Diagnostic source association and simple English word overlap only; not verification of truth, study quality or entailment.

Diagnostic evidence strength: limited. Judge-declared strength: limited.

Supporting sources selected by synthesizer

A source association is not proof that the source supports this claim. Review the source text and its limitations.

[C652] Programming education and learner motivation in the age of generative AI: student and educator perspectives · Information and Learning Sciences · 2024 · DOI: 10.1108/ils-10-2023-0163 Open source

Moderate evidence

Overreliance on generative AI risks outsourcing metacognitive and critical thinking skills.

C651 and C654 note concerns about cognitive offloading; while some learners reflect critically, survey data show generally low self-monitoring, suggesting vulnerability to passive use.

Support review: academically_supported

Diagnostic source association and simple English word overlap only; not verification of truth, study quality or entailment.

Diagnostic evidence strength: moderate. Judge-declared strength: moderate.

Supporting sources selected by synthesizer

A source association is not proof that the source supports this claim. Review the source text and its limitations.

[C651] Pedagogical Applications of Generative AI in Higher Education: A Systematic Review of the Field · TechTrends · 2025 · DOI: 10.1007/s11528-025-01100-1 Open source

[C654] Understanding self-directed learning in AI-Assisted writing: A mixed methods study of postsecondary learners · Comput. Educ. Artif. Intell. · 2024 · DOI: 10.1016/j.caeai.2024.100247 Open source

Sources

  1. [C651] Pedagogical Applications of Generative AI in Higher Education: A Systematic Review of the Field

    TechTrends · 2025

    DOI: 10.1007/s11528-025-01100-1

    Open source ↗
  2. [C652] Programming education and learner motivation in the age of generative AI: student and educator perspectives

    Information and Learning Sciences · 2024

    DOI: 10.1108/ils-10-2023-0163

    Open source ↗
  3. [C653] AI literacy and mediated learner autonomy in ChatGPT-supported EFL writing: a qualitative study at a Palestinian university

    International Journal of Educational Technology in Higher Education · 2026

    DOI: 10.1186/s41239-026-00597-7

    Open source ↗
  4. [C654] Understanding self-directed learning in AI-Assisted writing: A mixed methods study of postsecondary learners

    Comput. Educ. Artif. Intell. · 2024

    DOI: 10.1016/j.caeai.2024.100247

    Open source ↗
  5. [C655] Supporting self-directed learning and self-assessment using TeacherGAIA, a generative AI chatbot application: Learning approaches and prompt engineering

    Learning: Research and Practice · 2023

    DOI: 10.1080/23735082.2023.2258886

    Open source ↗
  6. [C656] The Impact of Prompt Engineering and a Generative AI-Driven Tool on Autonomous Learning: A Case Study

    Education Sciences · 2025

    DOI: 10.3390/educsci15020199

    Open source ↗
  7. [C657] Clue before correction: ChatGPT-enhanced strategy for promoting autonomous and reflective language learning

    Innovation in Language Learning and Teaching · 2026

    DOI: 10.1080/17501229.2025.2612532

    Open source ↗
  8. [C658] From surface to deep learning approaches with Generative AI in higher education: an analytical framework of student agency

    Studies in Higher Education · 2024

    DOI: 10.1080/03075079.2024.2327003

    Open source ↗

Agreements / Disagreements

Agreement between AI models is not independent verification.

No disagreements were reported by the synthesizer.

Limitations

  • Most studies are recent (2023–2026) and short-term, limiting understanding of longitudinal impacts on autonomy.
  • Disciplinary scope is narrow, dominated by programming, EFL, and general writing contexts; non-STEM humanities and social sciences are underrepresented.
  • Definitions of 'autonomy' and 'self-directed learning' vary across studies, complicating synthesis.
  • Sample sizes and contexts are often localized (e.g., single universities in China, Palestine, or tech-focused institutions), reducing generalizability.
  • Few studies experimentally compare AI-supported vs. traditional autonomous learning, making causal claims difficult.

Recommended interpretation

Generative AI shows significant potential to support learner autonomy when embedded in thoughtfully designed pedagogical frameworks that emphasize AI literacy, ethical use, and metacognitive reflection. However, this potential is not automatic—it depends on learner agency, instructor guidance, and institutional support. Without these, AI may foster dependency rather than independence. Current evidence is promising but preliminary; robust, longitudinal, and cross-disciplinary research is urgently needed.

Evidence preparation details

Priority scores organize the context; they do not decide the answer.

C651 · Priority

C652 · Priority

C653 · Priority

C654 · Priority

C655 · Priority

C656 · Priority

C657 · Priority

C658 · Priority

Omitted papers: 11. Omitted agents: .

Retry controls

learning autonomyand geenrative AI articles

Stage: PARTIAL

Partial research available. Review failures below; retry controls are available.

Latest semantic_scholar attempt failed: Semantic Scholar retrieval failed (rate_limit). Any earlier successful result remains active.

Retries make new API requests and may incur charges. Provider retries preserve the accepted answer; re-run synthesis afterward to incorporate changed evidence.

Provider attempt history (5)

Active means the latest successful attempt. A newer failure does not replace it.

#179 · semantic_scholar · academic-graph-search · Oct. 8, 2026, 4 a.m. · Latest · Failed

Semantic Scholar retrieval failed (rate_limit).

This attempt is displayed in the semantic_scholar results above.

#178 · consensus · search-v1 · Oct. 8, 2026, 4 a.m. · Latest · Active · Succeeded

This attempt is displayed in the consensus results above.

#177 · Planner 3 — Qwen3.5-27B · qwen/qwen3.5-27b · Oct. 8, 2026, 3:59 a.m. · Latest · Active · Succeeded

This attempt is displayed in the Planner 3 — Qwen3.5-27B results above.

#176 · Planner 2 — Llama 4 Scout · meta-llama/llama-4-scout · Oct. 8, 2026, 3:59 a.m. · Latest · Active · Succeeded

This attempt is displayed in the Planner 2 — Llama 4 Scout results above.

#175 · Planner 1 — Gemini 3.5 Flash · google/gemini-3.5-flash · Oct. 8, 2026, 3:58 a.m. · Latest · Active · Succeeded

This attempt is displayed in the Planner 1 — Gemini 3.5 Flash results above.

Synthesis history (1)
#37 · qwen/qwen3-max · Oct. 8, 2026, 4 a.m. · Succeeded · Latest · Active / latest accepted

Model: qwen/qwen3-max · Latency: 34819 ms · Estimated cost: 0.0119433600 USD

Input tokens: 6402 · Output tokens: 1782

{"research_topics": [{"topic": "The impact of generative AI on self-regulated learning behaviors in postsecondary writing", "rationale": "Understanding how learners manage, monitor, and reflect on AI-assisted writing is critical for designing effective pedagogical interventions.", "existing_literature": "C654 shows mixed evidence: while learners report high responsibility and strategy use, self-monitoring remains low; C651 notes risks of cognitive offloading but also potential for fostering autonomy.", "unresolved_question": "How can educators scaffold metacognitive monitoring to prevent passive reliance on generative AI during autonomous writing tasks?", "population": "Postsecondary students engaged in academic writing", "variables": ["AI literacy", "self-monitoring frequency", "revision behaviors", "perceived competence"], "methodology": "Longitudinal mixed-methods design combining log analysis, surveys, and reflective interviews", "feasibility": "High—writing contexts are accessible, tools like ChatGPT are widely available, and existing frameworks (e.g., ICAP-ME in C657) support measurement", "supporting_source_ids": ["C654", "C651", "C657"], "limitations_addressed": ["Short-term data in C654", "lack of standardized autonomy definitions"]}, {"topic": "Prompt engineering as a lever for learner agency across disciplines", "rationale": "Prompt literacy may mediate the shift from dependency to autonomy, yet most studies focus on language or programming contexts.", "existing_literature": "C656 demonstrates that structured prompt engineering courses improve autonomous learning in academic English; C652 links LLM use to competence and bespoke learning in programming; C651 calls for more research on prompt literacy.", "unresolved_question": "Do disciplinary differences in epistemic practices affect how prompt engineering supports or hinders autonomy?", "population": "Undergraduate students in STEM, humanities, and social sciences", "variables": ["prompt sophistication", "disciplinary epistemic beliefs", "perceived control", "task engagement"], "methodology": "Comparative case studies with discourse and performance analysis", "feasibility": "Moderate—requires cross-disciplinary collaboration but builds on TeacherGAIA (C655) and course designs in C656", "supporting_source_ids": ["C656", "C652", "C651", "C655"], "limitations_addressed": ["STEM bias in current research", "rapid obsolescence of AI tools"]}, {"topic": "Mediated autonomy in under-resourced EFL contexts", "rationale": "Generative AI may compensate for limited instructional support, but ethical and literacy gaps could exacerbate inequities.", "existing_literature": "C653 reveals that ChatGPT acts as a compensatory tool in Palestinian EFL programs, but autonomy is mediated by AI literacy and ethical awareness; C658 highlights agency types (receptive, reflective, etc.) that vary by context.", "unresolved_question": "How can institutions develop context-sensitive AI literacy curricula that promote responsible autonomy without reinforcing dependency?", "population": "Undergraduate EFL learners in under-resourced higher education settings", "variables": ["institutional support", "AI literacy", "ethical reasoning", "writing autonomy"], "methodology": "Participatory action research co-designing literacy modules with students and instructors", "feasibility": "High in targeted contexts; builds directly on C653 findings and addresses digital native myth", "supporting_source_ids": ["C653", "C658"], "limitations_addressed": ["Overgeneralization of autonomy constructs", "neglect of Global South contexts"]}]}

Rejected source IDs: None recorded

Confidence: 70.0

Current research indicates generative AI can both enhance and threaten learner autonomy. Systematic reviews (C651) and empirical studies (C652–C658) show AI tools support self-directed learning through personalized scaffolding, motivation, and reduced cognitive load, particularly in writing and programming. However, risks include overreliance, diminished critical thinking, and unequal outcomes due to varying AI literacy. Autonomy is not inherent but mediated by prompt engineering skills, ethical awareness, and institutional context. Most evidence comes from short-term, discipline-specific studies in higher education, with limited attention to longitudinal effects or diverse academic fields. The boundary between productive assistance and passive dependence remains poorly defined.

Generative AI can enhance learner autonomy when used with sufficient AI literacy and ethical awareness. · moderate

Multiple studies (C652, C653, C654) report increased sense of competence, bespoke learning, and strategic use, but emphasize that benefits depend on learners’ ability to critically evaluate and responsibly use AI outputs.

Supporting sources selected by synthesizer: C652, C653, C654

Prompt engineering and intentional instructional design are key to fostering autonomous, not dependent, AI use. · moderate

C655 and C656 demonstrate that structuring AI interactions via constructivist prompt engineering promotes self-assessment and self-regulation, contrasting with default chatbot modes that encourage passive reception.

Supporting sources selected by synthesizer: C655, C656

Student agency mediates the relationship between AI use and learning outcomes. · moderate

C658 identifies four agency types (receptive, resistive, resourceful, reflective) linked to deeper learning, showing that how students position themselves toward AI determines its impact on autonomy.

Supporting sources selected by synthesizer: C658

Generative AI cannot replace social support, a core component of sustained motivation and autonomy. · limited

C652 explicitly states that while LLMs improve competence and affect, they fail to provide social relatedness, which remains essential under self-determination theory.

Supporting sources selected by synthesizer: C652

Overreliance on generative AI risks outsourcing metacognitive and critical thinking skills. · moderate

C651 and C654 note concerns about cognitive offloading; while some learners reflect critically, survey data show generally low self-monitoring, suggesting vulnerability to passive use.

Supporting sources selected by synthesizer: C651, C654

[C651] Pedagogical Applications of Generative AI in Higher Education: A Systematic Review of the Field · TechTrends Open source

[C652] Programming education and learner motivation in the age of generative AI: student and educator perspectives · Information and Learning Sciences Open source

[C653] AI literacy and mediated learner autonomy in ChatGPT-supported EFL writing: a qualitative study at a Palestinian university · International Journal of Educational Technology in Higher Education Open source

[C654] Understanding self-directed learning in AI-Assisted writing: A mixed methods study of postsecondary learners · Comput. Educ. Artif. Intell. Open source

[C655] Supporting self-directed learning and self-assessment using TeacherGAIA, a generative AI chatbot application: Learning approaches and prompt engineering · Learning: Research and Practice Open source

[C656] The Impact of Prompt Engineering and a Generative AI-Driven Tool on Autonomous Learning: A Case Study · Education Sciences Open source

[C657] Clue before correction: ChatGPT-enhanced strategy for promoting autonomous and reflective language learning · Innovation in Language Learning and Teaching Open source

[C658] From surface to deep learning approaches with Generative AI in higher education: an analytical framework of student agency · Studies in Higher Education Open source

Agreements:

Disagreements:

Limitations: Most studies are recent (2023–2026) and short-term, limiting understanding of longitudinal impacts on autonomy.; Disciplinary scope is narrow, dominated by programming, EFL, and general writing contexts; non-STEM humanities and social sciences are underrepresented.; Definitions of 'autonomy' and 'self-directed learning' vary across studies, complicating synthesis.; Sample sizes and contexts are often localized (e.g., single universities in China, Palestine, or tech-focused institutions), reducing generalizability.; Few studies experimentally compare AI-supported vs. traditional autonomous learning, making causal claims difficult.

Generative AI shows significant potential to support learner autonomy when embedded in thoughtfully designed pedagogical frameworks that emphasize AI literacy, ethical use, and metacognitive reflection. However, this potential is not automatic—it depends on learner agency, instructor guidance, and institutional support. Without these, AI may foster dependency rather than independence. Current evidence is promising but preliminary; robust, longitudinal, and cross-disciplinary research is urgently needed.

Developer evaluation (manual)

Ratings do not affect synthesis. Rate the active answer and evidence you reviewed.

Developer diagnostics

Balanced primary: qwen/qwen3-max. Fallback: openai/o4-mini.

Fallback triggered: No. Reason: None. Accepted synthesizer: qwen/qwen3-max.

Synthesis routing latency: 34819 ms. Total routing cost (USD): 0.0119433600.

Plan-and-Solve diagnostics

Generated queries: 11; retrieval queries: 5; duplicates removed: 6; unique papers: 19.

semantic_scholar: 1 requests; 0 results; 1 failed requests.

consensus: 5 requests; 25 results; 0 failed requests.

Normalized ResearchPlan
original_question
learning autonomyand geenrative AI articles
canonical_search_queries
['"generative AI" AND "learner autonomy"', 'generative AI and learning autonomy', '("learner autonomy" OR "self-directed learning") AND ("generative AI" OR "large language models")', '"ChatGPT" AND "self-directed learning"', 'autonomous learning with generative AI']
keywords
['generative AI', 'learner autonomy', 'self-directed learning', 'self-regulated learning', 'student agency', 'learning autonomy', 'autonomous learning', 'AI in education', 'large language models', 'educational technology']
synonyms
['ChatGPT', 'large language models', 'independent learning', 'autonomous learning', 'artificial intelligence in education', 'machine learning', 'artificial intelligence', 'self-directed learning', 'learner independence', 'self-management', 'GAI', 'LLM']
research_subquestions
['How does student use of generative AI tools affect their development of self-regulated learning skills?', 'What pedagogical frameworks effectively promote learner autonomy while utilizing generative AI in higher education?', 'To what extent does reliance on generative AI lead to cognitive offloading and reduced critical thinking?', 'How do educators perceive the shift in student autonomy due to generative AI assistants?', 'What is the impact of generative AI on learning autonomy?', 'How can generative AI be used to support autonomous learning?', 'What are the potential benefits and challenges of using generative AI in autonomous learning environments?', 'How does generative AI impact learner autonomy in higher education?', 'What are the effects of AI tools on self-regulated learning behaviors?', 'Does reliance on generative AI diminish or enhance student independence?']
candidate_gap_hypotheses
['Longitudinal impact of continuous generative AI usage on independent problem-solving capabilities in K-12 and higher education.', 'The role of demographic differences in student adaptation to AI-supported self-directed learning environments.', 'investigating the long-term effects of generative AI on learning autonomy', 'examining the role of generative AI in supporting diverse learner needs', 'developing frameworks for integrating generative AI into autonomous learning environments', 'Long-term effects of GAI on intrinsic motivation are unknown', 'Ethical implications of AI-assisted autonomy lack standardization', 'Differences across academic disciplines are underexplored']
uncertainties
['The precise boundary between productive AI scaffolding and passive cognitive dependence in student learning.', 'The generalizability of early pedagogical frameworks to diverse non-STEM academic disciplines.', 'the effectiveness of generative AI in promoting learning autonomy', 'the potential risks and challenges associated with using generative AI in autonomous learning environments', 'Definition of autonomy varies across studies', 'Rapid evolution of AI tools makes findings quickly outdated', 'Distinction between assistance and dependency is unclear']
filters
{'suggestions': [{'year_from': 2022, 'year_to': 2025, 'fields': ['Education', 'Computer Science Education', 'Educational Technology', 'Psychology'], 'study_types': ['empirical study', 'systematic review', 'conceptual paper', 'case study']}, {'year_from': 2020, 'year_to': None, 'fields': ['education', 'computer science'], 'study_types': ['experimental', 'review']}, {'year_from': 2020, 'year_to': None, 'fields': ['Education', 'Educational Technology', 'Psychology', 'Computer Science'], 'study_types': ['Empirical Study', 'Review', 'Qualitative Research', 'Quantitative Research']}], 'policy': 'Advisory only; configured provider filters apply.'}
generated_query_count
11
successful_planners
3

Retrieval is incomplete; absence of results is not proof of absence.

Provider counts describe latest attempts; evidence and answer metrics describe active results. Duration and costs include all attempts, including retries. Cost is USD, OpenRouter only; Consensus billing is not estimated. Unknown is not zero.

total_duration_ms
124117
interrupted_execution_metrics_incomplete
False
successful_providers
4
failed_providers
1
successful_agents
3
consensus_success
True
synthesis_success
True
paper_count
19
total_estimated_openrouter_cost
0.0341023150
known_cost_subtotal
0.0341023150
attempts_missing_cost
0
valid_source_percent
100.0
removed_source_ids
0
agreements_count
0
disagreements_count
0
evidence_strength_distribution
{'moderate': 4, 'limited': 1}
judge_confidence
70.0
answer_length
3614
Attempt / modelSuccessLatency msInput / output / total tokensCost USDError
#179 academic-graph-searchNo596? / ? / ?Unknown rate_limit: Semantic Scholar retrieval failed (rate_limit).
#178 search-v1Yes25730? / ? / ?Unknown :
#177 qwen/qwen3.5-27bYes30499333 / 2877 / 32100.0045530550 reported:
#176 meta-llama/llama-4-scoutYes22123310 / 398 / 7080.0001504000 reported:
#175 google/gemini-3.5-flashYes101641185 / 1742 / 29270.0174555000 reported:
#37 qwen/qwen3-maxYes348196402 / 1782 / 81840.0119433600 reported:

Judge: qwen/qwen3-max. Papers used: 8. Papers omitted by limit: 11.

Rejected source IDs: None recorded

Conversation history
User
Experiences of learning autonomy among Master of Health Professions Education Scholars using Generative AI
User
act as an expert research in mhpe and work on the topic to find the gap relevant in the literature to the title of research proposal,look into the rationale of the study,how is it impactful and justifiable ,how will it add any contribuion to the recent studies and also when there are guidleiens by HEC and UNESCo for usage of generative AI in research work ,extratct relevant articles to cite and identify the gaps in it (atleas 10 article for now),what i sthe actual concept of the whole study with reelavnt justiciation withteh artciles avaiabl.how will teh tudy sample be taken,how the methods will be decided,hw to amke study more impactable ,what are the objectives and what questinnaire can be geenrated from the ttile of the study.
User
learning autonomyand geenrative AI articles

Three AI perspectives + academic evidence · Check sources before relying on them

Manage research