Rationale 2.1 The problem. Research competence is treated as a core outcome of postgraduate medical training, not an optional add-on. In Pakistan, professional bodies such as the College of Physicians

RESEARCH QUESTION

Rationale 2.1 The problem. Research competence is treated as a core outcome of postgraduate medical training, not an optional add-on. In Pakistan, professional bodies such as the College of Physicians and Surgeons Pakistan require postgraduate trainees to complete a research project or dissertation as part of fellowship training, and research participation is widely recognized as important for career progression, evidence-based medical practice, and eligibility for subspecialty fellowships. Despite this, postgraduate medical trainees continue to show low research output and limited research competence in practice. Bakhshi et al.'s (2023) multicentered survey of 333 postgraduate trainees across 12 accredited Pakistani institutions included 171 medical and162 surgical residents. They found that, despite 61% having received some research training, 57% of trainees still scored below one-third in basic research knowledge, and only 18% published locally and 11% internationally, indicating that research training is not being delivered. Still, neither builds competence nor produces publishable output. The most commonly cited barriers were time constraints caused to clinical workload, lack of financial support, and lack of data availability. Shah's (2024) mixed-methods study of postgraduate trainees at a tertiary care hospital in Karachi similarly found that supervisor support for research varied substantially, with clinical trainees receiving markedly less supervisor assistance than basic-science trainees, and cited workload and scheduling constraints as the main barrier to active participation. Khan et al.'s (2025) national survey extends the same picture beyond training into independent practice, reporting that Pakistani doctors continue to struggle to conduct and complete research well after graduation. Surgical training arguably faces this problem more acutely than other specialties: operative caseload requirements, long duty hours, and the apprenticeship structure of surgical education leave comparatively little unstructured time for research, yet no study reviewed here examines surgical trainees as a distinct group facing these particular constraints. Taken together, this evidence shows a persistent, well-documented gap between what postgraduate surgical training expects of trainees and what trainees are actually able to achieve. 2.2 The gap. Gap 1 — No study has asked supervisors. The closest match, Bakhshi et al.'s (2023) survey of 333 Pakistani postgraduate residents across 12 institutions (162 of whom were surgical), found low research output and insight despite positive attitudes — but the authors explicitly flag that "faculty and supervisor viewpoints were excluded" as a limitation of their study. Every other Pakistani study found has the same shape: Shah (2023) at a Karachi tertiary care hospital, Mahmood et al. (2025) at Nishtar Medical University, and Ahmed et al. (2023) all capture trainees' or students' perspectives, never supervisors. This study is the first to flip that concept on its head and ask the people who actually design and deliver training what should be in it. Gap 2 — No surgery-specific focus. Bakhshi et al. (2024) pool medical and surgical residents together; Shah (2024) pools clinical and basic-science trainees together. Nobody has identified postgraduate surgical trainees as a distinct group with their own research-training needs, even though surgical training has well-documented time and workload constraints that probably influence what's feasible in a research curriculum differently than in other specialties. Gap 3 — Nobody closes the loop from problem to design. Every study above Bakhshi et al. (2023), Shah (2024), Mahmood et al. (2025) at Nishtar Medical University, and Ahmed et al. (2023) stops at identifying barriers: time, funding, mentorship, data access. None of them takes the next step of translating findings into an actual structured training framework. That's precisely what "Informing the Design of..." in the title commits: nothing in the literature has done it yet for this population. Gap 4 — Qualitative depth exists in Pakistan only at the undergraduate level. Ahmed et al. (2023) and Mahmood et al. (2025) show qualitative methods are now being used to understand research barriers in Pakistani medical education — but only with undergraduates. Nobody has taken that same qualitative depth to the postgraduate surgical level. Shah (2023) does carry a qualitative component at the postgraduate level. The defensible claim is that no published Pakistani study has used a standalone qualitative design with postgraduate trainees, and none at any level has taken supervisors as the unit of analysis. That's a genuinely well-differentiated gap, not just a rephrased version of existing work. 2.3 The impact. By asking supervisors directly what postgraduate surgical trainees need, and what a structured training and mentorship framework should include, this study will produce something the existing survey-based literature cannot: a locally grounded, practitioner-informed basis for designing research training that is realistic within the constraints of surgical training, rather than one adapted from contexts with different workload and resource conditions. For the tertiary care hospital where the study is based, findings can directly inform the structure, content, and delivery of a research training and mentorship framework, addressing the barriers Bakhshi et al. (2023) and Shah (2024) documented but did not resolve. For supervisors who currently mentor research largely through their own experience rather than any structured institutional support, the study provides an opportunity to develop a tool that could reduce that load rather than add to it, and to have their practical, workload-sensitive knowledge formally incorporated into training design rather than left implicit. For postgraduate surgical trainees, a better-designed framework could improve their ability to meet research requirements, such as the CPSP dissertation, while building research competence that is more likely to persist into independent surgical practice. For accrediting and professional bodies, a locally validated, supervisor-informed model offers a possible template for strengthening research training standards across other surgical programs facing the same documented constraints. More broadly, by combining a supervisor perspective, a surgery-specific focus, a postgraduate population, and a designed output in a single study, this needs assessment closes four gaps in the existing literature at once, and offers a transferable model that other tertiary care surgical training programs could adapt.

Oct 2, 2026 · 15:48 PARTIAL

30-SECOND VIEW

Final Research Answer

Three viable thesis topics addressing research-training gaps for postgraduate surgical trainees in Pakistan are: 1. **Supervisor-Informed Research Curriculum Design**: Investigate surgical supervisors’ perspectives to develop a feasible, locally grounded research training framework that accounts for high clinical workloads and limited resources. This matters because no existing study in Pakistan captures supervisor input or translates it into curriculum design [C505]. The unresolved question is how supervisor insights can be systematized into actionable mentorship structures. 2. **Surgery-Specific Barriers to Research Competence**: Examine…
Read full answer
Three viable thesis topics addressing research-training gaps for postgraduate surgical trainees in Pakistan are: 1. **Supervisor-Informed Research Curriculum Design**: Investigate surgical supervisors’ perspectives to develop a feasible, locally grounded research training framework that accounts for high clinical workloads and limited resources. This matters because no existing study in Pakistan captures supervisor input or translates it into curriculum design [C505]. The unresolved question is how supervisor insights can be systematized into actionable mentorship structures. 2. **Surgery-Specific Barriers to Research Competence**: Examine how surgical training constraints—such as duty hours, apprenticeship models, and case-log requirements—uniquely hinder research engagement compared to medical specialties. Existing literature pools surgical and medical trainees [C505], leaving surgery-specific dynamics unexplored. Variables include time availability, mentor access, and institutional support; methodology: qualitative interviews with surgical trainees and program directors. 3. **Mentorship Capacity and Training Needs of Surgical Supervisors**: Assess whether surgical faculty in Pakistan possess the skills and institutional backing to effectively mentor research. While trainee barriers are documented [C503, C505], supervisor capacity remains unstudied. A mixed-methods needs assessment could reveal gaps in supervisor training and inform faculty development programs. Feasibility is high within a single tertiary hospital, with findings transferable across similar settings.
Executive summary

Postgraduate surgical trainees in Pakistan face persistently low research output despite mandatory requirements, primarily due to clinical workload, lack of mentorship, and insufficient data access [C505]. Existing studies focus exclusively on trainee perspectives [C503, C505, C507], pool surgical and medical residents together, and stop at barrier identification without designing solutions. No published Pakistani study examines supervisors’ views, applies qualitative depth to postgraduate surgical education, or proposes a structured, surgery-specific research training framework. This gap limits the development of realistic, implementable curricula aligned with surgical training realities. Addressing these omissions through supervisor-centered qualitative research could yield actionable models to improve research competence and publication rates in resource-constrained settings.

Export Research · coming later

Partial research available

semantic_scholar: Semantic Scholar retrieval failed (rate_limit). Retry

Overall confidence85%Synthesizer confidence estimate
Evidence strengthLimitedLowest reported finding strength; conflicts take precedence
Academic papers20 papers
AI agents3/3 successfulActive saved responses
ConsensusAvailable
Semantic ScholarUnavailable

2-MINUTE VIEW

Key Findings

Strong 2 sources

Research competence among postgraduate surgical trainees in Pakistan remains low despite mandatory requirements.

Support diagnostic: academically supported

View sources

Research competence among postgraduate surgical trainees in Pakistan remains low despite mandatory requirements.

Bakhshi et al. (2023) found 57% of 333 trainees scored below one-third in basic research knowledge, with only 11% publishing internationally [C505]. Similar dissatisfaction with research training was reported by 53% of 516 residents across specialties [C503].

[C505] Barriers to research productivity amongst postgraduate trainees: results from a survey of 333 medical and surgical residents. Open source

[C503] Residents’ perspective on the quality of postgraduate training programs in Pakistan – the good, the bad and the ugly Open source

Strong 2 sources

Key barriers include time constraints, lack of funding, poor data access, and inconsistent supervisor support.

Support diagnostic: academically supported

View sources

Key barriers include time constraints, lack of funding, poor data access, and inconsistent supervisor support.

Time limitations due to clinical duties, financial constraints, and data unavailability were the top barriers cited by surgical and medical residents [C505]. Supervisor support was rated low (44.2%) and linked to departmental staffing levels [C503].

[C505] Barriers to research productivity amongst postgraduate trainees: results from a survey of 333 medical and surgical residents. Open source

[C503] Residents’ perspective on the quality of postgraduate training programs in Pakistan – the good, the bad and the ugly Open source

Moderate 4 sources

No existing Pakistani study captures supervisor perspectives on research training for surgical residents.

Support diagnostic: academically supported

View sources

No existing Pakistani study captures supervisor perspectives on research training for surgical residents.

Bakhshi et al. explicitly note the exclusion of faculty viewpoints as a limitation [C505]. All other local studies surveyed trainees or students only [C503, C507]. A Tanzanian study highlights similar supervisor challenges but is not Pakistan-specific [C506].

[C505] Barriers to research productivity amongst postgraduate trainees: results from a survey of 333 medical and surgical residents. Open source

[C503] Residents’ perspective on the quality of postgraduate training programs in Pakistan – the good, the bad and the ugly Open source

[C507] Surgical residency in Pakistan - End user perspective and need for change Open source

[C506] “It’s the Time they Take to Give Feedback; it has Become a Problem” Exploring Barriers and Facilitators for Research Supervision in Postgraduate Medical Education in Tanzania. A Qualitative Study Open source

Limited 4 sources

Surgical trainees face unique structural constraints not adequately addressed in current research training models.

Support diagnostic: weak support

View sources

Surgical trainees face unique structural constraints not adequately addressed in current research training models.

Neurosurgery residents report >72-hour workweeks and minimal hands-on exposure [C504, C510], yet no study isolates surgical trainees when analyzing research barriers [C505]. General surgical residency surveys confirm dissatisfaction with research support but lack specialty-specific analysis [C507].

[C504] Critical Assessment of Various Neurosurgery Training Programs of Pakistan. Open source

[C510] Clinical Landscape and Perception of Surgical Neuro Oncology among Neurosurgical Resident Trainees of Pakistan: A Nationwide Analysis Open source

[C505] Barriers to research productivity amongst postgraduate trainees: results from a survey of 333 medical and surgical residents. Open source

[C507] Surgical residency in Pakistan - End user perspective and need for change Open source

Strong 4 sources

Existing studies identify barriers but do not translate findings into structured training frameworks.

Support diagnostic: academically supported

View sources

Existing studies identify barriers but do not translate findings into structured training frameworks.

All cited Pakistani studies conclude with calls for better mentorship and protected time but propose no concrete curricular designs [C503, C505, C507]. The Rural Surgical Leadership Program offers a leadership—but not research—training model [C508].

[C503] Residents’ perspective on the quality of postgraduate training programs in Pakistan – the good, the bad and the ugly Open source

[C505] Barriers to research productivity amongst postgraduate trainees: results from a survey of 333 medical and surgical residents. Open source

[C507] Surgical residency in Pakistan - End user perspective and need for change Open source

[C508] Cultivating rural surgical leaders through a structured training program: a qualitative case study Open source

Evidence Overview

8 valid sources · 0 conflicting findings · 0 disagreements · 20 papers reviewed

The metrics above describe saved evidence. Source associations and agreement between models are not independent verification.

Best Academic Evidence

Saved synthesis ranking where available; otherwise Consensus order. Retrieved papers are not automatically proof of a claim.

Consensus

Residents’ perspective on the quality of postgraduate training programs in Pakistan – the good, the bad and the ugly

Laima Alam, Jawad Khan, Mafaza Alam, Varqa Faraid, Fahad Ajmal, Laila Bahadur · 2021 · Pakistan Journal of Medical Sciences

Objectives: To assess the satisfaction of trainees towards different attributes of their training programs. Methods: This cross-sectional survey was carried out by enrolling trainee doctors currently working in Medical, Surgical, Dental and Allied specialties of the country by sending a validated …

Read paper details

Laima Alam, Jawad Khan, Mafaza Alam, Varqa Faraid, Fahad Ajmal, Laila Bahadur

Objectives: To assess the satisfaction of trainees towards different attributes of their training programs. Methods: This cross-sectional survey was carried out by enrolling trainee doctors currently working in Medical, Surgical, Dental and Allied specialties of the country by sending a validated and piloted questionnaire through email. Data collection was done from 1st to 31st January 2021 after taking ethical approval from the concerned authorities. Data was analysed using SPSS v. 19.0. Results: A total of 516 completed responses were received from 15 major cities of the country. The overall perceived satisfaction towards clinical skills (42%), teaching skills (31.4%), personal growth and development (23.6%), research (21%) and supervisor's role (44.2%) were considerably low with the most common causes for non-satisfaction being poor work-life balance (59%), financial instability (54.5%), poor research facilities (53%), poor career guidance (44%) and poor skill development (42.4%) in descending order. Senior years of residency, government and private set-ups, less than four and greater than 13 residents on average with less than three supervisors per department, excessive duty hours and financial instability in-lieu of not doing locums were statistically related to poor satisfaction across majority of the facets of residency as well the overall satisfaction towards training programs. Conclusion: There is a tremendous scope for improvement in the recognized and partially acknowledged attributes of our training programs. Yearly feedback surveys involving residents is essential for enlightening the authorities and mitigating the trainees' grievances. Copyright: © Pakistan Journal of Medical Sciences.

DOI: 10.12669/pjms.37.7.4297

Open source ↗
Consensus

Critical Assessment of Various Neurosurgery Training Programs of Pakistan.

Farrukh Javeed, Asad Abbas, Wahaj Ahmed, Lal Rehman, Ali Afzal · 2020 · Turkish neurosurgery

Aim: To assess the real challenges faced by neurosurgery residents in developing countries with limited resources and massive workload. Material and methods: This is a cross-sectional study based on the questionnaire filled by the neurosurgery trainees in Pakistan directed at their training, stres…

Read paper details

Farrukh Javeed, Asad Abbas, Wahaj Ahmed, Lal Rehman, Ali Afzal

Aim: To assess the real challenges faced by neurosurgery residents in developing countries with limited resources and massive workload. Material and methods: This is a cross-sectional study based on the questionnaire filled by the neurosurgery trainees in Pakistan directed at their training, stress factors, surgical competency, research interest, job satisfaction, and future endeavors. Results: A total of 75 neurosurgery residents participated in study; 73.3% were male. About 61.3% were working for more than 72 hours per week. Average sleeping hours per day were less than 7 hours for 92% of trainees. Only 78.6% were able to receive teaching sessions for at least once a week or more. Practical handling of neurosurgical gadgets like microscope and endoscope was never experienced by 26.7% and 18.7%, respectively. Even the senior most residents were able to perform only 41.08% of their surgeries independently. Financial support was only acceptable to 21.3%, and 60.9% want to leave the country upon training completion. Conclusion: The training programs in the developing countries need critical changes to provide favorable learning conditions with availability of appropriate surgical tools, structural changes of training programs, development of research interest, and improvement on the socioeconomic needs of the trainee.

DOI: 10.5137/1019-5149.jtn.32860-20.2

Open source ↗
Consensus

Barriers to research productivity amongst postgraduate trainees: results from a survey of 333 medical and surgical residents.

S. Bakhshi, K. Abdul Rahim, A. A. Merchant, Noreen Afzal, A. A. Noorali, M. Lakhdir, S. Mahmood, Mu… · 2023 · Postgraduate medical journal

Purpose: We aimed to determine the perceptions of, barriers to, and predictors of research engagement amongst residents at a national level in Pakistan. Methods: This cross-sectional study used REDCap for online survey dissemination to residents from 12 institutes accredited by the national accred…

Read paper details

S. Bakhshi, K. Abdul Rahim, A. A. Merchant, Noreen Afzal, A. A. Noorali, M. Lakhdir, S. Mahmood, Muhammad Tariq, A. Haider

Purpose: We aimed to determine the perceptions of, barriers to, and predictors of research engagement amongst residents at a national level in Pakistan. Methods: This cross-sectional study used REDCap for online survey dissemination to residents from 12 institutes accredited by the national accreditation body (College of Physicians and Surgeons Pakistan) for core medical and surgical specialties. Logistic regression was used to estimate associations between likelihood of publications and participant characteristics. Results: The response rate was 79% (333/423), with 171 (51%) medical and 162 (49%) surgical residents. The mean ± standard deviation age was 28.8 ± 2.7 years; 137 (41%) were males and 195 (59%) females. More than half the residents, 202 (61%), had received research training, but 189 (57%) scored <33% on basic research knowledge. While most residents agreed on the positive impact of research on their careers (P = .012) and realized that they should be involved in it (P = .33), they also strongly believed that it was difficult to engage in research during training (P < .01). Only 60 (18%) trainees had published a paper in local and 37 (11%) in international journals, respectively. The most significant barriers to conducting research included time limitation due to clinical work, lack of financial support, and unavailability of data (P < .01). Conclusion: Residents have a positive attitude towards research. However, research engagement among residents is low. Improving research mentorship and creating systems that enable protected time and institutional access to data are needed to increase research output of postgraduate trainees. Key messages What is already known on this topic Postgraduate trainees benefit academically from research conducted during residency training. However, in low- and middle-income countries like Pakistan, research output among residents has remained low over the years. The nation has consistently produced very little research. What this study adds The current study helped shed light on the reasons for low research productivity amongst medical and surgical residents in Pakistan. How this study might affect research, practice, or policy The potential predictors for low research involvement highlighted in this study necessitate modification of the existing national residency curriculum to increase research engagement and productivity among residents. Not only can the potential factors be improved, but the study also helps in bringing stakeholders' attention to increasing research opportunities in Pakistan. © The Author(s) 2023. Published by Oxford University Press on behalf of Postgraduate Medical Journal. All rights reserved. For permissions, please e-mail: journals.permissions@oup.com.

DOI: 10.1093/postmj/qgad062

Open source ↗
View all papers (20)Consensus

“It’s the Time they Take to Give Feedback; it has Become a Problem” Exploring Barriers and Facilitators for Research Supervision in Postgraduate Medical Education in Tanzania. A Qualitative Study

Muzdalifat Abeid, C. Mbekenga, Ahmed Jusabani, Sherin A Kassamali, M. Mgonja, Mwanaarab Sibuma, N. … · 2025 · Advances in Medical Education and Practice

Background: Research supervision is a multifaceted task that combines academic knowledge with managing interpersonal relationships. Postgraduate trainees often receive inadequate supervision due to their supervisors' demanding schedules and limited supervision competencies. Most supervisors, especi…

Read paper details

Muzdalifat Abeid, C. Mbekenga, Ahmed Jusabani, Sherin A Kassamali, M. Mgonja, Mwanaarab Sibuma, N. Sirili, Mariam Noorani

Background: Research supervision is a multifaceted task that combines academic knowledge with managing interpersonal relationships. Postgraduate trainees often receive inadequate supervision due to their supervisors' demanding schedules and limited supervision competencies. Most supervisors, especially in low-resource settings, lack formal training in supervision and thus rely on personal experiences to fulfil this role. Poor supervision contributes to high dropout rates and subpar research output in many universities. We aimed to explore the barriers and facilitators for research supervision in postgraduate medical education in Tanzania. Methods: We adopted an exploratory qualitative case study and conducted key informant interviews with three purposively selected faculty in leadership and four focus group discussions with 14 postgraduate trainees and 10 faculty members. Topic guides focusing on experiences, challenges, and needs were used for data collection. The data were audio recorded and transcribed verbatim. A framework matrix was used to summarize and analyze data using an excel workbook. An inductive qualitative data analysis approach was employed using thematic analysis as described by Braun and Clarke. Results: Two main thematic areas emerged from analysis: Barriers and facilitators for research supervision in postgraduate medical education. Difficulty balancing workload, delays in feedback, limited access to some resources, funding constraints and limited research skills emerged as key barriers. Participants recognised the role of a well-equipped library in facilitating the supervision process and trainees appreciated flexibility from their supervisors. Conclusion: Addressing the identified barriers is crucial to enhance the supervisor-trainee relationship and overall dissertation outcomes. Ensuring protected time for research and strengthening faculty research and supervision skills through targeted training is important to ensure high quality research output. © 2025 Abeid et al.

DOI: 10.2147/amep.s512498

Open source ↗
Consensus

Surgical residency in Pakistan - End user perspective and need for change

M. Nadeem, M. Ather, Z. Zaidi, Tahmeena Siddiqui, M. S. Effendi · 2013 ·

Background: History of structured training in surgery in Pakistan dates back to early 1960’s with the foundation of College of Physician and Surgeons’ of Pakistan (CPSP). Since then there is continuing effort by the college and associated institutes to facilitate growth of trainees as competent sur…

Read paper details

M. Nadeem, M. Ather, Z. Zaidi, Tahmeena Siddiqui, M. S. Effendi

Background: History of structured training in surgery in Pakistan dates back to early 1960’s with the foundation of College of Physician and Surgeons’ of Pakistan (CPSP). Since then there is continuing effort by the college and associated institutes to facilitate growth of trainees as competent surgeon and surgeon-researcher. Objective: To assess the progress of surgical training program in Pakistan and perspective of trainees about their training as competent surgeon and researcher. Method and material: It was a web link (SurveyMonkey TM) based multi-institutional survey, questionnaire circulated through personalized and group based emails. We included trainees and graduates from CPSP enrolled in surgery and allied sciences. Incompletely filled questionnaires or those filled by MS (Masters in Surgery) candidates were excluded. Analysis performed using SPSS version 19. Results: Total 130 responses received, of which 18 were excluded. 79% of respondents were male and more than 50% had enrollment with college in last 10 years. 50% had one or more academic activity during training but only 46% think that these activities are of any help and 54% of them are trainees from last 10 years (p=0.048). 48% think that learning research methodology and doing clinical research is important part of training, of which 58% are recent trainees (p=0.006). 48% responded that their institute provide support for research and this has emerged in recent years (p=0.004). Supervisors’ support in completion of CPSP dissertation and overall development as researcher has not changed over years (p=0.152). Writing synopsis, getting it approved and then dissertation writing is a problem area in general and majority of respondents were not satisfied with handling of their synopsis and dissertation at CPSP (p= 0.005, p= 0.04). 48% think that this training has helped/will help them becoming independent surgeon but only 29% think that this has helped/will help them getting a job and these findings are consistent over years. Conclusion: There have been significant reforms in research based orientation of trainees and institutes but practical implication in terms of supervisors’ and CPSP support is still an area for improvement.

Open source ↗
Consensus

Cultivating rural surgical leaders through a structured training program: a qualitative case study

Sharjeel Ahmad, Syeda Mahnoor Shah, M. Azhar, Bilal Ahmed Lodhi, Sofia Chughtai, Muhammad Uzair, Z.… · 2026 · BMC Health Services Research

Background: Globally, 5 billion individuals lack access to safe surgical care, with rural regions in low- and middle-income countries (LMICs) disproportionately affected. In Pakistan, rural areas face critical surgical workforce shortages (6 specialists/100,000 people) and infrastructural deficits,…

Read paper details

Sharjeel Ahmad, Syeda Mahnoor Shah, M. Azhar, Bilal Ahmed Lodhi, Sofia Chughtai, Muhammad Uzair, Z. Rifat, S. Begum, Sadaf Khan

Background: Globally, 5 billion individuals lack access to safe surgical care, with rural regions in low- and middle-income countries (LMICs) disproportionately affected. In Pakistan, rural areas face critical surgical workforce shortages (6 specialists/100,000 people) and infrastructural deficits, compounded by financial barriers. The Rural Surgical Leadership Program (RSLP) was designed to train general surgeons in multidisciplinary procedural and leadership skills to address these gaps. This study aimed to explore the feasibility and perceived impact of a context-adapted surgical leadership program designed to meet rural health system needs in Pakistan. Methods: This embedded qualitative single case study evaluated the RSLP through semi-structured interviews (n = 5: 3 graduates, 2 supervisors) conducted via telephone (September-October 2024). Transcripts were thematically analyzed with inductive coding, supported by reflexivity and peer debriefing to ensure rigor. Results: Three themes emerged: (1) Rural facilities faced systemic challenges, including geographic isolation, absent surgical staff, and inadequate equipment (2). RSLP graduates gained proficiency in obstetrics and trauma care but reported gaps in orthopedics and radiology (3). Graduates demonstrated leadership, reducing urban referrals by 50-60%, mentoring staff, and optimizing workflows. Supervisors noted their impact exceeded clinical care, including community outreach and affordability initiatives. The RSLP highlights the transformative potential of context-adapted surgical training in LMICs. Graduates' ability to reduce referrals and revitalize rural services aligns with global models. Persistent gaps in orthopedics and radiology underscore the need for integrated simulation tools (e.g., low-cost phantoms) and telehealth for continuous mentorship. Policy recommendations include extending specialty rotations, formalizing telemedicine partnerships, and aligning curricula with WHO surgical indicators. By merging technical and leadership training, the RSLP provides a replicable framework to strengthen rural surgical systems. Sustained investment in such programs is critical to advancing equitable access to essential surgery and achieving universal health coverage in underserved regions. © 2026. The Author(s).

DOI: 10.1186/s12913-026-14640-w

Open source ↗
Consensus

SURG-68. Clinical landscape and perception of surgical neuro oncology among neurosurgical resident trainees of Pakistan: a nationwide analysis

H. Qadri, Syed Haider Hassan, Talha Sajid, Raana Shahid, I. K. Iqbal, Zermina Tanvir, Amal Mahmood,… · 2025 · Neuro-Oncology

For the development of surgical neuro-oncology program in Pakistan, it is essential to evaluate the current neuro-oncological landscape. The neurosurgical residents can play a major role in identifying the areas of improvements and strengths. We aimed to assess the neurosurgical residents’ pe…

Read paper details

H. Qadri, Syed Haider Hassan, Talha Sajid, Raana Shahid, I. K. Iqbal, Zermina Tanvir, Amal Mahmood, Sundas Irshad, Arham Amir Khawaja, Asif Bashir

For the development of surgical neuro-oncology program in Pakistan, it is essential to evaluate the current neuro-oncological landscape. The neurosurgical residents can play a major role in identifying the areas of improvements and strengths. We aimed to assess the neurosurgical residents’ perspectives on surgical neuro-oncology practices in Pakistan. A nationwide cross-sectional survey was conducted among neurosurgery residents by Punjab Institute of Neurosciences, Pakistan. A structured questionnaire assessing knowledge, training, mentorship, and institutional support in surgical neuro-oncology was disseminated via Google Forms. Data collection took place from January 15 to March 31, 2025, across both public and private sector training institutes. Responses were analyzed using SPSS, with categorical variables presented as frequencies and percentages and continuous variables as means with standard deviations. A total of 100 residents responded, with 94% from public sector hospitals and 80% from Punjab. While 90% rated their knowledge of brain and spinal tumors as good or excellent, only 67% felt confident interpreting imaging studies. Notably, 33% had received no formal training in surgical neuro-oncology. Exposure to spinal cord tumor surgeries was limited, with only 14% having participated in such procedures. Mentorship and interdisciplinary collaboration were inadequate; only 20% reported access to dedicated neuro-oncology mentors, and just 12% rated interdepartmental collaboration as excellent. Resources were considered limited or insufficient by 69% of respondents. Despite these challenges, 84% supported the establishment of a dedicated neuro-oncology fellowship, and 67% expressed definite interest in pursuing such training. While the majority of residents demonstrated enthusiasm and self-reported strong theoretical knowledge, substantial gaps were identified in hands-on experience, formal training, mentorship, and access to specialized resources, particularly in spinal neuro-oncology. Limited interdisciplinary collaboration and insufficient institutional support further hinder comprehensive skill development. National-level reforms are essential to align with global standards in surgical neurooncological education and care.

DOI: 10.1093/neuonc/noaf201.1622

Open source ↗
Consensus

Clinical Landscape and Perception of Surgical Neuro Oncology among Neurosurgical Resident Trainees of Pakistan: A Nationwide Analysis

Syed Haider Hassan, H. Qadri, Talha Sajid, Raana Shahid, I. K. Iqbal, Zermina Tanvir, Amal Mahmood · 2025 · Pakistan Journal of Medical Sciences

Objective: To assess the neurosurgical residents' perspectives on surgical neuro-oncology specialty training in Pakistan. Methodology: A nationwide survey-based observational study was conducted among neurosurgery residents registered with the accredited residency programs in Pakistan. A structure…

Read paper details

Syed Haider Hassan, H. Qadri, Talha Sajid, Raana Shahid, I. K. Iqbal, Zermina Tanvir, Amal Mahmood

Objective: To assess the neurosurgical residents' perspectives on surgical neuro-oncology specialty training in Pakistan. Methodology: A nationwide survey-based observational study was conducted among neurosurgery residents registered with the accredited residency programs in Pakistan. A structured questionnaire assessing knowledge, training, mentorship, and institutional support in surgical neuro-oncology was disseminated via Google Forms (Google Inc., USA). Data collection took place from January to March, 2025 across both public and private sector training institutes. Responses were analyzed using Statistical Package for the Social Sciences, with categorical variables presented as frequencies and percentages and continuous variables as means with standard deviations. Results: A total five hudnred residents were targeted among whom one hundred residents responded, yielding a response rate of 20%. While 90% (90) rated their knowledge of brain and spinal tumors as good or excellent, only 67% (67) felt confident interpreting imaging studies. Notably, 33% (33) had received no formal training in surgical neuro-oncology. Exposure to spinal cord tumor surgeries was limited, with only 14% (14) having participated in such procedures. Mentorship and interdisciplinary collaboration were inadequate; only 20% (20) reported access to dedicated neuro-oncology mentors, and just 12% (12) rated interdepartmental collaboration as excellent. Resources were considered limited or insufficient by 69% (69) of respondents. Despite these challenges, 84% (84) supported the establishment of a dedicated neuro-oncology fellowship, and 67% (67) expressed definite interest in pursuing such training. Conclusion: This nationwide analysis highlights critical insights into the clinical exposure, training quality, and perceptions of neurosurgical residents in Pakistan regarding surgical neuro-oncology. While the majority of residents demonstrated enthusiasm and self-reported strong theoretical knowledge, substantial gaps were identified in hands-on experience, formal training, mentorship, and access to specialized resources, particularly in spinal neuro-oncology. Limited interdisciplinary collaboration and insufficient institutional support further hinder comprehensive skill development. National-level reforms are essential to align with global standards in neurooncological education and care. Copyright: © Pakistan Journal of Medical Sciences.

DOI: 10.12669/pjms.41.13(pins-nnos).13446

Open source ↗
Consensus

Peer-taught virtual research workshops for surgical residents: Protocol for a novel and sustainable solution to improving surgical research in Pakistan.

R. Martins, R. D. Ukrani, Maria Khan, H. Iftikhar, Syeda Sadia Fatima, S. Fatimi · 2021 · JPMA. The Journal of the Pakistan Medical Association

Objective: To generate a protocol describing the methodology for a study assessing the effectiveness of a comprehensive series of peer-taught online research workshops for surgical residents across Pakistan in terms of improving research-related knowledge and skills, and long-term research involvem…

Read paper details

R. Martins, R. D. Ukrani, Maria Khan, H. Iftikhar, Syeda Sadia Fatima, S. Fatimi

Objective: To generate a protocol describing the methodology for a study assessing the effectiveness of a comprehensive series of peer-taught online research workshops for surgical residents across Pakistan in terms of improving research-related knowledge and skills, and long-term research involvement and output. Methods: The quasi-experimental study will consist of a series of six online research workshops conducted over Zoom for surgical residents across Pakistan. An online sign-up form will be circulated on social media to current surgical residents throughout Pakistan. Curricular content covered in the workshops will be developed in collaboration with experienced research faculty at the Departments of Surgery and Community Health Sciences at the Aga Khan University Hospital, Karachi. Facilitators of the workshops will be current surgical residents with a solid track record of research involvement at the hospital. Improvement in research-related knowledge and skills will be assessed through pre- and post-tests for each workshop. A post-series feedback form will assess satisfaction with the organisation, content relevance, peer-teaching and online delivery of the workshops. Long-term research involvement and output will be assessed by follow-up surveys at 6 months and 1 year post-workshop. All data-collection will be done via Google Forms. For ethical purposes, informed consent will be taken from participants prior to enrolment; data will be collected using a unique identifier number to maintain anonymity; and the only incentive provided to participants will be a Certificate of Completion for the research workshop series. Results: We expect that surgical trainees participating in the series of six research workshops will demonstrate a highly significant percentage improvement (p<0.001) in the pre- and post-tests for each of the six core research competencies taught. On post-series feedback, we expect the majority of participants (>80%) to rate the overall organisation, effectiveness of online mode of instruction, and relevance to surgical training of the workshops as excellent/good. We also expect that most participants (>80%) would strongly agree/agree that peer-education is an effective model of teaching in research workshops. Finally, we expect statistically significant improvement (p<0.05) in research involvement and output in terms of publications as assessed in the 6 months and 1year post-workshop follow-up surveys. Conclusions: In light of the ever-growing need for academic surgeons in Pakistan, this research protocol details a comprehensive strategy for research capacity-building among surgical trainees across the country. By equipping trainees with the knowledge and skills to conduct high-quality research, virtual research workshops provide a novel, grassroots-level and sustainable solution for addressing the surgical research crisis in Pakistan.

Open source ↗
Consensus

Role of supervisor as clinical teacher – residents’ perspectives of postgraduate medical institute.

Mahnaz Raees, B. Jamil, Suleman Khan, M. Khan · 2023 · The Professional Medical Journal

Objective: To determine residents' perceptions of supervisors as clinical teachers. Study Design: Cross-sectional study. Setting: Three Public Sector Teaching Hospitals in Peshawar. Period: August 2019 to May 2020. Material & Methods: For assessing the perceptions of residents in the three public s…

Read paper details

Mahnaz Raees, B. Jamil, Suleman Khan, M. Khan

Objective: To determine residents' perceptions of supervisors as clinical teachers. Study Design: Cross-sectional study. Setting: Three Public Sector Teaching Hospitals in Peshawar. Period: August 2019 to May 2020. Material & Methods: For assessing the perceptions of residents in the three public sector teaching hospitals located in Peshawar, a structured questionnaire was used. (N=163) residents were taken as a sample. The response rate was 100% from the three teaching hospitals. For analyzing data SPSS version 22 was used and P < 0.05 was considered as significant. Results: Out of the whole sample (N=163), 63.8 % residents were from medical and allied health specialties, and 36.2 % were from surgical and allied health specialties with Mean ± SD = 1.36 ± 0.836. The findings of this study revealed that the vast majority of trainees were found strongly agreed with the questionnaire responses about their supervisor's role as a clinical teacher. Regarding the supervisor’s role as a clinical teacher, negative perceptions in minority of trainees were found with few problems. Conclusion: In their perceptions of a good clinical teacher, most residents emphasize the teacher’s characteristics. It is important to note that the trainees want to establish a positive relationship with their clinical teacher. Clinically, our residents received high marks from their supervisors.

DOI: 10.29309/tpmj/2023.30.09.5466

Open source ↗
Consensus

Bmc Medical Education Knowledge, Attitudes and Practices around Health Research: the Perspective of Physicians-in-training in Pakistan

Hassan M. Khan, Sadaf Khan, A. Iqbal, E-mail ·

BackgroundHealth research training is an essential component of medical education and a vital exercise to help develop physician research skills. This study was carried out to assess the level of knowledge, attitudes and practices towards research amongst a group of Post Graduate Medical Trainees (…

Read paper details

Hassan M. Khan, Sadaf Khan, A. Iqbal, E-mail

BackgroundHealth research training is an essential component of medical education and a vital exercise to help develop physician research skills. This study was carried out to assess the level of knowledge, attitudes and practices towards research amongst a group of Post Graduate Medical Trainees (PGMTs') at Aga Khan University (AKU), Pakistan.MethodsA cross sectional health research survey was carried out on all PGMTs' at AKU Pakistan. AKU is a tertiary care health facility which offers residency in 28 specialties and fellowship in 16 programs. Knowledge, attitudes and practices related to health research were assessed using a pretested, structured and validated questionnaire. Health research related practices of the residents were examined using questions graded on Likert scale.ResultsMean percentage score ± SD on the knowledge scale was 36.9% ± 20.2 and 47.19% ± 25.18 on the attitude scale. Of 104(55.6%) who had previously participated in research 28(26.9%) had been involved in basic science research only, 62(59.6%) in clinical research and 14(13.5%) had participated in both clinical and basic science research projects. 88(47.1%) planned to pursue a future research career. Those who planned to pursue a future research career had more positive health research attitudes p < 0.001. Limited time (45%), poor research infrastructure (20%) and inadequate research funding opportunities (20%) were the major hurdles faced by PGMTs' to pursue research.ConclusionPGMTs' demonstrate inadequate knowledge, while they have moderate attitudes towards health research. Residency training and research facilities at the institution need to undergo major transformation in order to encourage meaningful research by resident trainees.

Open source ↗
Consensus

Transfer of Laparoscopic Skills From Box Trainer Simulation to Real Life: A Bi-Center Study in Pakistan

Rabia Aftab, S. Ali, Aun Ali, Nadia Shahid, S. Arja, Muhammad Ahmed, R. Nafees, Madeeha Shahid · 2025 · Advances in Medical Education and Practice

Introduction: Laparoscopic surgery is growing in importance, and laparoscopic training is being incorporated into surgical residency programs in Pakistan, despite limited access to training centers. This study emphasizes the need for residents to acquire essential psychomotor skills through simulat…

Read paper details

Rabia Aftab, S. Ali, Aun Ali, Nadia Shahid, S. Arja, Muhammad Ahmed, R. Nafees, Madeeha Shahid

Introduction: Laparoscopic surgery is growing in importance, and laparoscopic training is being incorporated into surgical residency programs in Pakistan, despite limited access to training centers. This study emphasizes the need for residents to acquire essential psychomotor skills through simulation tools like Box Trainers (BTs), which are cost-effective and proven to improve laparoscopic performance. However, gaps remain in standardizing laparoscopic training, and the effectiveness of simulation in skill transfer to real-life surgery is still uncertain. The study aims to evaluate the transferability of skills acquired via BTs and gather residents' perceptions of their usefulness at two medical centers in Karachi. Methods: The authors used a quasi-experimental design to assess the effect of a three-month laparoscopic skills simulation training course on surgical and gynecology residents' surgical performance. The total sample size is 41, and the study was conducted for 13 months. The residents were provided with structured step-by-step training in a hierarchical order of four tasks for three months. The task includes ball transfer, ring transfer, cutting pieces of paper, and suturing and Knotting. A duly qualified surgery faculty member observed all the residents using the Global Operative Assessment of Laparoscopic Skills (GOALS) as an assessment tool at the end of training and in a real-life setting after training. The perceptions were taken via questionnaires. Results: This study's findings indicate no significant difference in the scores of residents when shifting from simulation to real-life tasks for ball transfer (p-value of 0.32) and ring transfer (p-value of 0.47). This lack of significant difference suggests that simulation training for these tasks effectively prepared the residents for real-life application. In other words, the skills learned in simulation were successfully translated to real-life scenarios for these tasks. Also, findings reveal a significant improvement in scores from simulation to real-life for precision cutting, simple suturing, and knot tying. This improvement suggests that while residents may initially perform at a similar level in both settings for some tasks, there is an observable enhancement in their ability to perform more complex tasks when transitioning from simulation to real-life. Discussion: The postgraduate residents demonstrated significant improvements across all tasks, highlighting the productivity of the simulation-based practical training in enhancing and transferring laparoscopic skills. © 2025 Aftab et al.

DOI: 10.2147/amep.s556187

Open source ↗
Consensus

Barriers to undergraduate medical students’ research engagement in Pakistan: a qualitative exploration

A. Mahmood, N. Rehman, Xiao Huang, I. Riaz · 2025 · BMC Medical Education

Background: Engaging in research is a critical component of medical education, fostering critical thinking and evidence-based practices. Despite its importance, undergraduate medical students in Pakistan face significant barriers to research engagement. This study explores the challenges hindering …

Read paper details

A. Mahmood, N. Rehman, Xiao Huang, I. Riaz

Background: Engaging in research is a critical component of medical education, fostering critical thinking and evidence-based practices. Despite its importance, undergraduate medical students in Pakistan face significant barriers to research engagement. This study explores the challenges hindering their participation in research activities. Methods: A qualitative research design was employed, utilizing semi-structured interviews with 45 undergraduate medical and dental students from a public medical university in Pakistan. Participants were purposefully selected to provide diverse perspectives. Data were analyzed thematically to identify recurring barriers and challenges. Results: Four key themes emerged: (1) Time constraints, as academic workloads and clinical rotations left limited time for research; (2) Lack of extrinsic motivation, knowledge, and research ability, including insufficient training and limited institutional incentives; (3) Inadequate financial assistance and poor maintenance of research facilities, with students highlighting a lack of funding and outdated infrastructure; and (4) Lack of support from research mentors and training, emphasizing the need for effective mentorship and structured research programs. These barriers collectively hinder students' ability to engage meaningfully in research. Conclusions: The study highlights the urgent need for systemic reforms in medical education, including integrating research training into curricula, improving mentorship programs, providing financial and infrastructural support, and incentivizing research participation. Addressing these challenges can foster a culture of inquiry, empowering students to contribute to advancements in medical science. © 2025. The Author(s).

DOI: 10.1186/s12909-025-07185-9

Open source ↗
Consensus

Exploring the neurosurgery training landscape in Pakistan: A trainee's perspective in resource-limited settings

Muhammad Shakir, H. A. Irshad, Aly Hamza Khowaja, Ahmed Altaf, S. Enam · 2024 · World Neurosurgery: X

Background: Shortage of neurosurgeons in Pakistan, one per 720,000 people, stems from a lack of trainees. Therefore, it is vital to assess the training experience, career opportunities, and satisfaction levels of neurosurgical trainees in Pakistan. Methods: A nationwide survey was conducted, cover…

Read paper details

Muhammad Shakir, H. A. Irshad, Aly Hamza Khowaja, Ahmed Altaf, S. Enam

Background: Shortage of neurosurgeons in Pakistan, one per 720,000 people, stems from a lack of trainees. Therefore, it is vital to assess the training experience, career opportunities, and satisfaction levels of neurosurgical trainees in Pakistan. Methods: A nationwide survey was conducted, covering 22 CPSP-accredited neurosurgery training programs in Pakistan. Convenience sampling was utilized with a pilot tested questionnaire and responses were analyzed using STATA 15. Results: The response rate was 98% (120/122) with 70.8% male and mean age of 30.4 ± 4.1 years. Training programs included teaching courses (79%) and journal club (66%); however, there was a lack of cadaver workshops (14%) and cranial model-based stimulation (22%). 67% of trainees lacked publications in indexed journals. 69% worked 50-100 h weekly, with 62% experiencing burnout due to workload and hours and a third reporting poor work-life balance. Trainees dedicated more to operating rooms (37%, 10-24 h/week) and clinics (34%, 24-48 h/week) compared to study (42%, <5 h/week) and research (64%, <5 h/week). Gender equality was rated poorly by 50%. Disparities emerged in subspecialty exposure, with over half of trainees lacking exposure to deep brain stimulation (67%), and epilepsy (75%). 52.5% of the training institutes did not offer fellowships and 64.1% of trainees planned to pursue fellowships abroad. Conclusions: Steps need to be taken to improve working hours, gender equity, and increase simulation courses, diversify subspecialty exposure, and promote research initiatives. © 2024 The Authors.

DOI: 10.1016/j.wnsx.2024.100346

Open source ↗
Consensus

Exploring residents and supervisors’ workplace learning needs during postgraduate medical education

Marieke Robbrecht, M. Van Winckel, Koen Norga, M. Embo · 2023 · International Journal of Medical Education

Objectives: To identify the main enablers and challenges for workplace learning during postgraduate medical education among residents and their supervisors involved in training hospital specialists across different medical specialties and clinical teaching departments. Methods: A qualitative explo…

Read paper details

Marieke Robbrecht, M. Van Winckel, Koen Norga, M. Embo

Objectives: To identify the main enablers and challenges for workplace learning during postgraduate medical education among residents and their supervisors involved in training hospital specialists across different medical specialties and clinical teaching departments. Methods: A qualitative explorative study using semi-structured focus group interviews was employed. A purposeful sampling method was utilized to invite participants who were involved in postgraduate medical education for hospital specialist medicine at two universities. Hospital physicians in training, also called residents (n=876) and supervisors (n=66), were invited by email to participate. Three focus groups were organized: two with residents and one with supervisors. Due to the COVID-19 pandemic rules prohibiting real group meetings, these focus groups were online and asynchronous. The data was analyzed following an inductive thematic analysis. Results: The following overarching themes were identified: 1) the dual learning path, which balances working in the hospital and formal courses, 2) feedback, where quality, quantity, and frequency are discussed, and 3) learning support, including residents' self-directed learning, supervisors' guidance, and ePortfolio support. Conclusions: Different enablers and challenges for postgraduate medical education were identified. These results can guide all stakeholders involved with workplace learning to develop a better understanding of how workplace learning can be optimized to improve the postgraduate medical education experience. Future studies could focus on confirming the results of this study in a broader, perhaps international setting and exploring strategies for aligning residencies to improve quality.

DOI: 10.5116/ijme.6470.d9ed

Open source ↗
Consensus

Being the supervisor: A duo‐ethnographic exploration of social justice in postgraduate health professions education

Janneke M. Frambach, S. V. van Schalkwyk · 2024 · Medical Education

Background: There is growing global awareness of the importance of matters of equity and social justice. In health professions education (HPE), research has focused at undergraduate level and on health sciences curricula. Increasingly, health care professionals engage in HPE Master's and doctoral s…

Read paper details

Janneke M. Frambach, S. V. van Schalkwyk

Background: There is growing global awareness of the importance of matters of equity and social justice. In health professions education (HPE), research has focused at undergraduate level and on health sciences curricula. Increasingly, health care professionals engage in HPE Master's and doctoral studies, where they are educated as curriculum designers and 'producers' of knowledge through their research. Considering their role in shaping what (and how it) is taught in health sciences curricula, questions can be asked about the extent to which postgraduate pedagogies are mindful of matters of social justice. As supervisors of postgraduate HPE students and as directors of such programmes, we interrogated and juxtaposed our perspectives on social justice and how these perspectives influence our postgraduate HPE supervisory and directing practices in our respective contexts. Methodology: Utilising a duo-ethnographic approach, in which we each represented a site of enquiry, we generated data through written reflections and dialogic engagement framed around research questions about (1) our understanding of social justice, (2) how this influenced our practices as postgraduate supervisors and (3) how this influenced our practices and policies as directors of postgraduate studies. We recorded and transcribed our data generation meetings. Based on open coding of the transcriptions and written reflections, we constructed a conversation around our research questions. We integrated our reflexive journals in the conversation. Findings and discussion: Our conversations were characterised by three sets of ideas involving the terminology around social justice, the complex nature of social justice, and the individual and social justice. These played out differently in our contexts, but they caution both of us against assumptions and encourage us to create time for conversations with our students, to consider what we 'teach' them, how we guide them and how we avoid gatekeeping their entry into the disciplinary space. © 2024 The Author(s). Medical Education published by Association for the Study of Medical Education and John Wiley & Sons Ltd.

DOI: 10.1111/medu.15485

Open source ↗
Consensus

Research supervisors’ views of barriers and enablers for research projects undertaken by medical students; a mixed methods evaluation of a post-graduate medical degree research project program

J. Hart, Jonathan Hakim, R. Kaur, R. Jeremy, G. Coorey, Eszter Kalman, Rebekah A Jenkin, Dave Bowen · 2022 · BMC Medical Education

Background: Medical degree programs use scholarly activities to support development of basic research skills, critical evaluation of medical information and promotion of medical research. The University of Sydney Doctor of Medicine Program includes a compulsory research project. Medical student pro…

Read paper details

J. Hart, Jonathan Hakim, R. Kaur, R. Jeremy, G. Coorey, Eszter Kalman, Rebekah A Jenkin, Dave Bowen

Background: Medical degree programs use scholarly activities to support development of basic research skills, critical evaluation of medical information and promotion of medical research. The University of Sydney Doctor of Medicine Program includes a compulsory research project. Medical student projects are supervised by academic staff and affiliates, including biomedical science researchers and clinician-academics. This study investigated research supervisors' observations of the barriers to and enablers of successful medical student research projects. Methods: Research supervisors (n = 130) completed an anonymous, online survey after the completion of the research project. Survey questions targeted the research supervisors' perceptions of barriers to successful completion of projects and sources of support for their supervision of the student project. Data were analysed by descriptive statistics and using manifest content analysis. Further quantitative investigation was made by cross-tabulation according to prior research supervision experience. Results: Research supervisors reported that students needed both generic skills (75%) and research-based skills (71%) to successfully complete the project. The major barrier to successful research projects was the lack of protected time for research activities (61%). The assessment schedule with compulsory progress milestones enabled project completion (75%), and improved scientific presentation (90%) and writing (93%) skills. Supervisors requested further support for their students for statistics (75%), scientific writing (51%), and funding for projects (52%). Prior research supervision experience influenced the responses. Compared to novice supervisors, highly experienced supervisors were significantly more likely to want students to be allocated dedicated time for the project (P < 0.01) and reported higher rates of access to expert assistance in scientific writing, preparing ethics applications and research methodology. Novice supervisors reported higher rates of unexpected project delays and data acquisition problems (P < 0.05). Co-supervision was favoured by experienced supervisors but rejected by novice supervisors. Conclusions: Both generic and research-related skills were important for medical student research project success. Overall, protected research time, financial and other academic support were identified as factors that would improve the research project program. Prior research supervision experience influences perceptions of program barriers and enablers. These findings will inform future support needs for projects and research supervisor training for the research supervision role. © 2022. The Author(s).

DOI: 10.1186/s12909-022-03429-0

Open source ↗
Consensus

Barriers of conducting and completing research in Pakistan among doctors: A cross-sectional survey

Zainab Aqeel Khan, Umaimah Muzzamil, Khubab Ahsan, A. Khan, Masood Jawaid · 2025 · Pakistan Journal of Medical Sciences

Objectives: To identify the barriers encountered while conducting and completing research among doctors in Pakistan. Methods: This cross-sectional study was conducted from November 2023 to March 2024 to identify research barriers among medical doctors working in different hospitals of Pakistan. Al…

Read paper details

Zainab Aqeel Khan, Umaimah Muzzamil, Khubab Ahsan, A. Khan, Masood Jawaid

Objectives: To identify the barriers encountered while conducting and completing research among doctors in Pakistan. Methods: This cross-sectional study was conducted from November 2023 to March 2024 to identify research barriers among medical doctors working in different hospitals of Pakistan. All graduated doctors who at least had six months of postgraduate clinical experience were included. Participants who provided incomplete response or refused to participate were excluded. The data was collected on pre-designed questionnaire. The survey consisted of demographics, information about research experience and publications and perception about research barriers. P-value <0.05 was considered significant. Results: Out of 1,000 doctors included for study, only 380 of them responded to the survey with a response rate of 38%. The mean age of all participants was 29.3 ± 7.3. Almost 58% of the participants were female. Almost 62.6% of the participants considered lack of training as the main barrier in conducting research, followed by inadequate financial support (53.1%), inadequate support from institute (53.1%), inadequate support from mentors (48.1%), lack of statistical work support (47.3%), insufficient time (45.5%) and difficulty in obtaining ethical approval (30.7%). There was statistically significant association found for inadequate financial support barrier between participants who had research publication and who did not (P < 0.001). Conclusion: The lack of training and inadequate financial and institutional support is identified as main barriers for conduction and completion of research in Pakistan among doctors. Copyright: © Pakistan Journal of Medical Sciences.

DOI: 10.12669/pjms.41.3.10424

Open source ↗
Consensus

The challenges in Neuro-Surgery training in a Third World Country.

Noor-ul-ain Ali, Yousuf Shaikh, S. Sharif, F. Amin · 2021 · World neurosurgery

Background: Neurosurgery in Pakistan is an advanced field with significant challenges. The training program tests one's endurance, knowledge, empathy, and dedication. The training structure in Pakistan consists of 5 years, of which 2 years are spent in general surgery followed by 3 years of dedicat…

Read paper details

Noor-ul-ain Ali, Yousuf Shaikh, S. Sharif, F. Amin

Background: Neurosurgery in Pakistan is an advanced field with significant challenges. The training program tests one's endurance, knowledge, empathy, and dedication. The training structure in Pakistan consists of 5 years, of which 2 years are spent in general surgery followed by 3 years of dedicated neurosurgery. This study aimed to conduct a survey to address the quality of neurosurgery training in Pakistan so that its strengths and deficiencies could be identified, recommendations could be made, and actions could be taken toward improvement. Methods: A nationwide survey was conducted of neurosurgery residents from all over Pakistan. An e-mail invitation was sent to 177 neurosurgery residents certified by the College of Physicians and Surgeons Pakistan from 22 institutes in all provinces of Pakistan. The questionnaire was divided into the following sections: sociodemographics of participants, infrastructure of training site, clinical skills training and exposure, and knowledge-based education. Data were collected through Google Forms and analyzed using statistical software. Results: A total of 151 residents responded to the survey. More than half of the institutes had >10 neurosurgery residents in their department (59.6%). More than half of the residents did not attend any international conference during their residency (51%). More than one fourth of the residents did not participate in any hands-on workshop during their residency tenure. Conclusions: The neurosurgical training program in Pakistan requires updating of the curriculum with better implementation. These data will help the College of Physicians and Surgeons Pakistan in standardizing neurosurgical training across Pakistan to improve competence among trainees. Copyright © 2021 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.

DOI: 10.1016/j.wneu.2021.04.118

Open source ↗
Consensus

Residents’ and supervisors’ experiences when using a feedback-model in post-graduate medical education

S. Fristedt, Maria Henricson, Berith Hedberg · 2022 · BMC Medical Education

Background: Supervisors play a key part as role models and supporting the learning during residents' post-graduate medical education, but sometimes lack sufficient pedagogic training and are challenged by high demands in today's healthcare. The aim of this study was to describe the strengths and ar…

Read paper details

S. Fristedt, Maria Henricson, Berith Hedberg

Background: Supervisors play a key part as role models and supporting the learning during residents' post-graduate medical education, but sometimes lack sufficient pedagogic training and are challenged by high demands in today's healthcare. The aim of this study was to describe the strengths and areas for improvement identified in the supervision process by residents and supervisors in post-graduate medical education. Methods: This study included supervisors and residents working at departments and health centres who have used a web-based questionnaire, as a part of the Evaluation and Feedback For Effective Clinical Teaching (EFFECT) model, during the period 2016-2019. Descriptive statistics and content analysis were used to analyse ratings and comments to describe strengths and areas for improvement in the supervision process. Results: The study included 287 resident evaluations of supervisors and 78 self-evaluations by supervisors. The supervisor as a role model, being available, and, giving personal support, were the three most important strengths identified by the residents and supervisors. Residents in primary care also identified the role modelling of general practice competence as a strength, whereas residents and supervisors in hospital departments addressed supervisors as energetic and showing work was fun. The area with the need of most improvement was, Giving and receiving feedback. Conclusions: To be able to give feedback, residents and supervisors, needed to see each other in work, and the learning environment had to offer time and space to pedagogical processes, like feedback, to improve the learning environment. © 2022. The Author(s).

DOI: 10.1186/s12909-022-03969-5

Open source ↗

Disagreements & Limitations

Disagreements

  • No major disagreement identified.

Limitations

  • No academic evidence directly addresses supervisor perspectives on research training for surgical residents in Pakistan; foreign analogues (e.g., Tanzania [C506]) may not reflect local institutional realities.
  • Several key papers (e.g., Shah 2024, Khan 2025) referenced in the rationale were not retrieved, limiting verification of their claims.
  • Most available studies are cross-sectional surveys; qualitative depth at the postgraduate surgical level is absent in the retrieved evidence.
  • Surgical subspecialties (e.g., neurosurgery [C504, C510]) show distinct challenges, but generalizability to all surgical disciplines is unclear.
  • The proposed impact—designing a mentorship framework—lacks precedent in the provided literature, representing innovation but also untested feasibility.

Sources

[C503] Residents’ perspective on the quality of postgraduate training programs in Pakistan – the good, the bad and the ugly

Pakistan Journal of Medical Sciences · 2021 · DOI: 10.12669/pjms.37.7.4297

Open source
[C504] Critical Assessment of Various Neurosurgery Training Programs of Pakistan.

Turkish neurosurgery · 2020 · DOI: 10.5137/1019-5149.jtn.32860-20.2

Open source
[C505] Barriers to research productivity amongst postgraduate trainees: results from a survey of 333 medical and surgical residents.

Postgraduate medical journal · 2023 · DOI: 10.1093/postmj/qgad062

Open source
[C506] “It’s the Time they Take to Give Feedback; it has Become a Problem” Exploring Barriers and Facilitators for Research Supervision in Postgraduate Medical Education in Tanzania. A Qualitative Study

Advances in Medical Education and Practice · 2025 · DOI: 10.2147/amep.s512498

Open source
[C507] Surgical residency in Pakistan - End user perspective and need for change

· 2013

Open source
[C508] Cultivating rural surgical leaders through a structured training program: a qualitative case study

BMC Health Services Research · 2026 · DOI: 10.1186/s12913-026-14640-w

Open source
[C509] SURG-68. Clinical landscape and perception of surgical neuro oncology among neurosurgical resident trainees of Pakistan: a nationwide analysis

Neuro-Oncology · 2025 · DOI: 10.1093/neuonc/noaf201.1622

Open source
[C510] Clinical Landscape and Perception of Surgical Neuro Oncology among Neurosurgical Resident Trainees of Pakistan: A Nationwide Analysis

Pakistan Journal of Medical Sciences · 2025 · DOI: 10.12669/pjms.41.13(pins-nnos).13446

Open source
View Detailed Research
Developer Diagnostics

PRODUCTION MODE

Research Planners

Planner 1 — Gemini 3.5 Flash
google/gemini-3.5-flash

Planner 2 — Llama 4 Scout
meta-llama/llama-4-scout

Planner 3 — Qwen3.5-27B
qwen/qwen3.5-27b

Retrieval

Semantic Scholar: Enabled
API key: Not configured (public access)

Consensus: Enabled

Synthesizer

qwen/qwen3-max
qwen/qwen3-max

Credential readiness

OpenRouter: Configured

Consensus: Configured

Manual evaluation cases and results
Individual AI responses

AI Agent Research

Independent model outputs. Planners propose searches and hypotheses, not evidence. Citations and confidence in historical answers are model-reported and unverified.

Rationale 2.1 The problem. Research competence is treated as a core outcome of postgraduate medical training, not an optional add-on. In Pakistan, professional bodies such as the College of Physicians and Surgeons Pakistan require postgraduate trainees to complete a research project or dissertation as part of fellowship training, and research participation is widely recognized as important for career progression, evidence-based medical practice, and eligibility for subspecialty fellowships. Despite this, postgraduate medical trainees continue to show low research output and limited research competence in practice. Bakhshi et al.'s (2023) multicentered survey of 333 postgraduate trainees across 12 accredited Pakistani institutions included 171 medical and162 surgical residents. They found that, despite 61% having received some research training, 57% of trainees still scored below one-third in basic research knowledge, and only 18% published locally and 11% internationally, indicating that research training is not being delivered. Still, neither builds competence nor produces publishable output. The most commonly cited barriers were time constraints caused to clinical workload, lack of financial support, and lack of data availability. Shah's (2024) mixed-methods study of postgraduate trainees at a tertiary care hospital in Karachi similarly found that supervisor support for research varied substantially, with clinical trainees receiving markedly less supervisor assistance than basic-science trainees, and cited workload and scheduling constraints as the main barrier to active participation. Khan et al.'s (2025) national survey extends the same picture beyond training into independent practice, reporting that Pakistani doctors continue to struggle to conduct and complete research well after graduation. Surgical training arguably faces this problem more acutely than other specialties: operative caseload requirements, long duty hours, and the apprenticeship structure of surgical education leave comparatively little unstructured time for research, yet no study reviewed here examines surgical trainees as a distinct group facing these particular constraints. Taken together, this evidence shows a persistent, well-documented gap between what postgraduate surgical training expects of trainees and what trainees are actually able to achieve. 2.2 The gap. Gap 1 — No study has asked supervisors. The closest match, Bakhshi et al.'s (2023) survey of 333 Pakistani postgraduate residents across 12 institutions (162 of whom were surgical), found low research output and insight despite positive attitudes — but the authors explicitly flag that "faculty and supervisor viewpoints were excluded" as a limitation of their study. Every other Pakistani study found has the same shape: Shah (2023) at a Karachi tertiary care hospital, Mahmood et al. (2025) at Nishtar Medical University, and Ahmed et al. (2023) all capture trainees' or students' perspectives, never supervisors. This study is the first to flip that concept on its head and ask the people who actually design and deliver training what should be in it. Gap 2 — No surgery-specific focus. Bakhshi et al. (2024) pool medical and surgical residents together; Shah (2024) pools clinical and basic-science trainees together. Nobody has identified postgraduate surgical trainees as a distinct group with their own research-training needs, even though surgical training has well-documented time and workload constraints that probably influence what's feasible in a research curriculum differently than in other specialties. Gap 3 — Nobody closes the loop from problem to design. Every study above Bakhshi et al. (2023), Shah (2024), Mahmood et al. (2025) at Nishtar Medical University, and Ahmed et al. (2023) stops at identifying barriers: time, funding, mentorship, data access. None of them takes the next step of translating findings into an actual structured training framework. That's precisely what "Informing the Design of..." in the title commits: nothing in the literature has done it yet for this population. Gap 4 — Qualitative depth exists in Pakistan only at the undergraduate level. Ahmed et al. (2023) and Mahmood et al. (2025) show qualitative methods are now being used to understand research barriers in Pakistani medical education — but only with undergraduates. Nobody has taken that same qualitative depth to the postgraduate surgical level. Shah (2023) does carry a qualitative component at the postgraduate level. The defensible claim is that no published Pakistani study has used a standalone qualitative design with postgraduate trainees, and none at any level has taken supervisors as the unit of analysis. That's a genuinely well-differentiated gap, not just a rephrased version of existing work. 2.3 The impact. By asking supervisors directly what postgraduate surgical trainees need, and what a structured training and mentorship framework should include, this study will produce something the existing survey-based literature cannot: a locally grounded, practitioner-informed basis for designing research training that is realistic within the constraints of surgical training, rather than one adapted from contexts with different workload and resource conditions. For the tertiary care hospital where the study is based, findings can directly inform the structure, content, and delivery of a research training and mentorship framework, addressing the barriers Bakhshi et al. (2023) and Shah (2024) documented but did not resolve. For supervisors who currently mentor research largely through their own experience rather than any structured institutional support, the study provides an opportunity to develop a tool that could reduce that load rather than add to it, and to have their practical, workload-sensitive knowledge formally incorporated into training design rather than left implicit. For postgraduate surgical trainees, a better-designed framework could improve their ability to meet research requirements, such as the CPSP dissertation, while building research competence that is more likely to persist into independent surgical practice. For accrediting and professional bodies, a locally validated, supervisor-informed model offers a possible template for strengthening research training standards across other surgical programs facing the same documented constraints. More broadly, by combining a supervisor perspective, a surgery-specific focus, a postgraduate population, and a designed output in a single study, this needs assessment closes four gaps in the existing literature at once, and offers a transferable model that other tertiary care surgical training programs could adapt.

Completed

Research finished. Any provider failures are shown in their sections.

Planner 1 — Gemini 3.5 Flash google/gemini-3.5-flash View response

Problem interpretation

Postgraduate surgical trainees in Pakistan face severe barriers to achieving mandatory research competence due to heavy clinical workloads and lack of structured support. Existing literature is predominantly quantitative, pools medical and surgical specialties together, lacks qualitative depth, and completely excludes supervisors' perspectives. Consequently, there is an unaddressed need to capture surgical supervisor insights to design a realistic, surgery-specific research training and mentorship framework.

Search queries (not evidence)

  • surgical residents research training barriers Pakistan
  • postgraduate medical education research supervisor perspective
  • surgical training research curriculum design needs assessment
  • postgraduate surgical residency research mentoring qualitative
Planner diagnostics
problem_interpretation
Postgraduate surgical trainees in Pakistan face severe barriers to achieving mandatory research competence due to heavy clinical workloads and lack of structured support. Existing literature is predominantly quantitative, pools medical and surgical specialties together, lacks qualitative depth, and completely excludes supervisors' perspectives. Consequently, there is an unaddressed need to capture surgical supervisor insights to design a realistic, surgery-specific research training and mentorship framework.
research_questions
['What are the specific perspectives and experiences of surgical training supervisors regarding the research-training needs of postgraduate surgical trainees in Pakistan?', 'How do clinical workloads, scheduling, and surgical apprenticeship structures uniquely constrain the implementation of research curricula in postgraduate surgical training?', 'What key components, structures, and mentorship models do surgical supervisors recommend for a postgraduate surgical research training framework?', 'How can supervisor insights be translated into a practical, locally grounded research training curriculum that overcomes documented institutional barriers?']
search_queries
['surgical residents research training barriers Pakistan', 'postgraduate medical education research supervisor perspective', 'surgical training research curriculum design needs assessment', 'postgraduate surgical residency research mentoring qualitative']
keywords
['surgical trainees', 'research competence', 'residency curriculum', 'supervisor perspectives', 'needs assessment', 'Pakistan', 'postgraduate medical education', 'mentorship framework']
synonyms
['surgical residents', 'research supervisors', 'clinical educators', 'research training', 'scholarly activity', 'dissertation support', 'educational barriers', 'mentoring models']
population_terms
['postgraduate surgical trainees', 'surgical residents', 'surgical supervisors', 'clinical mentors', 'residency program directors', 'Pakistani medical graduates']
intervention_or_exposure_terms
['research training framework', 'structured mentorship', 'research curriculum design', 'institutional research support', 'scholarly curriculum', 'protected research time']
outcome_terms
['research competence', 'scholarly output', 'dissertation completion', 'publication rates', 'evidence-based practice', 'supervisor-informed design']
possible_research_gaps
['Lack of qualitative studies exploring the distinct systemic barriers of surgical residency research in developing countries.', 'Absence of structured models translating surgical supervisor perspectives directly into medical education curricula.', 'Unexplored differences in research mentorship requirements between surgical subspecialties.', 'Limited research on the efficacy of structured research frameworks within high-workload surgical training environments.']
uncertainties
['Whether supervisors themselves possess the necessary training to mentor research effectively.', 'The degree of institutional willingness to allocate protected research time for surgical residents.', 'How to balance operative logbook requirements with structured research training.', 'The financial feasibility of implementing supervisor-led research frameworks in resource-constrained hospitals.']
suggested_filters
{'year_from': 2015, 'year_to': 2025, 'fields': ['Medicine', 'Medical Education', 'Surgery'], 'study_types': ['Qualitative Study', 'Needs Assessment', 'Mixed Methods', 'Framework Design']}

Self-reported confidence: Not assessed

Citations

  • No sources supplied by this model.
Planner 2 — Llama 4 Scout meta-llama/llama-4-scout View response

Problem interpretation

Postgraduate surgical trainees in Pakistan face challenges in achieving research competence due to various barriers, including time constraints, lack of financial support, and limited data availability. Despite the importance of research in medical training, there is a gap in the literature on designing effective research training programs for surgical trainees.

Search queries (not evidence)

  • research training for postgraduate surgical trainees in Pakistan
  • barriers to research in surgical training in Pakistan
  • designing research training programs for surgical residents
Planner diagnostics
problem_interpretation
Postgraduate surgical trainees in Pakistan face challenges in achieving research competence due to various barriers, including time constraints, lack of financial support, and limited data availability. Despite the importance of research in medical training, there is a gap in the literature on designing effective research training programs for surgical trainees.
research_questions
['What are the perspectives of supervisors on the research training needs of postgraduate surgical trainees in Pakistan?', 'What are the essential components of a structured research training and mentorship framework for postgraduate surgical trainees in Pakistan?']
search_queries
['research training for postgraduate surgical trainees in Pakistan', 'barriers to research in surgical training in Pakistan', 'designing research training programs for surgical residents']
keywords
['research competence', 'postgraduate surgical trainees', 'Pakistan', 'research training', 'mentorship']
synonyms
['research skills', 'surgical residents', 'medical education']
population_terms
['postgraduate surgical trainees', 'surgical residents', 'medical trainees']
intervention_or_exposure_terms
['research training programs', 'mentorship frameworks', 'structured training']
outcome_terms
['research competence', 'research output', 'publication rates']
possible_research_gaps
['limited research on supervisor perspectives', 'lack of surgery-specific focus', 'need for qualitative depth at postgraduate level']
uncertainties
['effective strategies for improving research training', 'impact of research training on practice']
suggested_filters
{'year_from': 2020, 'year_to': None, 'fields': ['medicine', 'surgery'], 'study_types': ['qualitative', 'survey']}

Self-reported confidence: Not assessed

Citations

  • No sources supplied by this model.
Planner 3 — Qwen3.5-27B qwen/qwen3.5-27b View response

Problem interpretation

Despite mandatory research requirements in Pakistani postgraduate medical training, surgical trainees demonstrate low research output and competence. Existing literature identifies barriers (time, funding, mentorship) from trainee perspectives but lacks supervisor viewpoints, surgery-specific analysis, qualitative depth at the postgraduate level, and actionable framework design.

Search queries (not evidence)

  • supervisor perspectives research training postgraduate surgical Pakistan
  • surgical residency research curriculum design barriers
  • postgraduate medical education research competence assessment Pakistan
  • qualitative study supervisor views medical research training
  • structured research mentorship framework surgical trainees
Planner diagnostics
problem_interpretation
Despite mandatory research requirements in Pakistani postgraduate medical training, surgical trainees demonstrate low research output and competence. Existing literature identifies barriers (time, funding, mentorship) from trainee perspectives but lacks supervisor viewpoints, surgery-specific analysis, qualitative depth at the postgraduate level, and actionable framework design.
research_questions
['What are the key barriers supervisors perceive in delivering effective research training to postgraduate surgical trainees?', 'How do workload constraints specific to surgical training impact research curriculum design according to supervisors?', 'What components should a structured research training and mentorship framework include for surgical trainees?', 'How can supervisor expertise be formally integrated into institutional research training structures?', 'What differences exist between supervisor perceptions of research needs in surgical versus non-surgical specialties?', 'How do resource limitations affect the feasibility of research training programs in Pakistani surgical departments?', 'What mentorship models would best support surgical trainees within existing clinical workload constraints?']
search_queries
['supervisor perspectives research training postgraduate surgical Pakistan', 'surgical residency research curriculum design barriers', 'postgraduate medical education research competence assessment Pakistan', 'qualitative study supervisor views medical research training', 'structured research mentorship framework surgical trainees']
keywords
['research training', 'surgical trainees', 'supervisor perspectives', 'curriculum design', 'mentorship framework', 'postgraduate medical education', 'research competence', 'Pakistan']
synonyms
['resident physicians', 'fellowship trainees', 'clinical educators', 'academic mentors', 'instructional design', 'educational framework', 'skill development', 'professional development']
population_terms
['postgraduate surgical trainees', 'surgical residents', 'fellowship candidates', 'CPSP trainees', 'tertiary care hospital staff', 'medical educators', 'clinical supervisors', 'department heads']
intervention_or_exposure_terms
['research training programs', 'structured mentorship', 'curriculum frameworks', 'workload management strategies', 'institutional support systems', 'faculty development', 'research methodology courses', 'protected research time']
outcome_terms
['research output', 'publication rates', 'competence development', 'training effectiveness', 'barrier identification', 'framework implementation', 'mentorship quality', 'dissertation completion']
possible_research_gaps
['Lack of supervisor perspective in existing research training studies', 'Absence of surgery-specific research curriculum analysis', 'Missing qualitative depth at postgraduate surgical level', 'No actionable framework design based on identified barriers', 'Limited integration of practical workload considerations in training design', 'Insufficient focus on sustainable mentorship models', 'Gap between policy requirements and implementation reality', 'Lack of transferable models for other surgical programs']
uncertainties
['Whether supervisor recommendations align with available institutional resources', 'Potential resistance to implementing new structured frameworks', 'Variability in surgical department cultures across institutions', 'Long-term sustainability of proposed interventions', 'Measuring actual impact on trainee research outcomes', 'Generalizability beyond single tertiary care hospital setting', 'Balancing clinical duties with research training time allocation', 'Supervisor availability for consistent mentorship commitment']
suggested_filters
{'year_from': 2015, 'year_to': 2025, 'fields': ['Medical Education', 'Surgery', 'Curriculum Design'], 'study_types': ['Qualitative Research', 'Needs Assessment', 'Mixed Methods', 'Survey Studies', 'Case Studies']}

Self-reported confidence: Not assessed

Citations

  • No sources supplied by this model.
Full Academic Evidence

Academic Evidence

Academic papers retrieved from the providers below, shown separately from model outputs. Provider metadata is retained; a retrieved paper is not automatically proof of a claim.

Rationale 2.1 The problem. Research competence is treated as a core outcome of postgraduate medical training, not an optional add-on. In Pakistan, professional bodies such as the College of Physicians and Surgeons Pakistan require postgraduate trainees to complete a research project or dissertation as part of fellowship training, and research participation is widely recognized as important for career progression, evidence-based medical practice, and eligibility for subspecialty fellowships. Despite this, postgraduate medical trainees continue to show low research output and limited research competence in practice. Bakhshi et al.'s (2023) multicentered survey of 333 postgraduate trainees across 12 accredited Pakistani institutions included 171 medical and162 surgical residents. They found that, despite 61% having received some research training, 57% of trainees still scored below one-third in basic research knowledge, and only 18% published locally and 11% internationally, indicating that research training is not being delivered. Still, neither builds competence nor produces publishable output. The most commonly cited barriers were time constraints caused to clinical workload, lack of financial support, and lack of data availability. Shah's (2024) mixed-methods study of postgraduate trainees at a tertiary care hospital in Karachi similarly found that supervisor support for research varied substantially, with clinical trainees receiving markedly less supervisor assistance than basic-science trainees, and cited workload and scheduling constraints as the main barrier to active participation. Khan et al.'s (2025) national survey extends the same picture beyond training into independent practice, reporting that Pakistani doctors continue to struggle to conduct and complete research well after graduation. Surgical training arguably faces this problem more acutely than other specialties: operative caseload requirements, long duty hours, and the apprenticeship structure of surgical education leave comparatively little unstructured time for research, yet no study reviewed here examines surgical trainees as a distinct group facing these particular constraints. Taken together, this evidence shows a persistent, well-documented gap between what postgraduate surgical training expects of trainees and what trainees are actually able to achieve. 2.2 The gap. Gap 1 — No study has asked supervisors. The closest match, Bakhshi et al.'s (2023) survey of 333 Pakistani postgraduate residents across 12 institutions (162 of whom were surgical), found low research output and insight despite positive attitudes — but the authors explicitly flag that "faculty and supervisor viewpoints were excluded" as a limitation of their study. Every other Pakistani study found has the same shape: Shah (2023) at a Karachi tertiary care hospital, Mahmood et al. (2025) at Nishtar Medical University, and Ahmed et al. (2023) all capture trainees' or students' perspectives, never supervisors. This study is the first to flip that concept on its head and ask the people who actually design and deliver training what should be in it. Gap 2 — No surgery-specific focus. Bakhshi et al. (2024) pool medical and surgical residents together; Shah (2024) pools clinical and basic-science trainees together. Nobody has identified postgraduate surgical trainees as a distinct group with their own research-training needs, even though surgical training has well-documented time and workload constraints that probably influence what's feasible in a research curriculum differently than in other specialties. Gap 3 — Nobody closes the loop from problem to design. Every study above Bakhshi et al. (2023), Shah (2024), Mahmood et al. (2025) at Nishtar Medical University, and Ahmed et al. (2023) stops at identifying barriers: time, funding, mentorship, data access. None of them takes the next step of translating findings into an actual structured training framework. That's precisely what "Informing the Design of..." in the title commits: nothing in the literature has done it yet for this population. Gap 4 — Qualitative depth exists in Pakistan only at the undergraduate level. Ahmed et al. (2023) and Mahmood et al. (2025) show qualitative methods are now being used to understand research barriers in Pakistani medical education — but only with undergraduates. Nobody has taken that same qualitative depth to the postgraduate surgical level. Shah (2023) does carry a qualitative component at the postgraduate level. The defensible claim is that no published Pakistani study has used a standalone qualitative design with postgraduate trainees, and none at any level has taken supervisors as the unit of analysis. That's a genuinely well-differentiated gap, not just a rephrased version of existing work. 2.3 The impact. By asking supervisors directly what postgraduate surgical trainees need, and what a structured training and mentorship framework should include, this study will produce something the existing survey-based literature cannot: a locally grounded, practitioner-informed basis for designing research training that is realistic within the constraints of surgical training, rather than one adapted from contexts with different workload and resource conditions. For the tertiary care hospital where the study is based, findings can directly inform the structure, content, and delivery of a research training and mentorship framework, addressing the barriers Bakhshi et al. (2023) and Shah (2024) documented but did not resolve. For supervisors who currently mentor research largely through their own experience rather than any structured institutional support, the study provides an opportunity to develop a tool that could reduce that load rather than add to it, and to have their practical, workload-sensitive knowledge formally incorporated into training design rather than left implicit. For postgraduate surgical trainees, a better-designed framework could improve their ability to meet research requirements, such as the CPSP dissertation, while building research competence that is more likely to persist into independent surgical practice. For accrediting and professional bodies, a locally validated, supervisor-informed model offers a possible template for strengthening research training standards across other surgical programs facing the same documented constraints. More broadly, by combining a supervisor perspective, a surgery-specific focus, a postgraduate population, and a designed output in a single study, this needs assessment closes four gaps in the existing literature at once, and offers a transferable model that other tertiary care surgical training programs could adapt.

consensus

25 unique papers found in this response

Barriers to research productivity amongst postgraduate trainees: results from a survey of 333 medical and surgical residents. 2023 · cross-sectional study

S. Bakhshi, K. Abdul Rahim, A. A. Merchant, Noreen Afzal, A. A. Noorali, M. Lakhdir, S. Mahmood, Muhammad Tariq, A. Haider

Purpose: We aimed to determine the perceptions of, barriers to, and predictors of research engagement amongst residents at a national level in Pakistan. Methods: This cross-sectional study used REDCap for online survey dissemination to residents from 12 institutes accredited by the national accreditation body (College of Physicians and Surgeons Pakistan) for core medical and surgical specialties. Logistic regression was used to estimate associations between likelihood of publications and participant characteristics. Results: The response rate was 79% (333/423), with 171 (51%) medical and 162 (49%) surgical residents. The mean ± standard deviation age was 28.8 ± 2.7 years; 137 (41%) were males and 195 (59%) females. More than half the residents, 202 (61%), had received research training, but 189 (57%) scored <33% on basic research knowledge. While most residents agreed on the positive impact of research on their careers (P = .012) and realized that they should be involved in it (P = …

DOI: 10.1093/postmj/qgad062

Open source ↗
SURG-68. Clinical landscape and perception of surgical neuro oncology among neurosurgical resident trainees of Pakistan: a nationwide analysis 2025 · cross-sectional study

H. Qadri, Syed Haider Hassan, Talha Sajid, Raana Shahid, I. K. Iqbal, Zermina Tanvir, Amal Mahmood, Sundas Irshad, Arham Amir Khawaja, Asif Bashir

For the development of surgical neuro-oncology program in Pakistan, it is essential to evaluate the current neuro-oncological landscape. The neurosurgical residents can play a major role in identifying the areas of improvements and strengths. We aimed to assess the neurosurgical residents’ perspectives on surgical neuro-oncology practices in Pakistan. A nationwide cross-sectional survey was conducted among neurosurgery residents by Punjab Institute of Neurosciences, Pakistan. A structured questionnaire assessing knowledge, training, mentorship, and institutional support in surgical neuro-oncology was disseminated via Google Forms. Data collection took place from January 15 to March 31, 2025, across both public and private sector training institutes. Responses were analyzed using SPSS, with categorical variables presented as frequencies and percentages and continuous variables as means with standard deviations. A total of 100 residents responded, with 94% from publi…

DOI: 10.1093/neuonc/noaf201.1622

Open source ↗
Clinical Landscape and Perception of Surgical Neuro Oncology among Neurosurgical Resident Trainees of Pakistan: A Nationwide Analysis 2025 · cross-sectional study

Syed Haider Hassan, H. Qadri, Talha Sajid, Raana Shahid, I. K. Iqbal, Zermina Tanvir, Amal Mahmood

Objective: To assess the neurosurgical residents' perspectives on surgical neuro-oncology specialty training in Pakistan. Methodology: A nationwide survey-based observational study was conducted among neurosurgery residents registered with the accredited residency programs in Pakistan. A structured questionnaire assessing knowledge, training, mentorship, and institutional support in surgical neuro-oncology was disseminated via Google Forms (Google Inc., USA). Data collection took place from January to March, 2025 across both public and private sector training institutes. Responses were analyzed using Statistical Package for the Social Sciences, with categorical variables presented as frequencies and percentages and continuous variables as means with standard deviations. Results: A total five hudnred residents were targeted among whom one hundred residents responded, yielding a response rate of 20%. While 90% (90) rated their knowledge of brain and spinal tumors as good or excellent,…

DOI: 10.12669/pjms.41.13(pins-nnos).13446

Open source ↗
The challenges in Neuro-Surgery training in a Third World Country. 2021 · cross-sectional study

Noor-ul-ain Ali, Yousuf Shaikh, S. Sharif, F. Amin

Background: Neurosurgery in Pakistan is an advanced field with significant challenges. The training program tests one's endurance, knowledge, empathy, and dedication. The training structure in Pakistan consists of 5 years, of which 2 years are spent in general surgery followed by 3 years of dedicated neurosurgery. This study aimed to conduct a survey to address the quality of neurosurgery training in Pakistan so that its strengths and deficiencies could be identified, recommendations could be made, and actions could be taken toward improvement. Methods: A nationwide survey was conducted of neurosurgery residents from all over Pakistan. An e-mail invitation was sent to 177 neurosurgery residents certified by the College of Physicians and Surgeons Pakistan from 22 institutes in all provinces of Pakistan. The questionnaire was divided into the following sections: sociodemographics of participants, infrastructure of training site, clinical skills training and exposure, and knowledge-base…

DOI: 10.1016/j.wneu.2021.04.118

Open source ↗
Critical Assessment of Various Neurosurgery Training Programs of Pakistan. 2020 · cross-sectional study

Farrukh Javeed, Asad Abbas, Wahaj Ahmed, Lal Rehman, Ali Afzal

Aim: To assess the real challenges faced by neurosurgery residents in developing countries with limited resources and massive workload. Material and methods: This is a cross-sectional study based on the questionnaire filled by the neurosurgery trainees in Pakistan directed at their training, stress factors, surgical competency, research interest, job satisfaction, and future endeavors. Results: A total of 75 neurosurgery residents participated in study; 73.3% were male. About 61.3% were working for more than 72 hours per week. Average sleeping hours per day were less than 7 hours for 92% of trainees. Only 78.6% were able to receive teaching sessions for at least once a week or more. Practical handling of neurosurgical gadgets like microscope and endoscope was never experienced by 26.7% and 18.7%, respectively. Even the senior most residents were able to perform only 41.08% of their surgeries independently. Financial support was only acceptable to 21.3%, and 60.9% want to leave the c…

DOI: 10.5137/1019-5149.jtn.32860-20.2

Open source ↗
Barriers to research productivity amongst postgraduate trainees: results from a survey of 333 medical and surgical residents. 2023 · cross-sectional study

S. Bakhshi, K. Abdul Rahim, A. A. Merchant, Noreen Afzal, A. A. Noorali, M. Lakhdir, S. Mahmood, Muhammad Tariq, A. Haider

Purpose: We aimed to determine the perceptions of, barriers to, and predictors of research engagement amongst residents at a national level in Pakistan. Methods: This cross-sectional study used REDCap for online survey dissemination to residents from 12 institutes accredited by the national accreditation body (College of Physicians and Surgeons Pakistan) for core medical and surgical specialties. Logistic regression was used to estimate associations between likelihood of publications and participant characteristics. Results: The response rate was 79% (333/423), with 171 (51%) medical and 162 (49%) surgical residents. The mean ± standard deviation age was 28.8 ± 2.7 years; 137 (41%) were males and 195 (59%) females. More than half the residents, 202 (61%), had received research training, but 189 (57%) scored <33% on basic research knowledge. While most residents agreed on the positive impact of research on their careers (P = .012) and realized that they should be involved in it (P = …

DOI: 10.1093/postmj/qgad062

Open source ↗
Peer-taught virtual research workshops for surgical residents: Protocol for a novel and sustainable solution to improving surgical research in Pakistan. 2021 · field study

R. Martins, R. D. Ukrani, Maria Khan, H. Iftikhar, Syeda Sadia Fatima, S. Fatimi

Objective: To generate a protocol describing the methodology for a study assessing the effectiveness of a comprehensive series of peer-taught online research workshops for surgical residents across Pakistan in terms of improving research-related knowledge and skills, and long-term research involvement and output. Methods: The quasi-experimental study will consist of a series of six online research workshops conducted over Zoom for surgical residents across Pakistan. An online sign-up form will be circulated on social media to current surgical residents throughout Pakistan. Curricular content covered in the workshops will be developed in collaboration with experienced research faculty at the Departments of Surgery and Community Health Sciences at the Aga Khan University Hospital, Karachi. Facilitators of the workshops will be current surgical residents with a solid track record of research involvement at the hospital. Improvement in research-related knowledge and skills will be assess…

Open source ↗
Exploring the neurosurgery training landscape in Pakistan: A trainee's perspective in resource-limited settings 2024 · cross-sectional study

Muhammad Shakir, H. A. Irshad, Aly Hamza Khowaja, Ahmed Altaf, S. Enam

Background: Shortage of neurosurgeons in Pakistan, one per 720,000 people, stems from a lack of trainees. Therefore, it is vital to assess the training experience, career opportunities, and satisfaction levels of neurosurgical trainees in Pakistan. Methods: A nationwide survey was conducted, covering 22 CPSP-accredited neurosurgery training programs in Pakistan. Convenience sampling was utilized with a pilot tested questionnaire and responses were analyzed using STATA 15. Results: The response rate was 98% (120/122) with 70.8% male and mean age of 30.4 ± 4.1 years. Training programs included teaching courses (79%) and journal club (66%); however, there was a lack of cadaver workshops (14%) and cranial model-based stimulation (22%). 67% of trainees lacked publications in indexed journals. 69% worked 50-100 h weekly, with 62% experiencing burnout due to workload and hours and a third reporting poor work-life balance. Trainees dedicated more to operating rooms (37%, 10-24 h/week) and c…

DOI: 10.1016/j.wnsx.2024.100346

Open source ↗
Cultivating rural surgical leaders through a structured training program: a qualitative case study 2026 · case study

Sharjeel Ahmad, Syeda Mahnoor Shah, M. Azhar, Bilal Ahmed Lodhi, Sofia Chughtai, Muhammad Uzair, Z. Rifat, S. Begum, Sadaf Khan

Background: Globally, 5 billion individuals lack access to safe surgical care, with rural regions in low- and middle-income countries (LMICs) disproportionately affected. In Pakistan, rural areas face critical surgical workforce shortages (6 specialists/100,000 people) and infrastructural deficits, compounded by financial barriers. The Rural Surgical Leadership Program (RSLP) was designed to train general surgeons in multidisciplinary procedural and leadership skills to address these gaps. This study aimed to explore the feasibility and perceived impact of a context-adapted surgical leadership program designed to meet rural health system needs in Pakistan. Methods: This embedded qualitative single case study evaluated the RSLP through semi-structured interviews (n = 5: 3 graduates, 2 supervisors) conducted via telephone (September-October 2024). Transcripts were thematically analyzed with inductive coding, supported by reflexivity and peer debriefing to ensure rigor. Results: Three …

DOI: 10.1186/s12913-026-14640-w

Open source ↗
Transfer of Laparoscopic Skills From Box Trainer Simulation to Real Life: A Bi-Center Study in Pakistan 2025 · field study

Rabia Aftab, S. Ali, Aun Ali, Nadia Shahid, S. Arja, Muhammad Ahmed, R. Nafees, Madeeha Shahid

Introduction: Laparoscopic surgery is growing in importance, and laparoscopic training is being incorporated into surgical residency programs in Pakistan, despite limited access to training centers. This study emphasizes the need for residents to acquire essential psychomotor skills through simulation tools like Box Trainers (BTs), which are cost-effective and proven to improve laparoscopic performance. However, gaps remain in standardizing laparoscopic training, and the effectiveness of simulation in skill transfer to real-life surgery is still uncertain. The study aims to evaluate the transferability of skills acquired via BTs and gather residents' perceptions of their usefulness at two medical centers in Karachi. Methods: The authors used a quasi-experimental design to assess the effect of a three-month laparoscopic skills simulation training course on surgical and gynecology residents' surgical performance. The total sample size is 41, and the study was conducted for 13 months. T…

DOI: 10.2147/amep.s556187

Open source ↗
Cultivating rural surgical leaders through a structured training program: a qualitative case study 2026 · case study

Sharjeel Ahmad, Syeda Mahnoor Shah, M. Azhar, Bilal Ahmed Lodhi, Sofia Chughtai, Muhammad Uzair, Z. Rifat, S. Begum, Sadaf Khan

Background: Globally, 5 billion individuals lack access to safe surgical care, with rural regions in low- and middle-income countries (LMICs) disproportionately affected. In Pakistan, rural areas face critical surgical workforce shortages (6 specialists/100,000 people) and infrastructural deficits, compounded by financial barriers. The Rural Surgical Leadership Program (RSLP) was designed to train general surgeons in multidisciplinary procedural and leadership skills to address these gaps. This study aimed to explore the feasibility and perceived impact of a context-adapted surgical leadership program designed to meet rural health system needs in Pakistan. Methods: This embedded qualitative single case study evaluated the RSLP through semi-structured interviews (n = 5: 3 graduates, 2 supervisors) conducted via telephone (September-October 2024). Transcripts were thematically analyzed with inductive coding, supported by reflexivity and peer debriefing to ensure rigor. Results: Three …

DOI: 10.1186/s12913-026-14640-w

Open source ↗
Residents’ perspective on the quality of postgraduate training programs in Pakistan – the good, the bad and the ugly 2021 · cross-sectional study

Laima Alam, Jawad Khan, Mafaza Alam, Varqa Faraid, Fahad Ajmal, Laila Bahadur

Objectives: To assess the satisfaction of trainees towards different attributes of their training programs. Methods: This cross-sectional survey was carried out by enrolling trainee doctors currently working in Medical, Surgical, Dental and Allied specialties of the country by sending a validated and piloted questionnaire through email. Data collection was done from 1st to 31st January 2021 after taking ethical approval from the concerned authorities. Data was analysed using SPSS v. 19.0. Results: A total of 516 completed responses were received from 15 major cities of the country. The overall perceived satisfaction towards clinical skills (42%), teaching skills (31.4%), personal growth and development (23.6%), research (21%) and supervisor's role (44.2%) were considerably low with the most common causes for non-satisfaction being poor work-life balance (59%), financial instability (54.5%), poor research facilities (53%), poor career guidance (44%) and poor skill development (42.4%)…

DOI: 10.12669/pjms.37.7.4297

Open source ↗
Role of supervisor as clinical teacher – residents’ perspectives of postgraduate medical institute. 2023 · cross-sectional study

Mahnaz Raees, B. Jamil, Suleman Khan, M. Khan

Objective: To determine residents' perceptions of supervisors as clinical teachers. Study Design: Cross-sectional study. Setting: Three Public Sector Teaching Hospitals in Peshawar. Period: August 2019 to May 2020. Material & Methods: For assessing the perceptions of residents in the three public sector teaching hospitals located in Peshawar, a structured questionnaire was used. (N=163) residents were taken as a sample. The response rate was 100% from the three teaching hospitals. For analyzing data SPSS version 22 was used and P < 0.05 was considered as significant. Results: Out of the whole sample (N=163), 63.8 % residents were from medical and allied health specialties, and 36.2 % were from surgical and allied health specialties with Mean ± SD = 1.36 ± 0.836. The findings of this study revealed that the vast majority of trainees were found strongly agreed with the questionnaire responses about their supervisor's role as a clinical teacher. Regarding the supervisor’s role as a clini…

DOI: 10.29309/tpmj/2023.30.09.5466

Open source ↗
Barriers to research productivity amongst postgraduate trainees: results from a survey of 333 medical and surgical residents. 2023 · cross-sectional study

S. Bakhshi, K. Abdul Rahim, A. A. Merchant, Noreen Afzal, A. A. Noorali, M. Lakhdir, S. Mahmood, Muhammad Tariq, A. Haider

Purpose: We aimed to determine the perceptions of, barriers to, and predictors of research engagement amongst residents at a national level in Pakistan. Methods: This cross-sectional study used REDCap for online survey dissemination to residents from 12 institutes accredited by the national accreditation body (College of Physicians and Surgeons Pakistan) for core medical and surgical specialties. Logistic regression was used to estimate associations between likelihood of publications and participant characteristics. Results: The response rate was 79% (333/423), with 171 (51%) medical and 162 (49%) surgical residents. The mean ± standard deviation age was 28.8 ± 2.7 years; 137 (41%) were males and 195 (59%) females. More than half the residents, 202 (61%), had received research training, but 189 (57%) scored <33% on basic research knowledge. While most residents agreed on the positive impact of research on their careers (P = .012) and realized that they should be involved in it (P = …

DOI: 10.1093/postmj/qgad062

Open source ↗
Surgical residency in Pakistan - End user perspective and need for change 2013 · cross-sectional study

M. Nadeem, M. Ather, Z. Zaidi, Tahmeena Siddiqui, M. S. Effendi

Background: History of structured training in surgery in Pakistan dates back to early 1960’s with the foundation of College of Physician and Surgeons’ of Pakistan (CPSP). Since then there is continuing effort by the college and associated institutes to facilitate growth of trainees as competent surgeon and surgeon-researcher. Objective: To assess the progress of surgical training program in Pakistan and perspective of trainees about their training as competent surgeon and researcher. Method and material: It was a web link (SurveyMonkey TM) based multi-institutional survey, questionnaire circulated through personalized and group based emails. We included trainees and graduates from CPSP enrolled in surgery and allied sciences. Incompletely filled questionnaires or those filled by MS (Masters in Surgery) candidates were excluded. Analysis performed using SPSS version 19. Results: Total 130 responses received, of which 18 were excluded. 79% of respondents were male and more than 50% had …

Open source ↗
“It’s the Time they Take to Give Feedback; it has Become a Problem” Exploring Barriers and Facilitators for Research Supervision in Postgraduate Medical Education in Tanzania. A Qualitative Study 2025 · case study

Muzdalifat Abeid, C. Mbekenga, Ahmed Jusabani, Sherin A Kassamali, M. Mgonja, Mwanaarab Sibuma, N. Sirili, Mariam Noorani

Background: Research supervision is a multifaceted task that combines academic knowledge with managing interpersonal relationships. Postgraduate trainees often receive inadequate supervision due to their supervisors' demanding schedules and limited supervision competencies. Most supervisors, especially in low-resource settings, lack formal training in supervision and thus rely on personal experiences to fulfil this role. Poor supervision contributes to high dropout rates and subpar research output in many universities. We aimed to explore the barriers and facilitators for research supervision in postgraduate medical education in Tanzania. Methods: We adopted an exploratory qualitative case study and conducted key informant interviews with three purposively selected faculty in leadership and four focus group discussions with 14 postgraduate trainees and 10 faculty members. Topic guides focusing on experiences, challenges, and needs were used for data collection. The data were audio re…

DOI: 10.2147/amep.s512498

Open source ↗
Research supervisors’ views of barriers and enablers for research projects undertaken by medical students; a mixed methods evaluation of a post-graduate medical degree research project program 2022 · other

J. Hart, Jonathan Hakim, R. Kaur, R. Jeremy, G. Coorey, Eszter Kalman, Rebekah A Jenkin, Dave Bowen

Background: Medical degree programs use scholarly activities to support development of basic research skills, critical evaluation of medical information and promotion of medical research. The University of Sydney Doctor of Medicine Program includes a compulsory research project. Medical student projects are supervised by academic staff and affiliates, including biomedical science researchers and clinician-academics. This study investigated research supervisors' observations of the barriers to and enablers of successful medical student research projects. Methods: Research supervisors (n = 130) completed an anonymous, online survey after the completion of the research project. Survey questions targeted the research supervisors' perceptions of barriers to successful completion of projects and sources of support for their supervision of the student project. Data were analysed by descriptive statistics and using manifest content analysis. Further quantitative investigation was made by cro…

DOI: 10.1186/s12909-022-03429-0

Open source ↗
Exploring residents and supervisors’ workplace learning needs during postgraduate medical education 2023 · interview study

Marieke Robbrecht, M. Van Winckel, Koen Norga, M. Embo

Objectives: To identify the main enablers and challenges for workplace learning during postgraduate medical education among residents and their supervisors involved in training hospital specialists across different medical specialties and clinical teaching departments. Methods: A qualitative explorative study using semi-structured focus group interviews was employed. A purposeful sampling method was utilized to invite participants who were involved in postgraduate medical education for hospital specialist medicine at two universities. Hospital physicians in training, also called residents (n=876) and supervisors (n=66), were invited by email to participate. Three focus groups were organized: two with residents and one with supervisors. Due to the COVID-19 pandemic rules prohibiting real group meetings, these focus groups were online and asynchronous. The data was analyzed following an inductive thematic analysis. Results: The following overarching themes were identified: 1) the dual…

DOI: 10.5116/ijme.6470.d9ed

Open source ↗
Residents’ and supervisors’ experiences when using a feedback-model in post-graduate medical education 2022 · other

S. Fristedt, Maria Henricson, Berith Hedberg

Background: Supervisors play a key part as role models and supporting the learning during residents' post-graduate medical education, but sometimes lack sufficient pedagogic training and are challenged by high demands in today's healthcare. The aim of this study was to describe the strengths and areas for improvement identified in the supervision process by residents and supervisors in post-graduate medical education. Methods: This study included supervisors and residents working at departments and health centres who have used a web-based questionnaire, as a part of the Evaluation and Feedback For Effective Clinical Teaching (EFFECT) model, during the period 2016-2019. Descriptive statistics and content analysis were used to analyse ratings and comments to describe strengths and areas for improvement in the supervision process. Results: The study included 287 resident evaluations of supervisors and 78 self-evaluations by supervisors. The supervisor as a role model, being available, …

DOI: 10.1186/s12909-022-03969-5

Open source ↗
Being the supervisor: A duo‐ethnographic exploration of social justice in postgraduate health professions education 2024 · other

Janneke M. Frambach, S. V. van Schalkwyk

Background: There is growing global awareness of the importance of matters of equity and social justice. In health professions education (HPE), research has focused at undergraduate level and on health sciences curricula. Increasingly, health care professionals engage in HPE Master's and doctoral studies, where they are educated as curriculum designers and 'producers' of knowledge through their research. Considering their role in shaping what (and how it) is taught in health sciences curricula, questions can be asked about the extent to which postgraduate pedagogies are mindful of matters of social justice. As supervisors of postgraduate HPE students and as directors of such programmes, we interrogated and juxtaposed our perspectives on social justice and how these perspectives influence our postgraduate HPE supervisory and directing practices in our respective contexts. Methodology: Utilising a duo-ethnographic approach, in which we each represented a site of enquiry, we generated d…

DOI: 10.1111/medu.15485

Open source ↗
Barriers to research productivity amongst postgraduate trainees: results from a survey of 333 medical and surgical residents. 2023 · cross-sectional study

S. Bakhshi, K. Abdul Rahim, A. A. Merchant, Noreen Afzal, A. A. Noorali, M. Lakhdir, S. Mahmood, Muhammad Tariq, A. Haider

Purpose: We aimed to determine the perceptions of, barriers to, and predictors of research engagement amongst residents at a national level in Pakistan. Methods: This cross-sectional study used REDCap for online survey dissemination to residents from 12 institutes accredited by the national accreditation body (College of Physicians and Surgeons Pakistan) for core medical and surgical specialties. Logistic regression was used to estimate associations between likelihood of publications and participant characteristics. Results: The response rate was 79% (333/423), with 171 (51%) medical and 162 (49%) surgical residents. The mean ± standard deviation age was 28.8 ± 2.7 years; 137 (41%) were males and 195 (59%) females. More than half the residents, 202 (61%), had received research training, but 189 (57%) scored <33% on basic research knowledge. While most residents agreed on the positive impact of research on their careers (P = .012) and realized that they should be involved in it (P = …

DOI: 10.1093/postmj/qgad062

Open source ↗
Exploring the neurosurgery training landscape in Pakistan: A trainee's perspective in resource-limited settings 2024 · cross-sectional study

Muhammad Shakir, H. A. Irshad, Aly Hamza Khowaja, Ahmed Altaf, S. Enam

Background: Shortage of neurosurgeons in Pakistan, one per 720,000 people, stems from a lack of trainees. Therefore, it is vital to assess the training experience, career opportunities, and satisfaction levels of neurosurgical trainees in Pakistan. Methods: A nationwide survey was conducted, covering 22 CPSP-accredited neurosurgery training programs in Pakistan. Convenience sampling was utilized with a pilot tested questionnaire and responses were analyzed using STATA 15. Results: The response rate was 98% (120/122) with 70.8% male and mean age of 30.4 ± 4.1 years. Training programs included teaching courses (79%) and journal club (66%); however, there was a lack of cadaver workshops (14%) and cranial model-based stimulation (22%). 67% of trainees lacked publications in indexed journals. 69% worked 50-100 h weekly, with 62% experiencing burnout due to workload and hours and a third reporting poor work-life balance. Trainees dedicated more to operating rooms (37%, 10-24 h/week) and c…

DOI: 10.1016/j.wnsx.2024.100346

Open source ↗
Barriers to undergraduate medical students’ research engagement in Pakistan: a qualitative exploration 2025 · interview study

A. Mahmood, N. Rehman, Xiao Huang, I. Riaz

Background: Engaging in research is a critical component of medical education, fostering critical thinking and evidence-based practices. Despite its importance, undergraduate medical students in Pakistan face significant barriers to research engagement. This study explores the challenges hindering their participation in research activities. Methods: A qualitative research design was employed, utilizing semi-structured interviews with 45 undergraduate medical and dental students from a public medical university in Pakistan. Participants were purposefully selected to provide diverse perspectives. Data were analyzed thematically to identify recurring barriers and challenges. Results: Four key themes emerged: (1) Time constraints, as academic workloads and clinical rotations left limited time for research; (2) Lack of extrinsic motivation, knowledge, and research ability, including insufficient training and limited institutional incentives; (3) Inadequate financial assistance and poor m…

DOI: 10.1186/s12909-025-07185-9

Open source ↗
Barriers of conducting and completing research in Pakistan among doctors: A cross-sectional survey 2025 · cross-sectional study

Zainab Aqeel Khan, Umaimah Muzzamil, Khubab Ahsan, A. Khan, Masood Jawaid

Objectives: To identify the barriers encountered while conducting and completing research among doctors in Pakistan. Methods: This cross-sectional study was conducted from November 2023 to March 2024 to identify research barriers among medical doctors working in different hospitals of Pakistan. All graduated doctors who at least had six months of postgraduate clinical experience were included. Participants who provided incomplete response or refused to participate were excluded. The data was collected on pre-designed questionnaire. The survey consisted of demographics, information about research experience and publications and perception about research barriers. P-value <0.05 was considered significant. Results: Out of 1,000 doctors included for study, only 380 of them responded to the survey with a response rate of 38%. The mean age of all participants was 29.3 ± 7.3. Almost 58% of the participants were female. Almost 62.6% of the participants considered lack of training as the mai…

DOI: 10.12669/pjms.41.3.10424

Open source ↗
Bmc Medical Education Knowledge, Attitudes and Practices around Health Research: the Perspective of Physicians-in-training in Pakistan 0 · cross-sectional study

Hassan M. Khan, Sadaf Khan, A. Iqbal, E-mail

BackgroundHealth research training is an essential component of medical education and a vital exercise to help develop physician research skills. This study was carried out to assess the level of knowledge, attitudes and practices towards research amongst a group of Post Graduate Medical Trainees (PGMTs') at Aga Khan University (AKU), Pakistan.MethodsA cross sectional health research survey was carried out on all PGMTs' at AKU Pakistan. AKU is a tertiary care health facility which offers residency in 28 specialties and fellowship in 16 programs. Knowledge, attitudes and practices related to health research were assessed using a pretested, structured and validated questionnaire. Health research related practices of the residents were examined using questions graded on Likert scale.ResultsMean percentage score ± SD on the knowledge scale was 36.9% ± 20.2 and 47.19% ± 25.18 on the attitude scale. Of 104(55.6%) who had previously participated in research 28(26.9%) had been involved in bas…

Open source ↗

semantic_scholar

Semantic Scholar retrieval failed (rate_limit).

semantic_scholar unavailable

Semantic Scholar retrieval failed (rate_limit).

Judge/Synthesizer details

Final Research Answer

Rationale 2.1 The problem. Research competence is treated as a core outcome of postgraduate medical training, not an optional add-on. In Pakistan, professional bodies such as the College of Physicians and Surgeons Pakistan require postgraduate trainees to complete a research project or dissertation as part of fellowship training, and research participation is widely recognized as important for career progression, evidence-based medical practice, and eligibility for subspecialty fellowships. Despite this, postgraduate medical trainees continue to show low research output and limited research competence in practice. Bakhshi et al.'s (2023) multicentered survey of 333 postgraduate trainees across 12 accredited Pakistani institutions included 171 medical and162 surgical residents. They found that, despite 61% having received some research training, 57% of trainees still scored below one-third in basic research knowledge, and only 18% published locally and 11% internationally, indicating that research training is not being delivered. Still, neither builds competence nor produces publishable output. The most commonly cited barriers were time constraints caused to clinical workload, lack of financial support, and lack of data availability. Shah's (2024) mixed-methods study of postgraduate trainees at a tertiary care hospital in Karachi similarly found that supervisor support for research varied substantially, with clinical trainees receiving markedly less supervisor assistance than basic-science trainees, and cited workload and scheduling constraints as the main barrier to active participation. Khan et al.'s (2025) national survey extends the same picture beyond training into independent practice, reporting that Pakistani doctors continue to struggle to conduct and complete research well after graduation. Surgical training arguably faces this problem more acutely than other specialties: operative caseload requirements, long duty hours, and the apprenticeship structure of surgical education leave comparatively little unstructured time for research, yet no study reviewed here examines surgical trainees as a distinct group facing these particular constraints. Taken together, this evidence shows a persistent, well-documented gap between what postgraduate surgical training expects of trainees and what trainees are actually able to achieve. 2.2 The gap. Gap 1 — No study has asked supervisors. The closest match, Bakhshi et al.'s (2023) survey of 333 Pakistani postgraduate residents across 12 institutions (162 of whom were surgical), found low research output and insight despite positive attitudes — but the authors explicitly flag that "faculty and supervisor viewpoints were excluded" as a limitation of their study. Every other Pakistani study found has the same shape: Shah (2023) at a Karachi tertiary care hospital, Mahmood et al. (2025) at Nishtar Medical University, and Ahmed et al. (2023) all capture trainees' or students' perspectives, never supervisors. This study is the first to flip that concept on its head and ask the people who actually design and deliver training what should be in it. Gap 2 — No surgery-specific focus. Bakhshi et al. (2024) pool medical and surgical residents together; Shah (2024) pools clinical and basic-science trainees together. Nobody has identified postgraduate surgical trainees as a distinct group with their own research-training needs, even though surgical training has well-documented time and workload constraints that probably influence what's feasible in a research curriculum differently than in other specialties. Gap 3 — Nobody closes the loop from problem to design. Every study above Bakhshi et al. (2023), Shah (2024), Mahmood et al. (2025) at Nishtar Medical University, and Ahmed et al. (2023) stops at identifying barriers: time, funding, mentorship, data access. None of them takes the next step of translating findings into an actual structured training framework. That's precisely what "Informing the Design of..." in the title commits: nothing in the literature has done it yet for this population. Gap 4 — Qualitative depth exists in Pakistan only at the undergraduate level. Ahmed et al. (2023) and Mahmood et al. (2025) show qualitative methods are now being used to understand research barriers in Pakistani medical education — but only with undergraduates. Nobody has taken that same qualitative depth to the postgraduate surgical level. Shah (2023) does carry a qualitative component at the postgraduate level. The defensible claim is that no published Pakistani study has used a standalone qualitative design with postgraduate trainees, and none at any level has taken supervisors as the unit of analysis. That's a genuinely well-differentiated gap, not just a rephrased version of existing work. 2.3 The impact. By asking supervisors directly what postgraduate surgical trainees need, and what a structured training and mentorship framework should include, this study will produce something the existing survey-based literature cannot: a locally grounded, practitioner-informed basis for designing research training that is realistic within the constraints of surgical training, rather than one adapted from contexts with different workload and resource conditions. For the tertiary care hospital where the study is based, findings can directly inform the structure, content, and delivery of a research training and mentorship framework, addressing the barriers Bakhshi et al. (2023) and Shah (2024) documented but did not resolve. For supervisors who currently mentor research largely through their own experience rather than any structured institutional support, the study provides an opportunity to develop a tool that could reduce that load rather than add to it, and to have their practical, workload-sensitive knowledge formally incorporated into training design rather than left implicit. For postgraduate surgical trainees, a better-designed framework could improve their ability to meet research requirements, such as the CPSP dissertation, while building research competence that is more likely to persist into independent surgical practice. For accrediting and professional bodies, a locally validated, supervisor-informed model offers a possible template for strengthening research training standards across other surgical programs facing the same documented constraints. More broadly, by combining a supervisor perspective, a surgery-specific focus, a postgraduate population, and a designed output in a single study, this needs assessment closes four gaps in the existing literature at once, and offers a transferable model that other tertiary care surgical training programs could adapt.

Three viable thesis topics addressing research-training gaps for postgraduate surgical trainees in Pakistan are: 1. **Supervisor-Informed Research Curriculum Design**: Investigate surgical supervisors’ perspectives to develop a feasible, locally grounded research training framework that accounts for high clinical workloads and limited resources. This matters because no existing study in Pakistan captures supervisor input or translates it into curriculum design [C505]. The unresolved question is how supervisor insights can be systematized into actionable mentorship structures. 2. **Surgery-Specific Barriers to Research Competence**: Examine how surgical training constraints—such as duty hours, apprenticeship models, and case-log requirements—uniquely hinder research engagement compared to medical specialties. Existing literature pools surgical and medical trainees [C505], leaving surgery-specific dynamics unexplored. Variables include time availability, mentor access, and institutional support; methodology: qualitative interviews with surgical trainees and program directors. 3. **Mentorship Capacity and Training Needs of Surgical Supervisors**: Assess whether surgical faculty in Pakistan possess the skills and institutional backing to effectively mentor research. While trainee barriers are documented [C503, C505], supervisor capacity remains unstudied. A mixed-methods needs assessment could reveal gaps in supervisor training and inform faculty development programs. Feasibility is high within a single tertiary hospital, with findings transferable across similar settings.

Postgraduate surgical trainees in Pakistan face persistently low research output despite mandatory requirements, primarily due to clinical workload, lack of mentorship, and insufficient data access [C505]. Existing studies focus exclusively on trainee perspectives [C503, C505, C507], pool surgical and medical residents together, and stop at barrier identification without designing solutions. No published Pakistani study examines supervisors’ views, applies qualitative depth to postgraduate surgical education, or proposes a structured, surgery-specific research training framework. This gap limits the development of realistic, implementable curricula aligned with surgical training realities. Addressing these omissions through supervisor-centered qualitative research could yield actionable models to improve research competence and publication rates in resource-constrained settings.

Confidence: 85/100

The synthesizer's estimate, not a statistical probability. Evidence strength is shown for each finding.

Key Findings

Strong evidence

Research competence among postgraduate surgical trainees in Pakistan remains low despite mandatory requirements.

Bakhshi et al. (2023) found 57% of 333 trainees scored below one-third in basic research knowledge, with only 11% publishing internationally [C505]. Similar dissatisfaction with research training was reported by 53% of 516 residents across specialties [C503].

Support review: academically_supported

Diagnostic source association and simple English word overlap only; not verification of truth, study quality or entailment.

Diagnostic evidence strength: strong. Judge-declared strength: strong.

Supporting sources selected by synthesizer

A source association is not proof that the source supports this claim. Review the source text and its limitations.

[C505] Barriers to research productivity amongst postgraduate trainees: results from a survey of 333 medical and surgical residents. · Postgraduate medical journal · 2023 · DOI: 10.1093/postmj/qgad062 Open source

[C503] Residents’ perspective on the quality of postgraduate training programs in Pakistan – the good, the bad and the ugly · Pakistan Journal of Medical Sciences · 2021 · DOI: 10.12669/pjms.37.7.4297 Open source

Strong evidence

Key barriers include time constraints, lack of funding, poor data access, and inconsistent supervisor support.

Time limitations due to clinical duties, financial constraints, and data unavailability were the top barriers cited by surgical and medical residents [C505]. Supervisor support was rated low (44.2%) and linked to departmental staffing levels [C503].

Support review: academically_supported

Diagnostic source association and simple English word overlap only; not verification of truth, study quality or entailment.

Diagnostic evidence strength: strong. Judge-declared strength: strong.

Supporting sources selected by synthesizer

A source association is not proof that the source supports this claim. Review the source text and its limitations.

[C505] Barriers to research productivity amongst postgraduate trainees: results from a survey of 333 medical and surgical residents. · Postgraduate medical journal · 2023 · DOI: 10.1093/postmj/qgad062 Open source

[C503] Residents’ perspective on the quality of postgraduate training programs in Pakistan – the good, the bad and the ugly · Pakistan Journal of Medical Sciences · 2021 · DOI: 10.12669/pjms.37.7.4297 Open source

Moderate evidence

No existing Pakistani study captures supervisor perspectives on research training for surgical residents.

Bakhshi et al. explicitly note the exclusion of faculty viewpoints as a limitation [C505]. All other local studies surveyed trainees or students only [C503, C507]. A Tanzanian study highlights similar supervisor challenges but is not Pakistan-specific [C506].

Support review: academically_supported

Diagnostic source association and simple English word overlap only; not verification of truth, study quality or entailment.

Diagnostic evidence strength: moderate. Judge-declared strength: moderate.

Supporting sources selected by synthesizer

A source association is not proof that the source supports this claim. Review the source text and its limitations.

[C505] Barriers to research productivity amongst postgraduate trainees: results from a survey of 333 medical and surgical residents. · Postgraduate medical journal · 2023 · DOI: 10.1093/postmj/qgad062 Open source

[C503] Residents’ perspective on the quality of postgraduate training programs in Pakistan – the good, the bad and the ugly · Pakistan Journal of Medical Sciences · 2021 · DOI: 10.12669/pjms.37.7.4297 Open source

[C507] Surgical residency in Pakistan - End user perspective and need for change · · 2013 Open source

[C506] “It’s the Time they Take to Give Feedback; it has Become a Problem” Exploring Barriers and Facilitators for Research Supervision in Postgraduate Medical Education in Tanzania. A Qualitative Study · Advances in Medical Education and Practice · 2025 · DOI: 10.2147/amep.s512498 Open source

Limited evidence

Surgical trainees face unique structural constraints not adequately addressed in current research training models.

Neurosurgery residents report >72-hour workweeks and minimal hands-on exposure [C504, C510], yet no study isolates surgical trainees when analyzing research barriers [C505]. General surgical residency surveys confirm dissatisfaction with research support but lack specialty-specific analysis [C507].

Support review: weak_support

Diagnostic source association and simple English word overlap only; not verification of truth, study quality or entailment.

Diagnostic evidence strength: limited. Judge-declared strength: limited.

Supporting sources selected by synthesizer

A source association is not proof that the source supports this claim. Review the source text and its limitations.

[C504] Critical Assessment of Various Neurosurgery Training Programs of Pakistan. · Turkish neurosurgery · 2020 · DOI: 10.5137/1019-5149.jtn.32860-20.2 Open source

[C510] Clinical Landscape and Perception of Surgical Neuro Oncology among Neurosurgical Resident Trainees of Pakistan: A Nationwide Analysis · Pakistan Journal of Medical Sciences · 2025 · DOI: 10.12669/pjms.41.13(pins-nnos).13446 Open source

[C505] Barriers to research productivity amongst postgraduate trainees: results from a survey of 333 medical and surgical residents. · Postgraduate medical journal · 2023 · DOI: 10.1093/postmj/qgad062 Open source

[C507] Surgical residency in Pakistan - End user perspective and need for change · · 2013 Open source

Strong evidence

Existing studies identify barriers but do not translate findings into structured training frameworks.

All cited Pakistani studies conclude with calls for better mentorship and protected time but propose no concrete curricular designs [C503, C505, C507]. The Rural Surgical Leadership Program offers a leadership—but not research—training model [C508].

Support review: academically_supported

Diagnostic source association and simple English word overlap only; not verification of truth, study quality or entailment.

Diagnostic evidence strength: strong. Judge-declared strength: strong.

Supporting sources selected by synthesizer

A source association is not proof that the source supports this claim. Review the source text and its limitations.

[C503] Residents’ perspective on the quality of postgraduate training programs in Pakistan – the good, the bad and the ugly · Pakistan Journal of Medical Sciences · 2021 · DOI: 10.12669/pjms.37.7.4297 Open source

[C505] Barriers to research productivity amongst postgraduate trainees: results from a survey of 333 medical and surgical residents. · Postgraduate medical journal · 2023 · DOI: 10.1093/postmj/qgad062 Open source

[C507] Surgical residency in Pakistan - End user perspective and need for change · · 2013 Open source

[C508] Cultivating rural surgical leaders through a structured training program: a qualitative case study · BMC Health Services Research · 2026 · DOI: 10.1186/s12913-026-14640-w Open source

Sources

  1. [C503] Residents’ perspective on the quality of postgraduate training programs in Pakistan – the good, the bad and the ugly

    Pakistan Journal of Medical Sciences · 2021

    DOI: 10.12669/pjms.37.7.4297

    Open source ↗
  2. [C504] Critical Assessment of Various Neurosurgery Training Programs of Pakistan.

    Turkish neurosurgery · 2020

    DOI: 10.5137/1019-5149.jtn.32860-20.2

    Open source ↗
  3. [C505] Barriers to research productivity amongst postgraduate trainees: results from a survey of 333 medical and surgical residents.

    Postgraduate medical journal · 2023

    DOI: 10.1093/postmj/qgad062

    Open source ↗
  4. [C506] “It’s the Time they Take to Give Feedback; it has Become a Problem” Exploring Barriers and Facilitators for Research Supervision in Postgraduate Medical Education in Tanzania. A Qualitative Study

    Advances in Medical Education and Practice · 2025

    DOI: 10.2147/amep.s512498

    Open source ↗
  5. [C507] Surgical residency in Pakistan - End user perspective and need for change

    · 2013

    Open source ↗
  6. [C508] Cultivating rural surgical leaders through a structured training program: a qualitative case study

    BMC Health Services Research · 2026

    DOI: 10.1186/s12913-026-14640-w

    Open source ↗
  7. [C509] SURG-68. Clinical landscape and perception of surgical neuro oncology among neurosurgical resident trainees of Pakistan: a nationwide analysis

    Neuro-Oncology · 2025

    DOI: 10.1093/neuonc/noaf201.1622

    Open source ↗
  8. [C510] Clinical Landscape and Perception of Surgical Neuro Oncology among Neurosurgical Resident Trainees of Pakistan: A Nationwide Analysis

    Pakistan Journal of Medical Sciences · 2025

    DOI: 10.12669/pjms.41.13(pins-nnos).13446

    Open source ↗

Agreements / Disagreements

Agreement between AI models is not independent verification.

No disagreements were reported by the synthesizer.

Limitations

  • No academic evidence directly addresses supervisor perspectives on research training for surgical residents in Pakistan; foreign analogues (e.g., Tanzania [C506]) may not reflect local institutional realities.
  • Several key papers (e.g., Shah 2024, Khan 2025) referenced in the rationale were not retrieved, limiting verification of their claims.
  • Most available studies are cross-sectional surveys; qualitative depth at the postgraduate surgical level is absent in the retrieved evidence.
  • Surgical subspecialties (e.g., neurosurgery [C504, C510]) show distinct challenges, but generalizability to all surgical disciplines is unclear.
  • The proposed impact—designing a mentorship framework—lacks precedent in the provided literature, representing innovation but also untested feasibility.

Recommended interpretation

The persistent research-output gap among Pakistani surgical trainees is well-documented from trainee perspectives, but the absence of supervisor input and surgery-specific curriculum design represents a credible and actionable research opportunity. A qualitative needs assessment targeting surgical supervisors could generate novel, context-sensitive insights for institutional reform.

Evidence preparation details

Priority scores organize the context; they do not decide the answer.

C503 · Priority

C504 · Priority

C505 · Priority

C506 · Priority

C507 · Priority

C508 · Priority

C509 · Priority

C510 · Priority

Omitted papers: 12. Omitted agents: .

Retry controls

Rationale 2.1 The problem. Research competence is treated as a core outcome of postgraduate medical training, not an optional add-on. In Pakistan, professional bodies such as the College of Physicians and Surgeons Pakistan require postgraduate trainees to complete a research project or dissertation as part of fellowship training, and research participation is widely recognized as important for career progression, evidence-based medical practice, and eligibility for subspecialty fellowships. Despite this, postgraduate medical trainees continue to show low research output and limited research competence in practice. Bakhshi et al.'s (2023) multicentered survey of 333 postgraduate trainees across 12 accredited Pakistani institutions included 171 medical and162 surgical residents. They found that, despite 61% having received some research training, 57% of trainees still scored below one-third in basic research knowledge, and only 18% published locally and 11% internationally, indicating that research training is not being delivered. Still, neither builds competence nor produces publishable output. The most commonly cited barriers were time constraints caused to clinical workload, lack of financial support, and lack of data availability. Shah's (2024) mixed-methods study of postgraduate trainees at a tertiary care hospital in Karachi similarly found that supervisor support for research varied substantially, with clinical trainees receiving markedly less supervisor assistance than basic-science trainees, and cited workload and scheduling constraints as the main barrier to active participation. Khan et al.'s (2025) national survey extends the same picture beyond training into independent practice, reporting that Pakistani doctors continue to struggle to conduct and complete research well after graduation. Surgical training arguably faces this problem more acutely than other specialties: operative caseload requirements, long duty hours, and the apprenticeship structure of surgical education leave comparatively little unstructured time for research, yet no study reviewed here examines surgical trainees as a distinct group facing these particular constraints. Taken together, this evidence shows a persistent, well-documented gap between what postgraduate surgical training expects of trainees and what trainees are actually able to achieve. 2.2 The gap. Gap 1 — No study has asked supervisors. The closest match, Bakhshi et al.'s (2023) survey of 333 Pakistani postgraduate residents across 12 institutions (162 of whom were surgical), found low research output and insight despite positive attitudes — but the authors explicitly flag that "faculty and supervisor viewpoints were excluded" as a limitation of their study. Every other Pakistani study found has the same shape: Shah (2023) at a Karachi tertiary care hospital, Mahmood et al. (2025) at Nishtar Medical University, and Ahmed et al. (2023) all capture trainees' or students' perspectives, never supervisors. This study is the first to flip that concept on its head and ask the people who actually design and deliver training what should be in it. Gap 2 — No surgery-specific focus. Bakhshi et al. (2024) pool medical and surgical residents together; Shah (2024) pools clinical and basic-science trainees together. Nobody has identified postgraduate surgical trainees as a distinct group with their own research-training needs, even though surgical training has well-documented time and workload constraints that probably influence what's feasible in a research curriculum differently than in other specialties. Gap 3 — Nobody closes the loop from problem to design. Every study above Bakhshi et al. (2023), Shah (2024), Mahmood et al. (2025) at Nishtar Medical University, and Ahmed et al. (2023) stops at identifying barriers: time, funding, mentorship, data access. None of them takes the next step of translating findings into an actual structured training framework. That's precisely what "Informing the Design of..." in the title commits: nothing in the literature has done it yet for this population. Gap 4 — Qualitative depth exists in Pakistan only at the undergraduate level. Ahmed et al. (2023) and Mahmood et al. (2025) show qualitative methods are now being used to understand research barriers in Pakistani medical education — but only with undergraduates. Nobody has taken that same qualitative depth to the postgraduate surgical level. Shah (2023) does carry a qualitative component at the postgraduate level. The defensible claim is that no published Pakistani study has used a standalone qualitative design with postgraduate trainees, and none at any level has taken supervisors as the unit of analysis. That's a genuinely well-differentiated gap, not just a rephrased version of existing work. 2.3 The impact. By asking supervisors directly what postgraduate surgical trainees need, and what a structured training and mentorship framework should include, this study will produce something the existing survey-based literature cannot: a locally grounded, practitioner-informed basis for designing research training that is realistic within the constraints of surgical training, rather than one adapted from contexts with different workload and resource conditions. For the tertiary care hospital where the study is based, findings can directly inform the structure, content, and delivery of a research training and mentorship framework, addressing the barriers Bakhshi et al. (2023) and Shah (2024) documented but did not resolve. For supervisors who currently mentor research largely through their own experience rather than any structured institutional support, the study provides an opportunity to develop a tool that could reduce that load rather than add to it, and to have their practical, workload-sensitive knowledge formally incorporated into training design rather than left implicit. For postgraduate surgical trainees, a better-designed framework could improve their ability to meet research requirements, such as the CPSP dissertation, while building research competence that is more likely to persist into independent surgical practice. For accrediting and professional bodies, a locally validated, supervisor-informed model offers a possible template for strengthening research training standards across other surgical programs facing the same documented constraints. More broadly, by combining a supervisor perspective, a surgery-specific focus, a postgraduate population, and a designed output in a single study, this needs assessment closes four gaps in the existing literature at once, and offers a transferable model that other tertiary care surgical training programs could adapt.

Stage: PARTIAL

Partial research available. Review failures below; retry controls are available.

Latest semantic_scholar attempt failed: Semantic Scholar retrieval failed (rate_limit). Any earlier successful result remains active.

Retries make new API requests and may incur charges. Provider retries preserve the accepted answer; re-run synthesis afterward to incorporate changed evidence.

Provider attempt history (5)

Active means the latest successful attempt. A newer failure does not replace it.

#144 · semantic_scholar · academic-graph-search · Oct. 2, 2026, 3:50 p.m. · Latest · Failed

Semantic Scholar retrieval failed (rate_limit).

This attempt is displayed in the semantic_scholar results above.

#143 · consensus · search-v1 · Oct. 2, 2026, 3:50 p.m. · Latest · Active · Succeeded

This attempt is displayed in the consensus results above.

#142 · Planner 3 — Qwen3.5-27B · qwen/qwen3.5-27b · Oct. 2, 2026, 3:50 p.m. · Latest · Active · Succeeded

This attempt is displayed in the Planner 3 — Qwen3.5-27B results above.

#141 · Planner 2 — Llama 4 Scout · meta-llama/llama-4-scout · Oct. 2, 2026, 3:49 p.m. · Latest · Active · Succeeded

This attempt is displayed in the Planner 2 — Llama 4 Scout results above.

#140 · Planner 1 — Gemini 3.5 Flash · google/gemini-3.5-flash · Oct. 2, 2026, 3:49 p.m. · Latest · Active · Succeeded

This attempt is displayed in the Planner 1 — Gemini 3.5 Flash results above.

Synthesis history (1)
#28 · qwen/qwen3-max · Oct. 2, 2026, 3:50 p.m. · Succeeded · Latest · Active / latest accepted

Model: qwen/qwen3-max · Latency: 23228 ms · Estimated cost: 0.0137506200 USD

Input tokens: 10454 · Output tokens: 1435

Three viable thesis topics addressing research-training gaps for postgraduate surgical trainees in Pakistan are: 1. **Supervisor-Informed Research Curriculum Design**: Investigate surgical supervisors’ perspectives to develop a feasible, locally grounded research training framework that accounts for high clinical workloads and limited resources. This matters because no existing study in Pakistan captures supervisor input or translates it into curriculum design [C505]. The unresolved question is how supervisor insights can be systematized into actionable mentorship structures. 2. **Surgery-Specific Barriers to Research Competence**: Examine how surgical training constraints—such as duty hours, apprenticeship models, and case-log requirements—uniquely hinder research engagement compared to medical specialties. Existing literature pools surgical and medical trainees [C505], leaving surgery-specific dynamics unexplored. Variables include time availability, mentor access, and institutional support; methodology: qualitative interviews with surgical trainees and program directors. 3. **Mentorship Capacity and Training Needs of Surgical Supervisors**: Assess whether surgical faculty in Pakistan possess the skills and institutional backing to effectively mentor research. While trainee barriers are documented [C503, C505], supervisor capacity remains unstudied. A mixed-methods needs assessment could reveal gaps in supervisor training and inform faculty development programs. Feasibility is high within a single tertiary hospital, with findings transferable across similar settings.

Rejected source IDs: None recorded

Confidence: 85.0

Postgraduate surgical trainees in Pakistan face persistently low research output despite mandatory requirements, primarily due to clinical workload, lack of mentorship, and insufficient data access [C505]. Existing studies focus exclusively on trainee perspectives [C503, C505, C507], pool surgical and medical residents together, and stop at barrier identification without designing solutions. No published Pakistani study examines supervisors’ views, applies qualitative depth to postgraduate surgical education, or proposes a structured, surgery-specific research training framework. This gap limits the development of realistic, implementable curricula aligned with surgical training realities. Addressing these omissions through supervisor-centered qualitative research could yield actionable models to improve research competence and publication rates in resource-constrained settings.

Research competence among postgraduate surgical trainees in Pakistan remains low despite mandatory requirements. · strong

Bakhshi et al. (2023) found 57% of 333 trainees scored below one-third in basic research knowledge, with only 11% publishing internationally [C505]. Similar dissatisfaction with research training was reported by 53% of 516 residents across specialties [C503].

Supporting sources selected by synthesizer: C505, C503

Key barriers include time constraints, lack of funding, poor data access, and inconsistent supervisor support. · strong

Time limitations due to clinical duties, financial constraints, and data unavailability were the top barriers cited by surgical and medical residents [C505]. Supervisor support was rated low (44.2%) and linked to departmental staffing levels [C503].

Supporting sources selected by synthesizer: C505, C503

No existing Pakistani study captures supervisor perspectives on research training for surgical residents. · moderate

Bakhshi et al. explicitly note the exclusion of faculty viewpoints as a limitation [C505]. All other local studies surveyed trainees or students only [C503, C507]. A Tanzanian study highlights similar supervisor challenges but is not Pakistan-specific [C506].

Supporting sources selected by synthesizer: C505, C503, C507, C506

Surgical trainees face unique structural constraints not adequately addressed in current research training models. · limited

Neurosurgery residents report >72-hour workweeks and minimal hands-on exposure [C504, C510], yet no study isolates surgical trainees when analyzing research barriers [C505]. General surgical residency surveys confirm dissatisfaction with research support but lack specialty-specific analysis [C507].

Supporting sources selected by synthesizer: C504, C510, C505, C507

Existing studies identify barriers but do not translate findings into structured training frameworks. · strong

All cited Pakistani studies conclude with calls for better mentorship and protected time but propose no concrete curricular designs [C503, C505, C507]. The Rural Surgical Leadership Program offers a leadership—but not research—training model [C508].

Supporting sources selected by synthesizer: C503, C505, C507, C508

[C503] Residents’ perspective on the quality of postgraduate training programs in Pakistan – the good, the bad and the ugly · Pakistan Journal of Medical Sciences Open source

[C504] Critical Assessment of Various Neurosurgery Training Programs of Pakistan. · Turkish neurosurgery Open source

[C505] Barriers to research productivity amongst postgraduate trainees: results from a survey of 333 medical and surgical residents. · Postgraduate medical journal Open source

[C506] “It’s the Time they Take to Give Feedback; it has Become a Problem” Exploring Barriers and Facilitators for Research Supervision in Postgraduate Medical Education in Tanzania. A Qualitative Study · Advances in Medical Education and Practice Open source

[C507] Surgical residency in Pakistan - End user perspective and need for change · Open source

[C508] Cultivating rural surgical leaders through a structured training program: a qualitative case study · BMC Health Services Research Open source

[C509] SURG-68. Clinical landscape and perception of surgical neuro oncology among neurosurgical resident trainees of Pakistan: a nationwide analysis · Neuro-Oncology Open source

[C510] Clinical Landscape and Perception of Surgical Neuro Oncology among Neurosurgical Resident Trainees of Pakistan: A Nationwide Analysis · Pakistan Journal of Medical Sciences Open source

Agreements:

Disagreements:

Limitations: No academic evidence directly addresses supervisor perspectives on research training for surgical residents in Pakistan; foreign analogues (e.g., Tanzania [C506]) may not reflect local institutional realities.; Several key papers (e.g., Shah 2024, Khan 2025) referenced in the rationale were not retrieved, limiting verification of their claims.; Most available studies are cross-sectional surveys; qualitative depth at the postgraduate surgical level is absent in the retrieved evidence.; Surgical subspecialties (e.g., neurosurgery [C504, C510]) show distinct challenges, but generalizability to all surgical disciplines is unclear.; The proposed impact—designing a mentorship framework—lacks precedent in the provided literature, representing innovation but also untested feasibility.

The persistent research-output gap among Pakistani surgical trainees is well-documented from trainee perspectives, but the absence of supervisor input and surgery-specific curriculum design represents a credible and actionable research opportunity. A qualitative needs assessment targeting surgical supervisors could generate novel, context-sensitive insights for institutional reform.

Developer evaluation (manual)

Ratings do not affect synthesis. Rate the active answer and evidence you reviewed.

Developer diagnostics

Balanced primary: qwen/qwen3-max. Fallback: openai/o4-mini.

Fallback triggered: No. Reason: None. Accepted synthesizer: qwen/qwen3-max.

Synthesis routing latency: 23228 ms. Total routing cost (USD): 0.0137506200.

Plan-and-Solve diagnostics

Generated queries: 12; retrieval queries: 5; duplicates removed: 5; unique papers: 20.

semantic_scholar: 1 requests; 0 results; 1 failed requests.

consensus: 5 requests; 25 results; 0 failed requests.

Normalized ResearchPlan
original_question
Rationale 2.1 The problem. Research competence is treated as a core outcome of postgraduate medical training, not an optional add-on. In Pakistan, professional bodies such as the College of Physicians and Surgeons Pakistan require postgraduate trainees to complete a research project or dissertation as part of fellowship training, and research participation is widely recognized as important for career progression, evidence-based medical practice, and eligibility for subspecialty fellowships. Despite this, postgraduate medical trainees continue to show low research output and limited research competence in practice. Bakhshi et al.'s (2023) multicentered survey of 333 postgraduate trainees across 12 accredited Pakistani institutions included 171 medical and162 surgical residents. They found that, despite 61% having received some research training, 57% of trainees still scored below one-third in basic research knowledge, and only 18% published locally and 11% internationally, indicating that research training is not being delivered. Still, neither builds competence nor produces publishable output. The most commonly cited barriers were time constraints caused to clinical workload, lack of financial support, and lack of data availability. Shah's (2024) mixed-methods study of postgraduate trainees at a tertiary care hospital in Karachi similarly found that supervisor support for research varied substantially, with clinical trainees receiving markedly less supervisor assistance than basic-science trainees, and cited workload and scheduling constraints as the main barrier to active participation. Khan et al.'s (2025) national survey extends the same picture beyond training into independent practice, reporting that Pakistani doctors continue to struggle to conduct and complete research well after graduation. Surgical training arguably faces this problem more acutely than other specialties: operative caseload requirements, long duty hours, and the apprenticeship structure of surgical education leave comparatively little unstructured time for research, yet no study reviewed here examines surgical trainees as a distinct group facing these particular constraints. Taken together, this evidence shows a persistent, well-documented gap between what postgraduate surgical training expects of trainees and what trainees are actually able to achieve. 2.2 The gap. Gap 1 — No study has asked supervisors. The closest match, Bakhshi et al.'s (2023) survey of 333 Pakistani postgraduate residents across 12 institutions (162 of whom were surgical), found low research output and insight despite positive attitudes — but the authors explicitly flag that "faculty and supervisor viewpoints were excluded" as a limitation of their study. Every other Pakistani study found has the same shape: Shah (2023) at a Karachi tertiary care hospital, Mahmood et al. (2025) at Nishtar Medical University, and Ahmed et al. (2023) all capture trainees' or students' perspectives, never supervisors. This study is the first to flip that concept on its head and ask the people who actually design and deliver training what should be in it. Gap 2 — No surgery-specific focus. Bakhshi et al. (2024) pool medical and surgical residents together; Shah (2024) pools clinical and basic-science trainees together. Nobody has identified postgraduate surgical trainees as a distinct group with their own research-training needs, even though surgical training has well-documented time and workload constraints that probably influence what's feasible in a research curriculum differently than in other specialties. Gap 3 — Nobody closes the loop from problem to design. Every study above Bakhshi et al. (2023), Shah (2024), Mahmood et al. (2025) at Nishtar Medical University, and Ahmed et al. (2023) stops at identifying barriers: time, funding, mentorship, data access. None of them takes the next step of translating findings into an actual structured training framework. That's precisely what "Informing the Design of..." in the title commits: nothing in the literature has done it yet for this population. Gap 4 — Qualitative depth exists in Pakistan only at the undergraduate level. Ahmed et al. (2023) and Mahmood et al. (2025) show qualitative methods are now being used to understand research barriers in Pakistani medical education — but only with undergraduates. Nobody has taken that same qualitative depth to the postgraduate surgical level. Shah (2023) does carry a qualitative component at the postgraduate level. The defensible claim is that no published Pakistani study has used a standalone qualitative design with postgraduate trainees, and none at any level has taken supervisors as the unit of analysis. That's a genuinely well-differentiated gap, not just a rephrased version of existing work. 2.3 The impact. By asking supervisors directly what postgraduate surgical trainees need, and what a structured training and mentorship framework should include, this study will produce something the existing survey-based literature cannot: a locally grounded, practitioner-informed basis for designing research training that is realistic within the constraints of surgical training, rather than one adapted from contexts with different workload and resource conditions. For the tertiary care hospital where the study is based, findings can directly inform the structure, content, and delivery of a research training and mentorship framework, addressing the barriers Bakhshi et al. (2023) and Shah (2024) documented but did not resolve. For supervisors who currently mentor research largely through their own experience rather than any structured institutional support, the study provides an opportunity to develop a tool that could reduce that load rather than add to it, and to have their practical, workload-sensitive knowledge formally incorporated into training design rather than left implicit. For postgraduate surgical trainees, a better-designed framework could improve their ability to meet research requirements, such as the CPSP dissertation, while building research competence that is more likely to persist into independent surgical practice. For accrediting and professional bodies, a locally validated, supervisor-informed model offers a possible template for strengthening research training standards across other surgical programs facing the same documented constraints. More broadly, by combining a supervisor perspective, a surgery-specific focus, a postgraduate population, and a designed output in a single study, this needs assessment closes four gaps in the existing literature at once, and offers a transferable model that other tertiary care surgical training programs could adapt.
canonical_search_queries
['surgical residents research training barriers Pakistan', 'research training for postgraduate surgical trainees in Pakistan', 'supervisor perspectives research training postgraduate surgical Pakistan', 'postgraduate medical education research supervisor perspective', 'barriers to research in surgical training in Pakistan']
keywords
['surgical trainees', 'research competence', 'residency curriculum', 'supervisor perspectives', 'needs assessment', 'Pakistan', 'postgraduate medical education', 'mentorship framework', 'postgraduate surgical trainees', 'research training', 'mentorship', 'curriculum design']
synonyms
['surgical residents', 'research supervisors', 'clinical educators', 'research training', 'scholarly activity', 'dissertation support', 'educational barriers', 'mentoring models', 'research skills', 'medical education', 'resident physicians', 'fellowship trainees']
research_subquestions
['What are the specific perspectives and experiences of surgical training supervisors regarding the research-training needs of postgraduate surgical trainees in Pakistan?', 'How do clinical workloads, scheduling, and surgical apprenticeship structures uniquely constrain the implementation of research curricula in postgraduate surgical training?', 'What key components, structures, and mentorship models do surgical supervisors recommend for a postgraduate surgical research training framework?', 'How can supervisor insights be translated into a practical, locally grounded research training curriculum that overcomes documented institutional barriers?', 'What are the perspectives of supervisors on the research training needs of postgraduate surgical trainees in Pakistan?', 'What are the essential components of a structured research training and mentorship framework for postgraduate surgical trainees in Pakistan?', 'What are the key barriers supervisors perceive in delivering effective research training to postgraduate surgical trainees?', 'How do workload constraints specific to surgical training impact research curriculum design according to supervisors?', 'What components should a structured research training and mentorship framework include for surgical trainees?', 'How can supervisor expertise be formally integrated into institutional research training structures?', 'What differences exist between supervisor perceptions of research needs in surgical versus non-surgical specialties?', 'How do resource limitations affect the feasibility of research training programs in Pakistani surgical departments?']
candidate_gap_hypotheses
['Lack of qualitative studies exploring the distinct systemic barriers of surgical residency research in developing countries.', 'Absence of structured models translating surgical supervisor perspectives directly into medical education curricula.', 'Unexplored differences in research mentorship requirements between surgical subspecialties.', 'Limited research on the efficacy of structured research frameworks within high-workload surgical training environments.', 'limited research on supervisor perspectives', 'lack of surgery-specific focus', 'need for qualitative depth at postgraduate level', 'Lack of supervisor perspective in existing research training studies', 'Absence of surgery-specific research curriculum analysis', 'Missing qualitative depth at postgraduate surgical level', 'No actionable framework design based on identified barriers', 'Limited integration of practical workload considerations in training design']
uncertainties
['Whether supervisors themselves possess the necessary training to mentor research effectively.', 'The degree of institutional willingness to allocate protected research time for surgical residents.', 'How to balance operative logbook requirements with structured research training.', 'The financial feasibility of implementing supervisor-led research frameworks in resource-constrained hospitals.', 'effective strategies for improving research training', 'impact of research training on practice', 'Whether supervisor recommendations align with available institutional resources', 'Potential resistance to implementing new structured frameworks', 'Variability in surgical department cultures across institutions', 'Long-term sustainability of proposed interventions', 'Measuring actual impact on trainee research outcomes', 'Generalizability beyond single tertiary care hospital setting']
filters
{'suggestions': [{'year_from': 2015, 'year_to': 2025, 'fields': ['Medicine', 'Medical Education', 'Surgery'], 'study_types': ['Qualitative Study', 'Needs Assessment', 'Mixed Methods', 'Framework Design']}, {'year_from': 2020, 'year_to': None, 'fields': ['medicine', 'surgery'], 'study_types': ['qualitative', 'survey']}, {'year_from': 2015, 'year_to': 2025, 'fields': ['Medical Education', 'Surgery', 'Curriculum Design'], 'study_types': ['Qualitative Research', 'Needs Assessment', 'Mixed Methods', 'Survey Studies', 'Case Studies']}], 'policy': 'Advisory only; configured provider filters apply.'}
generated_query_count
12
successful_planners
3

Retrieval is incomplete; absence of results is not proof of absence.

Provider counts describe latest attempts; evidence and answer metrics describe active results. Duration and costs include all attempts, including retries. Cost is USD, OpenRouter only; Consensus billing is not estimated. Unknown is not zero.

total_duration_ms
116267
interrupted_execution_metrics_incomplete
False
successful_providers
4
failed_providers
1
successful_agents
3
consensus_success
True
synthesis_success
True
paper_count
20
total_estimated_openrouter_cost
0.0415792500
known_cost_subtotal
0.0415792500
attempts_missing_cost
0
valid_source_percent
100.0
removed_source_ids
0
agreements_count
0
disagreements_count
0
evidence_strength_distribution
{'strong': 3, 'moderate': 1, 'limited': 1}
judge_confidence
85.0
answer_length
1598
Attempt / modelSuccessLatency msInput / output / total tokensCost USDError
#144 academic-graph-searchNo1153? / ? / ?Unknown rate_limit: Semantic Scholar retrieval failed (rate_limit).
#143 search-v1Yes25936? / ? / ?Unknown :
#142 qwen/qwen3.5-27bYes318961929 / 1835 / 37640.0044844300 reported:
#141 meta-llama/llama-4-scoutYes111591527 / 395 / 19220.0002712000 reported:
#140 google/gemini-3.5-flashYes226941618 / 2294 / 39120.0230730000 reported:
#28 qwen/qwen3-maxYes2322810454 / 1435 / 118890.0137506200 reported:

Judge: qwen/qwen3-max. Papers used: 8. Papers omitted by limit: 12.

Rejected source IDs: None recorded

Conversation history
User
Rationale 2.1 The problem. Research competence is treated as a core outcome of postgraduate medical training, not an optional add-on. In Pakistan, professional bodies such as the College of Physicians and Surgeons Pakistan require postgraduate trainees to complete a research project or dissertation as part of fellowship training, and research participation is widely recognized as important for career progression, evidence-based medical practice, and eligibility for subspecialty fellowships. Despite this, postgraduate medical trainees continue to show low research output and limited research competence in practice. Bakhshi et al.'s (2023) multicentered survey of 333 postgraduate trainees across 12 accredited Pakistani institutions included 171 medical and162 surgical residents. They found that, despite 61% having received some research training, 57% of trainees still scored below one-third in basic research knowledge, and only 18% published locally and 11% internationally, indicating that research training is not being delivered. Still, neither builds competence nor produces publishable output. The most commonly cited barriers were time constraints caused to clinical workload, lack of financial support, and lack of data availability. Shah's (2024) mixed-methods study of postgraduate trainees at a tertiary care hospital in Karachi similarly found that supervisor support for research varied substantially, with clinical trainees receiving markedly less supervisor assistance than basic-science trainees, and cited workload and scheduling constraints as the main barrier to active participation. Khan et al.'s (2025) national survey extends the same picture beyond training into independent practice, reporting that Pakistani doctors continue to struggle to conduct and complete research well after graduation. Surgical training arguably faces this problem more acutely than other specialties: operative caseload requirements, long duty hours, and the apprenticeship structure of surgical education leave comparatively little unstructured time for research, yet no study reviewed here examines surgical trainees as a distinct group facing these particular constraints. Taken together, this evidence shows a persistent, well-documented gap between what postgraduate surgical training expects of trainees and what trainees are actually able to achieve. 2.2 The gap. Gap 1 — No study has asked supervisors. The closest match, Bakhshi et al.'s (2023) survey of 333 Pakistani postgraduate residents across 12 institutions (162 of whom were surgical), found low research output and insight despite positive attitudes — but the authors explicitly flag that "faculty and supervisor viewpoints were excluded" as a limitation of their study. Every other Pakistani study found has the same shape: Shah (2023) at a Karachi tertiary care hospital, Mahmood et al. (2025) at Nishtar Medical University, and Ahmed et al. (2023) all capture trainees' or students' perspectives, never supervisors. This study is the first to flip that concept on its head and ask the people who actually design and deliver training what should be in it. Gap 2 — No surgery-specific focus. Bakhshi et al. (2024) pool medical and surgical residents together; Shah (2024) pools clinical and basic-science trainees together. Nobody has identified postgraduate surgical trainees as a distinct group with their own research-training needs, even though surgical training has well-documented time and workload constraints that probably influence what's feasible in a research curriculum differently than in other specialties. Gap 3 — Nobody closes the loop from problem to design. Every study above Bakhshi et al. (2023), Shah (2024), Mahmood et al. (2025) at Nishtar Medical University, and Ahmed et al. (2023) stops at identifying barriers: time, funding, mentorship, data access. None of them takes the next step of translating findings into an actual structured training framework. That's precisely what "Informing the Design of..." in the title commits: nothing in the literature has done it yet for this population. Gap 4 — Qualitative depth exists in Pakistan only at the undergraduate level. Ahmed et al. (2023) and Mahmood et al. (2025) show qualitative methods are now being used to understand research barriers in Pakistani medical education — but only with undergraduates. Nobody has taken that same qualitative depth to the postgraduate surgical level. Shah (2023) does carry a qualitative component at the postgraduate level. The defensible claim is that no published Pakistani study has used a standalone qualitative design with postgraduate trainees, and none at any level has taken supervisors as the unit of analysis. That's a genuinely well-differentiated gap, not just a rephrased version of existing work. 2.3 The impact. By asking supervisors directly what postgraduate surgical trainees need, and what a structured training and mentorship framework should include, this study will produce something the existing survey-based literature cannot: a locally grounded, practitioner-informed basis for designing research training that is realistic within the constraints of surgical training, rather than one adapted from contexts with different workload and resource conditions. For the tertiary care hospital where the study is based, findings can directly inform the structure, content, and delivery of a research training and mentorship framework, addressing the barriers Bakhshi et al. (2023) and Shah (2024) documented but did not resolve. For supervisors who currently mentor research largely through their own experience rather than any structured institutional support, the study provides an opportunity to develop a tool that could reduce that load rather than add to it, and to have their practical, workload-sensitive knowledge formally incorporated into training design rather than left implicit. For postgraduate surgical trainees, a better-designed framework could improve their ability to meet research requirements, such as the CPSP dissertation, while building research competence that is more likely to persist into independent surgical practice. For accrediting and professional bodies, a locally validated, supervisor-informed model offers a possible template for strengthening research training standards across other surgical programs facing the same documented constraints. More broadly, by combining a supervisor perspective, a surgery-specific focus, a postgraduate population, and a designed output in a single study, this needs assessment closes four gaps in the existing literature at once, and offers a transferable model that other tertiary care surgical training programs could adapt.

Three AI perspectives + academic evidence · Check sources before relying on them

Manage research