RESEARCH QUESTION
Hi Submit researchscholar.cloud in Google's Search Index to be visible in Google search results! Register researchscholar.cloud today: searchregister.pro
Oct 2, 2026 · 14:44 PARTIAL
30-SECOND VIEW
Final Research Answer
Final synthesis unavailable. Collected research is still available.
Partial research available
The synthesizer reached its output limit before completing the structured answer.
Reason: truncated_responsePlanner 2 — Llama 4 Scout: OpenRouter rate-limited this request. Please try again later. Retry
semantic_scholar: Semantic Scholar retrieval failed (rate_limit). Retry
2-MINUTE VIEW
Key Findings
No individual findings are available yet.
Evidence Overview
20 valid sources · 0 conflicting findings · 0 disagreements · 23 papers reviewed
The metrics above describe saved evidence. Source associations and agreement between models are not independent verification.
Best Academic Evidence
Saved synthesis ranking where available; otherwise Consensus order. Retrieved papers are not automatically proof of a claim.
ConsensusThe Role of Google Scholar in Evidence Reviews and Its Applicability to Grey Literature Searching
Neal R Haddaway, A. Collins, D. Coughlin, Stuart Kirk, K. B. Wray · 2015 · PLoS ONE
Google Scholar (GS), a commonly used web-based academic search engine, catalogues between 2 and 100 million records of both academic and grey literature (articles not formally published by commercial academic publishers). Google Scholar collates results from across the internet and is free to use. …
Read paper details
Neal R Haddaway, A. Collins, D. Coughlin, Stuart Kirk, K. B. Wray
Google Scholar (GS), a commonly used web-based academic search engine, catalogues between 2 and 100 million records of both academic and grey literature (articles not formally published by commercial academic publishers). Google Scholar collates results from across the internet and is free to use. As a result it has received considerable attention as a method for searching for literature, particularly in searches for grey literature, as required by systematic reviews. The reliance on GS as a standalone resource has been greatly debated, however, and its efficacy in grey literature searching has not yet been investigated. Using systematic review case studies from environmental science, we investigated the utility of GS in systematic reviews and in searches for grey literature. Our findings show that GS results contain moderate amounts of grey literature, with the majority found on average at page 80. We also found that, when searched for specifically, the majority of literature identified using Web of Science was also found using GS. However, our findings showed moderate/poor overlap in results when similar search strings were used in Web of Science and GS (10-67%), and that GS missed some important literature in five of six case studies. Furthermore, a general GS search failed to find any grey literature from a case study that involved manual searching of organisations' websites. If used in systematic reviews for grey literature, we recommend that searches of article titles focus on the first 200 to 300 results. We conclude that whilst Google Scholar can find much grey literature and specific, known studies, it should not be used alone for systematic review searches. Rather, it forms a powerful addition to other traditional search methods. In addition, we advocate the use of tools to transparently document and catalogue GS search results to maintain high levels of transparency and the ability to be updated, critical to systematic reviews.
DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0138237
Open source ↗Increasing visibility and discoverability of scholarly publications with academic search engine optimization
Lisa Schilhan, Christian Kaier, Karin Lackner · 2021 · Insights the UKSG journal
With the help of academic search engine optimization (ASEO), publications can more easily be found in academic search engines and databases. Authors can improve the ranking of their publications by adjusting titles, keywords and abstracts. Carefully considered wording makes publications easier to f…
Read paper details
Lisa Schilhan, Christian Kaier, Karin Lackner
With the help of academic search engine optimization (ASEO), publications can more easily be found in academic search engines and databases. Authors can improve the ranking of their publications by adjusting titles, keywords and abstracts. Carefully considered wording makes publications easier to find and, ideally, cited more often. This article is meant to support authors in making their scholarly publications more visible. It provides basic information on ranking mechanisms as well as tips and tricks on how to improve the findability of scholarly publications while also pointing out the limits of optimization. This article, authored by three scholarly communications librarians, draws on their experience of hosting journals, providing workshops for researchers and individual publication support, as well as on their investigations of the ranking algorithms of search engines and databases.
DOI: 10.1629/uksg.534
Open source ↗Ranking by Relevance and Citation Counts, a Comparative Study: Google Scholar, Microsoft Academic, WoS and Scopus
Cristòfol Rovira, Lluís Codina, F. Guerrero-Solé, Carlos Lopezosa · 2019 · Future Internet
Search engine optimization (SEO) constitutes the set of methods designed to increase the visibility of, and the number of visits to, a web page by means of its ranking on the search engine results pages. Recently, SEO has also been applied to academic databases and search engines, in a trend that i…
Read paper details
Cristòfol Rovira, Lluís Codina, F. Guerrero-Solé, Carlos Lopezosa
Search engine optimization (SEO) constitutes the set of methods designed to increase the visibility of, and the number of visits to, a web page by means of its ranking on the search engine results pages. Recently, SEO has also been applied to academic databases and search engines, in a trend that is in constant growth. This new approach, known as academic SEO (ASEO), has generated a field of study with considerable future growth potential due to the impact of open science. The study reported here forms part of this new field of analysis. The ranking of results is a key aspect in any information system since it determines the way in which these results are presented to the user. The aim of this study is to analyze and compare the relevance ranking algorithms employed by various academic platforms to identify the importance of citations received in their algorithms. Specifically, we analyze two search engines and two bibliographic databases: Google Scholar and Microsoft Academic, on the one hand, and Web of Science and Scopus, on the other. A reverse engineering methodology is employed based on the statistical analysis of Spearman’s correlation coefficients. The results indicate that the ranking algorithms used by Google Scholar and Microsoft are the two that are most heavily influenced by citations received. Indeed, citation counts are clearly the main SEO factor in these academic search engines. An unexpected finding is that, at certain points in time, Web of Science (WoS) used citations received as a key ranking factor, despite the fact that WoS support documents claim this factor does not intervene.
DOI: 10.3390/fi11090202
Open source ↗View all papers (23)
ConsensusDot-science top level domain: Academic websites or dumpsites?
E. Orduña-Malea · 2021 · Scientometrics
Dot-science was launched in 2015 as a new academic top-level domain aimed to provide ‘a dedicated, easily accessible location for global Internet users with an interest in science’. The main objective of this work is to find out the general scholarly usage of this top-level domain. In particular, t…
Read paper details
E. Orduña-Malea
Dot-science was launched in 2015 as a new academic top-level domain aimed to provide ‘a dedicated, easily accessible location for global Internet users with an interest in science’. The main objective of this work is to find out the general scholarly usage of this top-level domain. In particular, the following three questions are pursued: usage (number of web domains registered with the dot-science), purpose (main function and category of websites linked to these web domains), and impact (websites’ visibility and authority). To do this, 13,900 domain names were gathered through ICANN’s Domain Name Registration Data Lookup database. Each web domain was subsequently categorized, and data on web impact were obtained from Majestic’s API. Based on the results obtained, it is concluded that the dot-science top-level domain is scarcely adopted by the academic community, and mainly used by registrar companies for reselling purposes (35.5% of all web domains were parked). Websites receiving the highest number of backlinks were generally related to non-academic websites applying intensive link building practices and offering leisure or even fraudulent contents. Majestic’s trust flow metric has been proved an effective method to filter reputable academic websites. As regards primary academic-related dot-science web domain categories, 1175 (8.5% of all web domains registered) were found, mainly personal academic websites (342 web domains), blogs (261) and research groups (133). All dubious content reveals bad practices on the Web, where the tag ‘science’ is fundamentally used as a mechanism to deceive search engine algorithms.
DOI: 10.1007/s11192-020-03832-8
Open source ↗Academic Search Engine Optimization (ASEO)
Jöran Beel, Bela Gipp, Erik Wilde · 2010 · Journal of Scholarly Publishing
This article introduces and discusses the concept of academic search engine optimization (ASEO). Based on three recently conducted studies, guidelines are provided on how to optimize scholarly literature for academic search engines in general, and for Google Scholar in particular. In addition, we b…
Read paper details
Jöran Beel, Bela Gipp, Erik Wilde
This article introduces and discusses the concept of academic search engine optimization (ASEO). Based on three recently conducted studies, guidelines are provided on how to optimize scholarly literature for academic search engines in general, and for Google Scholar in particular. In addition, we briefly discuss the risk of researchers' illegitimately ‘over-optimizing’ their articles.
DOI: 10.3138/jsp.41.2.176
Open source ↗Academic Search Engine Optimization (aseo) optimizing scholarly literature for google scholar & co
Jöran Beel, Bela Gipp, Erik Eilde · 2009 ·
introduction Researchers should have an interest in ensuring that their articles are indexed by academic search engines such as Google Scholar, IEEE Xplore, PubMed, and SciPlore.org, which greatly improves their ability to make their articles available to the academic community. Not only should aut…
Read paper details
Jöran Beel, Bela Gipp, Erik Eilde
introduction Researchers should have an interest in ensuring that their articles are indexed by academic search engines such as Google Scholar, IEEE Xplore, PubMed, and SciPlore.org, which greatly improves their ability to make their articles available to the academic community. Not only should authors take an interest in seeing that their articles are indexed, they also should be interesting in where the articles are displayed in the results list. Like any other type of ranked search results, articles displayed in top positions are more likely to be read. This article presents the concept of academic search engine optimization (ASEO) to optimize scholarly literature for academic search engines. The first part of the article covers related work that has been done mostly in the field of general search engine optimization for Web pages. The second part defines ASEO and compares it to search engine optimization for Web pages. The third part provides an overview of ranking algorithms of academic search engines in general, followed by an overview of Google Scholar’s ranking algorithm. Finally, guidelines are provided on how authors can optimize their articles for academic search engines. This article does not cover how publishers or providers of
Academic Search Engine Spam and Google Scholar's Resilience Against it
Joeran Beel, Bela Gipp · 2010 · Journal of Electronic Publishing
In a previous paper we provided guidelines for scholars on optimizing research articles for academic search engines such as Google Scholar. Feedback in the academic community to these guidelines was diverse. Some were concerned researchers could use our guidelines to manipulate rankings of scientif…
Read paper details
Joeran Beel, Bela Gipp
In a previous paper we provided guidelines for scholars on optimizing research articles for academic search engines such as Google Scholar. Feedback in the academic community to these guidelines was diverse. Some were concerned researchers could use our guidelines to manipulate rankings of scientific articles and promote what we call ‘academic search engine spam’. To find out whether these concerns are justified, we conducted several tests on Google Scholar. The results show that academic search engine spam is indeed— and with little effort—possible: We increased rankings of academic articles on Google Scholar by manipulating their citation counts; Google Scholar indexed invisible text we added to some articles, making papers appear for keyword searches the articles were not relevant for; Google Scholar indexed some nonsensical articles we randomly created with the paper generator SciGen; and Google Scholar linked to manipulated versions of research papers that contained a Viagra advertisement. At the end of this paper, we discuss whether academic search engine spam could become a serious threat to Web-based academic search engines.
DOI: 10.3998/3336451.0013.305
Open source ↗Commercial Web sites: lost in cyberspace?
M. Thelwall · 2000 · Internet Res.
How easy are business web sites for potential customers to find? This paper reports on a survey of 60087 web sites from 42 of the major general and commercial domains around the world to extract statistics about their design and rate of search engine registration. Search engines are used by the maj…
Read paper details
M. Thelwall
How easy are business web sites for potential customers to find? This paper reports on a survey of 60087 web sites from 42 of the major general and commercial domains around the world to extract statistics about their design and rate of search engine registration. Search engines are used by the majority of web surfers to find information on the web. However, 23% of business web sites in the survey were not registered at all in the five major search engines tested and 82% were not registered in at least one, missing a sizeable potential audience. There are some simple steps that should also be taken to help a web site to be indexed properly in search engines, primarily the use of HTML META tags for indexing, but only about a third of the site home pages in the survey used them. Wide national variations were found for both indexing and META tag inclusion.
DOI: 10.1108/10662240010322939
Open source ↗Language Bias in the Google Scholar Ranking Algorithm
Cristòfol Rovira, Lluís Codina, Carlos Lopezosa · 2021 · Future Internet
The visibility of academic articles or conference papers depends on their being easily found in academic search engines, above all in Google Scholar. To enhance this visibility, search engine optimization (SEO) has been applied in recent years to academic search engines in order to optimize documen…
Read paper details
Cristòfol Rovira, Lluís Codina, Carlos Lopezosa
The visibility of academic articles or conference papers depends on their being easily found in academic search engines, above all in Google Scholar. To enhance this visibility, search engine optimization (SEO) has been applied in recent years to academic search engines in order to optimize documents and, thereby, ensure they are better ranked in search pages (i.e., academic search engine optimization or ASEO). To achieve this degree of optimization, we first need to further our understanding of Google Scholar’s relevance ranking algorithm, so that, based on this knowledge, we can highlight or improve those characteristics that academic documents already present and which are taken into account by the algorithm. This study seeks to advance our knowledge in this line of research by determining whether the language in which a document is published is a positioning factor in the Google Scholar relevance ranking algorithm. Here, we employ a reverse engineering research methodology based on a statistical analysis that uses Spearman’s correlation coefficient. The results obtained point to a bias in multilingual searches conducted in Google Scholar with documents published in languages other than in English being systematically relegated to positions that make them virtually invisible. This finding has important repercussions, both for conducting searches and for optimizing positioning in Google Scholar, being especially critical for articles on subjects that are expressed in the same way in English and other languages, the case, for example, of trademarks, chemical compounds, industrial products, acronyms, drugs, diseases, etc.
DOI: 10.3390/fi13020031
Open source ↗SEO for an open access scholarly information system to improve user experience
Minsoo Park · 2018 ·
This paper aims to introduce a case of search engine optimization (SEO), especially designed for a national scholarly open access information website in the field of STEM.,Korea Institute of Science and Technology Information (KISTI) collaborated with the Google Scholar team to open and share the r…
Read paper details
Minsoo Park
This paper aims to introduce a case of search engine optimization (SEO), especially designed for a national scholarly open access information website in the field of STEM.,Korea Institute of Science and Technology Information (KISTI) collaborated with the Google Scholar team to open and share the research outcomes of STEM in Korea worldwide. KoreaScience is a reference-linking platform for open access scientific and technical journals in Korea, operated by KISTI. KISTI worked with the Google Scholar team to embed machine-readable bibliographic metadata into its journal pages and to create an XML Sitemap to help Google find pages on KoreaScience.,As a result of implementation of metadata and creation of an XML Sitemap, the KoreaScience Web pages have noticeably increased the relevance of a search results’ list on Google and Google Scholar. In addition to this, the KoreaScience platform has received an increasing amount of its traffic from around the world.,Not much research has sought to understand SEO in the aspect of users and how it may be facilitated in “visible” academic Web environments such as search systems and open access information systems. For this project, the motivation for investigating SEO comes from its association with positive outcomes that range from personal benefits to global rewards, e.g. increased satisfaction in search user experience and, further, academic progress and scientific development by sharing and accessing scientific knowledge in the fast-growing field of STEM.
DOI: 10.1108/idd-08-2017-0060
Open source ↗Open access publications drive few visits from Google Search results to institutional repositories
E. Orduña-Malea, Cristina I. Font-Julián, Jorge Serrano-Cobos · 2024 · Scientometrics
Given the importance of Google Search in generating visits to institutional repositories (IR), a lack of visibility in search engine results pages can hinder the possibility of their publications being found, read, downloaded, and, eventually, cited. To address this, institutions need to evaluate t…
Read paper details
E. Orduña-Malea, Cristina I. Font-Julián, Jorge Serrano-Cobos
Given the importance of Google Search in generating visits to institutional repositories (IR), a lack of visibility in search engine results pages can hinder the possibility of their publications being found, read, downloaded, and, eventually, cited. To address this, institutions need to evaluate the visibility of their repositories to determine what actions might be implemented to enhance them. However, measuring the search engine optimization (SEO) visibility of IRs requires a highly accurate, technically feasible method. This study constitutes the first attempt to design such a method, specifically applied here to measuring the IR visibility of Spain’s national university system in Google Search based on a set of SEO-based metrics derived from the Ubersuggest SEO tool. A comprehensive dataset spanning three months and comprising 217,589 bibliographic records and 316,899 organic keywords is used as a baseline. Our findings show that many records deposited in these repositories are not ranked among the top positions in Google Search results, and that the most visible records are mainly academic works (theses and dissertations) written in Spanish in the Humanities and Social Sciences. However, most visits are generated by a small number of records. All in all, our results call into question the role played by IRs in attracting readers via Google Search to the institutions’ scientific heritage and serve to underscore the prevailing emphasis within IRs on preservation as opposed to online dissemination. Potential improvements might be achieved using enhanced metadata schemes and normalized description practices, as well as by adopting other actionable insights that can strengthen the online visibility of IRs. This study increases understanding of the role played by web indicators in assessing the web-based impact of research outputs deposited in IRs, and should be of particular interest for a range of stakeholders, including open access and open science advocates, research agencies, library practitioners, repository developers, and website administrators.
DOI: 10.1007/s11192-024-05175-0
Open source ↗ACADEMIC SEARCH ENGINE OPTIMIZATION
Rani Gujari, C. Sahithi, Navneet Parihar · 2020 ·
Search engine optimization or SEO is the process of optimizing the website and getting it onto the top of the list. There are various ways of optimizing the website as reviewed in this paper. The paper is a summation of the various review papers done by different researchers in different countries.…
Read paper details
Rani Gujari, C. Sahithi, Navneet Parihar
Search engine optimization or SEO is the process of optimizing the website and getting it onto the top of the list. There are various ways of optimizing the website as reviewed in this paper. The paper is a summation of the various review papers done by different researchers in different countries. It showcases the key determinant variables from various studies and their criteria in the implementation based on the purpose of the website design. Search engine optimization (SEO) is making small modifications to website. These modifications have a collective impact on the optimization of the website. They improve the user interface and performance of the website. It is a common practice for search engine users to click only the first 5 - 7 websites in the search engine and not search through the remaining pages of search results, so to rank the website in the top 10 search results, optimization is required. This article talks about the optimization techniques used across the various sectors and countries for their websites. The paper majorly focuses on building academic websites visibility.
DOI: 10.31838/jcr.07.13.227
Open source ↗Impact of searching clinical trials registers in systematic reviews of pharmaceutical and non‐pharmaceutical interventions: Reanalysis of meta‐analyses
Zainab Alqaidoom, Phi-Yen Nguyen, M. Awadh, M. Page · 2022 · Research Synthesis Methods
Systematic reviewers are advised to search trials registers to minimise risk of reporting biases. However, there has been little research on the impact of searching trials registers on the results of meta-analyses. We aimed to evaluate the impact of searching clinical trials registers for systemati…
Read paper details
Zainab Alqaidoom, Phi-Yen Nguyen, M. Awadh, M. Page
Systematic reviewers are advised to search trials registers to minimise risk of reporting biases. However, there has been little research on the impact of searching trials registers on the results of meta-analyses. We aimed to evaluate the impact of searching clinical trials registers for systematic reviews of pharmaceutical or non-pharmaceutical interventions. We searched PubMed, Scopus, Science Citation Index and Social Sciences Citation Index, and Education Collection for systematic reviews with meta-analyses indexed from 2 November to 2 December 2020. A random sample of systematic reviews was initially drawn, and for reviews which considered randomised trials eligible for inclusion, which had not searched a trials register, we searched ClinicalTrials.gov, EudraCT, ANZCTR, and the WHO ICTRP search portal for eligible trials. We compared meta-analytic effect estimates before and after including results from additional trials identified. We found additional trials for 63% (63/101) of eligible reviews; however, trials with results that could contribute to a meta-analysis were identified for only 20% (20/101) of the reviews. On average, there was no difference in the meta-analytic effect estimates before versus after adding the new trials. In summary, searching clinical trial registers led to identification of additional trials for many reviews; however, very few trials had results available for inclusion in meta-analyses. Including results from the new trials led to no change in the meta-analytic estimates, on average. Trials registers would be even more valuable to systematic reviewers if more trialists made use of them (i.e., registered their trials and posted results in a timely manner). © 2022 The Authors. Research Synthesis Methods published by John Wiley & Sons Ltd.
DOI: 10.1002/jrsm.1583
Open source ↗Google Web and Image Search Visibility Data for Online Store
Artur Strzelecki · 2019 · Data
This data descriptor describes Google search engine visibility data. The visibility of a domain name in a search engine comes from search engine optimization and can be evaluated based on four data metrics and five data dimensions. The data metrics are the following: Clicks volume (1), impressions …
Read paper details
Artur Strzelecki
This data descriptor describes Google search engine visibility data. The visibility of a domain name in a search engine comes from search engine optimization and can be evaluated based on four data metrics and five data dimensions. The data metrics are the following: Clicks volume (1), impressions volume (2), click-through ratio (3), and ranking position (4). Data dimensions are as follows: queries that are entered into search engines that trigger results with the researched domain name (1), page URLs from research domains which are available in the search engine results page (2), country of origin of search engine visitors (3), type of device used for the search (4), and date of the search (5). Search engine visibility data were obtained from the Google search console for the international online store, which is visible in 240 countries and territories for a period of 15 months. The data contain 123 K clicks and 4.86 M impressions for the web search and 22 K clicks and 9.07 M impressions for the image search. The proposed method for obtaining data can be applied in any other area, not only in the e-commerce industry.
DOI: 10.3390/data4030125
Open source ↗Search engine optimization (SEO) for digital marketers: exploring determinants of online search visibility for blood bank service
D. Mladenović, Anida Rajapakse, Nikola Kožuljević, Yupal S. Shukla · 2022 · Online Inf. Rev.
PurposeGiven that online search visibility is influenced by various determinants, and that influence may vary across industries, this study aims in investigating the major predictors of online search visibility in the context of blood banks.Design/methodology/approachTo formalize the online visibil…
Read paper details
D. Mladenović, Anida Rajapakse, Nikola Kožuljević, Yupal S. Shukla
PurposeGiven that online search visibility is influenced by various determinants, and that influence may vary across industries, this study aims in investigating the major predictors of online search visibility in the context of blood banks.Design/methodology/approachTo formalize the online visibility, the authors have found theoretical foundations in activity theory, while to quantify online visiblity the authors have used the search engine optimization (SEO) Index, ranking, and a number of visitors. The examined model includes ten hypotheses and was tested on data from 57 blood banks.FindingsResults challenge shallow domain knowledge. The major predictors of online search visibility are Alternative Text Attribute (ALT) text, backlinks, robots, domain authority (DA) and bounce rate (BR). The issues are related to the number of backlinks, social score, and DA. Polarized utilization of SEO techniques is evident.Practical implicationsThe methodology can be used to analyze the online search visibility of other industries or similar not-for-profit organizations. Findings in terms of individual predictors can be useful for marketers to better manage online search visibility.Social implicationsThe acute blood donation problems may be to a certain degree level as the information flow between donors and blood banks will be facilitated.Originality/valueThis is the first study to analyze the blood bank context. The results provide invaluable inputs to marketers, managers, and policymakers.
DOI: 10.1108/oir-05-2022-0276
Open source ↗Invisible Institutional Repositories: Addressing the Low Indexing Ratios of IRs in Google Scholar
Kenning Arlitsch, Patrick S. O'Brien · 2012 · Libr. Hi Tech
Purpose – Google Scholar has difficulty indexing the contents of institutional repositories, and the authors hypothesize the reason is that most repositories use Dublin Core, which cannot express bibliographic citation information adequately for academic papers. Google Scholar makes specific recomm…
Read paper details
Kenning Arlitsch, Patrick S. O'Brien
Purpose – Google Scholar has difficulty indexing the contents of institutional repositories, and the authors hypothesize the reason is that most repositories use Dublin Core, which cannot express bibliographic citation information adequately for academic papers. Google Scholar makes specific recommendations for repositories, including the use of publishing industry metadata schemas over Dublin Core. This paper aims to test a theory that transforming metadata schemas in institutional repositories will lead to increased indexing by Google Scholar.Design/methodology/approach – The authors conducted two surveys of institutional and disciplinary repositories across the USA, using different methodologies. They also conducted three pilot projects that transformed the metadata of a subset of papers from USpace, the University of Utah's institutional repository, and examined the results of Google Scholar's explicit harvests.Findings – Repositories that use GS recommended metadata schemas and express them in HTML m...
DOI: 10.1108/07378831211213210
Open source ↗Search engine visibility: the effect of generic top-level domain choice
Z. Hamdulay, M. Weideman · 2006 ·
The principle objective of this research project is to determine whether or not search engines rank websites in dot-com domains higher than alternative generic top-level domains (gTLDs). The research question is: Should websites in these other gTLDs have to increase their marketing exposure of thei…
Read paper details
Z. Hamdulay, M. Weideman
The principle objective of this research project is to determine whether or not search engines rank websites in dot-com domains higher than alternative generic top-level domains (gTLDs). The research question is: Should websites in these other gTLDs have to increase their marketing exposure of their websites? The methods to be employed in this research project are to build separate websites each having domain names in different gTLDs, e.g. mysite.com, mysite.net, mysite.biz etc. The content on all websites will be identical and will be submitted to major local and international search engines. Each website will be search engine crawler-friendly and will include title tags in hyperlinks, alt tags in graphics, definitive webpage titles and keyword phrases in the meta tags etc. These websites will not only be crawler friendly but also user friendly. All sites will be written in HyperText Markup Language (HTML). The domain names chosen will be descriptive and no scripting languages will be used e.g. Javascript. Each website will be thoroughly tested in known browsers e.g. Netscape and Microsoft Internet Explorer. Data will also be gathered via interviews with senior officials at local e-commerce traders and/or search engines. This interview will mainly consist of open-ended questions regarding their marketing infrastructure towards successfully branding their websites to Internet users. Expected results from the methods employed above could prove that websites in dotcom domains are ranked higher than alternative gTLDs by search engine crawlers. Further outcomes could also prove that websites in alternative gTLDs have to spend more money when branding their websites to Internet users. This study is intended to make website owners aware of the importance of choosing the appropriate URL to increase website visibility on the Internet.
Which academic search systems are suitable for systematic reviews or meta‐analyses? Evaluating retrieval qualities of Google Scholar, PubMed, and 26 other resources
Michael Gusenbauer, Neal R Haddaway · 2020 · Research Synthesis Methods
Rigorous evidence identification is essential for systematic reviews and meta-analyses (evidence syntheses) because the sample selection of relevant studies determines a review's outcome, validity, and explanatory power. Yet, the search systems allowing access to this evidence provide varying level…
Read paper details
Michael Gusenbauer, Neal R Haddaway
Rigorous evidence identification is essential for systematic reviews and meta-analyses (evidence syntheses) because the sample selection of relevant studies determines a review's outcome, validity, and explanatory power. Yet, the search systems allowing access to this evidence provide varying levels of precision, recall, and reproducibility and also demand different levels of effort. To date, it remains unclear which search systems are most appropriate for evidence synthesis and why. Advice on which search engines and bibliographic databases to choose for systematic searches is limited and lacking systematic, empirical performance assessments. This study investigates and compares the systematic search qualities of 28 widely used academic search systems, including Google Scholar, PubMed, and Web of Science. A novel, query-based method tests how well users are able to interact and retrieve records with each system. The study is the first to show the extent to which search systems can effectively and efficiently perform (Boolean) searches with regards to precision, recall, and reproducibility. We found substantial differences in the performance of search systems, meaning that their usability in systematic searches varies. Indeed, only half of the search systems analyzed and only a few Open Access databases can be recommended for evidence syntheses without adding substantial caveats. Particularly, our findings demonstrate why Google Scholar is inappropriate as principal search system. We call for database owners to recognize the requirements of evidence synthesis and for academic journals to reassess quality requirements for systematic reviews. Our findings aim to support researchers in conducting better searches for better evidence synthesis. © 2019 The Authors. Research Synthesis Methods published by John Wiley & Sons Ltd.
DOI: 10.1002/jrsm.1378
Open source ↗A technical review of three clinical trials register resources indicates where improvements to the search interfaces are needed
Chris Cooper, R. Court, Eleanor Kotas, Ute Schauberger · 2021 · Research Synthesis Methods
Clinical trials registers form an important part of the search for studies in systematic reviews of intervention effectiveness but the search interfaces and functionality of registers can be challenging to search systematically and resource intensive to search well. We report a technical review of …
Read paper details
Chris Cooper, R. Court, Eleanor Kotas, Ute Schauberger
Clinical trials registers form an important part of the search for studies in systematic reviews of intervention effectiveness but the search interfaces and functionality of registers can be challenging to search systematically and resource intensive to search well. We report a technical review of the search interfaces of three leading trials register resources: ClinicalTrials.gov, the EU Clinical Trials Register and the WHO International Clinical Trials Registers Platform. The technical review used a validated checklist to identify areas where the search interfaces of these trials register resources performed well, where performance was adequate, where performance was poor, and to identify differences between search interfaces. The review found low overall scores for each of the interfaces (ClinicalTrials.gov 55/165, the EU Clinical Trials Register 25/165, the WHO International Clinical Trials Registers Platform 32/165). This finding suggests a need for joined-up dialogue between the producers of the registers and researchers who search them via these interfaces. We also set out a series of four proposed changes which might improve the search interfaces. Trials registers are an invaluable resource in systematic reviews of intervention effectiveness. With the continued growth in systematic reviews, and initiatives such as 'AllTrials', there is an anticipated need for these resources. We conclude that small changes to the search interfaces, and improved dialogue with providers, might improve the future search functionality of these valuable resources. © 2021 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
DOI: 10.1002/jrsm.1477
Open source ↗Where to prospectively register a systematic review
D. Pieper, Tanja Rombey · 2022 · Systematic Reviews
Background: Prospective registration aims to reduce bias in the conduct and reporting of research and to increase transparency. In addition, prospective registration of systematic reviews is argued to help preventing unintended duplication, thereby reducing research waste. PROSPERO was launched in …
Read paper details
D. Pieper, Tanja Rombey
Background: Prospective registration aims to reduce bias in the conduct and reporting of research and to increase transparency. In addition, prospective registration of systematic reviews is argued to help preventing unintended duplication, thereby reducing research waste. PROSPERO was launched in 2011 as the first prospective register for systematic reviews. While it has long been the only option to prospectively register systematic reviews, recently there have been new developments. Our aim was to identify and characterize current options to prospectively register a systematic review to assist review authors in choosing a suitable register. Methods: To identify systematic review registers, we independently performed internet searches in January 2021 using keywords related to systematic reviews and prospective registration. "Registration" was defined as the process of entering information about a planned systematic review into a database before starting the systematic review process. We collected data on the characteristics of the identified registries and contacted the responsible party of each register for verification of the data related to their registry. Results: Overall, we identified five options to prospectively register a systematic review: PROSPERO, the Registry of Systematic Reviews/Meta-Analyses in Research Registry, and INPLASY, which are specific to systematic reviews, and the Open Science Framework Registries and protocols.io, which represent generic registers open to any study type. Detailed information on each register is presented in tables in the main text. Regarding the systematic-review-specific registries, authors have to trade-off between the costs of registration and the processing time of their registration record. All registers provide an option to search for systematic reviews already registered in the register. However, it is unclear how useful these search functions are. Conclusion: Authors can prospectively register their systematic review in five registries, which come with different characteristics and features. The research community should discuss fair and sustainable financing models for registers that are not operated by for-profit organizations. © 2022. The Author(s).
DOI: 10.1186/s13643-021-01877-1
Open source ↗Both clinical trial register and electronic bibliographic database searches were needed to identify RCTs for systematic reviews: an evaluation study.
T. Kaul, J. Colombijn, R. Vernooij, R. Spijker, D. Idema, Linde F. Huis In 't Veld, Johanna A.… · 2024 · Journal of clinical epidemiology
Objectives: To determine whether clinical trial register (CTR) searches can accurately identify a greater number of completed randomized clinical trials (RCTs) than electronic bibliographic database (EBD) searches for systematic reviews of interventions, and to quantify the number of eligible ongoi…
Read paper details
T. Kaul, J. Colombijn, R. Vernooij, R. Spijker, D. Idema, Linde F. Huis In 't Veld, Johanna A. A. Damen, L. Hooft
Objectives: To determine whether clinical trial register (CTR) searches can accurately identify a greater number of completed randomized clinical trials (RCTs) than electronic bibliographic database (EBD) searches for systematic reviews of interventions, and to quantify the number of eligible ongoing trials. Study design and setting: We performed an evaluation study and based our search for RCTs on the eligibility criteria of a systematic review that focused on the underrepresentation of people with chronic kidney disease in cardiovascular RCTs. We conducted a combined search of ClinicalTrials.gov and the WHO International Clinical Trials Registry Platform through the Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials to identify eligible RCTs registered up to June 1, 2023. We searched Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials, EMBASE, and MEDLINE for publications of eligible RCTs published up to June 5, 2023. Finally, we compared the search results to determine the extent to which the two sources identified the same RCTs. Results: We included 92 completed RCTs. Of these, 81 had results available. Sixty-six completed RCTs with available results were identified by both sources (81% agreement [95% CI: 71-88]). We identified seven completed RCTs with results exclusively by CTR search (9% [95% CI: 4-17]) and eight exclusively by EBD search (10% [95% CI: 5-18]). Eleven RCTs were completed but lacked results (four identified by both sources (36% [95% CI: 15-65]), one exclusively by EBD search (9% [95% CI: 1-38]), and six exclusively by CTR search (55% [95% CI: 28-79])). Also, we identified 42 eligible ongoing RCTs: 16 by both sources (38% [95% CI: 25-53]) and 26 exclusively by CTR search (62% [95% CI: 47-75]). Lastly, we identified four RCTs of unknown status by both sources. Conclusion: CTR searches identify a greater number of completed RCTs than EBD searches. Both searches missed some included RCTs. Based on our case study, researchers (eg, information specialists, systematic reviewers) aiming to identify all available RCTs should continue to search both sources. Once the barriers to performing CTR searches alone are targeted, CTR searches may be a suitable alternative. Copyright © 2024 The Author(s). Published by Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
DOI: 10.1016/j.jclinepi.2024.111300
Open source ↗Cochrane Centralised Search Service showed high sensitivity identifying randomised controlled trials: A retrospective analysis.
A. Noel-Storr, G. Dooley, S. Wisniewski, Julie May Glanville, J. Thomas, S. Cox, R. Featherstone, R… · 2020 · Journal of clinical epidemiology
Background and objectives: The Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials (CENTRAL) is compiled from a number of sources, including PubMed and Embase. Since 2017, we have increased the number of sources feeding into CENTRAL and improved the efficiency of our processes through the use of applica…
Read paper details
A. Noel-Storr, G. Dooley, S. Wisniewski, Julie May Glanville, J. Thomas, S. Cox, R. Featherstone, R. Foxlee
Background and objectives: The Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials (CENTRAL) is compiled from a number of sources, including PubMed and Embase. Since 2017, we have increased the number of sources feeding into CENTRAL and improved the efficiency of our processes through the use of application programming interfaces, machine learning, and crowdsourcing.Our objectives were twofold: (1) Assess the effectiveness of Cochrane's centralized search and screening processes to correctly identify references to published reports which are eligible for inclusion in Cochrane systematic reviews of randomized controlled trials (RCTs). (2) Identify opportunities to improve the performance of Cochrane's centralized search and screening processes to identify references to eligible trials. Methods: We identified all references to RCTs (either published journal articles or trial registration records) with a publication or registration date between 1st January 2017 and 31st December 2018 that had been included in a Cochrane intervention review. We then viewed an audit trail for each included reference to determine if it had been identified by our centralized search process and subsequently added to CENTRAL. Results: We identified 650 references to included studies with a publication year of 2017 or 2018. Of those, 634 (97.5%) had been captured by Cochrane's Centralised Search Service. Sixteen references had been missed by the Cochrane's Centralised Search Service: six had PubMed-not-MEDLINE status, four were missed by the centralized Embase search, three had been misclassified by Cochrane Crowd, one was from a journal not indexed in MEDLINE or Embase, one had only been added to Embase in 2019, and one reference had been rejected by the automated RCT machine learning classifier. Of the sixteen missed references, eight were the main or only publication to the trial in the review in which it had been included. Conclusion: This analysis has shown that Cochrane's centralized search and screening processes are highly sensitive. It has also helped us to understand better why some references to eligible RCTs have been missed. The CSS is playing a critical role in helping to populate CENTRAL and is moving us toward making CENTRAL a comprehensive repository of RCTs. Copyright © 2020 The Authors. Published by Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
DOI: 10.1016/j.jclinepi.2020.08.008
Open source ↗Beyond Google Scholar, Scopus, and Web of Science: An evaluation of the backward and forward citation coverage of 59 databases' citation indices
Michael Gusenbauer · 2024 · Research Synthesis Methods
Citation indices providing information on backward citation (BWC) and forward citation (FWC) links are essential for literature discovery, bibliographic analysis, and knowledge synthesis, especially when language barriers impede document identification. However, the suitability of citation indices …
Read paper details
Michael Gusenbauer
Citation indices providing information on backward citation (BWC) and forward citation (FWC) links are essential for literature discovery, bibliographic analysis, and knowledge synthesis, especially when language barriers impede document identification. However, the suitability of citation indices varies. While some have been analyzed, the majority, whether new or established, lack comprehensive evaluation. Therefore, this study evaluates the citation coverage of the citation indices of 59 databases, encompassing the widely used Google Scholar, Scopus, and Web of Science alongside many others never previously analyzed, such as the emerging Lens, Scite, Dimensions, and OpenAlex or the subject-specific PubMed and JSTOR. Through a comprehensive analysis using 259 journal articles from across disciplines, this research aims to guide scholars in selecting indices with broader document coverage and more accurate and comprehensive backward and forward citation links. Key findings highlight Google Scholar, ResearchGate, Semantic Scholar, and Lens as leading options for FWC searching, with Lens providing superior download capabilities. For BWC searching, the Web of Science Core Collection can be recommended over Scopus for accuracy. BWC information from publisher databases such as IEEE Xplore or ScienceDirect was generally found to be the most accurate, yet only available for a limited number of articles. The findings will help scholars conducting systematic reviews, meta-analyses, and bibliometric analyses to select the most suitable databases for citation searching. © 2024 The Author(s). Research Synthesis Methods published by John Wiley & Sons Ltd.
DOI: 10.1002/jrsm.1729
Open source ↗Disagreements & Limitations
Disagreements
- No major disagreement identified.
Limitations
- No specific limitations reported. This does not establish completeness or certainty.
Sources
No sources were cited by the synthesizer.